Opposing the Death Penalty
?Capital Punishment is the infliction of the death penalty on persons convicted of a crime? (Americana 596). Killing convicted felons has been one of the most widely practiced forms of criminal punishment in the United States. Currently, the states that do not practice the death penalty are Alaska, Hawaii, Iowa, Kansas, Maine, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, New Jersey, North Dakota, Ohio, Rhode Island, West Virginia and Wisconsin. But for the remaining states that still do practice the death penalty it has been a topic of debate for many years. There are two parties who argue over its many points, including whether or not it is a fitting and adequate punishment, whether or not it acts as a deterrent to crime or whether or not it is morally wrong. These two classes of people can be grouped together as the retentionists, or the proponents, and the abolitionists, or the opponents (596). For the retentionists, the main reasons they are in support of the death penalty are to take revenge, to deter others, and to punish. They are most concerned with the protection of society from dangerous criminals. In spite of all this however, the death penalty is not a good form of criminal punishment for many reasons: it is morally wrong, it does not act as a deterrent for crime, it is irreversible and can be done on people who are innocent, it is more expensive than imprisonment and those who are convicted commonly use the costly process of appealing the decision and there is no chance to make restitution to the victim and/or the victim?s family.
?People that favor the death penalty agree that capital punishment is relic of barbarism, but as murder itself is barbaric, they contend that death is a fitting punishment for it? (Jayewardne 87). Retentionists are most often subscribers to an ?eye for an eye? principle and feel that execution is the only way to satisfy the public as well as themselves. Who doesn?t enjoy it when, for example, someone steals ten dollars from you and then the person who stole your money has the same thing happen to them? Retentionists feel the same way about murderers who are sentenced to die. As far as they are concerned, the criminal brought his punishment upon himself; they deserve what they get. When proponents of the death penalty are thrown the argument of capital punishment being a tragic loss of human life, the majority respond ?even in the tragedy of human death there are degrees, and that is much more tragic for the innocent to lose his life than for the State to take the life of a criminal convicted of a capital offense? (Bedau 308).
Fear of death deters people from committing crimes, proponents say. They also believe that if attached to certain crimes, the penalty of death exerts moral influence by placing a stigma on certain crimes like manslaughter, resulting in attitudes of disgust and horror to such acts. Furthermore, retentionists insist that the deterrent influence of the death penalty reaches across state lines into jurisdictions that have abolished it, and so all benefit by its continued use. Perhaps this is the intended goal of the Violent Crime Control and Law Enforcement Act of 1994. It ?establishes constitutional procedures for the imposition of the death penalty for federal crimes. It applies to federal statutes that previously carried the death penalty and creates many new capital offenses. As a result of the Act, the death penalty may now be imposed for nearly sixty federal crimes. New capital offenses include the murder of a federal prisoner serving a life sentence, and drive by shootings in the course of certain drug offenses? (Internet 8/7/00). Those in support of capital punishment think achieving model citizens and a better society happen through fear and intimidation.
Retentionists do not see the death penalty as being morally wrong. For them the most likely source of constitutional difficulty with capital punishment is the prohibition against ?cruel and unusual punishment,? otherwise known as the Eighth Amendment. When told by the opposing side that the death penalty is cruel, inhumane and degrading, most proponents argue that murder is too. In fact, some retentionists consider execution to be more human than life imprisonment because it is quick and instantaneous. Those in support of capital punishment felt that by making the prisoner suffer by rotting in jail for the rest of their life is more torturous and inhumane than execution. To sum up the basic views of the proponents, imprisonment is simply not a sufficient safeguard against the future actions of criminals because it offers the possibility of escape and release on parole. ?We think that some criminals must be made to pay for their crimes with their lives, and we think that we, the survivors of the world they violated, may legitimately extract the payment because we, too, are their victims? (Bedau 317).
Even though the retentionists pose some interesting arguments, I myself feel that the abolitionist perspective contains much stronger backing and more reasons for opposition, the first of which is that the death penalty is morally wrong because it is cruel and inhuman taking of a human life. The methods by which executions are carried out can involve physical torture. ?Electrocution has on occasion cause extensive burns and need more than one application of electric current to kill the condemned? (Amnesty 6). To many opponents, capital punishment is a euphemism for legally killing people and no one, not even the state, has the authority to play God.
Contrary to public belief, the death penalty does not act as a deterrent to crime. ?Expert after expert and study after study have emphasized and emphasized the lack of correlation between the threat of the death penalty and the occurrence of violent crime? (Meador 69). Isaac Ehrlich?s study on the deterrent effect of capital punishment in America reveals this. It spans twenty-five years, 1957-1982, and it shows that in the first year the study was conducted there were eight thousand and sixty murders in 1957 and sixty-five executions. However, in the last year of the study, there were twenty two thousand five hundred and twenty murders committed and one execution performed. The absence of deterrence is clearly shown. The death penalty is irrevocable. ?In case of mistake, the executed prisoner can not be given another chance. Justice can miscarry. In the last hundred years there have been more than seventy-five documented cases of wrongful conviction of criminal homicide. The death sentence was carried out in eight of these case? (Draper 47). Undoubtedly other cases of mistaken conviction and execution occurred and remain undocumented. A prisoner discovered to be blameless can be freed; but neither release nor compensation is possibly for a dead body.
