Essay, Research Paper
Frankl and Beckett: An Comparison of Existetialism
Parallel tracks are not better or worse, merely different. Luke Skywalker
A man is running through a tunnel; it is long and dark. He does not remember entering, he does not know when or where the next turn is, yet he proceeds. He proceeds, but to where? He has the freedom to choose where to go: the entrance, the end, to backtrack a few paces, or to stay put. Viktor Frankl, author of Man s Search for Meaning and existentialist thinker, would say it is necessary to move forward. The man must know his drive, his desire to reach the end, or he will never see the light. He will die, unfulfilled and in the dark. Samuel Beckett, author of Waiting for Godot and fellow existentialist, would say that the journey through the tunnel has no meaning. Any meaning the man ascribes to his trip would be absurd. The only meaning that could come to the man would be for someone to break the tunnel down and show him true existence. Frankl and Beckett: two thinkers branded existentialists but each with a very different approach to finding meaning.
Existentialism is a way of looking at life. It is pessimistic, dank, dark, and angst-ridden at best. It promotes things like isolation and nothingness as key factors in human life. That is not to say that there is no happiness in life, but that both sides of the coin have no meaning. Whether one is happy or sad is meaningless, and it absurd to think otherwise. Another trait of existentialism is the concept of freedom/responsibility of choice. Whereas some philosophies regard man as a separate entity from the world or as an observer, existentialism says man is an active participants. People are in the world not of the world . People make choices; those choices affect the way things are and where our lives go. However, the meaning, drive, and outcome of these choices are what come into question when reading Frankl and Beckett. While both support the similar themes of existentialism, they find meaning in different places.
Victor Frankl was a victim of the Nazi concentration/extermination camps of World War II. He experienced first hand isolation, nothingness, and the absurdity of his existence. Yet he established a form of psychiatry based on the concept of knowing one s meaning. Not only was Frankl isolated by race/faith/gender when sent to the camps, he was isolated from the world because of hatred. Frankl was stripped of all possessions and connections to his life before the camps; he was left with nothing but his mere existence. He was in a place that put no value on human existence. He became a tool, an animal, an instrument for completing a task and was to be discarded when no longer efficient . Where is the hope, where is the meaning? What freedom of choice exists to a prisoner? The choice is to live. Frankl says it is the first part of surviving, and the second part is the intervention of Fate, another existential theme. One must have the will to survive, the will to find meaning, if one is to have a hope of survival.
From his experiences, Frankl developed logotherapy, a unique brand of psychiatry that Frankl describes as introspective rather than retrospective (Frankl 120). Logotherapy takes patients and has them focus on giving their lives a meaning. One is to find what is most important to them, and in doing so the person finds a meaning for his life. It is desire that separates humans from the fixed observers of the world like rocks and trees; it is drive that allows people to put purpose in the things they do. Instead of saying life is meaningless, Frankl proposes the idea that a person must ascribe his own meaning to life, and each person s life, each person s meaning will be different. As Bruce Lee said: There is no fixed teaching. All I can provide is an appropriate medicine for a particular ailment. Frankl may have agreed that life begins meaningless, but it is through knowing one s purpose that one can give life meaning.
Samuel Beckett, however, gives a much different answer to the question What is the meaning of life? Beckett calls human existence absurd and meaningless. Whereas Frankl says man must ascribe the meaning to the journey, Beckett states any meaning man gives to life is artificial and as meaningless and the one who ascribes it. Beckett implies with his play, Waiting for Godot, that an unknown force puts us here or there or somewhere or nowhere. Some have come to call this force God , and real meaning must come from him. God is outside the meaninglessness of the life imposed upon man, and as the detached observer, only he can provide a true meaning to life. The four characters in Waiting for Godot represent four types of people: Vladimir is the questioner, focused on finding his purpose in life. Estrogon, his companion through dependence and fate, is a man who shrugs off reality by filling life with meaningless, menial chores. Pozzo, the self-absorbed slave driver, is content as long as he is above everyone else and everyone else knows it. Lucky is the broken man, a slave who, like Estrogon, has no grasp or care for what is going on, or where he is going next. But none of them seeks out their meaning, as Frankl would have them do. All four seem to think their meaning will come to them if they wait long enough. Chance and Fate will surely intervene.
