Good morning, ladies and gentlemen! Today we’ll discuss the problem that often appears towards the manager. This is a problem of organizational choice or how to group product activities by product or by function. In other words, should all specialists in a given function be grouped under a common boss, regardless of differences in products they are involved in, or should the various functional specialists working on a single product be grouped together under the same superior.
But the aim of our presentation is not to persuade you that only one way is the right and only this way should be used in each organization. We’ll try to show you that each reorganization is temporary and manager always have to find some middle positions between that two ways of organization, he have to find some compromise. Another point I’d like to underline that all our presentation will be told from the behavioral scientist’s viewpoint.
So, during our presentation we’ll offer you some elements to consider, then we’ll talk about behaviorist’s findings on that matter and consider the example with two plants. After that we’ll summarize all our presentation and maybe give some useful advice for managers.
If that clear let me begin our presentation.
First of all we have to understand what makes those issues so difficult. It is useful to review all the criteria often relied on during making decisions. Typically, managers have used technical and economic criteria. For example, they may ask themselves “Which choice will minimize payroll costs?” or “Which will best utilize equipment and specialists. This approach shows us the real logic of traditional management and has strong support from classical school of organizational theory. The classical school theorists suggested that the manager should make the choice based on the following three criteria:
· Which approach permits maximum use of special technical knowledge?
· Which provides the most efficient utilization of machinery and equipment?
· Which provides the best hope of obtaining the required control and coordination?
As you can see there is nothing wrong with these criteria, but they fail to recognize the complex set of trade-offs involved in these decisions, cause managers often make changes that produce unanticipated results and even reduce the effectiveness of organization. For example there is an organization which few years ago shifted from a product basis to a functional basis. The reason was that it would lead to improved control of production costs and efficiencies in production and marketing. While the organization did accomplished these aims, it found itself less able to obtain coordination among its local sales and production units.
This example pinpoints the major trade-off that the traditional criteria omit. Developing highly specialized functional units makes it difficult to achieve coordination or integration among these units. On the other hand, having product units as the basis for organization promotes collaboration between specialists, but the functional specialists feel less identification with functional goals.
Now lets turn to another point of view. Behaviorists’ recent studies highlighted three other important factors about specialization and coordination. They are:
· Differentiation
· Integration
· Communication
Lets talk about these three factors in more detail. First, differentiation
, which simply means the differences in behavior and thought pattern that develop among different specialists in relation to their respective tasks. Differentiation is necessary for functional specialists to perform their jobs effectively.
Differentiation is closely related to achievement of coordination
, or what behavioral scientists call integration. This means the collaboration between specialized units or individuals.
While achievement of both differentiation and integration is possible, it can occur only when well-developed means of communication
among specialists exist in the organization and when the specialists are effective in resolving the inevitable cross-functional conflicts.
These recent behaviorists studies point to the following three questions that managers must consider when they choose between a product or functional basis of organization.
1. How will the choice affect differentiation among specialists?
2. How does the decision affect the prospects of accomplishing integration?
3. How will the decision affect the ability of organization members to communicate with each other resolve conflicts and reach the necessary joint decisions?
There appears to be a connection between the appropriate extent of differentiation and integration and the organization’s effectiveness in accomplishing its economic goals. What the appropriate pattern is depends on the nature of external factors – markets, technology and so on – facing the organization, as well as the goals themselves. The question of how the organizational pattern will affect individuals members is equally complex. Management must consider how much stress will be associated with a certain pattern and whether such stress should be a serious concern.
To explore in more detail the significance of modern approaches to organizational structuring, we shall describe one recent study conducted in two manufacturing plants – one organized by product
, the other on a functional basis
.
Другие работы по теме:
Classroom Observation Essay Research Paper My middle
Classroom Observation Essay, Research Paper My middle school observation was with a seventh-grade English class at the New Boston Middle School on February 16, 2001. Mrs. Messer was the teacher and she actually remembered me as one of her students in the same class several years ago. The assistant principal, Mary Lovelace, was the one to assign where I was to observe.
