The Clock Stopped Essay, Research Paper
This clock stopped at 8:15 am the morning of August 6, 1945 when America released the fatal forces of an atomic bomb on Hiroshima. Unfortunately the owner of this watch, Kengo Futagawa, was terribly burned and mortally wounded by the atomic forces as he stood only 1600 meters from the point of impact. Sad deaths like Futagawa?s are commemorated each year by various Anti-Atomic Warfare organizations that try to spread the realism and the devastation of Atomic Warfare through the told accounts of individual Hiroshima victim?s horrific stories. They, the people of Hiroshima paid an awful price as do many victims in the time of warfare, but their story is different because it was a price that did not need to be so heavy. Due to ruthless war tactics, negligence, and ulterior motives America, the power of peace, used excessive force on Japan when it dropped the atomic bomb on Hiroshima.
There are many ways to cruelly explain America?s actions in this matter; such as revenge, or simply a quickened end to the war, but the plain truth is the A-Bombing of Hiroshima could have been easily avoided. If the decision to bomb or not to bomb was placed solely on the threat of Japan at the present time of the decision anyone could see that atomically bombing Hiroshima was unnecessary and by all means should have been used as a last resort.
Scientist, Botanist, and creator of the theories behind the Atomic Bomb, Leo Szilard and 58 others protested against the use of Atomic Bombs in the war against Japan by writing a letter to the President of the United States. The petition respectfully asked that the use of this new weapon be used in a last resort. An excerpt from the petition clearly states their intentions. ?The war has to be brought speedily to a successful conclusion and the destruction of Japanese cities by means of Atomic bombs may very well be an effective method of warfare. We feel, however, that such an attack on Japan could not be justified in the present circumstances. We believe that the United States ought not to resort to the use of atomic bombs in the present phase of the war, at least not unless the terms which will be imposed upon Japan after the war are publicly announced and subsequently Japan is given an opportunity to surrender.? (Dannen pg. 2 )
Unfortunately, this view was not shared by the decision makers, aconfined group of men; ?only about a dozen, high government officials, military advisers, and Scientist who were appointed by President Truman to help advise in the awesome decision of whether and where the bomb would be dropped.? (Fogelman pg.2 ) The recommendations of this committee and above all the advice of Secretary of War Stimson, confirmed President Truman?s own conviction that use of an atomic bomb against Japan would be necessary to bring the war to a speedy end. However, it seemed as if the speedy end Truman was so desperately seeking was around the corner. With America?s very strong air raids, and a strong chokehold on Japanese importing systems, Japan was already frantically looking for a way to surrender.
America?s strong air raids were due to ?Area Bombing,? an air raid tactic that the U.S. Airforce adopted from the Germans in their war against England, sought not to hit specific targets, but struck rather at whole cities, killing thousands of citizens. They aimed to ?de-house? enemy industrial workers, disrupt the enemy war effort, crush enemy morale, and ultimately send the enemy into submission. With this ruthless tactic in place the ?Americans had already killed well over half a million Japanese civilians by ?Area Bombing? efforts, perhaps nearly a million. This was before atomic weapons were even ready for use.? (Long pg.4 )
While Japan was being bombarded from the sky, a naval blockade was strangling Japan?s ability to import oil and other vital materials and its ability to produce war materials. Admiral William Leahy, the Chief of Staff to President Roosevelt and then to President Truman , wrote, ?By the beginning of September [1994], Japan was almost completely defeated through a practically complete sea and air blockade.? (Long pg. 3)
The most troubling aspect in the actual decision of the bombing of Hiroshima relies on the Postdam Conference and its declaration for peace issued to the Japanese from the Postdam by the United States, Great Britain, and China as an ultimatum to ?complete and utter destruction?. Two features of this Postdam Declaration are especially controversial: first, the absence of explicit mention of the new atomic weapon; and , second the absence of an explicit guarantee that the Japanese Imperial System would be preserved. Critics of the declaration have maintained that, if the Japanese leaders had been specifically warned about the impending atomic attack and if they had been assured that their Emperor would remain on his throne during the occupation, then surrender would have followed without the bombing of Hiroshima.
