Ebonics 3 Essay, Research Paper
This week s reading about race questioned the common idea of what race is. Most people would think of race as a physical, concrete identity stemming from ancestry. Superficial qualities, such as skin color, dominate the common views of race. Fields, however, throws out the idea of race being a concrete entity, and instead says that race is purely ideological. It is something brought about by social issues and concerns, and is entirely socially and historically constructed as an ideology in a way that class is not. Because people really do concretely own or not own land and workplaces, class has ‘objective’ dimensions. Though not at all valid, the objective dimension of race is what I said earlier skin color. Moreover, race is constructed differently across time by people in the same social class and differently at the same time by people whose class positions differ. Though it is crucial for us to recognize and appreciate the vast differences across our different cultural heritages, these differences should not be addressed in a way that will separate everyone into white , black , asian , et cetera. This is the root of racism, the fact that we are all different based on which box we check on a questionnaire.
This brings me to the matter of Ebonics — a word derived from the marriage of “ebony” with “phonics” — which members of the Oakland School Board first used in 1996 to describe the speech dialect of some Americans of African descent. The idea came up that if teachers were certified via special training in Ebonics (which was formerly called Black English), they would more easily be able to help the African-American students who were having problems mastering standard English.
On December 18, 1996, the Board of Education of Oakland, California, passed a resolution concerning Ebonics . I will go through a few of the interesting WHEREAS s of this resolution, each with a comment on its particulars .
WHEREAS, numerous validated scholarly studies demonstrate that African-American students as a part of their culture and history as African people possess and utilize a language described in various scholarly approaches as “Ebonics” (literally “Black sounds”) or “Pan-African Communication Behavior” or “African Language Systems”; and
** If a linguistic system of expression is called a “language,” a user of that system is given a certain amount of respect, whereas a user of a “dialect” will be scorned and pressured in many ways to conform to the dominant language. This makes a big difference in education and an even bigger difference in the economic world of marketing and employment. It also makes a big difference in terms of Federal law, where grant money is available to teach students whose native languages are “not English,” but NOT for students who speak a “dialect.”
WHEREAS, these studies have also demonstrated that African Language Systems are genetically based and not a dialect of English; and
**Genetically based? We all know that since our parents are English-speaking, we are automatically predisposed to speak the same language. It is unarguable that a particular speech pattern or “language” is a learned behavior. Nobody is born already able to speak; we have to be taught. Children who are not taught to walk learn by themselves, and everybody walks pretty much the same way. Children who are not taught to speak develop languages of their own, which have no resemblance at all to the language of their biological parents. We know this from the experiences of feral children and from experiments done in earlier centuries where newborns were taken from their mothers and raised in environments where nobody spoke to them at all. Since these isolated children tended to develop some language, we can draw the conclusion that the tendency toward language is genetically based, but there is absolutely no evidence to show that African genes predispose a person to speak English in a particular way. In fact, the numerous people of African descent who can read, write and speak flawless Standard American English are living proof of the opposite.
WHEREAS, the interests of the Oakland Unified School District in providing equal opportunities for all of its students dictate limited English proficient educational programs recognizing the English language acquisition and improvement skills of African-American students are as fundamental as is application of bilingual education principles for others whose primary languages are other than English; and
**Like I said before, is it really a language that is completely non-English, or is it rather a dialect? Some would say it is simply an accent that originated with slave times. Sure there are different sounding word structures, but do we change the spelling of words for those with a thick southern accent?
**This one also goes along with the idea that Black English is its own separate
language ..
WHEREAS, the standardized tests and grade scores of African-American students in reading and language arts skills measuring their application of English skills are substantially below state and national norms and that such deficiencies will be remedied by application of a program featuring African Language Systems principles in instructing African-American children both in their primary language and in English; and
No matter how I’ve tried to understand the logic of declaring Ebonics a language, I can’t escape the view that the effort is demeaning to American children of African descent. It is one thing to “get down to it” with friends and with family members in the privacy of your own group and speak in the familial and folksy matter that allows you to identify with the cultural roots of a treasured historical past. It is quite another thing to try to elevate the folksy dialect to the level of a language because you think you are better able to reach and educate the children who use it or to justify getting federal money for doing it.
Because this isn t simply intended to be an anti-Ebonics rant, there are some points that I do think could be thought of as beneficial. Though not as evident here in Minnesota as it is in Oakland, I do realize that it is sometimes hard for teachers of standard English to understand everything their students say, whether they use Black English or a mixture of English and some other language. If you want to teach English to Russian-speaking students, surely you will acknowledge that you will have a tremendous advantage if you know some Russian. You will be able to compare and contrast much more effectively, whether you are working on phonetics or grammar. Why shouldn’t that same principle apply to those who try to teach English to speakers of Black English? I think it does, but because I don t consider Black English to be a language, per se, I don t feel it should be addressed by teaching teachers how to talk black . Supposedly there are over 100 languages being spoken in California. Can you imagine the difficulty of running an educational system that was founded on the principle that all children should be instructed in the language they learned from their parents in their first 5 years?