This is where both authors have come to agree. The will to survive is only half the battle. If Fate does not intervene on one s behalf, then the game is over. Beckett says Fate must intervene. Chance determines existence. Beckett states it best on page 8 where Vladimir is discussing the parable of the two thieves crucified with Jesus. He says, One of the thieves was saved. It’s a reasonable percentage From there, Vladimir goes on about how only one of the four Evangelists mentions the thief being saved at all. From a 100% chance of being saved, the percentage is reduced to 50% and then to 25%. Beckett, a Christian existentialist, believed that meaning came from an external force, God. By citing the Bible and showing how even it reduces the route of life to chance, he illustrates how important the role of Fate is in existing and in knowing one s meaning in life.
Both Frankl and Beckett have different conclusions as to where meaning must come from. They agree, however, on the free choice man has in the search for meaning. Whether the person going through the tunnel chooses to run, walk, stand, or sit, the choice and its repercussions are the sole responsibility of that man. They also agree in that waiting for meaning to come does one no good. Waiting for liberation, for God to bestow a meaning, for the suffering to end, will give not bring even a meaningless existence; it will bring the end of one s existence. Lastly, they both agree that the tunnel does end. A chance-driven existence of struggle and transcendence or of isolation and meaninglessness must end one day. The differences lie in the journey and how the void between entrance and exit is filled.
Другие работы по теме:
Aging Essay Research Paper During a story
Aging Essay, Research Paper During a story, an author sometimes chooses to include his opinions on certain important issues, such as aging. This applies to Samuel Beckett?s short story, Krapp?s Last Tape. In this story an old man named Mr. Krapp, relives his life through a sort of audio journal that he has kept through the years.
Krapp In Krapps Last Tape Essay Research
Paper by Samuel Beckett During the course of our lives, we tend to look back on our past. We remember the good times and the bad times. But sometimes, the past is something we don?t want to go back to. In Krapp?s Last Tape, Krapp is an old man who looks back on his life and concludes that he wouldn?t want those years back.
Camus Philosophy As Revealed In L
’etranger Essay, Research Paper In L Etranger, Camus uses Mersaults experiences such as his mothers death, killing the Arab, the trial, and his interactions with other characters throughout the novel to convey his philosophy, which satisfies all principals of existentialism.
Waiting For Sisyphus Essay Research Paper Every
Waiting For Sisyphus Essay, Research Paper Every mind has struggled with Existentialism. Its founders toiled to define it, philosophers strained to grasp it, teachers have a difficult time explaining it. Where do these Existentialists get the right to tell me that my one and only world is meaningless? How can a student believe that someone was sitting in jail and figured out that our existence precedes our essence? Existentialism places man in the center of his own universe; free to make his own choices and decide his purpose.
Waiting For Godot Essay Research Paper The
Waiting For Godot Essay, Research Paper The Play about Nothing Waiting for Godot has been a subject of my thoughts for about two weeks now. While considering the work, its author, and the comments I have found about the play, I have come up with three hypotheses as to the meaning and overall theme. Either it is about Humanity waiting for a savior that does exist to return; or it could be about the hopelessness of Humanity waiting for a savior that doesn’t exist, and therefore will never come; or, the easiest of possibilities, that Waiting really has no theme at all.
Existentialism A WorldView Essay Research Paper Existentialism
Existentialism: A WorldView Essay, Research Paper Existentialism: A WorldView Existentialistic thought is predominately a 20th century revelation. As a philosophy, it states that man possesses free will over his fate and the direction he wants his life to take. Those who follow this believe they are in a world that does not always make sense, a world that is filled with uncertainty where well intended actions can become obscure and chaotic.
