Plate Tetonics Essay, Research Paper
When Albert Einstein proposed his Theory of Relativity it was not accepted immediately but eventually over time and after some debate it became a replacement for the idea of physical mechanics formulated by Isaac Newton to explain the motion of large bodies in the presence of gravity. Relativity did not totally discredit Newtonian Mechanics but it did raise new questions and could prove certain things that Newton could not. There were questions, critics, and proponents of the new idea but it came in time and after much debate. Shifting from one theory to another after the original idea has existed and been accepted for so long never sits well with scientists. This same shift of ideas is true for Alfred Wegener and his theory of Pangaea and plate tectonics. Wegener?s theories gave a plausible explanation for the presence of the same species of fossils found on two different continents. His theory refuted the current theory of huge land bridges that connected the continents. This shift from one idea to another, according to Thomas Kuhn, is considered a paradigm shift. Kuhn said, a paradigm is term that relates closely to ?Normal Science?. Normal science being ?research firmly based upon one or more past scientific achievements, achievements that some particular scientific community acknowledges for a time as supplying the foundation for its further practice? (Kuhn p.159). In the sense of scientific discoveries a paradigm is considered an example of a model formed by the theories presented by a scientist. Wegener?s theory of plate tectonics and continental drift is an example of a Kuhn paradigm shift because it took an original idea that was believed to be true and expanded on it to form a new theory and model that is still followed today.
The current theory on plate tectonics is the theory that Earth’s outer layer is made up of plates, which have moved throughout Earth’s history. The theory explains the how and why behind mountains, volcanoes, and earthquakes, as well as how, long ago, similar animals could have lived at the same time on what are now widely separated continents. Perhaps initiated by heat building up underneath the vast continent, Pangaea began to rift, or split apart, around 200 million years ago. Oceans filled the areas between these new sub-continents. The landmasses continued to move apart, riding on separate plates, until they reached the positions they currently occupy. One theory is that convection within the Earth’s mantle pushes the plates causing them to rift moving the continents and hitting other plates causing mountains to form and earthquakes to occur. Exploration of the ocean floor was the proof Wegener needed to prove his theory about plate tectonics and how it affected the movement of the continents.
The original theory for the presence of organisms on two separate continents was huge land bridges that connected one continent to the other. These bridges disappeared after huge amounts of ice melted and filled the ocean with more water. The land bridges sunk under the water and the higher elevated areas are what can be seen today. Wegener concluded that the land bridges were not the cause for organisms to be present on two continents separated by an ocean. He believed that the Earth and all its continents were one large land mass at one time and he called it Pangaea. He concluded that the continents were all connected and that explained how fossilized organisms are present in Africa and South America. He explained the position of the continents current location from Pangaea with his theory of continental drift. Continental drift theory says the continents moved and the moving plates under the Earth folding up and causing cracks in the Earth?s crust formed mountains. Wegener knew his ideas were more believable than land bridges but he could not find proof to make his theory believable. Wegener displayed his content for the scientists who did not want to accept his new theory in his book, The Origins of Continents and Oceans (4th edition) when he said:
“Scientists still do not appear to understand sufficiently that all earth sciences must contribute evidence toward unveiling the state of our planet in earlier times, and that the truth of the matter can only be reached by combing all this evidence. . . It is only by combing the information furnished by all the earth sciences that we can hope to determine ‘truth’ here, that is to say, to find the picture that sets out all the known facts in the best arrangement and that therefore has the highest degree of probability. Further, we have to be prepared always for the possibility that each new discovery, no matter what science furnishes it, may modify the conclusions we draw.”
Thomas Kuhn presents a theory about the formation of a paradigm and how there can be a shift from one paradigm to another with the emergence of a new theory. Kuhn says that science revolves around a paradigm that is formed by the ideas and theories of a scientist. Kuhn?s idea of a paradigm is like a circle whose center is the question and perimeter are the answers. When a theory is proposed and accepted the circle is complete and all other questions and answers form around the circle. A shift occurs when an answer does not seem correct or when a question exists that cannot be answered and a new circle forms around it. There is an overlap of circles but the new focus is centered on the new idea. When this new idea can be answered and more information is gathered in explaining it better than the previous circle the paradigms shifts and the new theory is accepted. The new paradigm is not accepted right away. It is argued and accepted by many people especially when it replaces something that was believed to be the standard for so long. In the case of Wegener and his theory of plate tectonics and continental drift replacing the land bridge theory; Wegener used theories from the land bridge to come up with his own theory that accounted for the continents and went further to explain formation of mountains, volcanoes and earthquakes. This paradigms shift does not prove or disprove anything because what it is explaining is only a theory. The shift is only a shift in the belief of the theory held within a paradigm. Because of ocean exploration can Wegener?s theory be accepted more enthusiastically over the land bridge theory. There is nobody alive today to prove either theory thus the land bridge theory and the plate tectonic theory are both valid. One theory just expands and explains more than the other and can be more believable.
