Untitled Essay, Research Paper
BETA PICTORIS: PLANETS? LIFE? OR WHAT?JARAASTRONOMY
The ultimate question is; Is there a possibility that life might exist on a planet in the
Beta Pictoris system? First, one must ask, Are there planets in the Beta Pictoris system?.
However, that question would be impossible to answer if one did not answer the most basic
questions first; Where do planets come from? and do the key elements and situations,
needed to form planets, exist in the Beta Pictoris system?.
To understand where planets come from, one has to first look at where the planets in our
solar system came from. Does or did our star, the sun, have a circumstellar disk around
it? the answer is believed to be yes.
Scientists believe that a newly formed star is immediately surrounded by a relatively
dense cloud of gas and dust. In 1965, A. Poveda stated, “That new stars are likely to
be obscured by this envelope of gas and dust (1).” In 1967, Davidson and Harwit
agreed with Poveda and then termed this occurrence, the “cocoon nebula” (1).
Other authors have referred to this occurrence as, a “placental nebula” (1),
noting that it sustains the growth of planetary bodies.
For a long time, even before there was the term cocoon nebula, planetary scientists knew
that a cocoon nebula had surrounded the sun, long ago, in order for our solar system to
form and take on their currents motions (1).
In 1755, a German, named Immanuel Kant, reasoned that “gravity would make circumsolar
cloud contract and that rotation would flatten it (1)." Thus, the cloud would assume
the general shape of a rotating disk, explaining the fact that the planets, in our solar
system, revolve in a disk-shaped distribution.
This idea, about the disk-shaped nebula that was formed around the early sun, came to be
known as the nebula hypothesis (1). Then, in 1796, a French mathematician named Laplace,
proposed that the rotating disk continued to cool and contract, forming planetary bodies
(1). Also, when investigating the evolution of stars, it was proposed “that a star
forms as a central condensation in an extended nebula… The outer part remains behind as
the cocoon nebula (1)”. During the same study it was also indicated that under
various conditions such as: rotation, turbulence, etc. the nucleus of the forming star may
divide into two or more bodies orbiting each other (1). This may be the explanation as to
why more than half of all star systems are binary or multiple, rather than singles stars,
like ours, the sun.
This same fragmentation may also form bodies too small to become stars. However, they
could form into large planets, about the same size as Jupiter (1).
In 1966, Low and Smith calculated that the dust must be orbiting the star at a distance of
many tens of astronomical units, in order for planets to from (1). Others have reasoned
that the cocoon nebula must contain silicate and/or ice particles (planet-forming
materials), in order for the presence of planetary bodies (1). Still others have concluded
that planets form during the early life of a star (1).
After determining that planets are formed in a circumstellar disk surrounding a star, we
must ask ourselves, Does Beta Pictoris have a cirumstellar disk around it?
Beta Pictoris was found to have a circumstellar disk in 1983. It was first detected by the
Infrared Astronomy Satellite. The disk is seen to extend to more than 400 astronomical
units from the star (2). The orbits of most of the particles are inclined 5 degrees or
less to the plane of the system (2). These minimal orbital inclinations are typical of the
major planets in our own solar system. There is evidence that the circumstellar material
around Beta Pictoris takes the form of a highly flattened disk, rather than a spherical
shell implies an almost certain association with planet formation (2). The disk material
itself is believed to be a potential source for planet accretion (2). This retention of
nearly coplanar orbits in the Beta Pictoris disk is a qualitative argument in support of
its being a relatively young system (2). Some astronomers believe that we are witnessing
planet formation in the process.
Lagage and Pantin found that the inner region of the disk surrounding Beta Pictoris is
clear of dust, a prime indicator that there is evidence of one or more planetary bodies
(3).
The depletion zone extends to about 15 AU from the star, about the same size as our solar
system; and has an average particle density only one tenth of the area just outside this
zone (3).
Lagage and Pantin believe that the inner zone may have been swept clean by the
gravitational pull of a planet orbiting around Beta Pictoris (3). A planet would
gravitationally deflect the particles out of the inner zone. This planet, which is only
believed to exist, may also be deflecting comets into the star, as indicated by the
presence of highly variable absorption lines in the spectrum of Beta Pictoris (3).
The infrared image by Lagage and Pantin also provide information that the edge-on disk is
not symmetrical around the star (3). This suggests a more intimate relationship between
the asymmetry and the properties of the inner disk. As the orbital timescale for particles
is relatively short (less than 100 years), one would expect that the irregularities in the
disk would have been smoothed out by now (3). Unless, there was something stirring it up,
such as a planet (3).
