Stanford Experiment Essay, Research Paper
English 101-02
December 5, 1996
A Critique Of the Stanford Experiment
“The Education of a Torturer” is an account of experiments that has similar results
to that of Milgram’s obedience experimentsthat were performed in 1963. Though both
experiments vary drastically, both have one grim outcome, that is that, “it is ordinary
people, not psychopaths, who become the Eichmanns of history.”
The Stanford experiment was performed by psychologists Craig Haney, W. Curtis
Banks, and Philip Zimbardo. Their goal was to find out if ordinary people could become
abusive if given the power to do so. The results of the six day experiment are chilling. The
experiment took ordinary college students and had some agree to be prisoners and the rest
would be guards for the prisoners. Both groups received no training on what to do or act
like. They had to get all of their knowledge of what to do from outside sources, such as
television and movies. The guards were given uniforms and night sticks and told to act
like an ordinary guard would. The prisoners were treated like normal criminals. They
were finger printed and booked, after that they were told to put on prison uniforms and
then they were thrown into the slammer (in this case a simulated cellblock in the
basement was used). All of the participants in this experiment at first were thought to be
similar in behavior but after one week, all of that changed. The prisoners became
“passive, dependent, and helpless.” The guards on the other hand were the exact
opposite. They became “aggressive and abusive within the prison, insulting and bullying
the prisoners.”
After the experiment was finished, many of the mock guards said that they enjoyed
the power. Others said that they had no idea that they were capable of being so corrupt.
The experimenter was shocked at the results as well saying, “It was degrading….To me,
those things are sick. But they (the prisoners) did everything I said. They abused each
other because I requested them to. No one questioned my authority at all.”
I have a hard time believing the statement that they experimenter said. He had
reviewed the work of Stanley Milgram’s experiment and how individuals became so
violent. Haney, Banks, and Zimbardo had to of known that if they gave the power to take
control of a situation the guards that the power would be abused. The experiment took
place in 1986 and though there had been many years passed since Milgram’s experiment
was conducted in 1963, people then and still today try to get to the top of every situation.
In this case, the guards were given the power, and it probably took a day or so before they
began to abuse they power and abuse the inmates. If only they experiment would have
been conducted a year later, Haney, Banks, and Zimbardo may have been able to foresee
the outcome by reading Robert Reich’s “An American Morality” which includes a parable
entitled “Rot at the Top.” The last line in the parable just goes to prove my point, “Power
corrupts, privilege perverts.” I agree with this totally because I can’t think of anytime that
I have seen somebody not take advantage of the power given to them in some way or form.
Haney, Banks, and Zimbardo did have one good thing come out of this
experiment. That is that they used ordinary people just like Milgram years earlier and put
them to the test. They subjects obviously failed because all of them showed that, “it is
ordinary people, not psychopaths, who become the Eichmanns of history.”
Другие работы по теме:
Reading And Comprehension Essay Research Paper Reading
Reading And Comprehension Essay, Research Paper Reading and Comprehending English is a strong complex language. It can be very difficult to read and comprehend. To ask one, who s first language is not English they would tell you that English is painstakingly hard to understand. That is why people need to learn to read and understand what they read.
Moon Essay Research Paper Conclusion on the
Moon Essay, Research Paper Conclusion on the Moon Watch When I first got this assignment I was thinking I am never going to be able to do this every night for a month. I surprised myself once again. This class has made me doubt myself many times but I always seem to pull myself up to do it. I believe I did very well on this experiment and I achieved the purpose.
What I Think Of English Class Essay
, Research Paper I cant believe it?s the last year of high school, hopefully. It feels like just the other day when I was a Freshman. English has always been my worst subject, but I have always seemed to be able to get through it. I have always done the minimal work to pass in the past classes I have taken. Mr. MacKenzie?s senior English class isn?t like most I have taken before.
Men Essay Research Paper Experiment Aims to
Men Essay, Research Paper Experiment Aims to Get Real Men to Go to the Doctor This article from the New York Times explains men not admitting their sick or hurt. The men which were tested in this article men would ignore their aches and pains, mental and physical, until it is too late. I think that it is true that some men are afraid to look ?wimpy? or be called.