Before the Atomic Bomb was dropped, May 28, 1945, Herbert Hoover visited President Truman and suggested a way to end the Pacific war quickly: ? I am convinced that if you, as President, will make a short-wave broadcast to the people of Japan-tell them they can have their Emperor if they surrender, that it will not mean unconditional surrender except for the militarists- you?ll get peace in Japan- you?ll have both wars over.? (Long/quotes pg.2)
Unfortunately this advice given by Herbert Hoover was not followed and in the end the conditional surrender was given to Japan anyway. The Emperor kept his place in the thrown during the occupation. If this is true, why did the Atomic Bombing take place? Japan was obviously beaten and trying to surrender to terms that the United States was willing to agree to! Were there ulterior motives to the bombing? And if so, what could the U.S. gain by bombing Hiroshima? Could it have been revenge for Pearl Harbor?s devastation, or maybe an even further motive, the ability to show Russia America?s awesome power.
Many found the revenge of atomically bombing Hiroshima satisfying, regardless of the loss of additional American lives spent to achieve it. Truman reflected this feeling in a radio broadcast to the public on the night of August 9, after an atomic bomb had been exploded upon the Nagasaki populace: ?Having found the bomb we have used it. We have used it against those who attacked us without warning at Pearl Arbor, against those who have starved and beaten and executed American prisoners of war, against those who have abandoned all pretense of obeying international laws of warfare? (Long/quotes pg. 10)
Yet another ulterior motive for the Atomic Bombing of Hiroshima can be proven. Unbelievable as it might seem, it was to make a point to the Soviet Union. Vannevar Bush (Chief Aide for atomic matters to Stimson, the Secretary of State for War) confirmed this when he said that the bomb was: ?delivered on time so there was no necessity for any concessions to Russia at the end of the war.? (Bloomfield pg. 4)
The US did not want the Soviet Union to be involved in the anticipated ?last push? land invasion of Northern China, since this would put it in a good position to exert influence in the area once hostilities ceased. The US therefore attempted to end the fighting before the Red Army entered Chinese territory but did not accept Japanese moves to surrender, leaving President Truman confident about finishing the war in the Far East with as little help from Russia as possible.
Ultimately, the atomic bombing of Hiroshima was not needed in America?s effort to win over Japan, however, due to a sense of revenge and egotism, America?s leaders saw it justifiable in their decision. So the question comes to whether or not revenge is right or wrong? In a time of war this issue can become increasingly clouded due to high tensions and hardened emotions. Defending or reputing America?s decision does not solve history, but realizing that war in itself is a needless effort, and that needless lives will always be lost on both sides of the lines can certainly help to discourage future war efforts.
Fogleman, Edwin. Hiroshima; The Decision to Use The A-Bomb. Ed. Martin Steinmann,Jr. New York: Scribner Research Anthologies. 1964. Pg.1-75.
Tsuchida, Hiromi. Hiroshima Collection. Ed. Mayu Tsuruya
Available: lclark.edu/~history/HIROSHIMA/photos 3-4.html
Danne, Gene. Szilard petition Version 1 July 3, 1945. (damneng@peak 1995-1996) ?Atomic Bomb Decision? Available: peak/~danneng/decision/43-07-03.html.
Long, Doug. Hiroshima: Was it Necessary? Mercury
Available: /~dlong/index.html
Bloomfield, Janet Why the atom bomb wasn?t necessary to end the war. Chair of the Campaign for nuclear Disarmament. Available: oneworld/news/world/bloomfield.html
Другие работы по теме:
Racism Essay Research Paper The story Nightwatch
Racism Essay, Research Paper The story Nightwatch takes place in a small seacoast town. The neighborhood has many elegant old houses that line Main Street. In the corner of the street, there is an old Colonial Church, which has a big tower with a clock. Bare horse-chestnut trees cast shadows against the old Colonial Church.