The belief that execution costs less than imprisonment is false. ?The cost of the apparatus and maintenance of the procedures attending the death penalty, including death row and endless appeals and legal machinery, far outweighs the expense of maintaining in prison the tiny fraction of criminals who would otherwise be slain? (Draper 46).
Abolitionists believe that the offender should be required to compensate the victim?s family with the offender?s own income from employment or community service. There is no doubt in my mind that someone can do more alive rather than dead. By working, the criminal inadvertently ?pays back? society and also their victim and/or the victim?s family. There is no reason for the criminal to receive any compensation for their work. Money is of no value in jail. One of the most well known examples of the criminal contributing to the betterment of society is the case of Leopold and Loeb. Leopold and Loeb were nineteen years old when they committed ?The Crime of the Century.? In 1924 they kidnapped and murdered a fourteen-year-old boy just to see what it was like. They were both spared the death penalty and were sentenced to life imprisonment. Together, their accomplishments include working at hospitals, teaching illiterates to read, creating a correspondence school, making significant developments in the World War II Malaria Project and writing a grammar book. ?An inestimable amount of people were directly helped by Leopold and Loeb; both of them making a conscious commitment to atone by serving others? (Horwitz 109).
Abolitionists consider the death penalty an insufficient form of punishment because it is cruel and inhuman, there is no proof that it deters violent crime, it can be inflicted upon people innocent of any crime, the costly process of appealing gives the death penalty a hefty price tag and with the death penalty, the chance to make restitution to the victim and/or the victim?s family does not exist. The essence of the abolitionist perspective is this:
The death penalty has been a gross failure. Beyond its horror and incivility, it has neither protected the innocent nor deterred the wicked. The recurrent spectacle of publicly sanctioned killing has cheapened human life and dignity without the redeeming grace which comes from justice meted out swiftly, even humanely? (Draper 44).
Amnesty International Report. The Death Penalty. England: Amnesty International Publications, 1979.
?Angel on Death Row? pbs/wgbh/pages/frontline/angel/procon/deathissue.html 2 Aug 2000.
Bedau, Hugo Adam. The Death Penalty in America. New York: Okford University Press, 1982.
?Capital Punishment.? Encyclopedia Americana. 1990 ed.
Draper, Thomas. Capital Punishment. New York: H.W. Wilson, 1985.
Howitz, Elinor Lander. Capital Punishment U.S.A. New York: J.B. Lippincott, 1973.
Jayewardene, C.H.S. The Penalty of Death. Massachusetts: Lexington, 1977.
Meador, Roy. Capital Revenge: 54 Votes Against Life. Philadelphia: Dorrance, 1975.
Другие работы по теме:
Humanity And The Death Penalty Essay Research
Paper Humanity And The Death Penalty Write up by Paul Arguin One of the more controversial issues these days is the death penalty, and it does come up more than once in a while. Over the course of this assignment, I will tell you about the Death penalty in Canada and in other countries around the world and why it should be abolished from the face of the planet forever.
Capital Punishment Essay Research Paper Capital PunishmentMy
Capital Punishment Essay, Research Paper Capital Punishment My opinion on capital punishment is very shaky because of the unstable facts and controversy surrounding this topic. I personally, am caught somewhere in the middle of deciding on being for or against the death penalty. I am for the death penalty for several reasons: I think that we need to get the hardened criminals off the streets and out of our court and jail systems.
Death Penalty Essay Research Paper Support for
Death Penalty Essay, Research Paper Support for the death penalty has fluctuated throughout the century. According to Gallup surveys, in 1936, 61% of Americans favored the death penalty for persons convicted of murder. Support reached an all-time low of 42% in 1966. Throughout the 70s and, 80s the percentage of Americans in favor of the death penalty increased steadily culminating in an 80% approval rating in 1994.
Death Penalty Essay Research Paper The most
Death Penalty Essay, Research Paper The most severe of all sentences, known as the death penalty, capital punishment is the most severe form of corporal punishment as it is requires law enforcement officers to kill the offender. It has been banned in many countries, in the United States, an earlier move to eliminate capital punishment has now been reversed and more and more states are resorting to capital punishment for serious offenses such as murder.
