Autonomy Vs. Paternalism Essay, Research Paper
Focus: Discuss the advantages and disadvantages on autonomy and paternalism.
Decision-making would be so much easier if we all maintained our autonomy in making the decision, however, because our decisions do not always abide by autonomistic values paternalistic intervention must occur. The purpose of autonomy is to allow us to choose to do things that affect only ourselves and does not negatively affect those around us. Unfortunately, many choices do, whether we know it or not, involve those in our environment. Paternalism is in place to protect the rights that are in our best interest and that will benefit us in the long run. Paternalistic intervention occurs when decisions are no longer in our best interests. If the decision is like to be regretted and irreversible in the future, paternalism is again justified. Autonomy is a fleeting concept, for as soon as someone chooses to do something that will later cause an addiction, his or her autonomy is lost. They no longer have the decision to do or not to do the action; it becomes a need.
Autonomy does have its advantages and disadvantages. One perk to autonomy is that it allows us to make decisions that we feel are in our best interests, as long as they either, do not affect those around us or are beneficial for them as well. As long as choices made based on autonomy are a result of the person acting on relevant, settled, preferred, and their own preferences; paternalistic intervention is not justified. However, autonomy is one of the easily lost characteristics. As I mentioned above, once an addictive substance has entered your life due to an autonomistic decision, your autonomy is lost. The addiction takes over and you can neither choose to have this addictive substance, nor choose not to have it. It controls your life and compels you to keep using it, therefore your decision is no longer your own. An example of this is any type of drug. Cigarette smoking is an excellent example. Most people who smoke look at it as a choice they made that only affects their lungs, but smoking doesn?t just affect the smoker?s body. Secondhand smoke kills more nonsmokers than firsthand smoke kills smokers. The choice to smoke becomes an addictive habit, which kills your autonomy. You do not have the choice to stop anymore.
Paternalism is in place to look out for and enforce what is in our best interest, whether they are choices we would or would not make. If decisions we make now are likely to be regretted in the future and are more likely to be irreversible, paternalistic intervention is there to step in and aid the decision. For example, someone chooses to drop out of school at a young age. That person will eventually regret this decision because they will find it hard to get a job with limited education, and also find it virtually impossible to put themselves back through school with limited funds to do so. This situation is a justified situation for paternalism to step in. Paternalism is mainly used in large decisions in people?s lives, decisions that involve high stakes. The advantages of having paternalism in place is that in the long run, with paternalistic intervention, our decisions will be better made. Paternalism is used by officials when make public policy. They look at your surface preferences and judge them on a standard of deeper preferences when configuring limitations and freedoms. There are, however, four types of preferences that prevent paternalistic intervention. They are relevant, settled, preferred, and your own preferences. As long as officials are convinced you are acting on one or all of those preferences, they have no right to step in. The disadvantages to paternalism is that most feel that they should be able to make their own decisions without having any interference. Paternalism is looked down upon when someone feels that their best interest was in the choice they made but paternalists feel differently. In the story of Rose Cipollone, paternalism was too late for her. She had been smoking from the age of 16, a very impressionable age, and though she attempted to quit many times, the loss of her autonomy caused the addiction to take over. Her smoking then caused cancer. The paternalistic view says that, at age 16, Rose?s decision may have been to smoke, but her decision later in life is to live. Had paternalistic intervention occurred when she was 16, she may not have liked it then, but knowing what she knows now, she would have been grateful later in life. This is an example of the decision being something you would regret later and being irreversible.
I believe that autonomy only goes so far in our decision making. Many of our decisions are made by paternalism. There are so many policies that protect our best interests that autonomy does not have much breathing room. I am a supporter of paternalistic intervention because I have seen what smoking has done to many people around me as well as to myself. Knowing the side effects and damage smoking can do, I do not see how someone can knowing choose to pick up a cigarette. I know it is an addictive habit because I was a smoker for two years and it has been the hardest thing to quit for me. It started with peer pressure and naivet?. I was in a mindset of ?that can?t happen to me?. I knew all of the horrible things it could do to you because my grandfathers and father were smokers and I looked at it as a disgusting habit. Boy, how your views change when you are making the decision for yourself. I believe that paternalism is a good thing to have, especially in cases where the outcome of the decision is not foreseen clearly.
Другие работы по теме:
Paternalisic Laws Essay Research Paper The Seatbelt
Paternalisic Laws Essay, Research Paper The Seatbelt Law A paternalistic law is an interference with a person s liberty for that person s own good. An example of a paternalistic law is the law that says: all people must were seatbelts when riding in the front seat of a car. According to John Stuart Mill in his essay On Liberty a problem occurs when the government enforces paternalism.
