Stanley Milgram Essay, Research Paper
Obedience is a basic part in the structure of society, and its destructiveness has been questioned throughout time. Stanley Milgram conducted an experiment to test the destructiveness of obedience; however, Diana Baumrind discredits Milgram and criticizes his experiments in her article Review of Stanley Milgram s Experiments on Obedience.
Baumrind s commentary discusses how Milgram s experiments could not make a difference in society claiming that the subjects experienced emotional harm and the procedures were carried out in an environment which could have influenced the results. Milgram s experiments were an attempt to discover the control authority has over society.
Milgram wanted to test the level of obedience in society by seeing how much pain a person would inflict on another because they were given orders. The experiment was conducted at Yale University inside a laboratory. The tests consisted of a teacher who is the subject, a learner who is an actor, and an experimenter who gives the orders. The teacher gives the learner shocks, increasing the voltage with each wrong answer, while the experimenter
watches. The learner protested the shocks by screaming and yelling. Throughout the experiments, many of the subjects argued with the authority figure due to the harm they were inflicting on the learner, but did not stop the tests fearing that they would seem disrespectful. Some of the subjects were happy with the experiment thinking they were a step which could lead
to scientific knowledge. Those that were upset with the experiment thought that due to the learners protests nothing was accomplished. A survey was taken before the experiment to see how far people thought the subjects would go. Many people believed that the subjects would be disobedient, but the results were different. Many of the subjects were actually obedient throughout the experiment. Milgram concluded that many people were able to carry out
destructive deeds because they were following orders. By obeying orders and participating in the experiment, the subjects experienced emotional harm.
Baumrind believes Milgram s treatment of the subjects was unethical; as a result, the subjects were changed, but not society. Each subject chose to participate in the experiment expecting that the psychologist would have some concern for them; however, this was not the case with Milgram and his subjects. The subject first endured emotional harm by having to inflict the learner with shocks despite his protests. Afterwards, during a conference with the experimenter, the subject was informed that there was no electrical current. The subject then feels foolish, his mind weakens, and he loses self-esteem. Milgram claims that the subject was returned to the proper state of mind after the experiment. Baumrind finds that the emotional harm endured was great and Milgram s claim that he dissipated their harm was hard to believe
(Baumrind 376). The subjects entered the experiment with hopes of being a part of discovering scientific knowledge, but left feeling foolish realizing that they were the ones being tested. Society was not changed, just the subjects. The subjects would no longer answer to authority the same way; as a result of the pain they endured and the authoritative laboratory setting.
Baumrind asserts that a laboratory setting did not accurately represent society; therefore, the experiments could not have made an impact on the public. The unfamiliar setting causes the subject to be more submissive than usual society. The subject volunteered himself to the tests; therefore, he knows he should follow through with the experimenter s orders. Milgram
concluded that by being obedient one could carry out evil deeds, such as Nazi Germany (Milgram 371). Baumrind finds his conclusion does not represent society or Nazi Germany, but only the behavior of his subjects within a laboratory.
Baumrind s article justifies her claims that the subjects endured emotional harm and the setting caused the subjects to be submissive. These points make Milgram s experiments seem unconvincing. Society was not accurately represented; therefore, there was no overall impact on
human nature. One could question how long the subjects endured pain after the experiment. The article implies, but never supports, that the subjects had emotional harm for a lengthy duration after the experiment. One could not know the emotional effect the experiment had on the subjects without a direct consultation with them. By following up on the subjects, the article
could have been more effective. Even with this weakness, the lack of influence the experiment had on society was accurately represented.
According to Diana Baumrind, Milgram s tests could not have accurately represented society. Little scientific knowledge was gained due to the setting and the negative effects experienced by the subjects. Baumrind s findings discredit Milgram and imply that society and science were not changed. The only thing that the experiment changed was the subjects attitude
towards authority. Baumrind reveals that even though the destructiveness of obedience has always been questioned, experiments such as Milgram s would never find the answer.
Другие работы по теме:
Children And Physical Punishment Essay Research Paper
“Spare the rod and spoil the child.” These famouswords are found in Proverbs 13:24 and are familiare to every parent. “Should I, or should I not?” This is one of the many questions that a parent may ask himself when his child needs phyiscal punishment.Obedience, respect, and trust are very important in a child’s life because these three qualities build character.
Holes By Louis Sachar Essay Research Paper
Holes Holes by Louis Sachar’s is a cool book. Stanley Yelnats is an unusual hero-dogged by bad luck coming from an ancient family curse. He is overweight, and unlikely to stick up for himself when challenged by the class bully; even though he is a really big kid for his age. He was in the wrong place, at the wrong time when a stolen pair of shoes lands on him after being thrown over an over pass.
