– Nollan Vs. CCC Essay, Research Paper
Environmental Law
Nollan vs. CCC
Abstract of:
483 U.S. 825, 97 L. Ed.2d 677
James Patrick Nollan, et
ux., Appellant
v.
California Coastal
Commission.
Case Definition:
The case is Nollan versus the California Coastal Commission. The
Nollans were the appellates against a decision made by the California
Coastal Commission (CCC).
The Nollans had been leasing a property on the California coast with
which they had an option to buy. The property lies directly at the foot
of the Pacific Ocean and is a prime piece of real estate on the
California Coast. The property had been used by the Nollans to rent out
during the summer months to vacationers. At the end of the Nollans?
lease they took the option to purchase the land and began preparing for
the terms of purchase by the previous land owner. Among those terms was
the demolishing of the small deteriorating bungalow that the Nollans had
been leasing. The Nollans had planned to expand the structure from the
small bungalow that it was to a three bedroom house more complimentary
to the surrounding homes and their needs. In order to begin destruction
of the property and begin rebuilding the site the Nollans had to secure
a permit from the California Coastal Commission. Upon submitting the
permit application, the CCC found that the permit should be granted on
the condition that the Nollans provide public access to the beach and to
the local county park, which lay adjacent to the property. This
provision called for the Nollans to use a portion of their land to be
used as a public walkway to the beach and park. The Nollans protested
to the condition, but the CCC overruled the objection and granted the
permit with the condition intact.
Case Decision:
The Nollans filed a petition to the Ventura County Superior Court
asking that the condition to supply easement be removed from their
permit. The Nollans? argument was that there was not enough evidence to
support the developments limiting of public access to the beach. The
argument was agreed upon by the court and the case was remanded to the
California Coastal Commission for a full evidentiary hearing on the
issue of public access to the beach.
The CCC held a public hearing which led to further factual findings
which reaffirmed the need for the condition. The CCC?s argument was
that the building of the new structure would limit view of the ocean,
and therefore limit access to the public who had full rights to use the
beach. To compensate for the limitations on the public the Nollans
would have to provide access to the beach from their property. The CCC
also noted that all of the other developments on the same tract of land
had been conditioned similarly in having to provide public access to the
ocean.
The Nollans filed a supplemental petition for a writ of administrative
mandamus (a writ that would order a public official or body to comply
with a specified duty issued by a superior court). The Nollans argument
was that the permit condition violated the Takings Clause in the V
Amendment, and also in the XIV Amendment of the Constitution.
The court agreed that the administrative record did not provide for in
showing the existence of adverse impact on the publics? access to the
ocean. The court granted the writ of mandamus, and directed that the
public access condition be removed from the permit.
The CCC appealed the case in the California Court of Appeal and won the
decision. The Court of Appeal found an error in the Supreme Courts
interpretation of the Coastal Act which mandates public access to any
category of developments on the coast. The Court of Appeal also found
that the Takings claim was unsubstantiated by the Nollans. The permit
condition did take from the value of the land, but did not restrict them
of reasonable use of their property.
The Nollans then appealed to the United States Supreme Court. The
argument made by the Nollans continued to revolve around the Takings
Clause in the V Amendment. The Supreme Court found that the requirement
of the permit only put a restriction on the use of the property and not
a ?taking? of the property. The Supreme Court also held the California
State Constitution to have standing, and upheld the ruling made by the
Court of Appeals.
Reasoning for Decision:
I believe that the reason the Supreme Court decided as it did was that
its interpretation of the California State Constitution provided for the
authority of the CCC?s permit regulation. The part within the states
constitution says that access to any navigable waters shall not be
limited by any person when it is required for any public purpose. The
?navigable water? clause infers the actual use of the water and not the
beach itself. The Supreme Court did not want to make a case of this for
intervening in states? constitutions is nasty business; and there was
not a big deal concerning the language of the law from either of the
parties. I think that a similar case could be argued attacking the
Constitution of the State of California concerning the navigable waters
clause. I would still have to agree with the CCC?s permit condition of
allowing public access to the beach, because I like the beach and am in
no position to purchase land bordering it so I need access.
349
Другие работы по теме:
Environmental problems in Arkhangelsk region
Threat of ecological accident as a result of business activity of the person. The industrial enterprises polluting atmosphere. Growing number of the illnesses caused by an air way and pollution of water. Environmental problems in the Arkhangelsk region.