Art History Essay Research Paper M
Art History Essay, Research Paper ?M & M ? s? When I entered in the gym, the outside morning quiet, softly blowing breeze stopped and the screams of go Phillips was
The Cave Essay Research Paper Notes on
The Cave Essay, Research Paper Notes on ?The Cave? author- Jean McCord George- Bum who lived in a cave and made statues Charles- Main char. Charles was running when he saw a cave. He stopped and
Descriptive Essays Essay Research Paper The Separating
Descriptive Essays Essay, Research Paper The Separating White Line I glance up at the scoreboard; the clock reads 2:15 left in the fourth quarter. My team is down by 3 points; we have eighty-five yards to go, and have no time outs left. I yell out the cadence and the center snaps the oblong ball into my hands. Taking a short three-step drop I glance to my left.
My Love Essay Research Paper You are
My Love Essay, Research Paper You are my everything My one true love My heart will sing If we can stay forever in love When I first laid eyes upon you My jaw dropped
Red Death Essay Research Paper Red Death
Red Death Essay, Research Paper Red Death Critique Even though Edgar Allen Poe has publicly stated his dislike for the technique of allegory (a type of metaphor abstract). Uses of it can be found in his short story “The Masque of the Red Death”. Two that are evident are; the clock that signals Deaths approach, and the repetition of the number seven to implies life’s end.
Theo Essay Research Paper SummaryThis article shows
Theo Essay, Research Paper Summary This article shows us how Christianity has changed throughout the ages. We can see how Jesus has become the dominant figure in today?s western culture. It tells of how Christianity differed with the teaching of the ancient Romans, and how God wanted us to live our lives. People stopped being afraid of death and their values were changing, becoming much different than those of the Romans.
Shangeid To China Essay Research Paper The
Shangeid To China Essay, Research Paper The book is about a boy named Neil who came down to Liverpool to stay with his grandparents . While Neil was there, he snuck out of the house and went to the waterfront.There he stopped to
Stairway To Heaven Essay Research Paper In
Stairway To Heaven Essay, Research Paper In the first verse the writer talks about a lady who is buying him a present. If she gets the right thing than he will be happy and it would be
Vincent
’s Musuem Essay, Research Paper ARTIFACTS GENUINE!!!BY,JEFF MCCLURE VINCENT?S MUSEUM?S ARTIFACTS PROVED REAL see below Recently at Vincent?s museum alot of talk was about the artifact?s
Nuclear Weapons Essay Research Paper The topic
Nuclear Weapons Essay, Research Paper The topic of nuclear weapons is one that will be around forever. One of my favorite lines from the reading we had was that we cannot uninvent nuclear
Meaningful Event Essay Research Paper At about
Meaningful Event Essay, Research Paper At about four o clock on a Tuesday evening I arrived home after a rugby practice. I was idly kicking off my shoes as I noticed a letter sitting on my kitchen table from Queen s University. Not knowing what to expect, I opened it greedily. What I read caused perhaps the most disappointing moment of my life.
Leslie BricusseS Scrooge Essay Research Paper ScroogeThe
Leslie Bricusse?S ?Scrooge? Essay, Research Paper Scrooge The play that I read for my independent reading report was Leslie Bricusse’s “Scrooge”. This play is a Christmas musical, which takes place in the 1800’s. It stars Ebenezer Scrooge, a grouchy old businessman who hates Christmas, and every other day of the year.
Kitty Essay Research Paper I wrote this
Kitty Essay, Research Paper I wrote this when I was 12.When the tea is brought at five o’clock, And all the curtains are drawn with care, The little kitty with bright green eyes
Rock N Roll Essay Research Paper title
Rock N Roll Essay, Research Paper title: Rock N RollWhile the exact time frame that the first strains of rock and roll music came bursting forth is nearly impossible to pinpoint, 1955 is arguably the year that it all began. On July 9 of that year, the new #1 single on the Best Sellers in Stores chart was (We’re Gonna) Rock Around the Clock by Bill Haley and the Comets.
