In England And America (A Plato Critique) Essay, Research Paper
Comments on Matthew Arnold s Philistinism in England and America
In his essay, Philistinism in England and America, Matthew Arnold examines the ancient ideas of Plato in the context of a twentieth century, capitalist society. As he agrees with almost all of what Plato had to say, he also admits that he is outdated, and that some of his teachings cannot be applied to us, living in an industrial superpower such as the United States. Still, though, Arnold defends the ancient philosopher. Education as a route to mental and physical righteousness is always a good idea, whether it is in modern America or Ancient Greece. I disagree with this, and it is here that I must contest the writings of Plato, as well as the essay by Arnold, for he is definitely a strong backer of the ancient ideals.
In Plato s mind, the value of an education is to clear one s mind of impure thought, bring it to a higher lever than at the start, and attain a certain level of righteousness. This may have been a good idea 2300 years ago, but today, I see it as very limiting and impractical. In his time, only the rich aristocrats went to school. It s purpose was not for the students to learn skills or ideas that would help them later in life, but to expand their minds, thus making them into better people. There was no need for them to learn any job skills. Back then, if you came from a rich family, you were rich. Working at simple jobs was for the peasants and slaves. Today, life is different. Our society is completely unlike that of the ancient Greeks. We have no caste system limiting the wealth and prominence of any citizen, we have no slavery to handle all the manual labor, our army is proportionately smaller and much less honored, and religion is a part of one s private life, not a dominating public force as it was to the Ancient Greeks. Most people today have a regular, day to day job, whether it be in an office, store, factory, or anywhere else. We have to earn our wealth by working, not inheritance. That is why most people go to school today.
I am attending NYU so that I can get a job later in life. I study chemistry and engineering, in the hopes that I can become a chemical engineer. According to Plato, this is wrong, and I m corrupting my mind. At this point in my life, I should be reading history and literature, enhancing my mind, and not worrying about developing a skill. To me, that is an unrealistic goal. As I get older, I want to have a job that pays well, so that I can support a family, and be free to do whatever I want in my spare time. I don t want to have to deal with restrictions in my life caused by a lack of money. If I lived and was educated in the way that Plato suggests, my life would probably turn out differently from that, and that is why I dislike his ideas.
In the fourth century BC, when Plato was alive and writing, society was different. His writings on education relate to that time, when modern capitalism was over two thousand years away. He had no idea what life would be like today, so it is ridiculous to base one s life on what he said so long ago. Arnold refuses to admit this. He does say that Plato s ideas are outdated, but adds that the basis for his thoughts could still be applied today, for the betterment of society and the people that live in it. If that s the way he feels, I m fine with it, but for me, learning a skill that will make me some money when I m older is more important than purifying my mind.
Другие работы по теме:
The Birth Narrative Through The Gospels Of
Matthew Luke And John (Comparison) Essay, Research Paper The birth narratives of the gospels of Matthew, Luke and John are versions of the stories of the Messiah’s birth. They are not exactly the same. John’s gospel doesn’t even give word of the virgin birth. In Biblical Theology class, we remembered each birth narrative as “the one with the shepherds,” or “the one with the wise men.” Matthew’s gospel starts with the Messiah’s genealogy.
The Nanny Murder Case Essay Research Paper
Massachusetts v. Woodward Louise Woodward, a British Nanny, was hired in November of 1996 by Sunil and Deborah Eappen, for their sons, Matthew and Brendan. On February 4, 1997, the Massachusetts police received a phone call from Woodward stating that Matthew Eappen was having trouble breathing. When the paramedics examined Matthew, they said he had a 2-? inch skull fracture.
Stone Boy Essay Research Paper Creative Task
Stone Boy Essay, Research Paper Creative Task: The Stone Boy Six years ago, Arnold Curwing accidentally shot his brother with a .22 caliber rifle. He was nine years old at the time. Surrounding this incident, as you would expect, he was under fire by his neighbors and peers from thereon, even though it was an accident.