Dianne Day Essay Research Paper Dianne Day
Dianne Day Essay, Research Paper Dianne Day isn t as famous as Mary Higgins Clark but she had a childhood similar to her. When she was a baby in Mississippi her father died. Dianne went on to live with her grandparents and they also were not a well-financed family. When Dianne was seven she rejoined her mother was now remarried.
English Class 009 Essay Research Paper I
English Class 009 Essay, Research Paper I am taking English 009 to benefit me in the future. It gives me the skills I need to succeed. I would be able to write a paper; because of the writing skills I have learned in English 009. From studying hard, my grammar could be improved. I would be offered a teaching position as a substitute teacher for English because of my experience in English 009.
Obedience Essay Research Paper Comparison Contrast EssayIn
Obedience Essay, Research Paper Comparison/ Contrast Essay In “The Perils of Obedience” by Stanley Milgram, Milgram explains that obedience is a natural occurring behavior, which acts on instinct ignoring a persons ethics, sympathy, and moral conduct (Milgram 343). In this experiment two people come into the laboratory where they are told they will be taking part in a study of memory and learning.
ExpirementHuman Research Essay Research Paper Experiment
Expirement-Human Research Essay, Research Paper Experiment: Figure Voting ration from Gore to Bush (Al Gore to George W. Bush) First step is to watch or read something of politics having to do with the Presidential Elections. Than send out QUESTIONAIRES to RESPONDENTS to do some UNSTRUCTED INTERVIEWS on a possible 5 minute INTERVIEW.
Finding The Density Of Air Essay Research
Paper The density of air In this experiment we are to measure the density of air. It is a quite simple experiment, you learn how important it is to measure exact and be aware of the sources of error when measuring such small quantities. The whole idea is that you know the mass of a certain volume of air, and then measure the volume.
Blue Bottle Experiment Essay Research Paper Description
Blue Bottle Experiment Essay, Research Paper Description In the demonstration, a bottle of colourless liquid is shaken for a few seconds until the liquid turns blue. Upon standing for about a minute, the solution goes clear again. This sequence can be repeated many times.
Fusion Heat Essay Research Paper The objective
Fusion Heat Essay, Research Paper The objective of this experiment is to find the heat of fusion of water by using a calorimeter. The calorimeter will be used to melt ice in water to find the
Milgrim
’s Shock Psychology Essay, Research Paper Paul Brown 10/10/00 Methods pp.3 The most famous experiment Milgram conducted was also his most controversial. The issue dealt with the
Physics Lab Essay Research Paper III ResultsAnalysisMy
Physics Lab Essay, Research Paper III. Results/Analysis: My lab partner and I worked diligently in this experiment to be as accurate and as precise in our measurements and calculations with the technology provided. In part one of the experiment, we calculated the amount of force on the planet at the closest distance to be approximately 18 F.
The First Reactor Essay Research Paper The
The First Reactor Essay, Research Paper The First Reactor The First Reactor chronicles the conception and implementation of the first self-sustaining nuclear pile. The booklet has three main sections to it. The first one tells of the history and background of the organizations and research that were used for the momentous experiment, as well as the actual proceedings that occurred on December 2, 1942.
Stars Essay Research Paper Bright Star Would
Stars Essay, Research Paper Bright Star, Would I were Steadfast as Thou Art Endymion (excerpts) The Eve of St. Agnes Fancy The Human Seasons Hyperion If by Dull Rhymes our English must be Chain’d
Peoms Essay Research Paper English 3
Peoms Essay, Research Paper English 3 The Sky is Filled With Laughter The sky is filled with laughter Like a little kid at a fair With streaks of blue and white
Perils Of Obedience Essay Research Paper The
Perils Of Obedience Essay, Research Paper The Perils of Obedience This experiment is a test to see if people are naturally aggressive. Milgram does not believe that people are naturally aggressive. Although some people think people are naturally aggressive. Ordinary people can be part of a bad course of actions without having any anger toward then victim.