After careful consideration of both theories and the explanation of Kuhn?s notion of a paradigm shift I believe that Wegener?s theory of plate tectonics from the land bridge theory was a paradigm shift. The land bridge theory explained the presence of fossils on different continents with the knowledge of the time; there was no overhead picture of how South America looked when fit next to Africa. Wegener saw mountains, knew what the continents looked like from above, and felt earthquakes to know that there could possibly be something more the Earth. Since he could not prove the tectonic theory without going underwater he fell short but after some underwater discoveries it was found he was right. Because of new information and technology a theory can be discredited and a new one can replace it causing a paradigm shift in thought. It is up to the individual to accept or refute the specific paradigm but everyone must know that there is more than one explanation for things that occur in nature. Alfred Wegener theory of plate tectonics clearly represents Thomas Kuhn?s idea of paradigm shift of a theory.
Другие работы по теме:
LO System Essay Research Paper ME Lube
LO System Essay, Research Paper ME Lube Oil System Cleanliness of the lube oil is very vital in the Main Diesel Engine Lube Oil System. A strainer is a device that is usually made up of a single layer of course gauze, and a very course wire mesh. This setup is used to filter out large objects that could cause blockage or damage to the lube oil system.
The Birdcage Essay Research Paper The BirdcageThe
The Birdcage Essay, Research Paper The Birdcage The landscape in the movie, The Birdcage, adds tremendously to the plot and humor of the film. The movie opens with a transvestite singing in a nightclub. We can almost predict at this point, from the setting alone, what the theme of this film is.
The Best Possible Temperature For Electrolysis Essay
, Research Paper Aim: ??????????? .Factors to be affected: ??????????? TemperatureFactors not to be affected: ??????????? Concentration, Current, Surface Area, Air Pressure And Weight Of Brass And Copper Plates.Hypothesis: ??????????? I
Two Hearted River Essay Research Paper In
Two Hearted River Essay, Research Paper In this story Nick and the fish at the bottom of the river share many similarities. Of course the do not look alike but they seem to think the same in a way. They both have reasons to be where they are.
Plate Essay Research Paper Plates
Plate Essay, Research Paper Plates The structure of the earth is made up of many layers, but the crust and theupper mantle make up the lithosphere. The lithosphere is divided intoindividual sections called plates. The rest of the mantle makes up theasthenosphere. Convection in asthenosphere causes the plates to shift andmove about.
A Woman Scorned Essay Research Paper The
A Woman Scorned Essay, Research Paper The Cook, the Thief, his Wife, and her Lover by Peter Greenway is an astounding tale of sex, deceit, corruption, and abuse. This movie is partial about a woman named Georgina and the relationship she holds between her and the two men in her life, Michael and Albert. Michael is her lover and Albert, her husband, is a head gangster.
Maradona Essay Research Paper BUENOS AIRES Racing
Maradona Essay, Research Paper BUENOS AIRES.- Racing, club que en los ?ltimos a?os estuvo a punto de desaparecer por problemas econ?micos y legales, podr?a coronarse el domingo campe?n del f?tbol argentino, despu?s de 35 a?os de sequ?a.
Mudi And Company Essay Research Paper Keemato
Mudi And Company Essay, Research Paper Keema to make qeemae wali spaghetti, first you take a little oil and put crushed garlic and ginger in it and fry a little. then put qeema it and put salt and mirchi in it. cook it without any water,
Albert Camus Essay Research Paper PHL 342
Albert Camus Essay, Research Paper PHL 342 2-15-99 Albert Camus’ quote reaches me in a meaningful way. I am going to analyze this quote by the sentence because each one carries significance in the way I interpret them. The first sentence, “ Society proceeds sovereignly to eliminate the evil ones from her midst as if she were virtue itself.” This seems to me like Camus is saying that our society is acting as if it were perfect.
Albert Eienstein Essay Research Paper ALBERT EINSTEINThe
Albert Eienstein Essay, Research Paper ALBERT EINSTEIN The German-American physicist Albert EinsteiN, contributed more than any other scientist to the 20th-century . Born in the town of Ulm, Germany, Mar. 14, 1879, HE then later died in Princeton, N.J., Apr. 18, 1955. In the wake of World War I, Einstein’s theories, especially his theory of relativity, seemed to many people to point to a pure quality of human thought, one far removed from the war and its aftermath.
Symbolism In Camus
’ The Plague Essay, Research Paper For the first essay for Integrative Studies 300 I would like to write on the Camus work, The Plague. Since Albert Camus has a philosophical view unlike that of many
Techtonic Plates Essay Research Paper Lab Report
Techtonic Plates Essay, Research Paper Lab Report The structure of the earth is made up of many layers, but the crust and the upper mantle make up the lithosphere. The lithosphere is divided into
Theory Of Knowledge
– Mathematics Essay, Research Paper “As far as the laws of mathematics refer to reality, they are not certain; as far as they are certain, they do not refer to reality.” — Albert Einstein
Al Gore Essay Research Paper Albert Gore
Al Gore Essay, Research Paper Albert Gore, Jr., b. Washington, D.C., March. 31, 1948, a U.S. representative (1977-1985) and senator (1985-1992) from Tennessee, was elected to the vice- precidency oh the United States on a Democtratic ticket with Gov. Bill Clinton of Arkansas in 1992. he is the son of Albert Gore, Sr., who was also a congressman (1953-1971).
