“The primitive world was able to achieve a harmony, unstable at times, between the needs of the individual and the requirements of community. The problem of order, responsibility and integrity were solved with the problem of bread.”
-Thomas Belmonte
The Broken Fountain, Belmonte’s book on urban Naples is a prime example of a society struggling to defeat the problem of “bread”. “Bread” being used here as a metaphor for the necessities of life. A society requires its members to maintain order, resposibility and integrity to achieve a harmonious social life. Belmonte found that the people of urban Naples could not maintain order due to the ever lasting struggle for “bread”. But does a lack of “bread” affect the behavior of the members of its society?
Going by the information in Belmonte’s ethnography, one could argue that a lack of “bread” can drive a society of people to a life of immorality and disoranization. The people of the urban Naples struggled for work and food. There was no work inside their section of town so the people had to travel across water to find work. Even if they were to find a quick job, it would still not be enough to properly support a family. One of the
people Belmonte studied has to resort to garbage picking for any used parts he could sell or restore for money. But still that was not enough. Habitually the people of urban Naples would turn to theift and other immoral acts just to get by. The people were completely dishonest with eachother that one could never be held accountable for any piece of truth. They would rob, cheat and even kill just for “bread”.
The homes in urban Naples were filled will domestic voilence. It was normal for a man to abuse his wife, for he was usually the main supporter of the family. There was no divorce there because they just could not afford it. There was no way that a family, could have been supported in Naples, with only on parent. That is why the hubands and wives would stay to gether. But somewhere behind all of the stress and violence, the members in the family still could find a moment or two to love each other. That love for eachother was one of the olny few positive aspects of their lives.
In my opinion, this example of a poor community shows no respects of maintaining order, responsibility or integrity. Due to the lack of “bread”, this social group has altered their moral beliefs, which has aroused a level of almost complete anarchy in their section of town. The problem of oranizing the individuals in a society was not solved in urban Naples. This is evident in their chaotic lifestyles and pragmatic outlook. A term of social solidarity must be met for there to be a harmonious social life. The problem with the urban Naples people is that they have not accepted an altruistic
solution to their problems. The lack of “bread” seems to shy an individual away from sharing, especially when they have nothing to even share.
In other societies such as the Kalahari Kung the problem of “bread” is solved with their social conditions of mechanical solidarity. Boiling Energy, Richard Katz’s socialogical analysis on the Kung society shows us a different approach to the distibution of the essentail elements of life. In both societies food is scarce, but does a limitation on the food supply truly affect the behavior of the members in its community?
Katz shows us that the lack of “bread” doesn’t necessisarily have to turn a society to anarchy. His ethnography of the Kung people shows us that it is possible for a small society to work harmoniously together and overcome the problem of “bread”. The people of the Kalahari Desert are egalitarians whose lifestyle encourages the social conditions of mechanical solidarity. The Kung have survived on the infertile land of the Kalahari for many years. They have endured for so long because the have a well respected system of hunting, gathering and sharing. Their altruistic views allow them to accept the fact that they all need eachother to survive in the arid desert. Cooperation and order in Kung society is vital to their survival.
The Kung have developed a system of division of labor, to make life easier for all members of the society. Their system is based primarily on sex. Hunting is done by the physically fit men of the Kung, and the gathering of plants and other vegitation is done primarily by the women. Due to the lack of technology, hunting is a rather difficult task
in a vast desert. Therefore plantlife makes up nearly seventy percent of the Kung people’s diet. But when a kill of any animal is made, the Kung have no problem sharing it with the rest of their people. For they know that if it were not them who made the kill, they themselves would want a fair portion of the much praised meat. Even the women in Kung society are held accountable for sharing their collected goods too. There is a balance that must be met, that is why the Kung have endured this long
In both societies we have studied, we have seen evidence of a lack of food. This situation has been managed differently in both of the societies. The Kung divide the labor up amongst their group and support each other. In urban Napoles, the people fight over the scraps that are thrown to them by the higher society. Yet somehow throughout all of the stress and anguish the people of urban Napoles endure, they still somewhere find a time to love one another. Love is the most beautiful thing that any human can share, so is that human nature?