One Scary Night Essay Research Paper The
One Scary Night Essay, Research Paper The One Scary Night Once upon a time there was a girl and a boy that lived in a small town of Roughville. They were best friends. They did every thing together sleep, eat, just everything. There were about 700 people in the Roughville. Most of which were hard workers in the town next to Roughville.
Love And Friendship Essay Research Paper Two
Love And Friendship Essay, Research Paper Two men lived, and two men died, And each saw the world through a different pair of eyes, And throughout their ventures, they often stopped to cry,
A Trip To China Essay Research Paper
I went to China at 4th April, with my grandma and grandpa. That day, we got up at 7 o*clock in the morning. We went on the ship at 9:40am. When we reached China, we saw our relation, they saw us and helped us to carry the luggage. They are very kind to us.
Nothing Can Bring You Peace But Yourself
. Essay, Research Paper Nothing can bring you peace but yourself. ?Nothing can bring you peace but yourself.” “Yourself,”? I am thinking about the time when my best friend died, and when I stopped
Sport Is Greatest School Of Vanity Essay
, Research Paper Sport Is The Greatest School Of Vanity It is two o’clock on Saturday the 22 February 2000. It is the day of the annual Hilton VS Michael House rugby game. In the stands, five hundred schoolboys eagerly await the arrival of the fifteen so-called “Gods” dressed in the black and white to come racing onto the field.
Snooze Essay Research Paper It is seven
Snooze Essay, Research Paper It is seven o clock in the morning and your ever faithful alarm clock shatters your restful slumber into early morning chaos. You are running late. Half-dressed and
The Monastery And The Clock Essay Research
Paper “The clock, not the steam engine, is the key machine of the modern industrial age.” (Mumford, “The Monestary and the Clock”, page 326.) represents the thesis of Mumford’s “The Monastery and the Clock”.
InClass Writing Essay Research Paper Inclass Writing
In-Class Writing Essay, Research Paper In-class Writing or Homework Desks and paper rattle while time slowly tics away from the clock. This time these distractions do not bother you because you are finishing one of your most well written papers. In-class writings are great because they include many positive opportunities.
Pet Shop Essay Research Paper Ive been
Pet Shop Essay, Research Paper I?ve been in lots of pet shop, and they?fve alwaays seemed to be cute, happy, friendly, clean places. That?fs why, on a recent Sunday afternoon, I stopped in a pet shop for to see pets. I?fd been visiting my friends, whom I talked about cute pets, and saw that we were favorite pets.
My Dog Essay Research Paper Over the
My Dog Essay, Research Paper Over the past several months, my family and I noticed that Molly, our 12-year-old dog, had progressively become more torpid about the house and outside. At first, we thought something was wrong. We believed that she had come down with some sort of sickness. After a while, we came to our senses and deduced that it was probably just old age.
Disaster Recovery Essay Research Paper Windows on
Disaster Recovery Essay, Research Paper Windows on Management – Disaster Recovery in the New Information Age This window talks about some of the benefits of a recovery system for businesses with round the clock electronic commerce. If a disaster happens and these companies don’t have a recovery system, it can cause massive delays and that can lead to loss of business and profits.
Fear And Lonelines Essay Research Paper Fear
Fear And Lonelines Essay, Research Paper Fear and Loneliness Fear exists in all human. We all have that natural sense of fear in our mind. My name is Bo Peng, and my greatest fear in life is being alone. I believe Loneliness is the most horrific thing in life.
Gun Control Essay Research Paper Gun EssayShould
Gun Control Essay, Research Paper Gun Essay Should we really just keep adding gun control laws? Well, I don’t think so. I think that Senator Larry E. Craig said it best “the criminal that wasn’t stopped by 20,000 laws won’t stop at 20,001.“ My viewpoint is that we should have better law enforcemnt.
Grand Unified Theory Essay Research Paper Final
Grand Unified Theory Essay, Research Paper Final essay 7 Essay 7 There are many laws to help us understand motion and the way things move and work. Most of the modern excepted theories were either thought up by Sir Isaac Newton or Albert Einstein, and Greene?s theory tried to tie them all together.