The Stone Boy Essay Research Paper Psychiatric
The Stone Boy Essay, Research Paper Psychiatric Report “The Stone Boy” I would like to bring to your attention one of my new patients, Arnold Curwing. Mr. Curwing, 21, lives a quiet life alone withdrawn from his family and friends. He has lived these past 12 years in frustration and isolation, unable to be confident, unable to express feelings.
Oates
’ “Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been?”: Arnold Fiend Essay, Research Paper Oates’ “Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been?”: Arnold Fiend In Joyce Carol Oates’ ?Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been??
Work Conditions In The 1800
′S Essay, Research Paper In the 1800’s, it was not out of the ordinary for a child to work sixteen-hour days, seven days a week. Michael Thomas Sadler tried to show in the Sadler Report of the House of Commons, how brutal it was. The Sadler Report was volumes of testimonies from children workers and older people, who once had to work as children in the mines and factories.
Sermon On The Mount Essay Research Paper
The Sermon on the MountThroughout the book of Matthew the reader can notice many instances when Jesus wants his people to act differently then they were told to before. During Jesus’ Sermon on the Mount, he tells his people how they should live their lives, he also tells them how to pray and how to treat others.
Culture Essay Research Paper Many different people
Culture Essay, Research Paper Many different people have interpreted culture, which has an impact directly on every living human in the world today, and no one has been able to obtain a final, absolute answer. Two of the premier theorists in the field of psychology, Karl Marx and Matthew Arnold, have attempted in this endeavor and have had diverse opinions on this topic.
Joyce Carol Oates Essay Research Paper 1
Joyce Carol Oates Essay, Research Paper English 101 ?Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been? In Joyce Carol Oates? ?Where Are you Going, Where Have You Been?, there is a clear interpretation of evil in Arnold Friend and how he as a demon tries to pull Connie into the dark world of sex and emotion. Oates seems to extract scenarios of real life and add them into her story.
Joyce Carol Oates Analysis Of His Short
Story Essay, Research Paper ?Did Connie Bring Arnold?s Actions Upon Herself? ?Her heart was almost too big for her chest and its pumping made sweat break out
Untitled Essay Research Paper In the novel
Untitled Essay, Research Paper In the novel, To Kill A Mockingbird, by Harper Lee, the author comments onlife. Specifically, Harper Lee comments on racism and true courage. Racism is the first subject that the author comments on. It is obviousfrom her writing that she feels racism is that it is wrong. This is displayed inseveral ways.
Dover Beach Essay Research Paper How can
Dover Beach Essay, Research Paper How can life or anything be so wonderful, but at times seem so unbearable? This is a question that Matthew Arnold may have asked himself one day, while writing
Dover Beach Essay Research Paper In the
Dover Beach Essay, Research Paper In the poem "Dover Beach",witten in 1867 Matthew Arnold creates the mood of the poem through the usage of different types of imagery. He uses a dramatic plot in the form of a soliloquy. Arnold also uses descriptive adjectives, similes and metaphors to create the mood.
Gospel Of Matthew Essay Research Paper Response
Gospel Of Matthew Essay, Research Paper Response to Matthew The book of Matthew is written to the Jews. We see this because of the many quotes from the Old Testament. The Jews knew the Old Testament better than anyone of that time, and they should have been looking for the messiah that was promised. The main point that Matthew was trying to make by his book it that, Jesus was the messiah promised to us in the Old Testament.
Matthew 57 Essay Research Paper Matthew 57
Matthew 5-7 Essay, Research Paper Matthew 5-7 Reaction Paper Matthew 5-7 is better known as the Beatitudes. The Beatitudes are sets of rules that God gives us to abide by. There are a lot of different rules, but they
My Last Duchess Essay Research Paper Intro
My Last Duchess Essay, Research Paper Intro to Literature Paper II . My analysis of the setting in My Last Duchess and Dover Beach At first glance the setting of a poem is the psychological and physiological
The Devil In Disguise Essay Research Paper
The Devil’s Advocate Is Arnold Friend the Devil in disguise in Joyce Carol Oates’ short story “Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been?” If one were to look at the facts surrounding the actual event this story was based on, any assumption that “Friend” was anything but a man would be thrown out due to logic. However, if one were to look at the story alone, he could concede that Friend is indeed the Devil or at least the Devil’s angel.
