Captain Swing Essay, Research Paper
Captain Swing is an enjoyable collaboration between E. J. Hobsbawm and George Rude that depicts the social history of the English agricultural wage-laborers? uprising of 1830. According to Hobsbawm and Rude, historiography of the laborers? rising of 1830 is negligible. Most of what is known by the general public comes from J. L. And Barbara Hammond?s The Village Laborer published in 1911. They consider this an exceedingly valuable work, but state that the Hammonds oversimplified events in order to dramatize them. They placed too much emphasis on enclosure, oversimplified both the nature and prevalence of the ?Speenhamland System? of poor relief, and neglected the range and scope of the uprising. Hobsbawm and Rude do not claim to present any new data, and believe that the Hammonds will still be read for enjoyment, but believe that by asking different questions, they can shed new light on the social history of the movement. Therefore, this book tries to ?describe and analyze the most impressive episode in the English farm-labourers? long and doomed struggle against poverty and degradation.?
In the nineteenth century, England had no peasantry to speak of in the sense that other nations did. Where families who owned or occupied their own small plot of land and cultivated it themselves, apart from work on their lord?s farms, farmed most of Europe, England?s ?peasants? were agricultural wage-laborers. As such, both tithes and taxes hit them hard. Lords and farmers were also against tithes and taxes and tolerated or even welcomed some outcry against them. Most county leaders in 1830 agreed with the laborers, but the government in London did not.
Further, enclosure eliminated the common lands whose use had helped the very poor to live. As a result, the relationship between farmers and laborers changed to a ?purely market relationship between employer and proletarian.? At the same time, work once done by annual servants was given over to wage labor. Farmers were driven by income rather than social concerns and it was cheaper to pay a small wage for all positions and let laborers pay their own living out of it than to provide them room and board, however minimal.
The laborers were not revolutionary, however. They did not wish to overturn the traditional social order. They merely demanded the restoration of their meager rights within it. Unfortunately, they only had five forms of protest or self-defense available to them. They occasionally protested against wage cuts or demanded higher wages, grasped ever tighter to parish poor relief, resorted to crimes such as stealing food or poaching game, performed acts of terrorism such as incendiarism, and destroyed the machines which created or intensified unemployment. Threshing machines took away the standard winter labor, creating high unemployment at the worst time of year and generating an almost universal hatred of them among laborers. Of these, the most ambitious was the destruction of threshing machines, but poaching was most indicative of increasing social tensions in the villages. Theoretically, political devices such as petitions and delegations were available tools as well, but agricultural wage-laborers had neither political rights nor the experience to put them to use.
Local correspondents almost universally attributed the riots of 1830 to unemployment and harsh treatment of laborers. The winter of 1829 had been particularly hard. The unemployed, tired and hungry, knew that they would not likely survive another winter as hard. Aware of the French revolution and Britain?s own upcoming elections, which offered the promise of a Whig overthrow of the Tories, English laborers rebelled against the cause of their hunger.
Laborers destroyed their first threshing machine on the night of August 28, 1830. This became the characteristic feature of their uprising of 1830, although it was only one of many. Other forms of revolt included arson, threatening letters (signed by ?Captain Swing?), inflammatory handbills and posters, robbery, wages meetings, and assaults on overseers, parsons, and landlords. Spreading from county to county, the universal demand was for a living wage and an end to rural unemployment.
In spite of the severe living conditions suffered by the laborers and their informal support from many of those against whom they rebelled, the rioters were punished severely. Of 1,976 prisoners, 252 were sentenced to death and nineteen were actually executed. 505 were sentenced to transportation to penal colonies and 644 were imprisoned. Less than half (800) were acquitted or bound over.
The defeat of the 1830 rising did not end the laborers’ efforts, however. While some might claim that the failure of the revolt plunged the laboring class into dumb acquiescence, Hobsbawm and Rude argue that it woke the farmers and nobility to the inner strength of their hitherto silent workers.
Hobsbawm and Rude, in this collaborative effort, made use of an enormous amount of primary and secondary source material yet managed to produce an eminently readable work which looks at the rebellion from a social, rather than purely economic, point of view. I enjoyed reading this book and would recommend it to anyone who desires and in-depth description of the social causes of a rebellion by men who many believed did not have it in them to rebel.
Bibliography
Hobsbawm, E. J. and Rude, George (1975) Captain Swing. New York, NY: W.W.
Norton and Company, Inc., 384 pp.
Другие работы по теме:
Warstrider Essay Research Paper WarstriderWilliam H Keith
Warstrider Essay, Research Paper Warstrider William H. Keith, Jr. Pgs: 327 1. Do not trust anyone, even if they look harmless. In this book Dev Cameron is trying to fight the Confederations army. They have taken over many planets and recently took over New America. Along the way, Dev xenolinked with an alien species called the Naga.
