Morality Essay, Research Paper
The Endless Quest for the Universalization of Morality
Throughout history, philosophers have been preoccupied with the notion of a universal “right” and “wrong”. Philosophers want to have a sort of morality measuring stick that would enable them to judge a person’s decision as being morally right or wrong, independent of the situation and circumstances that led to that decision. Since an Universal Law of Morality hasn’t been discovered yet, philosophers have to use various moral theories to evaluate the morality of decisions. Some of the moral theories philosophers have developed over the years have come very close to being accepted as as universal, but none have had the characteristics that it takes to be classified as universal. Since philosophy lacks an Universal Law of Morality, philosophers must take into account the reasons and circumstances behind moral decisions, therefore they must use moral theories that are relative to decision-maker and his/her situation.
Conventional moral relativism is the idea that morality is defined by individual cultures and that each culture has its own morality that is relative to that culture. William Graham Sumner believed that every culture has its own set of values and customs, so “The ‘right way’ is the way which the ancestors used and which has been handed down”(Sommers 213). Even though some cultures share many of the same values, they don’t have the same morality. Values are what effect people’s decision making, but they do not work independently. Values work as a system, where some values are worth more than others, so two cultures with identical values could have completely opposite morals because of the order of importance of the values in their value system. This allows for the possibility of different cultures making different decisions when faced with the same moral dilemma and to still be “right”, relative to their morality.
Ruth Benedict believed that “Most individuals are plastic to the moulding force of the society into which they are born”(Sommers 205), and since each individual is influenced by many different societies, individuals develop differently as well. Individuals are exposed to a wide array of beliefs and values, and because humans have freewill they have the ability to choose what aspects of society’s morality they want to accept and/or adapt to their own morality. Subjective moral relativism is the belief that morality is relative to the individual and that every individual can have his or her own morality. This theory is commonly opposed mainly for the fact that those who accept it are denying philosophers the right to judge morality. Philosophers use their theories of morality to judge other people’s morality. In order for a philosopher to unbiasedly judge someone’s morality they must have an Universal Law of Morality by which to judge, without one philosophers are just, in an essence, comparing two relative views of morality and saying “my views are better than yours”. The Judeo-Christian tradition says “Do not judge…….Do not condemn”(Sommers 93) so philosophers, in theory, have no right to judge the decision of another.
Louis Pojman believed that “If Morality is relative to its culture, then there is no independent basis for criticizing the morality of any other culture but one’s own”(Sommers 248). When philosophers who judge someone else’s morality, unless that someone has the same morality of the philosopher, the philosopher is trying to compare the person to a set of standards that aren’t relative to the person. In a sense, philosophers, who believe their moral theories to be universal, are ethnocentric. Ethnocentrism is a form of prejudice in which a person rejects the views of all cultures except his or her own, and when philosophers criticize someone else’s moral beliefs the philosopher isn’t being tolerant of other cultures/individuals. Conventional moral relativism would allow philosophers to judge others within his/her own culture, since conventional moral relativism says morality is relative to each culture/society. According to subjective moral relativism an individual’s morality is relative to the individual, therefore the only morality philosophers can judge is their own. Philosophers always consider subjectivism invalid because if they considered it valid they would be out of a job, and unable criticize moral decision-making.
The only time when a Universal Law of Morality was attainable was back at the beginning of time, at the time of creation, because every minute since then humans have been having experiences that change them and make them evolve. Alasdair MacIntyre felt that “The meaning and ethical worth of any person’s acts can be understood only as a part of the life story of that person”(Sommers 316). Universalization in morality can only be true when there is a clean slate for which it to judge, when everybody has the same amount of experiences. Each culture since the beginning of time has evolved and/or changed at their own pace, and no two cultures have evolved identically. Since no two cultures are identical, and no individual is effected by just one culture, each individual is a unique melting pot of different ideas and values. Diversity is essential for the positive future of our world. Universalization would stifle any ideas or values that go against or differ slightly from the norm. Our civilization would no longer continue to develop and evolve, it takes new ideas and values to bring about change. For example, if we had a Law of Universalization of Morality people like Martin Luther King would have been considered morally wrong because the majority’s morality was pro-segregation while his morality called for all people to live together.