Dover Beach
& My Last Duches Essay, Research Paper Setting in Dover Beach & My Last Duches Intro to Literature Paper II . My analysis of the setting in My Last Duchess and
Dover Beach Essay Research Paper Dover Beachby
Dover Beach Essay, Research Paper ?Dover Beach? by: Matthew Arnold In the poem ?Dover Beach? by: Matthew Arnold there is a lot of irony, appeal to the auditory and visual sense, and illusions. The tone in this poem is very sad and dismal, but he shows us how to keep faith and hope in spite of that and how important being honest, true, and faithful to one another, really is.
Comparison Dover Beach And Dover Bitch
Essay, Research Paper A man stands on the cliffs of Dover, looking out at the ocean. He is self-absorbed and experiencing feelings of dejection. This man goes on for stanzas uttering thoughts to himself, at least that is what one could surmise from the indifferent tone. Then, when the reader is convinced that the man is simply philosophizing out loud to himself, the man addresses for the first time another party.
Arnold Essay Research Paper What changes a
Arnold Essay, Research Paper What changes a military hero from a great patriot to a treasonous traitor? Benedict Arnold is the only man in our history to be a military hero for both sides. He is known to most in our country as a traitor but without his valiant efforts in battle against the British forces our country may not be singing the National Anthem but God Save the Queen.
Matthew Arnold Essay Research Paper Matthew Arnolds
Matthew Arnold Essay, Research Paper Matthew Arnolds melancholy in life, religion, and love In Dover Beach, Matthew Arnold discusses his religious views, the melancholy in his life, and a new love, which he experiences by an isolated individual as he confronts the turbulent historical forces and the loss of religious faith in the modern world.
Comparison Of Karl Marx And Matthew Arnold
Essay, Research Paper Comparison of Karl Marx and Matthew Arnold Through their writing, Karl Marx and Matthew Arnold show their opposing views on the importance of internal and external functions of culture. In the
Analysis Of Dead Man Walking Essay Research
Paper People in society today have changed their feelings towards humanity and religious practises. This change is seen clearly in the movie ?Dead Man Walking.? The characters go through changes in their
Dover Beach Essay Research Paper Dover BeachHow
Dover Beach Essay, Research Paper Dover Beach How can life be so wonderful, but at times seem so unbearable? This is a question that Matthew Arnold may have asked himself, while writing “Dover Beach.” The poem, one of Arnolds best works, is about a beach that is truly beautiful, but holds much deeper meaning than what meets the eye.
Dover Beach Vs Dover Bitch Essay Research
Paper Hecht’s parody “Dover Bitch” is a mockery of Victorian values shown in “Dover Beach”, as well as those of his own period. Hecht candidly exaggerates the speech, ideas and symbols in “Dover Beach.”.
Matthew Arnold
’s Dover Beach And Self-Dependece Essay, Research Paper Matthew Arnold s Dover Beach and Self-Dependence Matthew Arnold was born at Laleham on the Thames, the eldest son of Thomas Arnold, in 1822. He had to live in the shadow of his famous father who ran the Rugby school beginning in 1828. He went to the Rugby school since age 6, but his achievement were inconsistent.
Benedict Arnold Essay Research Paper Arnold was
Benedict Arnold Essay, Research Paper Arnold was born on January 14, 1741, in Norwich, Connecticut. Both his parents were of long-established, well-respected New England families. He was helper to a pharmacist when he was a young. However, he liked the battlefield to a druggist’s life and enlisted in the militia during the French and Indian War (1754-1763).
Benedict Arnold Essay Research Paper SS 9
Benedict Arnold Essay, Research Paper S.S 9 L.G 10 Benedict Arnold Benedict Arnold was one of the important figures in the American Revolution. He began as a patriot, and soon later married a loyalist. Benedict
Benedict Arnold Essay Research Paper Benedict Arnold
Benedict Arnold Essay, Research Paper Benedict Arnold ARNOLD, Benedict (1741-1801). The name Benedict Arnold has become a synonym for a traitor to one’s country. In the first years of the American Revolution, however, Arnold was a brilliant and dashing general, highly respected for his service to the patriot cause (see Revolution, American).