Belmonte suggests that human nature is a biosocial potential for altruism and harmonious communal life. This is what separates us from the rest of the species on earth. He is saying that humans have the potential to leave behind the competition for survival, for the good of all beings. That humans can work together to allow the survival of all that blesses our society. This is much like how our constitution says that all men are created equal and that we all desrve the right to life, liberty and freedom. This is
insinuating that we don’t need to hoard away and compete, there is room for everyone to survive. Well, this is all good in theory, but what happens when the social conditions are changed.
The creators of the Survivor Show cunducted an experiment to discover how human nature can be modified by changing the environment, social conditions and by lowering people to their primative state. Their theory was that average Americans human nature could be altered by changing their social conditions to that of isolation on a deserted island and deprivation of the basic comforts of the modern world. The players were to survive on a deserted island, and who ever lasted the longest would win a cash prize of one million dollars. The players would vote each other off the island until it was narrowed down to two people, then the audience would decided who would win the money.
Through the players of the Survivor game, the creators learned that human nature can be modified by changing social condition. This was evident in the players thoughts,
feelings and behaviors that we saw on the show. The players were split up into two tribes, that were to compete in various tests of skill, knowledge and strength. The losing tribe would have to vote a member off the island each time they lost a competition. We saw that the players in each tribe worked together to avoid banishment. The only catch was, that it was imposible to ultimatly avoid banishment. So, in order to avoid being
voted off, we saw the players making aliances with eachother. The aliances helped them work together and allocate responsibility and power. But ultimately every one of them would be banished except for the one true survivor, who would win one million dollars.
In my opinion, I do not necessarily feel that this was a good way to break humans down to their bare minimums and see what their human nature is. I belive this because no matter what happened to the people on the island, they would still be able to go home in due time. The cash prize was also a factor that effected the way each player survived. The million dollars gave the people on the island an insentive to sacrifice their morals, values and ethics to “act” out the part of the “true” survivor. In the Kalahari Desert and in urban Napoles, there is no “acting” and no cash prize at the end of the “game”. These people actually work to survive, and ultimatly avoid death. The players of the Survivor game knew that the game was a false reality and would be over soon. For the Kung and urban people, survival is an evergoing process. They are not pampered with the knowledge of advanced technology that we see in our modern culture. For these reasons I do not feel that the castaways in the Survivor game were actually lowered down to a “primative” state.
So is Belmonte’s veiw on human nature acurate? Well I can not exactly answer that question. All that I can say is that human nature seems to be effected by an individuals social condition. The people of the arid, stifling and infertile Kalahari desert
have organized themselves together to ensure survival of the entire community. On the other hand the people of urban Napoles have developed a lifestyle of curroption to fit the needs of their life. “Bread”, being a metaphor for the essential elements of survival, definatly effects a societies inhabilities to function as a whole. The lack of bread can drive people to curroption in despirate times. This is evident in urban Napoles. The lack of bread in the Kalahari desert has brought their socie
ty together to struggle as a whole rather that individual competition. The key here is to overcome eachothers differences in a society and work together to create a harmonious social life.
Другие работы по теме:
Romeo An Juliet Essay Research Paper hi
Romeo An Juliet Essay, Research Paper hi i need an essay about a character in romeo and juliet that demonsrtated maturity. in a well developed multi pagraph essay and say why you think the character’s maturity was greater than the other characters in the play.
Vonnegut Essay Research Paper After graduating from
Vonnegut Essay, Research Paper After graduating from Shortridge High in 1940 Kurt Vonnegut entered Cornell University. Vonnegut?s father and brother strongly urged him to pursue a degree in biochemistry, and during his studies he found he had no desire for the subject and was rewarded with poor grades.
Constellations Essay Research Paper Every culture known
Constellations Essay, Research Paper Every culture known to history and anthropology has seen in the heavens distinctive patterns, called constellations, and formed by the stars. Constellations are usually comprised of bright stars that appear close to each other. Oriental cultures (the ancient Chinese, for example) formed intricate patterns from some of the faintest stars, creating hundreds of constellations where the West saw only a few.
