Comparison Essay, Research Paper
In William Shakespeare s King Lear and Jane Smiley s A Thousand Acres, the reader will
find that both works use similar character types that mirror each other to increase further
the similarities and meaning of the works.
Perhaps no similarity is as striking as that of the fathers . They share three
characteristics which bind them and make their parallels unmistakable. The first, and most
obvious, is that they are both proprietors of a large estate. King Lear s property consists
of England and Larry Cook s property is that of a thousand acres of land in Iowa. This
land brings the primary conflicts of the two works into focus. Before their downward
spiral, both men are revered and respected. Their social status has brought them honor,
only up to the point where the fathers seek to divide their land. After that, things take a
turn for the worse. As it relates to King Lear, he gathers his royal entourage and begins to
divide the kingdom between his three daughters. To determine who would receive what,
Lear asks that his daughters profess their love for him. When his two eldest, Goneril and
Regan speak falsely about their affection for their father, Lear bestows upon each of them
a portion of the kingdom. When it comes time for Cordelia to speak, she admits,
Unhappy that I am, I cannot heave/ My heart into my mouth. I love my majesty/
According to my bond, no more nor less (Shakespeare, 13). Her insolence results in her
exile. As the play progresses, Lear becomes maddened by his decision, culminating with a
storm on the heath. Before that, his other two daughters throw Lear out of their houses.
Regan says, The old man and s people/ Cannot be well bestowed (117). Similarly, Ginny
and Rose disrespect their father. Ginny says, Daddy, if you think this is bad, then you d
be amazed at what you really deserve. You don t deserve even the care we give you. As
far as I m concerned, from now on you re on your own (Smiley, 183). In yet another
parallel, this tirade occurs during a storm. Because of the betrayal at their daughters
hands, the fathers take similar courses of action against their children. Shortly following
the threat by Ginny, Larry shouts, I curse you! You ll never have children, Ginny, you
haven t got a hope. And your children are going to laugh when you die! (183). Similarly,
an enraged Lear says, All the stored vengeances of heaven fall/ On her ingrateful top!
Strike her young bones/ You taking airs, with lameness! (109).
In addition to the fathers resemblance, the daughters bear striking correlation
themselves. In a grammatical sense, the letters of the daughters first names match in
chronological order of their births, i.e., Goneril-Ginny, Regan-Rose, Cordelia-Caroline. As
obvious as that is, it is no coincidence. Aside from that, the girls share other unmistakable
parallels. Goneril and Regan split their inheritance with their husbands. Lear confirms this:
Of all these bounds, even from this line to this…To thine and Albany s issue/ Be this
perpetual (11). Similarly, To thee and thine heredity ever/ Remain this ample third of
our fair kingdom (13). Ginny and Rose also receive a substantial portion of land. In the
meantime, Cordelia and Caroline receive nothing. In fact, Lear banishes his youngest
daughter for failing to profess her love to him: If on the tenth day following/ Thy
banished trunk be found within our dominions/ The moment is thy death. Away! By
Jupiter/ This shall not be revoked (19). The relationship between the novels continues to
become clear.
The subplots of these two works are indeed also similar. Gloucester is blinded by
Cornwall in Act III, scene vii. Corwall says, Lest it see more, prevent it. Out, vile jelly!
(165). The medieval foil of Gloucester, Harold Clark becomes blind as a result of a
chemical known as anhydrous ammonia. Ty explains, Harold Clark s had an anhydrous
accident. He s blind now (233). Edgar, the legitimate son of Gloucester, can be compared
to Loren Clark, who has stayed to work on the family farm. Loren, much like the
legitimate Edgar, is well-liked by the residents of Zebulon County. Ginny describes Loren
as, …a big sweet guy…seeing him somewhere was always a pleasure, like taking a drink
of water (7). Conversely, in Shakespearean times, illegitimate children had few rights.
