Gods Of Management Essay, Research Paper
Gods of Management
The author, in the Gods of Management, attempts to classify four distinct management cultures that exist within all organizations. The author further uses the ancient Greek gods to symbolize these management cultures or philosophies. There are four types of management cultures or philosophies present within all organizations. The four cultures are the club (Zeus), role (Apollo), task (Athena), and existential (Dionysus) cultures.
The first culture the author discusses is the club or Zeus culture. The author uses a spider web to represent the club culture. ?[T]he lines radiating out from the center? represent ?divisions of work based on functions or products? (Handy p. 14). The most important lines however ?are the encircling [lines], the ones that surround the spider in the middle, for these are the lines of power and influence, losing importance as they go farther from the center. The relationship with the spider matters more in this culture than does any formal title or position description? (Handy p.14).
The author also maintains that this type of culture is excellent for ?speed of decisions? (Handy p. 15). However, the author also informs the reader that because of it?s speed, quality is dependent upon Zeus and his inner circle. This results in an emphasis being placed upon the selection and succession of Zeus.
The club culture achieves its speed through empathy. This in turn leads to very little documentation within the organization and face to face meetings between Zeus and his subordinates or contacts. Furthermore, this culture is dependent upon networks of ?friendships, old boys, and comrades? (Hardy p.16). Because of the high level of trust, the author asserts that this type of organization is cheap to operate. The only costs incurred in this type of organization are those of phone and travel expenses. In essence, these types of organizations value the individual, give him or her free rein, and reward their efforts.
The second type of culture that the author discusses is the role or Apollo culture. This type of culture bases its approach on the definition of the role or the job to be done. The symbol the author uses to represent this type of culture is a Greek temple. The pillars of the temple represent the functions and divisions in an organization. ?The pillars are joined managerially only at the top, the pediment, where the heads of the functions and divisions join together to form the board, management committee, or president?s office? (Handy p. 44). Besides being joined at the pediment, the pillars are also connected through rules and procedures.
This type of organization looks to the past in order to predict the future based on the premise that tomorrow will be like yesterday. This then allows the organization to examine and pull apart yesterday in order to formulate improved rules and procedures. ?Stability and predictability are assumed and encouraged? (Handy p. 45).
The role or set of duties are fixed in the Apollo culture. Furthermore, in this type of organization, efficiency is determined upon meeting deadlines and standard objectives. Exceeding the objectives or beating the deadlines does not lead to reward but rather a reevaluation the institutions goals and objectives. This in turn results in very little initiative among the employees. According to the author, some typical examples of the role or Apollo culture are ?life insurance companies, civil service, state industries, and local government? (Handy p.47).
Furthermore, apollonian cultures abhor change. Generally an apollonian response to a change in the environment would be to first ignore it and then usually do more of what they were already doing. ?Role cultures respond to drastic changes in the environment (changing consumer preferences, new technologies,, new funding sources) by setting up a lot of cross-functional liaison groups to hold the structure together. If these measures don?t work, the management will fall, or the whole temple will collapse in merger, bankruptcy, or a consultants? reorganization? (Handy p. 48).
The next type of organization is the task or Athena culture. This type of organization basically views management ?as being basically concerned with the continuous and successful solution of problems? (Handy p. 70). The management accomplishes this by first locating or finding the problem. After locating the problem, appropriate resources are given to solve the problem and waits for the results. In this type of organization, performance is judged by the results or problems solved.
The symbol the author uses for the task culture is a net. According to Handy, these types of organizations draw resources from various parts of the organization in order to solve a problem. In this type of culture, ?power lies at the interstices of the net? and is a ?network of loosely linked commando units, each unit being largely self-contained but having a specific responsibility within an overall strategy? (Handy p. 72).
In the Athena culture, only expertise in a specific field is the source for one?s power or influence. For example the author states that ?[t]o contribute to your group, you need talent, creativity, a fresh approach, and new intuitions. It is a culture where youth flourishes and creativity is at a premium? (Handy p.72).
However, the author asserts that task cultures are expensive organizations to run. The author supports his assertion by stating that these types of organizations are staffed by experts who demand their market worth. Furthermore, the author maintains that these experts discuss in excess the problems an organization faces which results in costing the organization a large quantity of money. Also he states that some problems are not solved the first time around, so there is a need to experiment which results in some errors and those errors also cost the organization money. This leads the author to conclude that these types of organizations ?tend to flourish in times of expansion, when the products , technologies, or services are new or when there is some sort of cartel arrangement that provides a price floor? (Handy p. 74).