Waiting For Godot Essay Research Paper Who
Waiting For Godot Essay, Research Paper Who is Godot and what does he represent? These are two of the questions that Samuel Beckett allows both his characters and the audience to ponder. Many experiences in this book expand and narrow how these questions are viewed. The process of waiting comforts the characters in Beckett’s play that they do indeed exist.
Existentialism Essay Research Paper When the word
Existentialism Essay, Research Paper When the word “existentialism” is mentioned, what comes to mind? Lack of faith? Secular beliefs? It is a belief in living life. Could it be any simpler than that? Existentialists believe in free will, making choices, and living with those consequences. This is not some kind of weird “hippy” philosophy; it makes sense.
Waiting For Godot Essay Research Paper Existentialists
Waiting For Godot Essay, Research Paper Existentialists believe, in short, that life is pointless and man petty and miserable. Though existentialism covers many topics the beliefs about religion remain some of the more notable. Samuel Beckett embraces the idea that religion is absurd, irrational and pointless.
Logotherapy By Dr Viktor E Frankl Essay
, Research Paper Logotherapy, practiced and described by Dr. Viktor E. Frankl, is a form of psychotherapy that requires individuals to assume responsibility for their own existence to search for meaning. Dr. Frankl, himself a prisoner in a Nazi concentration camp during World War II, developed this psychotherapeutic method as a means to endure the horror and suffering he witnessed and endured in the camp.
Happiness Essay Research Paper
HarleyHall1st hr. Happiness Happiness, word that brings forth both joys, and at the same time miseries. Hedonism, anything that brings joy or pleasure to an individual, brings many responsibilities that society in is not prepared to take on. There are many reasons that happiness is an unrealistic goal in society.
Existentialism Essay Research Paper Existentialism has been
Existentialism Essay, Research Paper Existentialism has been defined as a philosophical movement or tendency, emphasizing individual existence, freedom and choice that influences many diverse writers in the 19th and 20th centuries. The philosophical term existentialism came from Jean Paul Sartre, a French philosopher.
Existentialism 2 Essay Research Paper ExistentialismExistentialism is
Existentialism 2 Essay, Research Paper Existentialism Existentialism is one of the fastest growing worldviews in the world. Its new age ideas and down to earth thinking makes it very easy to follow, but as with all world views there are obvious flaws which cannot be hidden. Christianity expresses extremely different views to those of Existentialism.
Reflections Of An Era Essay Research Paper
Samuel Beckett wrote Waiting for Godot in the late 1940’s, in Paris, France. As a man who lived through the horrors of WWII Beckett often questioned the meaning of existence and the possibility of a God. These two ideas were sown into his paly Waiting for Godot.
Happy Days Essay Research Paper Samuel Beckett
Happy Days Essay, Research Paper Samuel Beckett s Happy Days is to be read anyway but literal. Beckett uses his brilliance to create an allegory for human condition. Winnie babbling away pretends that she has created an order out of her odd predicament. The play abandons realism and takes on the role of an optimistic idealism.
Waiting For Godot By Samuel Beckett Essay
, Research Paper Samuel Beckett was born in Ireland in 1906. His family was both relatively well to do and fairly eccentric. Athletic and imposing, Beckett was also awkward and socially maladjusted. This all comes to play in “Endgame” where we see the twisted remains of two
What Is Existentialism Essay Research Paper From
What Is Existentialism? Essay, Research Paper From what I understand reading Jean-Paul Sartre’s work the Existentialism is philosophy that places emphasis on individual existence, subjectivism, and freedom of making choice.
Vladimir And Estragon A Symbol Of
Man Essay, Research Paper AP EnglishJanuary 19, 1999 Vladimir and Estragon: A Symbol of Man Many Authors use different techniques in their wittings. Samuel Beckett usesallusions and references to characters to help the reader understand what the charactersrepresent. In his drama Waiting for Godot, Beckett s two main characters, Estragon andVladimir, are symbolized as man.