Edmund expounds bitterly on his situation:
This is the excellent foppery of the world, that/ when we are sick
in fortune (often the surfeits of/ our own behavior) we make guilty of our
disasters/ the sun, moon, and stars, as if we were villains/ on necessity…An
admirable/ evasion of whoremaster man, to lay his goatish/ disposition on the
charge of a star! (37).
Jess Clark was just as neglected when he left for Vietnam. Ginny says, …Jess and
everything about him slipped into the category of unmentionable, and no one spoke of him
again until the spring of 1979 (6). The secondary characters in these works bear evident
parallels.
Although separated by hundreds of years, these similarities help to tie the works
together. Be it through patriarchal mirroring with Lear and Larry Cook both dividing their
property, or through filial conflict between the daughters, or even congruity within the
subplots, these correlations send a clear message: the basic conflicts between family
members never change. These conflicts may be disguised, which coincidentally is a
prevalent theme in King Lear, but the root problem is unchanged. Sibling rivalry and
patriarchal power struggles inevitably lead to devastating family consequences, often
causing rifts to emerge between the afflicted which can become irreconcilable with time.
Unfortunately, these issues, as is the case with the aforementioned works, are often driven
by the human condition itself, or more accurately, selfishness. The act of self-preservation
magnified beyond practical bounds can act as a catalyst to augment the hidden struggles
within a family structure. The similarities found in King Lear and A Thousand Acres serve
as a constant reminder that although time itself may change, the relationships and the
people whom they involve remain quite stoic in their ways.
Другие работы по теме:
Machiavellian Philosophy In King Lear Essay Research
Paper Machiavelli s ideas influence some of Shakespeare s characters in the play, King Lear. To use the critic A. P. Rossiter s phrase, Shakespeare s plays are about, the survival of the slickest. The characters in King Lear that reflect the Machiavellian philosophy are the two sisters, Goneril and Regan, and the son of Gloucester, Edmund.
Wisdom Does Not Come With Age Essay
, Research Paper Although it is never too late to learn, those lessons learned in old age are often the most difficult and the most costly. Following Lear s dispute with Goneril, the Fool tell him, Thou shoulds t not have been old till thou hads t/ Been wise [I, v, 43-44]. In William Shakespeare s tragedy King Lear, Lear illustrates that wisdom does not necessarily come with age.
Bad Things That Happen To King Essay
, Research Paper Why do bad things happen to good people? The majority of society believes that there are no logical answers to this question. The worst can happen to the best of us, for no particular reasons. Unfortunately, this is not always the case. In William Shakespeare’s “King Lear”, the main character, King Lear, who claims to be “a man more sinned against than sinning”, is responsible for his own downfall (3.2.60-61).
King Lear Essay 1 Essay Research Paper
Service and loyalty are big parts of the plot of King Lear. Some characters of this play show complete loyalty and service to the king. One of these is Kent. Throughout the play, Kent is completely loyal to his king, even after the Lear banishes him from the kingdom. This tells me that some people can be loyal to the end.
Cordelia And Lear Essay Research Paper Throughout
Cordelia And Lear Essay, Research Paper Throughout the play, King Lear, we are awaiting to see the reunion of Lear and his daughter Cordelia. In the begining of the play Lear wrongfully disowns Cordelia because he does not get the flattery from her that he wishes to hear. However, through much torment after he is reduced to nothing, Lear realizes that he cannot always get what he wants just because he is a king.
King Lea The Role Of The Fool
Essay, Research Paper In the play King Lear, by William Shakespeare, there are many intriguing characters. Perhaps the most intriguing of them all is the fool. The fool seems to exist outside the play appearing and disappearing without warning. The fool is, however, a necessary character to the evolution of Lear’s character, since he is the personification of truth and reason.
1000 Acres And King Lear Essay Research
Paper Every book adaptation of an existing work has its own set of problems. Not only was Jane Smiley’s 1991 novel a Pulitzer Prize-winning best seller with a large number of devoted fans, but the book A Thousand Acres was in turn self-conscious reworking of King Lear, which is a play with a larger number of more devoted fans.