National Environmental Policy Act Essay Research Paper
Environmental Rules & Regulations January 28, 2001 Barbara National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) Our Congress created the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) in 1969 in order to establish an environmental foundation for mankind. This policy endorses harmony between humans and the vast ecosystems surrounding them.
The Biggest Environmental Problem Essay Research Paper
The Biggest Environmental Problem The environmental problem that must be considered as the biggest, is the Global Warming. Temperature is slowly increasing all over the world. To understand this better it is also important to explain the greenhouse effect.
Environmental Economic Impact Of Pollution In Chesapeake
Bay Essay, Research Paper Environmental Economic Impact of Pollution in the Chesapeake Bay The Chesapeake Bay is the nation’s largest estuary with six major tributaries, the James, the Potomac, the Susquehanna, the Patuxent, the York, and the Rappahannock Rivers, feeding into the bay from various locations in Maryland, Virginia, Pennsylvania, and the District of Columbia (Chemical Contaminants in the Chesapeake Bay – Workshop Discussion 1).
The Innocence Of The Child Essay Research
Paper , has both good and evil sides. However, it is because of different environmental factors that bring out his evil side, eventually making Dick Prosser go ramped throughout the town. El, has both good and evil sides. However, it is because of different environmental factors that bring out his evil side, eventually making Dick Prosser go ramped throughout the town.
Medical Advancement Essay Research Paper
“This could be revolutionary in terms of environmental health,” Richard Jackson, director of the National Center for Environmental Health, told reporters. “For the first time, we’ve profiled what is in people.”
Environmental Archaeology Essay Research Paper IF
Environmental Archaeology Essay, Research Paper IF we want to know how humans functioned we must know what their world was like ? thus environmental reconstruction Geomorphical and biological processes occurring
Marketing Essay Research Paper FOREWORDThe first time
Marketing Essay, Research Paper FOREWORD The first time I visited an IKEA-store was in Elisabeth, New Yersey, The U.S. The year was 1995 and I still rember the joy and excitement when I entered the building. It was huge and it
Environmental Scanning Essay Research Paper This paper
Environmental Scanning Essay, Research Paper This paper will discuss environmental scanning, marketing procedures, and describe how the environment affects marketing in relation to the automobile detailing business.
Environmental Debate
– 2000 Essay, Research Paper After following the elections and debates between Al Gore and George W. Bush for quite some time, I found that they each have their own separate views on ?helping? the environment. On one side, the democratic representative who has been dubbed the ?environmental extremist? seems to understand much about the earth?s current state.
Environmental Management And Audits Essay Research Paper
AN ENVIRONMENTAL AUDIT: WHAT IT IS AND WHAT IT IS NOT An Audit is not the same as an Inventory Many people can confuse an audit with an inventory. The one vital difference between the inventory and an audit is that the inventory is concerned only with the environment, whereas an audit concerns the relationship of a community.
Societal Marketing Concept Essay Research Paper The
Societal Marketing Concept Essay, Research Paper The societal marketing concept holds that the organisation should concentrate on the needs and wants of their customers, and then deliver the desired satisfactions more effectively and efficiently than competitors, in a way that maintains or improves the consumer’s and the society’s well-being.
Environmental Apocalypse Essay Research Paper Environmental Apocalypse
Environmental Apocalypse Essay, Research Paper Environmental Apocalypse The environment is in a terrible condition and although an environmental apocalypse is not imminent we are definitely headed down that road. Some of the reasons for our Earth s trouble are overpopulation, consumerism, and overconsumption.
Ngos Help Or Hindrance Essay Research Paper
NGOs: Help or Hindrance? In his article, John McCormick establishes that the number of NGOs present in the world today probably exists well into the six figures (P. 60). Assuming that the role of NGOs is to keep governmental organizations in check when it comes to environmental issues, it frustrated me to think that there actually could be such problems with environmental issues.
Epa Essay Research Paper Environmental Protection AgencyDuring
Epa Essay, Research Paper Environmental Protection Agency During the 1970?s Richard Nixon took office. His administration had many goals for the future. During these years people were ready to change the way our society was going by helping the environment. Before it could get any worse the government decided to form an environmental protection agency after chemical pesticides were used.
Enviromental Systems In A Row Essay Research
Paper Environmental systems analysis of 2358 Flora St I chose to analyze an old three-story row house in Clifton. It happens to be the place I am subleasing currently. Although I have not had too much time to spend in it, since I spend all of my time in studio, I have noticed some major problems in the design and implementation of the environmental systems.
ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE Essay Research Paper Ch 1
ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE Essay, Research Paper Ch. 1 introduction: sustainability, stewardship, sound science A. The global environmental picture – population growth, degradation of soils, global atmospheric changes, loss of biodiversity
Intelligence Essay Research Paper Intelligence hereditary
Intelligence Essay, Research Paper Intelligence: hereditary or acquired? Is intelligence determined primary by heredity or by the environment? This issue has aroused intense debates because many believe it has a little bit of both, but to what extent? The ones that believe that believe that every person is born with a fixed amount of intelligence argue that there is little one can do to improve intelligence, so special education programs should not be expected to produce an increase in the children?s IQ.
Environmental protection in Ukraine
Our civilisation has gone so far in its development and polluted the environment to such an extend that it is very difficult to reverse it to primordial nature that is why the topic of environmental protection is very actual facing Ukraine today.
Genetically Altered Food Essay Research Paper Environmental
Genetically Altered Food Essay, Research Paper Environmental sctence Genetically Altered Foods It is quite evident that as technology advances m the scientific sense, we as Americans are becoming more interested. One of the conflicts that have raised concern here lately is that on genetically altered foods.
Environmental Scarcity Essay Research Paper Conflict From
Environmental Scarcity Essay, Research Paper Conflict From Environmental Scarcity or Lust For Wealth? In “Environmental Scarcities and Violent Conflict,” Thomas F. Homer-Dixon writes about the possible conflicts that are caused by environmental scarcities, using three different hypotheses’s to do so.
Sexual Harassment Essay Research Paper In Gretchen
Sexual Harassment Essay, Research Paper In Gretchen Morgenson?s essay ?Sexual Harassment Is Overestimated?, Morgenson discusses how 38% of sexual harassment cases have been confirmed according to The New York Times/CBS toll. There are two types of harassment: quid pro quo harassment, in which career or job advancement is guaranteed in return for sexual favors, and environmental and environmental harassment, which unwelcome sexual conduct ?unreasonable interferes with an individual?s working environment or creates an ?intimidating, hostile, offensive working environment.
Epa Essay Research Paper Environmental Protection AgencyThe
Epa Essay, Research Paper Environmental Protection AgencyThe Environmental Protection Agency, (EPA) in Edison, New Jersey is very successful in detecting and separating elements found in water. With it s expensive machinery and skilled workers the EPA proved to be successful in making New Jersey s drinking water safe.
Exxon Valdez Oil Spill
– An Environmental Disaster? Essay, Research Paper The Exxon Valdez Oil SpillAn Environmental Disaster?Presentation byDr. Ed Gilfilan Dr. Gilfilan?s presentation was about the studies that he did after the spill of theExxon Valdez. The Exxon Valdez ran aground on Bligh Reef and spilled 11,000,000 gallons ofoil into the Prince William Sound in Alaska.
Everglade Dilemma Essay Research Paper Everglade DilemmaThe
Everglade Dilemma Essay, Research Paper Everglade Dilemma The worlds systems of life are of such complexity that even modern man can’t fully understand and predict it. The common word for this is Mother Nature and the question is the mystery of life. Life was created by a specific set of environmental and geologic features present at the same time.
Environmental Conflicts In Literature Essay Research Paper
Conflicts are a very prominent element in literature. If you were to look up the dictionary definition of ?conflict?, you would find that it is a ?struggle, controversy, or fight.? Conflicts can take many forms, and each has its own place in literature. Environmental conflicts are certainly one of the more recognized and appreciated types of conflicts.
Environmental Racism Essay Research Paper There is
Environmental Racism? Essay, Research Paper There is a political theory of justice that was created by John Rawls that states, that all rational members of society in the original position should make decisions. Rawls called this method as a ?veil of ignorance.?
Epa Oil Spill Program Essay Research Paper
EPA Oil Spill Program Overview Welcome to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s Oil Spill Program. This website provides information about the U.S. EPA’s program for preventing, preparing for, and responding to oil spills that occur in and around inland waters of the United States.
Community Service Essay Research Paper Andrea OldhamCommunity
Community Service Essay, Research Paper Andrea Oldham Community Service Up to this date I haven’t participated in much community service, but once I get settled in a new home with my degree in environmental sciences, I plan to volunteer for a non-profit environmental organization, and this will be my job or career.