Walking Around Essay Research Paper Walking AroundPablo
Walking Around Essay, Research Paper Walking Around Pablo Neruda gives us a good example of Vanguard Literature in his poem Walking Around. We can see the influence of surrealism in the poem because it does not rhyme at all, instead is an effort to express feelings and emotions in a free style. We can also see the existentialism idea as Neruda is bold and tells us everything that is in his mind.
Untitled Essay Research Paper Man
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Man’s Search for Meaning; Victor Frankl Eric D. Clower Man?s Search for Meaning: Viktor E. Frankl ?He who has a why to live for can bear any how.? The words of Nietzsche begin to explain Frankl?s tone throughout his book. Dr. Frankl uses his experiences in different Nazi concentration camps to explain his discovery of logotherapy.
Victor Frankl Essay Research Paper
To comprehend the unfaltering love of Victor Frankl, we mustunderstand his circumstances. There is no way we can step into his shoes toexperience his tragedies, but his vivid descriptions help us vicariously relivehis tribulation. He opens a window into his world, and we can actually see thescenes he paints for us. ?The accompanying guards kept shouting at us anddriving us with the butts of their rifles,? he says (348).
Significance Of Themes Essay Research Paper Significance
Significance Of Themes Essay, Research Paper Significance of Themes 1. God One of the main theme’s that is displayed throughout Waiting For Godot is the idea that life on earth is more or less a long and confusing wait for God. This theme magnifies the idea that the infamous Godot is actually God and that the play is built upon a structure of Christian morals.
Existentialism In American Lit Essay Research Paper
Existentialism in American Literature “I must find a truth that is true for me, the idea for which I can live or die,” (Sfren Kierkegaard). Being the first acknowledged existentialist, Kierkegaard s ideas set the standards. Existentialist ideas are based mainly on the individual, his plights, and his confrontations.
Endgame By Samuel Beckett Essay Research Paper
As stated by Cohn in her article ” ‘Endgame’: The Gospel According to Sad Sam Beckett” there is much evidence given relating to the many comparable instances between the Bible and Beckett’s Endgame. With this interpretation as well as the discussion about the significance of the title, and the constant reference to the end of the world, it is nearly impossible to see Beckett’s Endgame as anything other than a post-apocalyptic tale.
Vladimir And Estragon A Symbol Of Man
Essay, Research Paper AP English January 19, 1999 Vladimir and Estragon: A Symbol of Man Many Authors use different techniques in their wittings. Samuel Beckett uses
Man S Search For Meaning Essay Research
Paper Man s Search For Meaning Victor E. Frankl who wrote Man s Search For Meaning, talks a great deal about suffering throughout the book. One of the main topics he discusses in regard to suffering is that of hope. Without hope then there would be no point in anyone enduring the suffering with which they endured during these nazi concentration camps.
Chance In Waiting For Godot Essay Research
Paper Chance in Waiting for Godot Chance plays a major role in Samuel Beckett s tragic comedy Waiting for Godot . In human life, chance rather than reason is the main influence on our lives. According to Beckett, life of humans is completely dependent on chance and as a result of this time would be meaningless.
Free Will Essay Research Paper Free WillBy
Free Will Essay, Research Paper Free Will By Jeffrey Shamberger Analyzing our individual free will can be very intriguing and can almost reach the point of being paradoxical. Ultimately, free will determines the level
Dave Matthews Existential Essay Research Paper The
Dave Matthews Existential Essay, Research Paper The Existentialism of Dave Matthews BandRhyme and Reason Existentialism is the main theme throughout the song Rhyme and Reason by Dave Matthews Band. Matthews cites the ideas of dying and the pointlessness of life in general within the song. His ideas follow the basic pattern of existentialism thinking.
Discussion Of Waiting For Godo Essay Research
Paper Discussion Paper #7 Waiting for Godot Samuel Beckett s Waiting for Godot is a play without meaning. Vladimir (Didi) and Estragon (Gogo) go on for pages with meaningless jibber-jabber. The setting is an obscure place with no distinguishable characteristics; there is only a tree and a road to decorate the mundane landscape.