Filtered Speech Experiment Essay Research Paper Filtered
Filtered Speech Experiment Essay, Research Paper Filtered Speech Experiment Purpose The purpose of the filtered speech experiment was to look for three things. The first was to see/hear which frequencies can be eliminated from speech signal and conversely which frequencies can not in order to understand speech.
The Milgram Experiment Essay Research Paper The
The Milgram Experiment Essay, Research Paper The Milgram Experiment The Milgram experiment is one of Psychology?s most controversial experiments. The study examines to what extend individuals obey an authority figure, and how far they will go, even if they believe their actions are harming another individual.
Prop 63 Essay Research Paper The Official
Prop. 63 Essay, Research Paper The Official English Language Proposition 63 will make English the Official Language of the United States and I am against The official English
Chemistry Lab Essay Research Paper Lab ReportIntroductionThe
Chemistry Lab Essay, Research Paper Lab Report Introduction: The purpose of this lab was determining the molecular weight of an unknown solid organic compound by freezing point depression. In order to do so, one has to first, freeze cyclohxane, by putting it in ice cold water, and see what the constant temperature comes out as.
Womens Brains Essay Research Paper English 104Essay
Womens Brains Essay, Research Paper English 104 Essay This is a brief summary of the essay “Women’s Brains” by Stephen Jay Gould, published in The Panda’s Thumb in 1980. Gould feals that the study of this is irrelevant to the field that they are studying and that the experiments should not have been conducted.
English Essay Research Paper She stood there
English Essay, Research Paper She stood there, staring in disbelief at her reflection. Could the person looking back at her from the mirror really be herself? She ran her fingers through her long dark
Poem The Beach Essay Research Paper Ryan
Poem: The Beach Essay, Research Paper Ryan Hartney English 9 3/8/01 The Beach I have always liked the beach best Its fun in the sun for everyone You can have a picnic
Metric System Essay Research Paper Metric SystemThe
Metric System Essay, Research Paper Metric System The Metric System, also known as the System Internationale (SI) was developed in France in 1799. The Metric System was created because the French and English were not in agreement politically, therefore the French did not want anything to do with the English including their system of measurements.
Journal Writing Essay Research Paper Journal Writing
Journal Writing Essay, Research Paper Journal Writing I write a lot in class but I don’t like writing one bit it gets on my nerves cause my hands are very sensitive and my hands get so tired that don’t even want to type anymore and that messes me up a lot cause in my English class you are required to write a lot. Now if it were typing that a whole other story but that’s not going to help me in life to come cause when you go get a job you are required to have punctuality.
Summary And Responce To
“Black English” Essay, Research Paper Summary and Response Word Count 366 Summary In the essay titled, ?If Black English Isn?t a Language, Then Tell Me, What Is??
Boyle
’s Law Experiment Essay, Research Paper Introduction This group experiment was to investigate Boyleґs Law. It was named Boyleґs Law, after Robert Boyle, who made the discovery. The experiment involved compressing a certain amount of air molecules into a smaller space. The way to do this is to trap the air in between the top end of a glass tube and a very thick layer of oil.
The English Language Essay Research Paper This
The English Language Essay, Research Paper This House affirms that the British Empire was a great success whose effects are still beneficial to the world. The world distribution of English users is divided into three categories : English as a native language; for example, UK, USA, Australia, English as a second language; for example, India, Singapore, Ghana, Philippines, and English as a foreign language; for example, France, Japan, Thailand.There are 72 countries with Englishs as an official language and 9 countries with English as a first language:Australia, Great- Britain, Canada, Ireland, Japan, Luxembourgh, Netherlands, New Zealand, and the USA.
What Is English Essay Research Paper English
What Is English? Essay, Research Paper English, well what is English? We all know that it is a language. But, what is the study of english? It is the study of literature in the english language. People attend english classes. This may be to learn the English Language or to learn about english literature or writing.