Nutrition Essay Research Paper Nutrition and Diet
Nutrition Essay, Research Paper Nutrition and Diet Project My average calorie intake per day was 1531.8. My caloric need per day was 3326. My intake is supposed to be way more than what it is. This is really surprising to me. The average percentage of carbohydrates, fat and protein is in the chart below. DAY FAT CARBS PROTEIN SUGAR1 20% 34% 20% 25%2 10% 73% 17% 0%3 21% 47% 13% 19%4 18% 52% 15% 16%5 20% 48% 17% 15% These numbers are around what I should have.
Blackmail Essay Research Paper Critical Philosophy PaperFMS
Blackmail Essay, Research Paper Critical Philosophy Paper FMS 106 Tom Ellis I will be discussing John Stuart Mill’s views on paternalism. I will argue how I feel about the subject. Then I will try my best to put myself into Mill’s shoes, argue back and try to see if I can understand where he is coming from with his arguments on paternalism.
Essay On The Movie
“Lord Of The Flies” Essay, Research Paper Essay On the Movie “Lord of the Flies” After viewing the movie The Lord of the Flies, I would say that this movie is
Philosophy 2 Essay Research Paper
#2 Explain how Augustine s conception of freedom relates to compatibilism and to freedom in the sense of autonomy. According to Augustine, Human beings are endowed with a power that he calls the will. He emphasizes the will to being the center of freedom. Unlike other philosophers, who are determinists, Augustine, who has a libertarian view, sees our will as free choice.
Oh Really Essay Research Paper Oh Reallyyou
Oh Really? Essay, Research Paper Oh Really, you think i am a lark, the dogs they run and bark, but when i say to them, shut up shut up shut up, you say to be nice to them,
Parenting Styles Essay Research Paper There are
Parenting Styles Essay, Research Paper There are 4 parenting styles based on parental responsiveness and demandiveness. These styles are Authoritative, Authoritarian, Indulgent parents, and Indifferent.
Human Cloning 2 Essay Research Paper The
Human Cloning 2 Essay, Research Paper The creation of life has often been the focus of many novels from Frankenstein to Brave New World. This former unconceivable chimera has now been transformed into a reality, with the science of genetics and cloning expanding much more rapidly than any other facet of today s technology.
Treatment Of The Prisoners In The Concentration
Camps Essay, Research Paper Interdisciplinary Research Research Proposal The Treatment of the Prisoners in the Concentration Camps The topic that I plan to focus on in my research paper is treatment inside different concentration camps during the Holocaust. I plan to focus on three different camps, but I have not narrowed down my choices yet.
Religion Mencius Essay Research Paper The Eastern
Religion: Mencius Essay, Research Paper The Eastern religions often focus on the human nature and condition. And such was the case for Mencius. Mencius devoted himself to expanding and elaborating Confucius? previous notion of human nature. Since the Eastern religions did not focus on a Wholly Other, and rather the here-and-now, such spiritual matters had to be related in a more tangible means.
East Timor Essay Research Paper The Indonesian
East Timor Essay, Research Paper The Indonesian invasion and occupation of East Timor is one of the worst atrocities of this century. The occupation has claimed the lives of over 200,000 Timorese people, one-third of the
John Donne Essay Research Paper Although the
John Donne Essay, Research Paper Although the main focus of many of his poems is death, Donne’s ego seems to steal the spotlight. In Holy Sonnet 10, he manages to defend humankind against death, possibly because he feels he cannot be defeated by God. As with most themes in his work, however, he often changes his opinion, leaving a confused reader to attempt to find his real belief about death.
Group Work Outline Essay Research Paper Group
Group Work Outline Essay, Research Paper Group Conflict Resolution Annotated Outline I. Introduction In this section, we will state our topic, which is group conflict resolution. We will present the subtopics we will focus on in the paper. We will briefly tie the four subtopics into each other under the umbrella topic of group conflict resolution.
Whats Wrong With Involuntary Euthanasia Essay Research
Paper A massive push is now underway to ensure that many people with a supposed poor “quality of life” — not only people with disabilities that are congenital, but also with disabilities caused by illness or injury — are “allowed” to die against their will.
President Clinton Essay Research Paper The content
President Clinton Essay, Research Paper The content of President Clinton’s speech was elaborated and over zealous. His focus was directed on three topics: the past, the present, and the future. In the introduction, he started by addressing the challenges that will be bestowed upon us in the next century.
What Is Wrong With Killing Essay Research
Paper What is wrong with Killing? Apparently, the killing of human beings whether people accept it or not, exists within our ever growing society. Obviously it’s against the law, however does this make it wrong? The answer to this question is no. From a religious perspective killing another individual is wrong.