If there is a planet orbiting Beta Pictoris, its orbit is probably eccentric, as are most
of the planetary orbits in our solar system (4). A planet with even a moderately eccentric
orbit would generate the asymmetry that is been noted in the dust disk surrounding Beat
Pictoris (4).
The Hubble Space Telescope, using the high-resolution spectrograph, found that the disk
surrounding beta Pictoris consists of two parts: an outer ring of small, solid particles,
and an inner ring of diffuse gas within a few hundred miles of the star (5).
Albert Boggess, an astronomer at NASA’s Goddard Space Flight Center, suspects that
the gas comes from the ring of solid particles (5). If he is correct, then the gas may be
a sign that planets are being born there. The gas could be a result from the collision of
solid particles in the outer ring accreting into planets that are still too small to see
because of the brightness of the star itself (5). During the collisions some of the
particles would be vaporized and drawn toward the star. The planets in our own solar
system are believed to have formed through countless numbers of such collisions (5).
Boggess also believes that Beta Pictoris is very similar to a very early phase of our own
solar system (5).
Additional evidence, from the Hubble, also suggests that Beta Pictoris might be following
in our footsteps. The gaseous inner ring appears to contain clumps of material spiraling
toward the star (5). These clumps may be comets, diverted from the normal paths by close
calls with protoplanets (5). This also fits with current ideas about the evolution of our
own solar system. Gases from comet impacts may have been the creating factor of the
Earth’s atmosphere and oceans (5).
Wetherill argues that life on Earth is reliant upon the existence of Jupiter and Saturn,
because they cleansed our Solar System of most of its planetesimals (comets) that,
otherwise, would be striking the Earth (6). In order for a planet to survive long enough
for life to begin, it is necessary for the existence of gas giants (Jupiter and Saturn) to
get rid of the hazardous comets.
No one person can say for sure whether there are planets in the Beta Pictoris System, or
not. However, it is definitely a possibility. There is a circumstellar disk surrounding
Beta Pictoris. It is a highly flattened disk, as was the disk that once surrounded the
Sun. The disk contains the necessary elements for planet formation. The star is a young
one. The inner zone of the disk is clear. All of these things point to the almost probable
formation of planets. Richard Terrile, from the Jet Propulsion Laboratory, says,
“It’s hard not to form planets from material like this (7).”
To answer whether or not there could be life on one of these planets, is not easy to say.
No one can really even speculate. I, believe that it is possible, if all the variables
come together in just the right way. I am not ‘earthnocentric’ to assume that
the earth is the only planet in the Universe that can sustain life. Whether or not a
planet in the Beta Pictoris system has what it takes, who knows, we can only wait and
watch.
BIBLIOGRAPHY(1) Moons And Planets, third edition; William K.
Hartman; Wadsworth Publishing company;
California; 1993.(2) A Circumstellar Disk Around Beta Pictoris; Science;
volume 226; pages 1421-1424.(3) Footprints in The Dust; Charles M. Telesco;
Nature; volume 369; pages 610-611.(4) Dust Depletion In The Inner Disk Of Beta Pictoris
As A Possible Indicator Of Planets; P. O. Lagage
and E. Pantin; Nature; volume 369; pages 628-
630.(5) Birth Of A Solar System?; Tim Folger; Discover;
volume 13; page 27.(6) Inhibition Of Giant-planet formation By Rapid Gas
Depletion Around Young Stars; B. Zucherman,
T. Forveille, and J. H. Kastner; Nature; volume
373; pages 494-496.(7) A Planet Around Beta Pictoris?; Sky and Telescope;
Volume 88; page 10.
ADDITIONAL BIBLIOGRAPHYA Closer Look At Beta Pictoris; Astronomy;
volume 21; Page 18.Birth Announcements; Scientific American;
volume 256; pages 60+.Faraway Planets; Science Digest; volume 94;
page 47.Protoplanetary nebula around Beta Pictoris;
Astronomy; volume 13; page 60.
318
Другие работы по теме:
Solar System Essay Research Paper Origin Of
Solar System Essay, Research Paper Origin Of The Solar System For more than 300 years there has been serious scientific discussion of the processes and events that led to the formation of the solar system.
Untitled Essay Research Paper On vacation this
Untitled Essay, Research Paper On vacation this summer I glanced out the window and sawa beautiful handglider hovering in these pretty mountains.A great looking background surrounded the mountains. About four-hundred feet above the mountain soaredthe handglider. The pilot who appears about five footeleven inches wears a yellow jacket and black snow pants.The handglider hangs with a span of about twenty-ninefeet.