Milgrams Shock Therapy Essay Research Paper Obeying
Milgrams Shock Therapy Essay, Research Paper Obeying authority in certain situations can place another individual’s health or life at stake. World War II is an example of this. A member of the German officer’s corps, when ordered to slaughter victims, had no remorse feelings about killing them due to the fact that within his mind he was acting rightly.
Sythesis OrwellHughesMilgrim Essay Research Paper DecisionsMany people
Sythesis, Orwell,Hughes,Milgrim Essay, Research Paper Decisions Many people find it difficult, if not impossible, to defy the unspoken tradition of modern authority. Stanley Milgrim s Perils of disobedience shows that an otherwise sensitive, good-natured citizen can easily be transformed into a tool, and perform actions that one would never do if given enough time to reflect.
They Know Essay Research Paper Out of
They Know Essay, Research Paper Out of my love for you is conceived only pain However that gives me some pleasure Your face reflects the night of a full moon
Stanley V Illinois Essay Research Paper Stanley
Stanley V. Illinois Essay, Research Paper Stanley v. Illinois 92 S.Ct. 1208 (1972) Nature of Case: The plaintiff is Peter Stanley. He said that his rights to equal protection of the law under the 14th Amendment have been violated. He believes that the Illinois law that makes children of unwed father?s wards of the state upon death of the mother violated his rights.
Agreeing To Disobey Essay Research Paper Blindly
Agreeing To Disobey Essay, Research Paper Blindly obeying authority often results in disobedience to one’s personal morality. Since rules were established and exist for the common interests of the general population, some would say adhering to the rules is obedient. However, when rules conflict with people’s morals, one has the right, and furthermore the responsibility to disobey.
A Streetcar Essay Research Paper Directing ConceptTennessee
A Streetcar Essay, Research Paper Directing Concept: Tennessee Williams A Streetcar Named Desire brings reality to a woman in desperate need of attention. In the production that this design team will put together from the lights to the set will be created a colorful outlook on life from the view of Blanche DuBois.
Obedience Essay Research Paper Comparison Contrast EssayIn
Obedience Essay, Research Paper Comparison/ Contrast Essay In “The Perils of Obedience” by Stanley Milgram, Milgram explains that obedience is a natural occurring behavior, which acts on instinct ignoring a persons ethics, sympathy, and moral conduct (Milgram 343). In this experiment two people come into the laboratory where they are told they will be taking part in a study of memory and learning.
Holes Essay Research Paper HolesThe book Holes
Holes Essay, Research Paper Holes The book Holes is about kids that do bad things and they get send to a detention center, Camp Green Lake. Camp Green Lake was once a very large lake, the largest lake in Texas. That was over a hundred years ago. Now it?s just a flat dry land. During the summer the temperature hovers around ninety-five degrees.
Stellar Stella Essay Research Paper Stellar StellaAfter
Stellar Stella Essay, Research Paper Stellar Stella After the reading of a play entitled A Streetcar Named Desire, written by Tennessee Williams, there was quite a discussion on what women thought of as the ideal man. Was Stanley Kawalski the type of guy women secretly yearned for their whole lives? Although many responses came up, a few questions were not mentioned: What makes the ideal woman? What is it that attracts men to women? Stanley Kawalski may be the ideal ?macho? man, but what about his wife, Stella? Upon closer investigation, I have concluded that indeed Stella is the ideal woman.
Social Control Essay Research Paper Conformityh Conformity
Social Control Essay, Research Paper Conformity h Conformity focuses upon the ways in which other people exert their influence upon us in such a way that we go along with them. For example some teenagers may go along with what their friends do when they themselves would have preferred to have gone elsewhere.
The Milgram Shock Experiment Essay Research Paper
The experiment was designed to compare German and American levels of obedience. The immoral acts of the Nazis were carried out through obedience. Milgram wanted to see if American’s would also obey and participate in a destructive process.
Was Milgram Ethical In His Obedience Studies
? Essay, Research Paper Was Milgram Ethical in his Obedience Studies? When trying to determine weather or not Stanley Milgram?s experiment on obedience vs. destructive obedience is ethical you need to know two things: One, determine a set of ethical means that Milgram must follow, in this case they were already laid out.
Conformity And Obedience Essay Research Paper Conformity
Conformity And Obedience Essay, Research Paper Conformity and Obedience The desire to be accepted and belong to a group is an undeniable human need. But how does this need affect an individual? Social psychologists have conducted numerous experiments and concluded that, through various forms of social influence, groups can change their members thoughts, feelings, and behavior.
A Streetcar Named Desire Themes Essay Research
Paper March 26, 2000 A Streetcar Named Desire: Themes The main theme of A Streetcar Named Desire is that reflected in the characters of Blanche and Stanley. The author presents the conflict between Blanche and Stanley as well as its inevitable conclusion, to criticize the extremes people envision when they consider love.