Interpersonal Communication Essay Research Paper There are
Interpersonal Communication Essay, Research Paper There are so many qualities about a person that we should consider, but normally the first thing that we are attracted to is how that person looks, many times even before we know the person we have made a decision about them. This is a big part of selection. We select those exterior qualities and at first, ignore the inner qualities.
Optics Essay Research Paper Aim To examine
Optics Essay, Research Paper Aim: To examine characteristics of a converging lens and the images they create. Also to examine the focal length and how the focus point may be found and developing rules for locating an image via ray drawings and the intersection of rays. Chromatic aberration will also be explored and why it happens.
Dolphin Essay Research Paper The Dolphin Circle
Dolphin Essay, Research Paper The Dolphin Circle exists to increase your awareness of dolphins and the world of marine mammals. Our special focus is on interspecies communication and the influence the dolphins may have on emotional and physical healing.
Liberty And Paternalism Essay Research Paper LIBERTY
Liberty And Paternalism Essay, Research Paper LIBERTY AND PATERNALISM John Stuart Mill and Gerald Dworkin have distinctly opposing views on legal paternalism in that Mill is adamantly against any form of paternalism, whereas Dworkin believes that there do exist circumstances in which paternalism is justified.
School Girls Essay Research Paper In the
School Girls Essay, Research Paper In the book School Girls by Peggy Orenstein, the focus is on young adolescent girls in middle school, and the effects that the ?Hidden Curriculum? and other elements have on their self esteem. ?Hidden Curriculum teaches girls to value silence and compliance.? (pg.35) The hidden curriculum is a theory that boys often get more attention than girls in the classroom, and that even if it is negative attention, the girls learn that they are not as important, and they eventually give up hope, and stop speaking out in class.
IMPROVING DOCUMENT PRODUCTIVITY Essay Research Paper IMPROVING
IMPROVING DOCUMENT PRODUCTIVITY Essay, Research Paper IMPROVING DOCUMENT PRODUCTIVITY My plan for improving my productivity in producing documents is to focus on time management and on work organization. If you can improve both of these factors, my overall productivity will be significantly higher.
Snowboarding And Safety Essay Research Paper RIDING
Snowboarding And Safety Essay, Research Paper RIDING SMART – ADVICE FOR SAFE SNOWBOARDING Preventing injuries will allow us to focus on fun, teamwork, and achieving individual goals. The most common injuries in snowboarding are to the wrist, shoulder, and head. Here are a few simple tips that I follow to reduce my risk of injury.
Freud Essay Research Paper Freud
Freud Essay, Research Paper Freud’s Personality Theory The development of gender roles in deifferent forms of feminsm gives us a revealing overview of Freud’s personality theory. It is relatively
Autonomy Vs. Paternalism In Mental Health Treatment
Essay, Research Paper Autonomy Vs. Paternalism In Mental Health Treatment The assignment for this Ethics class was to review Mr. Jacob’s treatment, as described by the New York State Commission on Quality of Care for the
Solutions 2 Essay Research Paper Even though
Solutions 2 Essay, Research Paper Even though the main area to attack is illiteracy we cannot ignore the other problems. To eliminate hunger and also boost the economy, the focus should be on new efficient farming methods so that more of the farmable land can be used. Improvements in farming equipment and methods, marketing, and transportation are needed to increase agricultural output; therefore, Ethiopia should form ties in the form of student exchanges with other first world nations.
Hamlet Movie Essay Research Paper The movie
Hamlet Movie Essay, Research Paper The movie of Hamlet was an excellent, as far as book-movies go. I believe it was produced with focus, reason, and logic. The characters were also portrayed with
MoneyThe Root Of All Evil Essay Research
Paper Money has screwed up society a lot. The times long ago were not focused around a green piece of paper that we have labeled as money. This piece of paper got an amount and then finally you have to have it. True, money buys you things. Things that you want. Things that you need. To me, money is just that; a thing.
Durkheim On Sociology Essay Research Paper To
Durkheim On Sociology Essay, Research Paper To begin his article Durkheim is says that Sociology is in the stage of system-building because the problem is proposes is not clear-cut. What he is saying here is that Sociology is not a fully excepted science at this time because of the uncertainties that possesses.
Ford Focus Copying Honda Civics Essay Research
Paper Ford Focus Copying Honda Civics? Have you ever heard of a live commercial? Or better yet ever seen one? Well Ford Motor Company is about to launch the new Focus. The Focus is targeted at the first time buyers market. Ford Motors is spending at least $100 million dollars in this new approach marketing strategy.