Gun Control Compair And Contrast Essay Research
Paper When it comes to guns, there are some major differences that are taken into consideration when grouping them into categories. Handguns are smaller, cancelable weapons, while Riffles are larger, non-cancelable weapons.
Chaucer 2
Chaucer – The Canterbury Tales Essay, Research Paper By far Chaucer’s most popular work, although he might have preferred to have been remembered by Troilus and Criseyde, the Canterbury Tales was unfinished at his death. No less than fifty-six surviving manuscripts contain, or once contained, the full text.
Methods Of Domination Essay Research Paper Methods
Methods Of Domination Essay, Research Paper Methods of Domination Power and domination are the driving forces in society. Throughout history, there have always been those in power and those that are dominated. Many tactics have been used to keep this cycle of domination in tact. Two of these tactics are described in Erika Apfelbaum?s Relations of Domination and Movements for Liberation: An Analysis of Power between Groups.
Hairdini Essay Research Paper Advertising
Hairdini Essay, Research Paper Advertising & Distribution Our product is the Hairdini magic styling wand, that is used for your hair to make French twists or buns or as they say ?fashionable hairstyles.? We found the product after looking in many stores and after finally giving up. Then when we had stopped looking we found the product in our home, our mother had bought it a year ago after seeing it on television.
MixedAbilities Versus SameAbilities Classrooms Essay Research Paper
Research on the social and cognitive effects of grouping students in mixed-abilities versus same-abilities classrooms is gaining increasing interest among practitioners and researchers. In hopes of attaining higher scores, many schools have adopted homogeneous ability grouping. Unlike them, our school has adopted the policy of mixed ability classes where students of different academic abilities study together in the same class.
Cadillac Essay Research Paper IntroductionNow that we
Cadillac Essay, Research Paper Introduction Now that we have looked at the Cadillac Escalade?s environment and target markets, lets look at the marketing mix to show what cadillac does to influence the demand of the Escalade.
Technology Factor Analysis Essay Research Paper The
Technology Factor Analysis Essay, Research Paper The main function of my project is to provide a means by which I can measure progress.? It will therefore have to provide resistance when it is used, and have an indicator,
Letter Of A Woman Homesteader Daughter Of
Earth, Mrs. Spring Fragrance Essay, Research Paper A person’s family can be one of the most influential forces in their life. It shapes a person’s character, values, and personality and influences their life in a positive or negative manner. What makes up a family can vary from person to person. Family could be a mother, father, and children, or it could be the people one cares about whether they are related or not.
Race In The Context Of Reading And
Writing Essay, Research Paper Race In the Context of Reading and Writing Hurston is saying in effect, I am colored but I am different from other members of my race in that I am not different from my race ( Race, Reading, and Difference 319).
Grecian Urn Essay Research Paper A Word
Grecian Urn Essay, Research Paper A Word Is Worth a Thousand Pictures? Shakespeare’s sonnet 18 (”Shall I compare thee to a summer’s day?”) and Keats’ “Ode on a Grecian Urn” were written with a common purpose in mind; to immortalize the subjects of their poems by writing them down in verses for people to read for generations to come.
Measure For Measure Essay Research Paper Shakespeare
Measure For Measure Essay, Research Paper Shakespeare’s theatrical works are generally categorized into three all encompassing groups: the uplifting comedy, the lamented tragedy, and the excruciatingly boring history play. However, things can get a little confusing when you end up with a comedy like Measure for Measure or a tragedy like Titus Andronicus.
The NonDesigner
’s Design Book Essay, Research Paper The Non-Designer s Design Book By Robin Williams I chose this book because I am very interested in the design of a page, whether it be an advertisement, invitation, or feature story. I learned some important principles to follow. This book was easy to read and understand.
Monology Vs Perfect Competition Essay Research Paper
Part 1 In a ?Perfect Competition? there are many firms that sell a product. Most likely it is a single product that they sell, competing against each other. They allow people to come in and out of the market very easily.