Treasure Isand Essay Research Paper Robert Louis
Treasure Isand Essay, Research Paper Robert Louis StevensonA thriller… Treasure Island is guaranteed to keep you on the edge of yourseat. When I read it I sat down and read it for hours. I could barley put itdown. All 296 pages are filled with suspense, action, and power. The authormakes you feel like your right there on Treasure Island with Jim Hawkins,Mr.
The Secret Sharer Essay Research Paper The
The Secret Sharer Essay, Research Paper The Secret Sharer This book has two main characters the Captain, who is the central main character, and Leggatt, the secret sharer, whom is the competitor, along with minor characters such as the first and second shipmates. The captain narrates the story, but he is telling the story years after it actually took place.
Zoot Suit Riot Essay Research Paper Analysis
Zoot Suit Riot Essay, Research Paper Analysis of Zoot Suit Riot For my analysis paper I chose to analyze the song Zoot Suit Riot, one of the swinging hits of the Cherry Poppin Daddies. There music consists of swing and ska tunes. Zoot Suit Riot is a part swing and part rock song that made them famous. This song comes from the Daddies fourth released album named for their hit song.
Crimson Tide Essay Research Paper When Russia
Crimson Tide Essay, Research Paper When Russia rebels gain control of nuclear weapons in the USSR, the United States retaliates by deploying the USS Alabama, a nuclear submarine. Which is commanded by Captain Frank Ramsey (Gene Hackman), a veteran solider and Naval Great. Ramsey selects Lt. Commander Ron Hunter (Denzel Washington), to be his right man on this mission; Hunter is a Harvard graduate and prefers to use his brains to weapons unlike his Commanding officer.
Rock N Roll Essay Research Paper From
Rock N Roll Essay, Research Paper From jazz and boogie of the thirties moved popular music away from the light entertainment of the theater toward a more exiting and dance oriented style that made the swing era a golden age. Do to jazz moving into rhythm and blues black people were recognized for talents in music and dance.
Ecology Essay Research Paper A number of
Ecology Essay, Research Paper A number of aspects about the film, ?Captain?s Courageous? were quite interesting. The first is the gap between the rich and the working class. The second is the way the shipmates could work their way up the ladder to captain. The third aspect that interested me was the very high mortality rate.
Treasure Island Essay Research Paper The plot
Treasure Island Essay, Research Paper The plot The book “Treasure Island” is an adventure story about a boy called Jim Hawkins. He’s fifteen years old and lives in a small village, in a quiet place near the sea. His father, a very diligent person, makes his living by running an inn. It was a day in September when an old seaman came to the Inn.
A Plea For Captain John Brown Essay
, Research Paper After reading A Plea for Captain John Brown , I find it hard to decide which side to take. Knowing a little history about the subject, I originally sided against the Captain, but by reading Thoreau s essay, I am swayed the other way. He makes a very strong argument for John Brown and probably persuaded many people at the time of his writing.
Saving Private Ryan Essay Research Paper Captain
Saving Private Ryan Essay, Research Paper Captain John H. Miller John H. Miller, played by Tom hanks in the outstanding Spealburg production Saving Private Ryan, was the captain of the American Army. Miller is truly a complex and mysterious character portrayed by his unwillingness and uneasiness when discussing his past.
The Secret Sharer By Joseph Conrad Essay
, Research Paper A Captain s Metamorphosis In the short story The Secret Sharer by Joseph Conrad, the captain of the ship, the Colorado, changes from an insecure and inexperienced ship captain to a more confident and secure individual, due to his experiences with the Secret Sharer. At first, the captain is not sure of his place on the ship and does not feel right about being in charge.
Performing A Full Golf Swing Essay Research
Paper To begin executing the proper golf swing, your feet must be shoulder width apart. When gripping the club, place the club in the joints of your left fingers with the thumb pointing down the center or slightly to the right of the shaft. (This is written for the right-handed golfer, all left-handers must reverse everything).
The Secret Sharer Essay Research Paper
“The Secret Sharer” The short story “The Secret Sharer” by Joseph Conrad centers around a character of a sea captain who is insecure and has great feelings of inadequacy on his fist job as Captain of a ship. In the story the Captain befriends a fugitive by the name of Legatt who is clearly shown to be a figment of the Captains imagination rather than an actual human being.
The Swing Essay Research Paper every summer
The Swing Essay, Research Paper every summer i go to my grandpa’s house it was when i was six years old that we first took the walk across the old bridge that bridge was a special bridge
Captain
’s Letter Regarding Macbeth Essay, Research Paper Captain’s Letter Regarding Macbeth Dear Family: I beg forgiveness for the prolonged period of silence previous to this
Billy Budd Was Captain Vere Right Essay
, Research Paper Billy Budd: Was Captain Vere Right? Captain Vere makes the right decision by executing Billy Budd. If CaptainVere lets Billy live the rest of the crew might get the impression that
Symbolism In Whitman
’s OCaptain! May Cap Essay, Research Paper O Captain! My Captain! By Walt Whitman O Captain! my Captain! our fearful trip is done. The ship has weather’d every rack, the prize we sought is won,
Captain Ahab Essay Research Paper Captain AhabIf
Captain Ahab Essay, Research Paper Captain Ahab If you ever saw Captain Ahab in a dark alley, you’d probably turn and run the other way. His scarred body and wooden leg are just a couple of characteristics that show who he is. Ahab is the captain of the whaling ship Pequod, and their mission is to go on a trip and bring back as many whales as possible.