However, the author contends that a task culture comes into difficult times when the organization needs to make the solutions permanent or routine, and that the cost of maintaining the culture seems excessively expensive. Furthermore, the author asserts that the life of task cultures are short. To support his assertion, the author states that ?if [organizations] are successful, they will grow big, and to pay their way will take on a lot of routine or maintenance work, which requires Apollonian structures? (Handy p. 74). In essence, this leads to the transformation of a task culture into that of a role culture.
The last type of culture or philosophy that the author discusses is the existential or Dionysus culture. In an existential culture, the author asserts that the organization exists to help the individual achieve his purpose. This is in contrast to the other three types of cultures where the individual is there to help the organization achieve its purpose.
The symbol the author uses for this type of culture is a cluster of individual stars loosely gathered in a circle. The members of this type of organization are not interdependent and thus does not cause an organizational change if one or more members leave the organization.
In this type of organization, management is considered a chore. Furthermore, a manager is considered the lowest status in such organizations. Furthermore, in an Dionysus culture, the manager can only manage by consent, and every individual has the right of veto, so that any coordinated effort becomes a matter of endless negotiation. An example the author gives the reader of a Dionysus culture is a university. The author maintains that a university is a existential culture in that ?there are no sanctions that can be used against [the] [professors], [and] [d]ismissal, money perks, or punishment are all outside the jurisdiction of the leader? (Handy p. 97). Furthermore the author states that these decisions are made by a ?group of equals? and not an individual.
In essence, the author asserts that the Dionysus culture is becoming more prevalent in society. The author states that ?[t]here is a growing band of ?new professionals?–individuals who define themselves according to their trade, not just doctors and lawyers, but now also the ?systems analyst,? ?research scientist,? ?public relations adviser,? and ?consultant?? (Handy p. 100) Furthermore, Handy asserts that these types of people view themselves as independent professionals who have temporarily lent their services or skills to an organization. According to the author, most people who belong to this culture are ?young and usually talented and can command an open market salary and reputation? (Handy p. 102).
In essence, the author argues that in order for a manager to be successful, the manager must first be aware of the different organizational cultures that exist within his or her organization. Once a manager is aware of the different cultures present in an organization, the manager may be effective as a liaison between the different cultures thereby eliminating slack or inefficiency.
Bibliography
Handy, C. (1995). Gods of management: The changing work of organizations. New York: Oxford University Press
Другие работы по теме:
Venus Aphrodite Essay Research Paper In the
Venus (Aphrodite) Essay, Research Paper In the begining, there was Chaos. From Chaos and Mother Earth came the first race of Greek deities, the Titans. These first gods were ruled by Saturn, who had received the prophesy that his son will over throw him. Well, he ate all his children save one, the one his wife, Mother Earth (Gaia) placed on an island.
Odyssey Essay Research Paper The OdysseyThe Odyssey
Odyssey Essay, Research Paper The Odyssey The Odyssey was full of wonder, power, and surprises. It is packed with epic heroes, creatures, gods, and goddesses. The gods, goddesses, and creatures had supernatural powers that effected the lives of Odysseus, his crew, and his family. Their actions proved to be powerful, beneficial, and deadly.
An Analysis Essay Research Paper An analysis
An Analysis Essay, Research Paper An analysis of the quotation ?The mills of the gods grind slowly, but they grind exceedingly small.? The quotation ?The mills of the gods grind slowly, but they grind exceedingly small,? could be compared to someone asking for something through prayer. This comparison is based on three beliefs.
Classics Essay Research Paper Humans during the
Classics Essay, Research Paper Humans during the time of The Epic of Gilgamesh depended heavily on the premonitions and forecasts of the gods. The residents of the town named Uruk awaited the messages in their dreams and through various signs. Another way people foretold the future was through divination, which is not used any more.
The Trial Of Socrates 2 Essay Research
Paper The Trial of Socrates Socrates is certainly not guilty of the crimes he is accused of. He is not corrupting the youth of Athens and he does indeed believe in gods. His manner is uncommon and because of that he is feared by his accusers (Meletus, Anytus, Lycon, et al.). Justice will be miscarried if he is put to death.
AngloSaxon Gods Essay Research Paper Anglo Saxon
Anglo-Saxon Gods Essay, Research Paper Anglo- Saxon Gods The Anglo-Saxon period was very interesting. Especially the ancient poems and mythology. While looking around, the Gods captured my attention. Three of them to be exact, Woden, Thunor and Tiw.