Trying to make a universalization about people that aren’t identical is inherently false, and who is to say that one idea, just because it is held by the majority, is right and another is wrong. Statistics should hold no value is judging the morality of an action. If 100 people tell lies and one person tells the truth, the philosopher who is trying to universalize, would consider the truth teller an outlier and conclude that lying is morally right. If we lived in a vacuum, where all people had identical experiences throughout their whole lives and no outside forces acted the people, an Universal Law of Morality would be very attainable. Today’s dominant moral values became dominant by accident, society just evolved in a way that catered to these dominant moralities. The normal should no longer be considered the normative .
You cannot expect a man to be bound to a Universal Law of Morality unless all men are identical. Until the day when we reach our maximum level of evolution, that we seem to be slowly approaching, and all men are at that level, the idea of universalization in regards to morality is a pipe dream. Philosophers then and only then will have the ability to fairly and efficiently judge another man’s morality.
Другие работы по теме:
Springtime Quest Filing An Income Tax Essay
, Research Paper The Springtime Quest: Filing an Income Tax Return Springtime is a period of rebirth of nature, the promise of warmer weather, and a sign that an impending deadline to file my income tax report is at
Janie
’s Quest In There Eyes Were Watching God Essay, Research Paper Zora Neale Hurston s Their Eyes Were Watching God shows the life of Janie, a black woman at the turn of the century. Janie is raised by her Grandmother and spends her life traveling with different men until she finally comes home. Robert E. Hemenway says about the book, Their Eyes Were Watching God is … one of the most revealing treatments in modern literature of a woman s quest for a satisfying life I partially disagree with Hemenway because, although Janie is on a quest, it is not for a satisfying
Quest For Fire Essay Research Paper Quest
Quest For Fire Essay, Research Paper Quest for Fire This story happens 80,000 years ago when our ancestors first discovered the power of fire, but did not know how to master it.
Does Neo Of The Matrix Fullfill Joseph
Cambell’s Heroic Archetype Essay, Research Paper An engine consists of many parts which work together to transform energy into mechanical force. With the absence of any of those parts, the collection is no longer an engine, but an assembly of parts with no purpose. Similar to this is the archetype of the hero.
Corrupt Romantic Quest Essay Research Paper In
Corrupt Romantic Quest Essay, Research Paper In The Great Gatsby, F. Scott Fitzgerald presents the 1920?s society as delusional. The book is set up to resemble a romantic story. It has a hero, villain, damsel in distress and a chronicler. Gatsby has set out on a Romantic Quest in the story to achieve love and fortune.
The Road To Happiness Essay Research Paper
Emptiness. This emotion is what Janie experiences at the beginning of Their Eyes Were Watching God. This lacking makes life practically unbearable for Janie, and she tries to find completeness. She tries various things to alleviate this feeling. Through the quests Janie undertakes, she grows and finds completeness in her life.
Epic Of Gilgamesh And The Book Of
Genesis Essay, Research Paper The Epic Of Gilgamesh is an important Middle East literary work, written in cuneiform on 12 clay tablets about 2000 BC by the oldest human author that we can name. The Epic tells the story of a great Mesopotamian king,Gilgamesh,who finds his kindered spirit and goes on a spiritual quest for understanding of death and the after life.
Greek Hero Essay Research Paper Greek Heros
Greek Hero Essay, Research Paper Greek Hero?s and Their Society The Greek heroes served society by demonstrating the morals and values of the Greek Gods in humanistic terms. All Greek heroes had similar characteristics and qualities. These qualities are an essential part of the hero?s make-up. Without them, the hero would not be able to overcome the challenges that life presented him.
Two Warriors A Comparison And Contrast
Of Beowulf And The Knight From The Canterbury Tales Essay, Research Paper The Canterbury Tales CharacterKnightBeowulf Quest- fights religious wars - fights for god
Earth Essay Research Paper I
Earth Essay, Research Paper I’ve watched all of history, watched great empires fall becuase of endless quarrels. I’m not a god yet I’m above humans and time itself. I’ve observered great minds prosecuted by others for something they have yet to understand, ideas turned into belief, trying to destroy one another over that one simple idea.