The Death Penalty 11 Essay Research Paper
The Penalty of Death In this essay, H.L. Mencken has two arguments that stand out in the beginning of this essay. These arguments are against the penalty of death, although his essay is in a way, for it. The first one is, That hanging a man (or frying him or gassing him) is a dreadful business, degrading to those who have to do it and revolting to those who have to witness it . (Mencken 455).
Capital Punishment 6 Essay Research Paper CAPITAL
Capital Punishment 6 Essay, Research Paper CAPITAL PUNISHMENTCapital Punishment or Life Imprisonment? I think that capital punishment should be use more often than just life imprisonment. Life imprisonment is just not working. The death penalty does have some cons but it has its share of pros too. Lets start with the pros.
My Beliefs Essay Research Paper My BeliefsThe
My Beliefs Essay, Research Paper My Beliefs The idea of putting another human being to death is hard to completely imagine. I think the emotions involved in carrying out a death sentence on another
Capital Punishment Essay Research Paper I am
Capital Punishment Essay, Research Paper I am all for Capital Punishment. I think that if you kill someone you should be given the death penalty. I think that the death of the killer would give family and friends a bit of ease
A Wise Decision Essay Research Paper A
A Wise Decision Essay, Research Paper A Wise Delay Governor Ryan?s decision to suspend the death penalty is already starting to have a valuable impact on the rest of nation. Other states are starting to aid in Governor Ryan?s quest to improve death penalty systems. Last week, a representative from the state of Wisconsin, requested that President Clinton put a hold on executions until the federal death penalty system can be reviewed.
Failures Of Capital Punishment Essay Research Paper
Failures of Capital Punishment Is the death penalty a just way of punishing those who commit a horrible crime? The answer to that depends on the standpoint of an individual. Fox Butterfield of the New York Times notices that ?In the view of some, the failure to enforce the death penalty reflects and enduring ambivalence about the capital punishment.
Alcohol Essay Research Paper DEATH PENALTYThe
Alcohol Essay, Research Paper DEATH PENALTY The Penalty should fit the Crime that is committed, then society would become a safer place to live in. Imagine a man who commits murder, do you think a fifteen
Death Penalty 9 Essay Research Paper After
Death Penalty 9 Essay, Research Paper After reading “The Death Penalty” by William Raspberry several topics surfaced in my mind. The death penalty is unjust and very ridiculous sentence for a human being . Capital punishment is not as effective as most people believe. There are alternative and beneficial solutions in place of the death penalty.
Death Penalty Essay Research Paper ABOLISH THE
Death Penalty Essay, Research Paper ABOLISH THE DEATH PENALTY I believe the death penalty should be abolished. I believe it should be abolished because it does not help curb crime. Another reason is It is not morally fair or just. We can?t be absolute in making sure people are guilty of the crime. It is more expensive than Imprisonment.
Capital Punishment Essay Research Paper Capital PunishmentWhat
Capital Punishment Essay, Research Paper Capital Punishment What type of society kills its own people? The American culture?s morals have accepted the death penalty as a reasonable punishment. However, who gives us the power to determine when someone?s life should end. People who murder others should be punished and pay the price of their crime, but not killed.
Death Penalty Essay Research Paper Why I
Death Penalty Essay, Research Paper Why I oppose the death penalty A central principle of a justice society is that every person has an equal right to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. That is why I oppose the death penalty. If you are Queer, or a woman who does not behave in socially acceptable ways, courts and juries are stacked against you, including those that can send you to death row.
Capital Punishment Essay Research Paper I have
Capital Punishment Essay, Research Paper I have an opinion on many subjects. Whether or not you agree with it is your opininon. This country, being a free country, gives me the right to persuade you to see things my way. This is my goal with the following essay.
Capital Punishment Essay Research Paper Capital PunishmentElectrocution
Capital Punishment Essay, Research Paper Capital Punishment Electrocution . . . gas chamber . . . lethal injection . . . field shooting . . . all are forms of the death penalty used across the United States. Some believe that when one person takes the life of another, that person’s life should be taken as well.
Death Penalty 6 Essay Research Paper Death
Death Penalty 6 Essay, Research Paper Death Penalty In The “Death Penalty is a Step Back” by Coretta Scott King, she makes some very good and strong points opposing the death penalty. To bad all those points can be countered very easily with logical explanations. Yes, Mrs. King is right when she states that two wrongs don’t make a right, but in some cases besides math it does, and the death penalty is one of those cases.
Deterrence Essay Research Paper The death penalty
Deterrence Essay, Research Paper The death penalty seems to be a controversial issue for most people. Supporters claim that it eliminates repeat offenders, deters potential murderers, and is the ultimate retribution. Opponents denounce it as murder, say that it does not cause deterrence but rather promotes violence, and claim that it introduces the chance of an innocent person being executed.
Crime In Today S World Has Become
More Gruesome With The Times Essay, Research Paper Crime in today s world has become more gruesome with the times. With the crimes comes jail, so more jails are being built for the prisoners. More people are be criminals are being sent to jail and getting the death penalty. Some feel that the death penalty is also a gruesome act of murder.