I think the move for Ebonics exaggerates the misunderstanding that many politically correct professional educators have learned regarding how children learn. The success of a child must be modeled after the best and the brightest this nation has produced. American education must get back to basics and stop experimenting with every educational fad that appears on the scene.
Ebonics is a very substantial means to separate blacks from quote-un-quote mainstream society . I m sure all of you have heard ebonics jokes, and most of us even find them rather amusing. It would be easy for an ignorant person to assume all black people speak in this separate language , generating yet another stereotype in this country of black versus white. I don t believe Fields would be a very big proponent of ebonics based on this very idea. As she thinks that race is socially-constructed, so are the inherent differences between whites and blacks. I m willing to bet that just like she said about race, she would also say that a language exclusive to those with dark skin is ‘a notion that is profoundly – and in its very essence ideological .
Другие работы по теме:
Tanning Beds Essay Research Paper Tanning BedsSalonsWhat
Tanning Beds Essay, Research Paper Tanning Beds/Salons What exactly is tanning? Tanning is your body?s natural response that occurs when your skin is exposed to ultraviolet radiation (UV) such as the sun. Exposure to UV radiation from sunlamps and beds can add to the total amount of UV radiation you can receive in your lifetime.
Los Dias Essay Research Paper Lindsay Thibault
Los Dias Essay, Research Paper Lindsay Thibault 10-20-00 Project #4 Computer Graphic Los Dias de la Semana (The Days of the Week) I would use this in a second grade classroom (eight-years-old), so students could practice the days of the week in Spanish. Towards the beginning of the school year, I would spend time teaching the students the days of the week in Spanish by going over them every morning.
Da Peoplz Language Essay Research Paper I
Da Peoplz Language Essay, Research Paper I wuz goin to da markit ta pik up sum food, when I said “yo G, wus up wit you.” He got pot an dope all ova ‘is coat, he got unuf *censored* ta fill up a boat. He took out a joint an a huge-ass gat, I said,”Yo man, thas phat!” He gave it ta me so I could look at it, and I said, ” yo, ware dyou get dat *censored*?” He tol me ware he got it, an got my ass ova dare, but wen I arived, it wuz a *censored*in nightmare. big tuf guys all ova da plase, I got scared, so grabbed my mace.
Sexual Abuse Essay Research Paper I have
Sexual Abuse Essay, Research Paper I have decided to do my paper on the repression of sexual abuse in adults. In my research though I came across a lot of things that I didn?t agree on.
Up My Ghan Essay Research Paper protection
Up My Ghan Essay, Research Paper protection because the total revenue did not exceed the variable costs that was incurred in the barial of people that wish to be baried in their cementary. Article #1 Date: November 2, 1999
La Madeleine Church Essay Research Paper La
La Madeleine Church Essay, Research Paper La Madeleine is a church in Paris that started during the reign XV, and designed by Constant d’Ivry using plans based on the St-Louis-des-Invalide church.
HOOKED ON EBONICS Essay Research Paper 15
HOOKED ON EBONICS Essay, Research Paper 15 Feb 97 dayz: Today?s Lesson: Hooked on Ebonics: 15 Feb 97 dayz: Today?s Lesson: Hooked on Ebonics: Leroy is a 20 year old 9th grader. This be Leroy?s homework assignment. He must use each vocabulary word in a sentence.
Ebonics Essay Research Paper Ebonics or Black
Ebonics Essay, Research Paper Ebonics, or Black English, was recently a controversial topic in the United States, when the Oakland School District school board attempted to classify ebonics as a completely different language from Standard American English (SAE). There was further controversy when the school board stated that ebonics was genetic.
Hazards In Placentia Essay Research Paper Hazards
Hazards In Placentia Essay, Research Paper Hazards in Placentia Earthquakes are probably the number one hazard that affects my area. I live about six to seven miles from the Whittier Fault and about 16-18 miles from the Newport Inglewood Fault. Just about a week or two ago, we experienced an earthquake around 2:30 a.m.
Lacrosse Essay Research Paper During spring break
Lacrosse Essay, Research Paper During spring break I went to the beautiful state of Arizona where me and my father were going to play golf all week long. We stayed with my dads old college friends. Well me
William Blake Essay Research Paper This week
William Blake Essay, Research Paper This week I was scheduled to work with Irene Balli. She is one of dining services main managers. She mostly oversees all of the banquets that go on here at Marywood. On the 16th of April was the Cor Marie, which is a very large banquet that consists of all major heads of all departments at Marywood.