Swing Kids Essay Research Paper Swing Kids
Swing Kids Essay, Research Paper Swing Kids was a disturbing film exposing the techniques of the nazi dictatorship in Germany during the early 1900?s. Peter, the main character is a student arrested for a petty theft. he was forced to join the Hitler Jugen (Nazi youth group) in order to avoid casting suspicion on his family.
Act4 Scene 4 Essay Research Paper For
Act4 Scene 4 Essay, Research Paper For this paper, I have chosen to analyze Act 4, scene 4. Here is a synopsis of the scene: Fortinbras’s army crosses the stage, and Fortinbras drops a captain off to visit the Danish court. The captain meets Hamlet, Rosencrantz, and Guildenstern. Hamlet asks about the army, and the captain says that Norway and Poland are fighting a stupid war over a worthless piece of land.
Gold Rush Essay Research Paper Gold RushGreedWelcome
Gold Rush Essay, Research Paper Gold Rush/Greed Welcome to Greed ladies and gentlemen here is today?s contests: Cleopatre, Jack and Rebecca. You all know how to play so let?s begin. Cleopatre what would you do with 2 million dollars?
Critical Essay On Billy Budd Essay Research
Paper Critical Essay on Billy Budd Charles Reich’s assessment of the conflict in Billy Budd focuses on the distinction between the laws of society and the laws of nature. Human law says
Carl Hooper Essay Research Paper Carl Hooper
Carl Hooper Essay, Research Paper Carl Hooper: Should He Be In The West Indies Team And If So Should He Captain It? A debated topic among the West Indian cricket community right now is whether or not Carl The Prodigal Son Hooper should be in the West Indies team for the upcoming series against South Africa. More importantly, some seem to think that he should not only be recalled but that he should be also made captain.
Titanic 3 Essay Research Paper It was
Titanic 3 Essay, Research Paper It was the largest ship in its day. It was labeled unsinkable. But on April 14 and 15, 1912, many people all around the wold found out that it wasn’t. The sinking of the Titanic was most likely the worst disaster ever to occur on the Atlantic Ocean. It sank because of many mistakes made by the builders, designer, and crew.
Golf Essay Research Paper GolfFrom Tee to
Golf Essay, Research Paper Golf-From Tee to Green 0013:section007 Video analysis project Instructor: My straight left arm is my only strengths in my back swing. My major weakness was that I did not rotate my shoulders far enough. This caused my entire swing to be short and inefficient. My wrists were also in an improper position.
Rockefeller Robber Baron Or Captain Of Industry
? Essay, Research Paper Rockefeller, Robber Baron or Captain of Industry? John D. Rockefeller was the first billionaire in the United States. He owned Standard Oil Company, and was the main person to organize the oil industry. When he
Setzer Rocks The Rapids Essay Research Paper
Bill Conway MUS 306 2/18/99 On Monday February 15th Brian Setzer and his 16-piece orchestra, rolled into Grand Rapids, Michigan. I just was one of the lucky ones who were able to see him perform with legend Bob Dylan.
Captain Ahab Essay Research Paper Captain AhabCaptain
Captain Ahab Essay, Research Paper Captain Ahab Captain Ahab in the novel Moby Dick is quite a character. He is the Captain of the whaling ship the Pequod and is out on a voyage to kill the great white whale named Moby Dick. Throughout his journey on sea, Ahab maintains focus on one thing, and only one thing, killing Moby Dick.
20000 Leagues Under The Sea Essay Research
Paper Captain Nemo is, by far, the best of all the characters. He show quickness, a cunning and charming personailty. Captain Nemo is the captain of this extravagent under water ship called the Nautilus. On his ship the scavage the surface of the ocean under them in search for food, supplies, and new species of animals.
Jazz 2 Essay Research Paper The band
Jazz 2 Essay, Research Paper The band played a series of live classical jazz in the concert. Most part of the concert gave great senses of relaxation and swing feelings by elegant tunes and fantastic melodies. As an audience, I was really impressed by the modulation in tone and the conspicuous musicianship.
Titanic Essay Research Paper The Titanic and
Titanic Essay, Research Paper The Titanic and how I Survived It Hello my name is Bob Merlock; I?m one of the last surviving members of the Titanic. I?m here to tell you the story of how I got off the ship. Some people think I?m a coward for not going down with the ship, but they don?t know the hardships I went through to get off the ship.