Untitled Essay Research Paper I messed up
Untitled Essay, Research Paper I messed up; I made a mistake, But please, haste do not take. I love you more than any action or words could ever express, Still I find my heart drowning in loneliness.
Untitled Essay Research Paper MATERIAL SAFETY DATA
Untitled Essay, Research Paper MATERIAL SAFETY DATA SHEET WOMEN: A Chemical Analysis ELEMENT: Woman SYMBOL: WO DISCOVERER Adam ATOMIC MASS: Accepted as 118 lbs, known to vary from 110 to 550 lbs. OCCURRENCE: Copious quantities throughout the world. PHYSICAL PROPERTIES: 1. Surface usually covered with a painted film. 2.
Untitled Essay Research Paper I am afraidI
Untitled Essay, Research Paper I am afraid. I am lonely. I want to be at home now. I hate the silence. I hate the circumstances. I want to feel love now. I want to feel passion not emptiness.
Untitled Essay Research Paper In the Heart
Untitled Essay, Research Paper In the Heart of Darkness, it is very easy to forget what is real and what is civilized. The rivets that Marlow talks about, to fix his boat, are very symbolic of his need to become riveted to reality. Marlow feels that he is slipping into savagery from what he sees around him. In the story, The Heart of Darkness, by Joseph Conrad, there is a fine line between civilization and savagery and Marlow needs the rivets to help him find himself in his own soul or where his own reality is.
Untitled Essay Research Paper Animal FarmMr Jones
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Animal FarmMr. Jones owned and managed Manor Farm. He was a bad man who liked to drink. Things on the farm got so bad one night that he fell asleep so drunk that he forgot to lock in the animals. The beasts took advantage of the situation and held a secret meeting. Led by the pigs, they ran the Joneses from their home.The animals of the renamed “Animal Farm” formed a system they called “Animalism.
Untitled Essay Research Paper Being a dental
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Being a dental assistant would be a great job because it has a variety of interesting duties. It has goo hours, pay and benefits. There are always advancement opportunities. Jobs will be available because the dental assistant is needed to help the dentist. Being a dental assistant has many good qualities.
Untitled Essay Research Paper Dear Mr Peace
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Dear Mr. Peace, The Connecticut River also known as by it s Algonquin name Long River is very rich and still useable for transportation. The chemical plant that you are proposing to put on the
Untitled Essay Research Paper Pride and Prejudice
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Pride and Prejudice has two main characters, Elizabeth and Darcy, who at the beginning seem to be disgusted at each other. During the book, their views toward each other seem to change and slowly make progress. At the end of the book, their opinions have completely turned around about each other and they even get engaged and later married.
NanoTechnology Essay Research Paper One of the
Nano-Technology Essay, Research Paper One of the big problems not fully appreciated with current ideas in nano technology research is the energy requirement for the development of shuttles and using it to carry the bots to other planets. First of all, the design of the shuttle would have to be very intricate because it would have to be able to manage to intense cold since it has to travel farther and farther away from the sun.
Untitled Essay Research Paper 7 I have
Untitled Essay, Research Paper 7. I have chosen the character Abigail and will show the impact she had on the witch hunt in Salem because of her strong leadership and the accusations she made towards others in Salem.Abby was a very fluensul girl in the play and the other girls looked up to her and would follow along for what ever she told them.
Pluto Essay Research Paper Pluto repeats an
Pluto Essay, Research Paper Pluto repeats an anomaly when compared with the terrestrial planets (Mercury, Venus, the Earth and Mars) or the giant planets (Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus and Neptune). This icy world is more like a huge asteroid or the satellites of the outer planets; it has even been suggested that Pluto was a satellite that escaped from Neptune’s pull.
Untitled Essay Research Paper NonHodgkins Lymphoma
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Non-Hodgkin?s Lymphoma Non-Hodgkin?s lymphoma is a disease in which cancer calls are found in the lymphsystem. The lymph system fights infections found in the body. People with AIDStend to pick up this disease. There are no specific early detections for this disease.Every body is different, and this disease is already difficult to diagnose.
Untitled Essay Research Paper In both the
Untitled Essay, Research Paper In both the traditional and not so traditional tales of ?Snow White? and ?Snow White Tale of Terror?despite there many differences, the plots are both based on jealousy. As viewers watch the movies they are dazzled by the mysterious mirror, entranced by the different takes of the story line, and know that there will be a happy ending.