Pinochet Essay Research Paper An Overview of
Pinochet Essay, Research Paper An Overview of Pinochet “It was a day in spring , December 20,1973 at about 4:30 pm , that I heard several knocks on the door of my house , which sounded unfamiliar and threatening. My brother had
Rennasance Overview Essay Research Paper RenaissanceRenaissance was
Rennasance Overview Essay, Research Paper Renaissance Renaissance was more than just a time period, it was a state of mind. No longer did the world think in turns of conquering, power, and the catholic church. It was a time of change politically, socially, economically, and culturally. The arts were explored, and the minds of many were expanded.
Oh Really Essay Research Paper Oh Reallyyou
Oh Really? Essay, Research Paper Oh Really, you think i am a lark, the dogs they run and bark, but when i say to them, shut up shut up shut up, you say to be nice to them,
Hunters
& Gatherers Essay, Research Paper Anthropology 1010: Assignment 1 The Asmat, Headhunters, people are located in New Guinea’s West Iran. These people actually cut off people heads and eat their brains and wear their jaws as a necklace. People’s brains are not their main source of food. The major food of these people is the starch of the sago palm that they roast.
Those Winter Sundays Essay Research Paper Joshua
?Those Winter Sundays? Essay, Research Paper Joshua Erd, Box 630 Fawn Knight ASEN 101-02 29 November 2000 Those Winter Sundays Review The poem of ?Those Winter Sundays? has a very interesting and peculiar ending. The author of the poem leaves the ending open. By an open ending I mean the author ends the poem with a question.
Antigone Overview Essay Research Paper Antigone by
Antigone: Overview Essay, Research Paper Antigone, by the great tragic poet Sophocles, is about conflicting duties. The heroine Antigone has defied her uncle Creon’s edict and buried her rebellious brother. Here, Creon, concerned with the safety of the state, learns of the crime and confronts Antigone, who places family duty above everything.
Men In The Workplace Essay Research Paper
TED LEWELLEN, Professor of Anthropology at the University of Richmond, received his B.A. from Alaska Methodist University, his M.A. from New York University, and his Ph.D. from the University of Colorado. He has done field work in Peru
Cultures Celebrating Our Differences Essay Research Paper
Celebrating Our Differences Around the World Overview Students will learn about similarities and differences between their own culture and the culture of other countries. Students will “celebrate our difference around the world” by participating in a vicarious voyage program with Semester at Sea. Students will write letters to their pen-pals and learn about different countries from the letters they receive and through various activities.
Adhd Essay Research Paper ADHDUnderstanding the ProblemUnderstanding
Adhd Essay, Research Paper ADHD Understanding the Problem Understanding the Problem | Getting Help | Sustaining Hope This three-part article provides an excellent overview of the current state of knowledge regarding a disorder that is often called the most “over-diagnosed” mental problem–attention deficit hyperactivity disorder or ADHD.
Anthropology Essay Research Paper Mike MartinsMarch 7
Anthropology Essay, Research Paper Mike Martins March 7, 2000 Video Reaction Paper Due: March 10, 2000 In the film, Dadi?s Family, a group lived in Haryana in northern India. This was a system that was a matrilineage society and it is bases on the mother-in-law. The mother-in law was the head of the household and ran almost everything, from managing the finances to taking care of the children, the mother-in-law held the power in the family.
Vitamin C Essay Research Paper Over the
Vitamin C Essay, Research Paper Over the past few years, vitamin c has been a topic of controversy. There have been studies stating that vitamin c can help prevent many various health problems including cancer and other life threatening diseases. The major researcher and name associated with this side of the research is Dr.
Japanese Media Overview Essay Research Paper Japanese
Japanese Media Overview Essay, Research Paper Japanese media overview Physically, the mass media in Japan are quite similar to those in any developed nation, although perhaps somewhat more advanced. In organizational structure, however, Japanese media are unique. Individual elements of the Japanese media mix may resemble counterparts in other nations, but the combination is purely Japanese.