Algebra Essay Research Paper ALGEBRA REPORTAlgebra is
Algebra Essay, Research Paper ALGEBRA REPORT Algebra is a branch of mathematics in which letters are used to represent basic arithmetic relations. As in arithmetic, the basic operations of algebra are addition, subtraction, multiplication, division, and the extraction of roots. Arithmetic cannot generalize mathematical relations such as the Pythagorean theorem: which states that the sum of the squares of the sides of any right triangle is also a square.
Calculus Essay Research Paper Calculus
Calculus Essay, Research Paper Calculus “One of the greatest contributions to modern mathematics, science, and engineering was the invention of calculus near the end of the 17th century,”
Ads On Cigarettes Essay Research Paper
“Surgeon General’s Warning” Advertising is a technique to display a product on the market. They are also ways to sell the product. There are many different ways to advertise ones product, such as magazine articles, billboards, and television commercials. Advertising claims and basic appeals can be used to persuade the audience that their product is better then their competions product.
Ethics 2 Essay Research Paper The business
Ethics 2 Essay, Research Paper The business world is all about selling a product or service and earning money. To sell the products, especially with all the other competition in the marketplace, marketing the product through advertising, packaging, and labeling is important. With all the pressure to sell “your” product, over someone else’s product, many use deceptive and/or manipulative marketing practices.
Advertisin Essay Research Paper Advertising No Effect
Advertisin Essay, Research Paper Advertising: No Effect or Negative Effect? No effect! If someone told you to jump off of a bridge would you do it? Maybe. If they told you to destroy your life and body by smoking a cigarette, would you? Possibly. But any of these descisions you make are not forced upon you by them and they have no impact on if you do what they say or not.
Tracking Essay Research Paper Betweenclass ability grouping
Tracking Essay, Research Paper Between-class ability grouping, which is the practice of lumping children together in separate classes according to their talents and ability level, is ineffective according to many research studies. Research findings claim that, “although ability grouping may have slight benefits for students who are assigned to high track classes, these benefits are balanced by losses for students who are assigned to low-tracked classes.
Bio Essay Of Protein Synthesis Essay Research
Paper Bio Essay of Protein SynthesisThere are three stages are involved in polypeptide chain synthesis. Theyare chain initiation, chain elongation, chain termination. All three stagesrequire enzymes. Initiation and elongation also require energy which isprovided by GTP (a molecule closely related to ATP).In initiation several proteins and GTP take part in the complex processthat initiates polypeptide synthesis.
American Dream Essay Research Paper scribes the
American Dream Essay, Research Paper scribes the defeat of the American dream, and that the American ideals differ with the actual social conditions that exist in society. For the American constitutions stands for the freedom, and equality among people, but the truth of the matter is that social discrimination still exists and the grouping among the classes can never be overcome.
Product Layouts Essay Research Paper Product Layouts
Product Layouts Essay, Research Paper Product Layouts Group Technologies In today?s world of operations management, layouts of manufacturing processes play a key role in achieving and maintaining long term goals. These layouts need to be well thought out and carefully planned for they can effect the cost or producing goods and delivering services for many years into the future.
Vitamins Essay Research Paper Vitamins are a
Vitamins Essay, Research Paper Vitamins are a natural living compounds required in the diet humans eat for normal growth and maintenance of life. Vitamins function as “cofactors” in metabolisms of products in the body. Vitamins can’t replace food. Vitamins must be supplied in the diet or in the dietary supplement.
Ability Tracking Essay Research Paper IntroductionIf there
Ability Tracking Essay, Research Paper Introduction If there is one general consensus among those who analyze America’s system of education, it is that we are lacking somewhere. Whether it’s in our inner-city schools, or rural districts, there is a distinct literacy dilemma that has yet to be resolved in our schools.
Principles Of Management Essay Research Paper Management
Principles Of Management Essay, Research Paper Management is a set of activities directed at an organization’s resources with the aim of achieving organizational goals in an efficient and effective manner. The first function of management is planning and decision making. Planning is setting and organization’s goals and deciding how best to achieve them.