Untitled Essay Research Paper November 6 1996
Untitled Essay, Research Paper November 6, 1996 Dear Joe, It was nice to hear from you again, I enjoyed hearing about your new business venture and I hope it works out. School is going great and I can’t wait to graduate in two months. The other day I finished reading a book by Michael Crichton called “JURASSIC PARK” you may have heard of the movie.
Babylonian
– Mayan Astronomy Essay, Research Paper Mayan Astronomy was better Than Babylonian Astronomy Mayan astronomy differed in several ways compared to Babylonian astronomy. Among the numerous ways were their different beliefs in the heavens, space, planets Earth and even their calendars.
Untitled Essay Research Paper Analysis of Crito
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Analysis of Crito The question is raised within the dialogue between Socrates and Crito concerning civil disobedience. Crito has the desire, the means, and many compelling
Untitled Essay Research Paper Business has always
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Business has always been the major of my choice because of the endless possibilities. You are on your own in a business – but you are also your own boss. And with this comes the privileges. Structure your business to the limits of your imagination. Anything can be sold for the right price.
Untitled Essay Research Paper Words 361
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Words = 361 At the conclusion of Barn Burning Sarty faces a major dilemma: go back to his family or just walk away. The consequences of this decision are great. For such a young boy, choosing to leave his family must be overwhelming and frightening. However, Sarty knows that in order for him to actually live, he must do this.
Blade Runner Essay Research Paper Blade RunnerThis
Blade Runner Essay, Research Paper Blade Runner This movie was very similar to the many other shall we say ?alien? movies out there. This movie may have been more correct with what may happen in the future. There wasn?t any explosions or planets blowing up, or anything as drastic as that. It was a more subtle thought of what happens if aliens really do take over.
Untitled Essay Research Paper In the novel
Untitled Essay, Research Paper In the novel, To Kill A Mockingbird, by Harper Lee, the author comments onlife. Specifically, Harper Lee comments on racism and true courage. Racism is the first subject that the author comments on. It is obviousfrom her writing that she feels racism is that it is wrong. This is displayed inseveral ways.
Untitled Essay Research Paper A hacker is
Untitled Essay, Research Paper A hacker is a person obsessed with computers. At the heart of the obsession is a drive master the computer. The classic hacker was simply a
Untitled Essay Research Paper A Biographical Report
Untitled Essay, Research Paper A Biographical Report on Thomas Fitzsimons Thomas Fitzsimons, or Fitzsimmons as his last name was sometimes spelled, was born during 1741 and died on August 26, 1811. Originally from Ireland,
Untitled Essay Research Paper Hmmmm I havent
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Hmmmm? I haven?t seen that many plays, but I did see this one, so here comes the review. Produced by Andrew Lloyd Webber, Cats is not his most famous production. Webber also did the Phantom of the Opera. I?ve never seen ?Phantom?, but I would imagine it is better than Cats. That?s not to say Cats was particularly bad, just cheesy.
Shampoo Planets 2
Shampoo Planets – Book Report Essay, Research Paper Shampoo Planets – book Report The book I chose is Shampoo Planet, writen by Douglas Coupland. I chose to read this particular book because it was written by an author of my generation; generation X. Most books that were on the list were book written by people that were either dead or very old.
Untitled Essay Research Paper A Farewell to
Untitled Essay, Research Paper A Farewell to Arms The overall tone of the book is much different than that of The Sun Also Rises. The characters in the book are propelled by outside forces, in this case WWI, where the characters in SAR seemed to have no direction. Frederick’s actions are determined by his position until he deserts the army.
Untitled Essay Research Paper Sand Pebbles essay
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Sand Pebbles essay The movie Sand Pebbles focus was on the flag. The flag was not only a symbol of a nation, but of nationalism, militarism and imperialism. During the 1800’s and early 1900’s there was a severe foreign influence in China. During this time period the European nations wanted to trade with the Chinese, but the Chinese had no interest in the European products for at the time China was self sufficient.
Untitled Essay Research Paper As John Stuart
Untitled Essay, Research Paper As John Stuart Mills, I believe that my philosophy on government will satisfy the needs of the society. Throughout the 1880?s people have revolted under the circumstances that the government is focused on the society and the individual. My system focuses on liberty, meaning the rights and principles of the individual of a society.
The Earth Essay Research Paper THE EARTH
The Earth Essay, Research Paper THE EARTH The Earth’s Place In Space: Despite its own special conditions,the Earth is in some ways similar to the other inner planets the group of planets
Near Earth Objects Essay Research Paper Near
Near Earth Objects Essay, Research Paper Near Earth Objects What are NEOs? Where do they come from? Do they pose any real threat to Earth? Can they provide viable space resources? All of these questions are now