Weekend Catastrophique Essay Research Paper L
Week-end Catastrophique Essay, Research Paper Lґйtй dernier je suis allй le Dordoigne, dans le sud de France, avec mes parents, ma sœur et mes amis : Chris et Ben. Nous sommes allйs en avion et en le bus. Je joue au football sur la plage avec mon pиre et Ben. Je tombй et jґai cassй mon poignet. Mon pиre а pris moi au lґhospital.
Traffic Essay Research Paper Questions to Consider2
Traffic Essay, Research Paper Questions to Consider 2. You are the city manager of a medium sized city. In an effort to reduce traffic congestion and improve air quality, you encourage workers to form car pools or choose other alternative ways of traveling to work. What kind of incentives might be effective for getting people to change their habits?
Reflection Essay Essay Research Paper My Reflection
Reflection Essay Essay, Research Paper My Reflection EssayBeing the billionth paper that I wrote in this class, I thought my observational essay was pretty good. It had decent wording in it, consisted of many different techniques of writing, and was just overall well written.To write this paper, I started a week in advance.
Ebonics Essay Research Paper One of the
Ebonics Essay, Research Paper One of the conflicting issues among African Americans and Caucasians is the issue of ebonics. It s not just an issue facing one race or the other it effects both races
Ebonics A Bridge To Help Black Students
Master In Standard English. Essay, Research Paper I feel that the discussion on Ebonics has gone beyond the original objectives of the program. Ebonics is a bridge to make Afro-American children understand more the English language. Mexican Americans use the code-switching technique to learn the language.
Ebonics Essay Research Paper EBONICSEbonics also known
Ebonics Essay, Research Paper EBONICS Ebonics, also known as Black English, is a nonstandard dialect spoken in many homes in the inner cities of America. This nonstandard language is often looked upon as low-class or lazy talk. This is not the case, however. Due to consistencies found in the dialect, there seems to be an order.
Ebonics Essay Research Paper EbonicsWhat is Ebonics
Ebonics Essay, Research Paper Ebonics What is Ebonics? Is it a language or not? Should it be used as a tool to teach Ebonic speaking students “standard” English or not? These issues recently came under fire when an Oakland, California school board unanimously voted that Ebonics, which is also referred to as black English, is a language with clearly evident African American roots.
Ebonics 2 Essay Research Paper EbonicsThe other
Ebonics 2 Essay, Research Paper Ebonics The other day I was talking on the subject of Ebonics. I feel Ebonics should be a language. I mean black adolescents that are seen as stupid and non-educated mostly use it. The talk compelled me to do some extensive studying on the subject.
Ebonics Essay Research Paper Ebonics Ebonics which
Ebonics Essay, Research Paper Ebonics Ebonics, which stands for Ebony + Phonics is a new term that Linguistics use to describe Black Dialect or Black English or many of the other names that it has been given for more that 350 years.. has been in the news recently but it is definitely not a new topic.
Time Essay Research Paper Time is of
Time Essay, Research Paper Time is of the essence! Be on time! Time to go to school! We are running out of time! You may not realize it, but our lives are controlled by time. From the time we get up to the time we go to bed we are its slaves.
EBONICS Essay Research Paper FOR AGES AFRICAN
EBONICS Essay, Research Paper FOR AGES AFRICAN AMERICANS HAVE BEE MANIPULATING THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE, WHICH APPEARS TO BE ACCEPTED BOTH THROUGH LITERATURE AND VERBAL SPEAKING. IN THE 21ST CENTURY THE EDUCATIONAL SYSTEM IS FACED WITH A TASK OF REFORMING A LANGUAGE SUPPOSIDLY CALL “BLACK ENGLISH” OR “EBONY PHONICS,” DEPICTING WHAT IS WIDELY KNOWN AS EBONICS.
Zoom Essay Research Paper send something else
Zoom Essay, Research Paper send something else | go to site map We got what you sent! This web site is updated every week with new content, and everything you send is also reviewed for use on the TV show. Plus, we read each and every Zmail and publish many in our Zmail area each week. Since we can’t respond to all of you personally, here are some frequently given answers:
Ebonics Essay Research Paper Ebonics is the
Ebonics Essay, Research Paper Ebonics is the name given to what linguists refer to as Black English or African American Vernacular English1. Black English has been around since the time of slavery and the slave trade in the United States. It is a mixture of West African languages and English which has been passed down from generation to generation of African Americans.
Perspective Of Black English Essay Research Paper
Black English Conclusions To the majority of the people we gave this survey to, a lot of them said it sounded like jibberish, but that at certain points it was understandable. They explained that the speaker talks fast, but for the most part are able to catch on to what they are saying. They didn t think that Ebonics should be accepted in today s society to the point that our leaders would be using it when making a speech to the nation.
Teen Fashion Essay Research Paper Teen FashionTeen
Teen Fashion Essay, Research Paper Teen Fashion Teen fashion is a big part of the fashion world today. Every week stores come out with many new clothes and accessories knowing that teens or the younger generation will