Astrology Essay Research Paper it was about
Astrology Essay, Research Paper it was about greek gods and they the way they were/suposidly like in roman days.it was about greek gods and they the way they were/suposidly like in roman days.it was about greek gods and they the way they were/suposidly like in roman days.it was about greek gods and they the way they were/suposidly like in roman days.it was about greek gods and they the way they were/suposidly like in roman days.it was about greek gods and they the way they were/suposidly like in roman days.it was about greek gods and they the way they were/suposidly like in roman days.it was about greek gods and they the way they were/suposidly like in roman days.it was about greek gods and they the way they were/suposidly like in roman days.it was about greek gods and they the way they were/suposidly like in roman days.it was about greek gods and they the way they were/suposidly like
Greek Mythology Essay Research Paper Since the
Greek Mythology Essay, Research Paper Since the days when man lived in caves and struggled to survive, he has wondered about the world that surrounds him. What makes the sun rise and set? Why are there seasons?
The Pantheon Essay Research Paper The Pantheon
The Pantheon Essay, Research Paper The Pantheon is the best preserved and one of the most impressive of all Roman buildings. It was constructed in AD 118-128 during the reign of Emperor Hadrian. The Pantheon was a temple to all the Olympic Gods, and the word pantheon is Greek for ?of all the gods?. The Pantheon today is a remake of the original one, which was built by M.
Odyssey Essay Research Paper The great muses
Odyssey Essay, Research Paper The great muses are called upon by Homer to tell the great adventure of Odysseus in his travel back to his home. Prayers are given to the Greek Gods and muses by
Greek And Roman Gods Essay Research Paper
1. The Queen and King of the gods and goddesses were Zeus and Hera (Greece), known as Jupiter and Juno (Rome). 2. Apollo had the same name in both Greece and Rome.
Religion In Ancient Greece Essay Research Paper
Religion in Ancient Greece The ancient Greeks were a deeply religious people. For them, religion was important because they believed that it would make their lives better while they were living. They also worshipped many gods whom they believed appeared in human form and yet were gifted with superhuman strength and timeless beauty.
Greek Gods Essay Research Paper The Greek
Greek Gods Essay, Research Paper The Greek Gods Many people would blatantly state that the importance of the gods in Greek society derives from the fact that Gods in any society are usually used to explain phenomenon that people cannot logically comprehend, but in ancient Greece gods were actually entities that took part in the workings of society itself.
MortalityAs Seen In Homer
’s Iliad Essay, Research Paper Zeus views mortality as the ability to pass to the domain of Hades, by which Zeus has no control over. The reader knows that even Gods are not immortal according to this definition, for Kronos long ago passed into Hades’ kingdom. Gods do not pass on as easily or as frequently as immortals, but as each immortal dies the Gods are reminded of the existence of the underworld.
Socraric Method Essay Research Paper The Socratic
Socraric Method Essay, Research Paper The Socratic Method of philosophy is basically a series of question leading to an answer. In order for this method to work though, two conditions must be met. The first one is that the interlocutor has to say what he believes. The second is that the answers must be kept short.
2 Chronicle Essay Research Paper solomon was
2 Chronicle Essay, Research Paper solomon was a king who had a hearts desire to have wisdom and knowledge from God so that he could lead his people whcih he says is Gods people. The significant
Agamemnon Essay Research Paper Odyssey
Agamemnon Essay, Research Paper Odyssey The relationship between the gods and humanity in The Epic of Gilgamesh and The Odyssey are the same. In each saga, the gods seem to live nearby and are always present. Both epic poems portray humans as simply at the mercy of the gods. The gods feel that it is their duty to intervene if they feel that man is traveling off course from his destiny.
Oedipus Rex Essay Research Paper Oedipus RexCharacters
Oedipus Rex Essay, Research Paper Oedipus Rex Characters in the play Oedipus the King attempt to block the horrible outcome of the gods? oracle. The first people to do so were Oedipus? mother and father, Laius and Jocasta. After hearing the unmoral and disruptive prediction, they attempted to execute their own child.
Religion Traid Essay Research Paper The god
Religion Traid Essay, Research Paper The god Agni was important in the context of the Vedas because Agni was the ancient god of fire. Agni the chief bestower of blessing was called upon to take the ancient Hindus sacrifice to the gods and make the gods present at sacrifice. Vedas scriptures were used for sacrifice during ancient times and the most important aspect of the sacrifice was fire.