An Acceptable Punishment Essay Research Paper An
An Acceptable Punishment Essay, Research Paper An Acceptable Punishment When you think of an extreme crime you think of murder. When you think of an extreme punishment you think of the death penalty. Crimes of such severity sometimes deserve an equal punishment and we as a society accept this. However, Supreme Court Justice William Brennan argues that society seriously questions the appropriateness of the death penalty.
Capital Punishment 12 Essay Research Paper Capital
Capital Punishment 12 Essay, Research Paper Capital punishment is the penalty of death for a crime. It has been part of the world’s criminal justice system since the time of Babylonia’s Hammurabic Code. The system of capital punishment is full of injustices and inequalities. All the arguements for the death penalty ared filled with holes.
Death Penalty Essay Research Paper One of
Death Penalty Essay, Research Paper One of the things I have heard is that the death penalty is cruel and unusual punishment. What about the victims families? What about the loss of a loved one? What about daddy not coming home again to tuck his babies into bed at night or mommy being there when the child falls and scrapes a knee? To hell with the criminal.
Death Penalty Essay Research Paper Is the
Death Penalty Essay, Research Paper Is the Death Penalty Right or Wrong? Should we be able to execute people that have been convicted of murder or should we give them a chance to break out of jail and maybe kill other people. Well the Death Penalty has been around for a while ever since the Old West use to hang people for punishment.
Against Capital Punishment Essay Research Paper Capital
Against Capital Punishment Essay, Research Paper Capital PunishmentAgainst Ca Against capital punnisment In view of the ever-increasing violent crimes, most people think that the re-enforcement of the death penalty is a good way to reduce the crime rate. However, there is not many statistics may show this.
Death Penalty 11 Essay Research Paper DEATH
Death Penalty 11 Essay, Research Paper DEATH PENALTY In 1972 the Supreme Court decide that the death penalty was cruel and unusual punishment according to the eighth amendment. The Furman vs. Georgia decision stop the death penalty in the United States. In 1976 the death penalty was back because of the ruling in Gregg vs.
Pros And Cons Of Death Penalty Essay
, Research Paper Texas is known for many things, both socially and politically. The death penalty is a very serious issue that we as Texans need to concentrate on in the upcoming election. The Death Penalty has been around forever even back into the dark ages. It is the way that we punish people for crimes they have been convicted of or have confessed.
Capitol Punishment Essay Research Paper CAPITOL PUNSIHMENTWe
Capitol Punishment Essay, Research Paper CAPITOL PUNSIHMENT We all know that capital punishment is for the scum of the earth, all the no hopers and drug dealers, the Mafia and usually non-whites fall into this category. They deserve to be treated like this as they abuse the right of responsibility and are a disgrace to mankind.
Death Penalty Essay Research Paper Chad HeldtSociologyPeriod
Death Penalty Essay, Research Paper Chad Heldt Sociology Period 1 4/28/98 The Death Penalty Should It Be Allowed Or Not? In my paper I plan to give my opinion and my position on the death penalty. I believe the death penalty should be for hardened criminals like the Charlie Mansons of the world and people like that.
The Death Penalty. Right Or Wrong
Essay, Research Paper The Death Penalty. Right? Or Wrong? Capital punishment, or better known as the death penalty, is a very controversial issue in the United States today. The death penalty has been viewed by many people as wrong, while still other people see the death penalty to be acceptable in today s society.
Death Penalty Furman Vs Georgia Essay Research
Paper Furman vs. Georgia I believe that Furman’s appeal to the Supreme Court to lift his death penalty sentence was invalid. The accused received a fair trial, with due process and appropriate representation. There was no act in his sentence that could be deemed unconstitutional. Death penalty cannot be branded an unconstitutional act, for it does not fall into the category of cruel and unusual punishment that is prohibited by the Eighth Amendment.
Death Penalty Essay Research Paper The risk
Death Penalty Essay, Research Paper The risk of executing the innocent precludes the use of the death penalty. The death penalty alone imposes an irrevocable sentence. Once an inmate is executed, nothing can be done to make amends if a mistake has been made. There is considerable evidence that many mistakes have been made in sentencing people to death.
The Death Sentence Essay Research Paper The
The Death Sentence Essay, Research Paper The Death Penalty Capital punishment is the legal infliction of the death penalty on persons convicted of a crime. Today, in modern law, the death penalty is corporal punishment in its most severe form. It is irrevocable: it ends the existence of those punished, instead of temporarily imprisoning them.
Pro Death Penalty Essay Research Paper PRO
Pro Death Penalty Essay, Research Paper PRO DEATH PENALTY In 1976 the death penalty was reinstated into the American government, and rightfully so. I believe in the motto: an eye for an eye , which means if someone kills