Comparison And Contrast Stanl Essay Research Paper
Lago and Stanley are villains in Othello and A Street Car Named Desire. They both plan a tragic scheme to draw the main Characters, Othello and Blanche to their “downfall” in their plays and they start it by their their hatred. Iago
The Obligation To Obey Essay Research Paper
It has been said that as long as the human species is in a living state conformity shall be part of how human society functions and part of man?s natural tendencies. The more people already agree upon or share a particular idea, the more easily a newcomer will in turn be converted to that idea, and the more difficult it will be for one already converted to reject that idea.
Dangers Of Obedience Essay Research Paper Most
Dangers Of Obedience Essay, Research Paper Most of us obey every day without a thought. In fact, since we live in a democratic society, we mechanically obey to the social norms that cause us to feel, think, and act in ways that are consistent with our group’s social standards, which describe what behaviors should and should not be performed in any social setting.
Streetcar Essay Research Paper A Streetcar Named
Streetcar Essay, Research Paper A Streetcar Named Desire In the play A Streetcar Named Desire , Tennessee Williams uses his brilliant writing to bring life to his characters in the story. I will be composing a character sketch on Stanley, one of the main actors in the play. I will focus on evaluating Stanley s ever-changing character traits in the role he plays.
The Street Car Named Desire Essay Research
Paper In the Street Car Named Desire, by Tennessee Williams, Stanley Kowalski displays his brutality in many ways. This classical play is about Blanche Dubois?s visit to Elysian Fields and her encounters with
Social Norms
– An Analysis Essay, Research Paper Social Norms : an analysisWe live in an environment that is strong with influence attempts. A large portion of the population makes a living simply attempting to get others to comply with their requests. Whether a manager encouraging productivity, a policeman directing traffic, a salesperson closing a sale, or a president telling us we need to spend more money on social programs.
Perils Of Obedience Essay Research Paper The
Perils Of Obedience Essay, Research Paper The Perils of Obedience This experiment is a test to see if people are naturally aggressive. Milgram does not believe that people are naturally aggressive. Although some people think people are naturally aggressive. Ordinary people can be part of a bad course of actions without having any anger toward then victim.
1984 Big Brother Is Watching You Essay
, Research Paper Someone has always been there to tell you what to do in life. As a young child, you were told to behave properly and not to eat too many sweets. As you grew older and older, it seemed as if the responsibilities became greater and greater in number. Even as an adult, there was always an officious boss telling you what to do.
150 Nazi Essay Research Paper 1 Hitler
150% Nazi Essay, Research Paper 1. Hitler demanded that the nation produce a “violently active, dominating, intrepid, brutal youth.” What part did the schools play in carrying out that
Rudolph Hoss True Believer Essay Research Paper
Rudolph Hoss, True Believer Death Dealer by Rudolph Hoss is a reflection and a look back on his life as the SS Kommandant at Auschwitz in the early 1940 s. Hoss was the leader of an extermination camp that gassed and killed millions of Jewish people that lived in Germany. In this book Hoss paints two very different and conflicting portraits of himself.
The Milgram Experiment Essay Research Paper The
The Milgram Experiment Essay, Research Paper The Milgram Experiment The Milgram experiment is one of Psychology?s most controversial experiments. The study examines to what extend individuals obey an authority figure, and how far they will go, even if they believe their actions are harming another individual.
Conformity And Obedience In An Enemy Of
The People Essay, Research Paper Conformity and Obedience in An Enemy of the People An Enemy of the People, by Henrik Ibsen, is the story of a man named Dr. Thomas Stockman, who becomes a deviant to society. After discovering that the waters in the town’s baths are polluted, Dr. Stockman tries to spread the news and have the baths shut down.
Streetcar Named Desire Essay Research Paper Streetcar
Streetcar Named Desire Essay, Research Paper Streetcar Named Desire In the play, Streetcar Named Desire, the author shows two different characters, who try to conceal from their true needs through hiding and fantasizing about their own way of desire. Particularly, Stella DuBois Kowalskis, who is in the middle of every conflict in the play, is doomed from using temporary solution.
Mindless Humans Essay Research Paper Humans have
Mindless Humans Essay, Research Paper Humans have been socially networked with each other since the time they have been created. Civilization was fashioned by humans interacting with one another. With this interaction with others and communal peers, ?social man is a somnambulist? (Asch 61). In other terms, when humans become social, they are really ?sleep walking?, or following the crowd, even though belief in the western world has it that people are ?free? to choose for themselves.
Are People Obedient Essay Research Paper ARE
Are People Obedient Essay, Research Paper ARE PEOPLE OBEDIENT? By Queron Thompson Does everyone in society go against what they believe in merely to satisfy an authority figure? Stanley Milgram?s ?Perils Of Obedience? expresses that most of society supports the authority figure regardless of their own personal ideals.