Goneril Vs Jinny Essay Research Paper It
Goneril Vs. Jinny Essay, Research Paper It is amazing to me the extraordinary job that Jane Smiley has done with her book A Thousand Acres. The parallels that she draws with Shakespeare’s classic story of King Lear are unsurpassed by any book to which I have had the pleasure of reading. These two works represent an excellent example of literature that is able to engage readers young and old.
King Lear
’s Death Essay, Research Paper King Lear’s Death At the end of Shakespeare’s play King Lear, Kent and Edgar survive to be offered their power and titles back so that they can jointly rule with Albany. The title character of the play is not so fortunate. Lear enters carrying the dead body of his loving daughter Cordelia, then collapses and dies beside her.
Good Vs Evil In King Lear Essay
, Research Paper In the King Lear play, Shakespeare creates many conditions in which humans live in the world. The main characters in the play are used to portray Shakespeare’s ideas. One of these ideas which Shakespeare is trying to portray is evil between the characters and in the world which are emphasized throughout the play.
Tragedy Of King Lear Essay Research Paper
Hamlet, Othello, Macbeth and King Lear are the four most prominent and revered works that William Shakespeare had ever produced, though the first three that I mentioned seem
King Lear Suffering Essay Research Paper King
King Lear: Suffering Essay, Research Paper King Lear: Suffering Suffering takes on many appearances, depending on how it is received. In King Lear, suffering was very painful to two people, and the giver wasn’t
King Lear The Role Of The Fool
Essay, Research Paper King Lear: The Role of the Fool In Shakespeare?s, King Lear, the Fool plays three major roles. One of these roles is of an ?inner-conscience? of Lear. The Fool provides basic wisdom and reasoning for the King at much needed times. The Fool also works as amusement for Lear in times of sadness and is also one of the only people besides the Duke of Kent and Cordelia who are willing to stand up to the King.
A Thousand Acres Essay Research Paper Just
A Thousand Acres Essay, Research Paper Just set back for a moment and think about a thousand acres, that s an area of land of almost mythic proportions. Just as the changes the people had to go through in this book. In this book the author takes material possessions and other tangible entities and identifies the characters through it.
King Lear Act 5 Scene 3 Essay
, Research Paper Unseen text-King Lear (The passage is taken from Act 5,scene 3 and only Lear speaks throughout) The thing I find most interesting about the language used in this passage, is the dream like image it creates. I think the amount of contradictive language, used in the passage is also of some note as it creates ambiguity.
Madness In King Lear Act 4 Essay
, Research Paper Madness in King Lear: Act 4 In Shakespeare’s play King Lear, Shakespeare introduces many themes. The most important theme shown in King Lear is the theme of
The Fool In King Lear Essay Research
Paper The Fool is a tremendously substantial character in William Shakespeare’s tragedy, King Lear. Traditionally, fools were the equivalent of court jesters and were thought to be insane. They were customarily physically and sometimes even mentally impaired. Persons became fools as the result of an aristocratic individual’s compassion or boredom.
King LearBlindness Essay Research Paper King Lear
King Lear-Blindness Essay, Research Paper King Lear is in many ways like Nunez in the story The country of the Blind . They are both simliar because they both do not realize that they are both blind in what others think of them. They might think that they are right beacause both of them think that the people around them are inferior because of the way that they appear.
Character Analysis In King Lear Essay Research
Paper Cordelia The virtuous daughter whom King Lear mistakenly rejects . knowing she will marry , Cordelia refuses to assert that all of her love will forever go to her father , unlike Regan and Goneril, her hypocritical sisters . Lear mistakes Cordelia’s honesty for a lack of affection and disinherits her , though the king of France recognizes her innate worth and marries her anyway .
Analyzing King Lear
’s Tragic Flaws Essay, Research Paper ANALYZING KING LEAR S TRAGIC FLAWS King Lear is a play about a tragic hero, by the name of King Lear, whose flaws get the best of him. A tragic hero must posess three qualities. The first is they must have power, in other words, a leader. King Lear has the highest rank of any leader.