DH Lawrence
’s The Rainbow: Quest, Passage, Awakening, And Change In Relationships Essay, Research Paper The Rainbow is one of DH Lawrence’s most controversial works. It was banned in Great Britain when it was first published. The Rainbow introduced sexual life into a family-based novel, portraying a visionary quest for love by three generations of English men and women.
Quests Not Dreams
– A Raisin In The Sun Essay, Research Paper Quests Not Dreams A Raisin in the Sun by Lorraine Hansberry is the story of black family living in the south side of Chicago. Each member of the family has a dream, a dream that has been put off for some reason. The storyline revolves around an insurance check for $10,000.
Yoga Basics Essay Research Paper KAITE HOOVER
Yoga Basics Essay, Research Paper KAITE HOOVER YOGA A teeny intro When I was in sixth grade, my friend and I found a book about yoga. We sorted through pictures of women in leotards doing poses that I found exhausting to look at. I never thought that I would fall in love with this thing called yoga. The reason I am in love with yoga is because it’s a complete way of life.
Notes On Everyday Use Essay Research Paper
? Dee?s perception of the quilts – as an icon or symbol of her roots ? The idea of roots and retracing/linking one to their heritage is significant in the shaping of ones identity, however, Dee lacks the sincere interest in her quest and as a result, views the quilts as mere wall trophies
Untitled Essay Research Paper Business has always
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Business has always been the major of my choice because of the endless possibilities. You are on your own in a business – but you are also your own boss. And with this comes the privileges. Structure your business to the limits of your imagination. Anything can be sold for the right price.
Odysseus Of The Odyssey Essay Research Paper
Quests for Self-knowledge In Homer s the Odyssey, there are two major quests. One quest is that of Odysseus, King of Ithaca, and the other is that of Prince Telemakhos, son of Odysseus. Both quests are alike in that both men search for self-knowledge and eventual happiness in Ithaca. In the quests of the King and Prince, both of the two undergo a great metamorphosis.
Gilgamesh Essay Research Paper Gilgamesh Essay over
Gilgamesh Essay, Research Paper Gilgamesh Essay over The Epic of Gilgamesh The main character in the book The Epic of Gilgamesh is Gilgamesh himself. Throughout the book, many things cause Gilgamesh to change. First, the quest for immortality after the death of Enkidu shows that Gilgamesh has changed. Gilgamesh has gone from arrogant to scared.
3 Doors Down The Search For The
Better Life Essay, Research Paper 3 DOORS DOWN: THE QUEST FOR THE BETTER LIFE We spend our lives searching for that something or someone that can fill the void and makes life’s trials bearable. The motif for the freshmen album from 3 Doors Down deals with this idea of finding “The Better Life.” Tracks 1, 3, and 5, titled “Kryptonite,” “Duck and Run,” and “Be Like That,” use the idea of the quest for the better life to explain the motif contained throughout the album.
American Dream Essay Research Paper Great Gatsby
American Dream Essay, Research Paper Great Gatsby By: Katherine The Great Gatsby, a novel by F. Scott Fitzgerald, deals with the difficulty of attaining the American dream. The American dream is different for every individual, but Jay Gatsby, the main character of the novel, believes the American dream is eternal ha iness through love.
Bridge Over The River Kwai Essay Research
Paper The Bridge over the River Kwai “Who pants for glory finds but short repose: a breath revives him, or a breath overthrows”…Alexander Pope The position of glory is a precarious one at best says Alexander Pope. One who desperately seeks glory will find it only in passing, and in his quest for it can, in fact be consumed and consequently destroyed by it.
Hamlet Hero Or Hoax Essay Research Paper
Hamlet: Hero or Hoax In his play, “Hamlet”, William Shakespeare shows us the life of a young man lost in turmoil. All of his turmoil and angst is very much related to his own state of indecision and passivity. His problems, and most of those in the play, are partially summed up in the line when Hamlet is questioned by Gertrude about his melancholy appearance, he replies, “Seems, madam? Nay it is.