Earthquakes Essay Research Paper Major Earthquakes for
Earthquakes Essay, Research Paper Major Earthquakes for 60s and 70s. In the map have plotted the major earthquakes for the 60s and 70s. The major earthquake areas are in the area around the Pacific Ocean. Most of the earthquakes happened at these areas and for this reason they call it “Pacific Ring of Fire”.
Italian Men Essay Research Paper Italian MenOne
Italian Men Essay, Research Paper Italian MenOne day I ma go to a bigga hotel. Ina da morning I go downa to eatta breakfast. Itella da waitress I wanna two pisses toast. She bring only one piss. I tell her I wanna twopisses. She say to go to da toilet. I say you no understand, I wanna two piss on my plate.She say you better not piss on the plate, you sonna ma bitch! I don t even know da ladyand she calla me a sonna ma bitch!Later I go to eatta lunch at da Duke Resturaunte.
Newton And Einstein Essay Research Paper Isaac
Newton And Einstein Essay, Research Paper Isaac Newton and Albert Einstein By: Briana Dreyer Albert Einstein and Isaac Newton were both the sons of farmers. Although Einstein lived in Germany and was Jewish while Newton was Catholic or Christian and lived in England. Albert taught himself geometry while Newton s family couldn t even read or write yet.
The Miracle Worker Essay Research Paper In
The Miracle Worker Essay, Research Paper In the play The Miracle Worker, Annie says to Kate “Mrs. Keller, I don’t think Helen’s worst handicap is deafness or blindness. I think it’s
The Righteous Spoon Essay Research Paper Hail
The Righteous Spoon Essay, Research Paper Hail the spoon, most righteous of all silver and table wear. The spoon, piously accepting his place at the right side of the plate alone with only a brother spoon to keep company with. Condemned to but two, at most a third appearance during a desert course, but usually two courses of a meal.
Albert Einsteins Life Essay Research Paper A
Albert Einsteins Life Essay, Research Paper A German-born American physicist and Nobel laureate, best known as the creator of the special and general theories of relativity and for his hypothesis with the particle nature of light . He is said, to be the most well known scientist of the 20th century.
Albert Einstein Essay Research Paper Relativity and
Albert Einstein Essay, Research Paper Relativity and the Cosmos In November of 1919, at the age of 40, Albert Einstein became an overnight celebrity, thanks to a solar eclipse. An experiment had confirmed that light rays from distant stars were deflected by the gravity of the sun in just the amount he had predicted in his theory of gravity, General Relativity.
The Silver Crown By Bernard Malamud Essay
, Research Paper Distrust is a major theme throughout “The Silver Crown” by Bernard Malamud. This lack of trust is not only justified by the circumstances in the story but also with the period the story was written and the author’s personal life.
Chinese Pottery Essay Research Paper Chinese potteryThe
Chinese Pottery Essay, Research Paper Chinese pottery The earliest Chinese pottery of which we have any records is the Neolithic ware from the river plains and loess highlands of north and north-west China. It was made between 5000 and 2000 B.C. and contains bowls, jars, pots and beakers of low-fires earthenware.
Clive Staples Essay Research Paper Clive Staples
Clive Staples Essay, Research Paper Clive Staples Lewis was born in Belfast Ireland on November 29,1898. He wrote many books and won many awards in his lifetime. Many of his books are still read today.
I Choose Thus Project Because When Watching
Television Both Name Brand Essay, Research Paper batteries claim to be the best. I wanted to see which one actually did last the longest. The Encyclopedia?s I did my research in say a battery is a device which
Convergent Plate Boundaries Essay Research Paper When
Convergent Plate Boundaries Essay, Research Paper When any two plates collide, some sort of activity is bound to take place. A specific type of boundary is a convergent plate boundary. At this type of boundary, two plates are moving towards each other. Neither plate is subducted into the mantle. Many things happen when plates drive into each other.
The Standard Essay Research Paper THE STANDARDI
The Standard Essay, Research Paper THE STANDARD I choose to do my essay on the St. Catharines Standard. The Standard is the St.Catharines and Thorold area newspaper. It provides us with the local news, advertising and it keeps us in touch with what is happening all over the world. It was first owned and runned by the Burgoyne family and was printed in St.
Plate Tectonics Essay Research Paper Plate TectonicsPrior
Plate Tectonics Essay, Research Paper Plate Tectonics Prior to World War II, humans were conformed with the idea that the Earth and its continents had been basically unchanged since the beginning of time. A German meteorologist, Alfred Wegener observed that the coastlines of the seven continents could be fitted together almost perfectly like a jigsaw puzzle.
Grand Unified Theory Essay Research Paper Final
Grand Unified Theory Essay, Research Paper Final essay 7 Essay 7 There are many laws to help us understand motion and the way things move and work. Most of the modern excepted theories were either thought up by Sir Isaac Newton or Albert Einstein, and Greene?s theory tried to tie them all together.