The Dead Child Essay Research Paper An
The Dead Child Essay, Research Paper An overview of the short story “The Dead Child” The Dead Child written by Gabrielle Roy is a story about how an young inexperienced substitute teacher helps her students to deal with the death of their peer-Yolande. The story takes place in a small Metis villege in Manitoba on a summer day in June during The Great Depression.
Social Sciences In Theatre Essay Research Paper
Social Sciences in Theatre How are the social sciences associated with theatre? In his article Performance Studies , Helbo identifies many social sciences associated with theatre including psychology, sociology, and semiotics. Psychology, he states, has greatly increased the work of the actor by giving him a tool to examine his character or role in greater depth.
Kadohata
’s The Story Devils: An Overview Essay, Research Paper Kadohata’s The Story Devils: An Overview The Story Devils, by Cynthia Kadohata is a look into the life of a young
Anthropologists Essay Research Paper Although anthropology dates
Anthropologists Essay, Research Paper Although anthropology dates back to Aristotle (384-322 BC), it became an established science during the era of colonial exploration and expansion, because of increased contact with different peoples of the world. Anthropology developed during the Industrial Revolution, along with the study of geography, and Charles Darwin’s theory of evolution.
Anthropology Essay Research Paper AnthropologyMuch better than
Anthropology Essay, Research Paper Anthropology: Much better than the other Darwin paper July 20, 1998 ——————————————————————————– When Charles Darwin released his findings on Natural Selection in 1858, he did not do so in a vacuum. Many factors contributed to the formulation of his theories, and many popular misconceptions contradicted his conclusions to the point that he was reluctant to publish them for sixteen years.
Freud Essay Research Paper Freud
Freud Essay, Research Paper Freud’s Personality Theory The development of gender roles in deifferent forms of feminsm gives us a revealing overview of Freud’s personality theory. It is relatively
Roaring Twenties Essay Research Paper The Roaring
Roaring Twenties Essay, Research Paper The Roaring Twenties The twenties are known as a decade of excess. It was apparent in the rebellious nature of the youth as well as the rise in consumerism bolstered by the increased industrial activity. The twenties were a time of developing balance – women attained the vote but immigration was more restrictive; prohibition sought to restrict the negative outcomes of a drinking society while it encouraged the development of organized crime; and black pride became a rallying cry for the back to Africa movement while the Klu Klux Klan gained in popularity and power.
Cross Cultural Psychology Essay Research Paper Psychology
Cross Cultural Psychology Essay, Research Paper Psychology is a science with abounding applications. It pertains to nearly all aspects of human life and behavior. It reveals mysteries about people, and culture as well. Psychology plays a large role in the field of Anthropology, a field devoted piecing together the puzzle of cultures around the world.
Starbucks Coffee Company Essay Research Paper CONCEPT
Starbucks Coffee Company Essay, Research Paper CONCEPT PAPER COMPANY: Starbucks Coffee Company The purpose of the video program is to orient and inform employees about the goals and objectives of the company. In addition to this, the rules and benefits of employees will be featured. The video will employ a factual style in conveying its purpose.
Anthropology Science Essay Research Paper Q2I What
Anthropology Science Essay, Research Paper I. What is Anthropology? Anthropology is the scientific and humanistic study of the human species; it attempts to answer questions to try and solve them; questions of where humans came from, the current status of our species and where we will be in the future.
The French Sociologists Essay Research Paper The
The French Sociologists Essay, Research Paper The French sociologists (holistic approach), during the eighteenth and nineteenth century were much concerned with the nature of society and of the human social institutions. Their interests
Retail Trade Essay Research Paper Write a
Retail Trade Essay, Research Paper Write a structure-performance study of the retail trade industry Paper should include the ff structure 1 Introduction. In this section you give an overview of the industry, its size, growth over the past 10-20 yrs, its important to the economy and other significant factors. 1-2 pages
Lucent Technologies Report Essay Research Paper LUCENT
Lucent Technologies Report Essay, Research Paper LUCENT TECHNOLOGY COMPANY OVERVIEW Lucent Technologies is a company that is focused on being a leader in the field of technology in building a broadband and mobile Internet community that will hopefully make a difference in the way people communicate. Lucent also provides the systems, software, silicon, and services for what has been created as the largest networking company built from the ground up in history.