Jack Kerouac Essay Research Paper The novel
Jack Kerouac Essay, Research Paper The novel On The Road written by Jack Kerouac is a book that can be read as a quest taken by Sal Paradise who sets out to test the American Dream by trying to pin down its promise of unlimited freedom by following the example of Dean Morairty. In the book ? the road? becomes a symbol of freedom or escape for Sal and his friends.
Poem How Much You Mean To Me
My Love Essay, Research Paper How much do you mean to me my love? The oceans and heavens could not contain my thoughts for you. If all the writers of the world sat down, they still could not describe your endless beauty.
First Tracks Essay Research Paper There
First Tracks Essay, Research Paper There’s nothing like hiking deep into the endless glacial mountains of Alaska to get a snowboarders heart pumping. It was almost 9 a.m. and the sun began to beat
Great Gatsby Quest Essay Research Paper Nick
Great Gatsby Quest Essay, Research Paper Nick and Gatsby s Quest In the novel The Great Gatsby, by F. Scott Fitzgerald, the thematic quest for the Holy Grail is shown through the conduct of Jay Gatsby and Nick Carraway. Gatsby s crusade is to attain Daisy Buchanan s love. While Nick s quest is to discover what matters in life and to live his life accordingly.
A Critical Analysis Of King Leer
’s Daughters’Attraction To Edmund. Essay, Research Paper Shakespeare? King Lear is a story of treachery and deceit. The villainy of the play knows no bounds. Family
Archetypal Criticism Essay Research Paper Archetypal Criticism
Archetypal Criticism Essay, Research Paper Archetypal Criticism: Joshua In the many stories of the Bible, one of the most acclaimed heroes is Joshua. To most he is known for his heroic actions at the battle of Jericho. But in reality, Joshua displays many archetypes of a hero like many other in the Bible. Archetype is the idea that recurring patterns in different assemblies exist universally and instinctively in the collective unconscious of man.
Quest For The Holy Grail Essay Research
Paper Jim Dougherty Mrs. Shah English IV 541-08 10 October 2000 King Arthur’s Quest for the Holy Grail The Quest for the Holy Grail was the greatest and noblest of all quests for King Arthur’s Knights of the Round Table. The Holy Grail was believed to be the cup used by Jesus Christ at the Last Supper, and it was the cup that caught Christ’s blood when he was thrust in the side with a spear at his crucifixion.
Moral Theory Essay Research Paper Moral TheoryRespect
Moral Theory Essay, Research Paper Moral Theory Respect for Persons: The moral theory, Respect for Persons, or Ethics of Respect for Persons, core theme is that all human beings should be paid equal respect. Like the bible says in Matthew 7:12, “. Do to others as you would have them do to you.”[1]. This theory has been connected to the German philosopher, Immanuel Kant.
Poem Objects Essay Research Paper Max E
Poem: Objects Essay, Research Paper Max E. Gaytan 4-5-00 One object can unlock All secrets of the world. It can create happiness And endless piece in the World. It can cure diseases
Frankenstien The Book Essay Research Paper Journal
Frankenstien The Book Essay, Research Paper Journal Chap. 24-end # 17 The end of the novel was left very open. I felt as though there is no conclusion. Where is the sequel? I think that Walton will not continue Victors quest to see the monster dead. The monster only had one reason to live, and that was to make Victor s life a living hell.
Quest For Pride Essay Research Paper Quest
Quest For Pride Essay, Research Paper Quest for Pride Pride is a central theme throughout many epics and novels. For any heroic character to succeed in their quest they must have a strong sense of inner pride. In many cases the hero does not already have that pride, but obtains it through the obstacles set before them.
What Is The Question That Is A
Question And Will Always Be A Question? Essay, Research Paper In this life, the number of questions is almost endless. There are so many answers we are in search for, some of which we will never find. Is
The World A Destroyer Essay Research Paper
The world is empty, an endless void Swirling, twirling, and hurling us all Facing the downfall no one foresaw. The world, a temptress, a taker of fates Fighting us all, giving unto the hate.
The Meaning Of Love Essay Research Paper
THE MEANING OF LOVE Love is just a four-letter word with so many meanings behind it. In other words the definition for love is endless? So what is love and do we