King Lear By William Shakespeare 1564
– 1616) Essay, Research Paper Since King Lear’s setting is pre-Christian Britain, some readers chafe under the sort of nihilistic fatalism that colors the characters’ thinking (”As flies to wanton boys we are to the
King Lear4 Essay Research Paper Lear s
King Lear4 Essay, Research Paper Lear s words: I am a man/More sinn d against than sinning. is an expression of Lear s internal anguish and pain, triggered by his two evil daughters Gonerill and Regan. Surely, Lear s statement is to some degree, agreeable, since his sufferings was an result of Gonerill s and Regan s thirst for power, which led to their attack on Lear.
King Lear Essay Research Paper Animal Imagery
King Lear Essay, Research Paper Animal Imagery in King Lear In the play King Lear by William Shakespeare, a collection of images are used to express different points Shakespeare is trying to relay to his audience. One reoccurring image is that of animal images. Shakespeare incorporates these animal images when King Lear and many of the other characters in the play talk about Goneril and Regan and the animals that Lear and the other characters compare the two sisters to are not very pretty.
King Lear Essay Research Paper Imagery in
King Lear Essay, Research Paper Imagery in King Lear (King-Lear) In the immense amount of writing that William Shakespeare had done in hiscareer as a playwright and or writer in general there
King Lear Essay Research Paper King LearIn
King Lear Essay, Research Paper King Lear In the play King Lear written by William Shakespeare a collection of images are used to express different points Shakespeare is trying to relay to his audience. One reoccurring image that kept popping up was animal images. Shakespeare displays these animal images when King Lear and many of the other characters in the play talk about Goneril and Regan.
King Lear Essay Research Paper The ending
King Lear Essay, Research Paper The ending of King Lear has proven itself very controversial in its history. in shakespeare’s other play, the conclusions are simple: Othello kills himself, Macbeth is executed, ans everyone dies in hamlet. lear, however, is not as simple as the preceding, and in fact, leaves many questions unanswered.
King Lear And The Fool Essay Research
Paper Sebastian Crichton King Lear and the Fool There is much to be said of Lear and The Fool. I believe that The Fool in King Lear serves as an unbiased advisor, providing Lear with many lessons that a more powerful being would not have attempted, due to fear of the king’s wrath. The Fool had the ability to be totally honest with Lear, fore he had no rank or status to be stripped of.
King Lear Play Essay Research Paper In
King Lear (Play) Essay, Research Paper In the play King Lear, Lear reaches old age without achieving any wisdom. This statement is very true, many evidences can be found throughout the acts. For example: Lear is ignorant of the truth, he only hears what he wants to hear and he makes several rash decisions that leads to his downfall.
King Lear Essay Research Paper Many of
King Lear Essay, Research Paper Many of the passages of King Lear, particularly those between the characters of Lear, Kent, the Fool, and Cordelia, all share a common theme. The imagery of nothing, as well as that of blindness, echoes throughout the play. King Lear is in many ways about nothing. However, Kent, the Fool, and Cordelia make him more than nothing does by serving faithfully, speaking bluntly, and loving unconditionally.
Kinglearcompare And Contrast Lear And Cloucester Essay
, Research Paper In The Tragedy of King Lear, King Lear is quite cruel to his loving daughter, Cordelia. Cordelia expresses her true love for her father, and Lear disowns her. Lear makes his three daughters, Cordelia, Regan, and Goneril, tell him how great of a father and king he is, in order to own and rule a part on England.
King Lear Essay Research Paper King LearKing
King Lear Essay, Research Paper King Lear King Lear is the tale of a vain, prideful, and foolish old man who is blinded by his rage and too stubborn to mend his ways. The “self”
King Lear And The Fatal Flaw Essay
, Research Paper How central is the idea of a fatal flaw in King Lear? More than any of Shakespeare s plays, King Lear explores the concept of a fatal flaw and the terrible downfall it could lead to. It is indeed the most central idea in the play. Shakespeare shows us how one flaw in an otherwise normal person can lead to their ultimate demise.