What Is Piety Essay Research Paper What
What Is Piety Essay, Research Paper What is Piety During the Periclean age (around 400 B.C.) in Athens Greece there was a man named Socrates. He was considered a very wise man by the Athenians. However
Aztec Religion Essay Research Paper At the
Aztec Religion Essay, Research Paper At the time of the Spanish conquest, the religion of the Aztecs was polytheistic, based on the worship of a multitude of personal gods, most of them with well-defined attributes. Nevertheless, magic and the idea of certain impersonal and occult forces played an important role among the people.
Sight And Blindness A Metaphor For Humanity
’s Place In The Universe Essay, Research Paper In Oedipus the King, sight and blindness were used as a metaphor for humanity’s place in the universe. The gods and unchangeable fate remained hidden from humans; therefore, they were blind to the truth of existence. It is ironic that the only insight Oedipus had into the gods’ will was through a blind man.
Antigone Civil Disobedience Essay Research Paper The
Antigone: Civil Disobedience Essay, Research Paper The short play, Antigone, was written in 441 B.C. by the Greek playwrightSophocles. It deals with some of the most basic problems that affect a society.One of them is Civil Disobedience. Civil Disobedience both a right andresponsibility of a person to fight an unjust law.
Greek Gods 2 Essay Research Paper Greek
Greek Gods 2 Essay, Research Paper Greek Gods Zeus is the king of all the gods. Zeus had to kill his father who eats Zeus s brothers and sisters, so that he can free them. He than had to marry his sister Hera. He was not always with Hera, but with mortal women. Hera the wife of Zeus is always jealous of Zeus sneaking of to another women and gets angry all the time.
Zeus Essay Research Paper Zeus was the
Zeus Essay, Research Paper Zeus was the son of Cronus and Rhea, an earlier race of ruling gods called Titans. Cronus was king of all the Titans. Zeus was the brother of Hades and Poseidon, Hades was the god of the
Echo Essay Research Paper Echo was a
Echo Essay, Research Paper Echo was a nymph who lived in the forest. She romped and played with all of her fellow nymphs. One day she came across a beautifull man named Narcissus. At first she was scared of him, but soon grew quite attached. The gods looked down upon an infatuated Narcissus with disdain. They sentenced him and his new love to horrible fates.
Epic Of Gilgamesh Essay Research Paper We
Epic Of Gilgamesh Essay, Research Paper We learn about ancient civilizations through literature, artifacts, and stories passed down from generation to generation. The Mesopotamian civilization is one of earth’s earliest civilizations, and it’s also one we know very little about. We can gather information about these people’s way life, beliefs, and geographical location.
Antigone Essay Research Paper Antigone did the
Antigone Essay, Research Paper Antigone did the right thing by defileing Creon’s strict orders on burying Polynices because the unalterable laws of the gods and our morals are higher than the blasphemous laws of man.
Is Antigone A Tragic Play As Defined
By Aristotles 6 Points Of Tragedy Essay, Research Paper Is Antigone a tragic play as defined by Aristotle? Antigone is not a tragic play. Rather it is a theological debate spawned by Sophocles, a debate that is still raging today, the debate of who holds the higher law, the Gods or the State. While this debate has slowly twisted into Church versus State, which is a very different argument, the highest questions still remain the same: Which one is held higher in men s (and women s) hearts? Antigone answers this question with shocking clarity in her admission of guilt to Creon, I should have praise and honor for what I have
Antigone Essay Research Paper Joe PrestonEnglish 10
Antigone Essay, Research Paper Joe Preston English 10 period 1 Antigone Essay Mrs. Bleeke 18 November 1999 Antigone Essay Antigone is an admirable character in some aspects through out the play. Her pride
Antigone Essay Research Paper Antigone The Tragic
Antigone Essay, Research Paper Antigone, The Tragic Heroine Antigone risks her life to bury her brother, Polyneices, who she loved dearly. As she pleased the Gods, she was punished by a King, Creon. Antigone was the main character or heroine in this tragic tale. She is a tragic character because we feel pity and fear for her.
Civil Vs Moral Essay Research Paper Civil
Civil Vs Moral Essay, Research Paper ?Civil Law vs. Moral law? In Sophocles? play ?Antigone?, Antigone?s life is taken from her because of her choice to follow the moral law by burying her brother and disobeying the civil law, which forbid this.