Paper
In order to answer the question posed it is important to firstly define what is meant by the important terms, we can then analyse Durkheimґs views and the way that they have been used to explain the complex issues surrounding suicide. The Oxford Dictionary of Sociology defines anomie as ‘An absence, breakdown, confusion or conflict in the norms of a society.ґ Marshall B. Clinard stated that anomie is “ A sense of confusion and (is when) people become disorientated from their world”.
Anomie is also one of the ways that Durkheim categorised the different types of suicide. Durkheim believed that social causes were the explanation for suicide and they could be examined and separated into four different categories, namely anomic, altruistic, egoistic and fatalistic, by their differences and similarities, Durkheim also states that of being morphological, his classification would be aetiological. (Durkheim, 1952 p147) Durkheim believed that anomic and egoistic are the commonest forms of suicide. Anomic suicide is when there is said to be insufficient rules, the individual often finds themselves in a new situation where they are unsure of the conditions and expectations and the rules which govern this new situation (Durkheim, 1952 p147) It is not only unfortunate circumstances which put an individual in this situation, it can also be fortune, which leaves no limits, and hence the individual becomes disillusioned and unsettled, as they have left their old regulated ways and they are now in an unstable situation where they cannot predict the future. They often feel unaccepted by their new state and also from what they were used to. Anomic suicide is often attributed to either economic boom or depression. In a depression the individual is catapulted to a position below what they are used to, they are often no longer able to afford the comforts and luxuries that they once had, they need to learn to cutback (Durkheim, 1952 p252). They are now in a period of unbalance, as they need time to adjust to their new situation, the future appears bleak and they do not understand the new rules which now govern their lives, they are moving in the opposite direction for any goals or aims they might have had in life, and so they are now forced to change aspirations for ones which seem suitable to their new life. With all this deregulation people are now much more susceptible to suicide. Clinard states that the “Disruption of the collective order allows manґs aspirations to rise beyond all possibility of their fulfilment.” Which also leads to increased suicide rates. An example of this is shown in the economic crisis in Vienna in 1873, there were 141 suicides in 1872 before the crisis, and in 1873 when it started there were 153, when the crisis climaxed in 1874 there were 216 suicides. We can clearly see here how the suicide rates increase dramatically during a period of economic upheaval when the balance is disturbed in an individualґs life.
The same also applies when the individual gains an increase in prosperity or power, they often feel like they do not belong, their goals and hopes have been achieved and they no longer know where to set their sights, with an increase in desires they often become less disciplined which means even less order in their lives (Durkheim, 1952 p253). Disappointment comes from not knowing oneґs limits, and the higher one rises, the further one has to fall, hence why an increase in suicide rates is often seen in economic boom – because the collective order has been upset. Altruistic suicide is when a person kills himself because they are too integrated into a group (Durkheim, 1952 p19) An example of altruistic suicide occurs in some societies of the Hindu religion, here men are told that once they have born a son they have no other role in life and in order to achieve lifeґs purpose they must kill themselves (Durkheim 1952 p223). Altruistic suicide is similar to anomic in that both are passionate (Durkheim, 1952 p284), however the type of passion is very different, as anomic involves more negative feelings, where as altruistic is more positive, people often believe that they are doing a good thing by committing altruistic suicide. Egoistic suicide is formed from a lack of integration into a group, rather than a lack or excess of rules. People who are prone to egoistic suicide are often highly intelligent, they feel segregated from everyday society, they withdraw and begin meditating and analysing (Durkheim 1952 p281) by doing this they endanger discovering that there is no real purpose for life, and so they kill themselves (Durkheim 1952 p288). Egoism is similar to anomie as by becoming less integrated the individual has separated himself from the rules controlling his situation (Durkheim 1952 p288), both are unregulated in their lives, however where one has no basis for living the other has nothing to aim for. Fatalistic suicide is the other category which Durkheim spoke of, it can be perceived as the opposite to anomic, as here the rules placed on the individualґs life are too great (unlike anomic where the rules are too weak) they are unable to control their life, their desires have been quashed and so their futures appear pointless (Durkheim 1852 p276). Along with the praise Durkheim received for his work on suicide, he also received much criticism. For example, it can be said that Durkheim did not clearly distinguish between egoistic and anomic suicide – he categorises some suicides as a fusion of both, but how can a suicide be a combination of opposites? Hendin states that Durkheim is ‘making the psychology of suicide seem irrelevant by the way he labels social facts as ‘thingsґ. Christie Davies believes that Durkheimґs theory is approached too simply (Davis lecture notes 2000) (although others have criticised him for trying to explain everything). Durkheim did not spend any time considering that some suicides may have been meant to be only an attempt, para-suicides which for whatever reason went wrong, and resulted in accidental deaths. Halbwachs (1930) argues that several of the factors that Durkheim isolates as being associated with a high rate of suicide are in fact combined in the conditions of modern urban life, and that perhaps the major explanatory factor in suicide is the difference between rural and urban ways of life, so a higher suicide rate among the unmarried, divorced or those who live alone could be because of a lack of integration in urban areas, and also because often in cases such as these there are no family or friends who might cover up any evidence of suicide (Giddens 1987 introductory sociology p493). Durkheim is also shown to sometimes give data which does not correspond with his ideas, for example in rural China more women commit suicide than men, contrary to Durkheimґs predictions, also suicide rates are higher in the rural areas here than in the urban areas. Durkheimґs theories were based on data from European countries; Durkheim has been criticised because when applied on a global scale, differences arise in suicide rates contrary to his predictions. Durkheim was also proved wrong when he stated that soldiers commit altruistic suicide because their social group excessively regulates them, so one would think from this that the suicide rates should rise in times of war because of the super excessive regulation. In actuality the suicide rate for soldiers falls in times of war, contradictory to Durkheimґs model. Durkheim received much criticism for the accuracy of his data, and the examples that he used in order to back up his models.
Durkheim has produced an interesting and valid piece of work that explains why and when suicide occurs he developed his own theories looking past what was traditionally believed about the cause of suicide. Durkheim found that the numbers of suicides are greatest at the extremes, i.e. when they are highly regulated or integrated or under regulated/integrated. Durkheim defined the sub groups as anomic, altruistic, egoistic and fatalistic. Durkheim has however been criticised for the way in which he used his data, often contradicting himself, and not applying his theories on a global scale. Durkheim did not consider the factor of intent during his studies, and some sociologists believe his work to be problematic, Sacks (1963 p3) maintains that ‘in terms of the history of sociology nothing is more tragic than that Durkheimґs ‘Suicideґ should be conceived as a model investigationґ (Giddens 1987 p487) . Most believe, however, that Durkheimґs work is probably the best theory on suicide and is a valuable tool in the understanding of this subject, Selvin (1965 p113) claims that ‘Sixty years after it first appeared in print, Emile Durkheimґs Suicide is still a model of research…few if any later works can match the clarity and power with which Durkheim marshalled his facts to test and refine his theory.ґ (Giddens 1987 p487). Through this essay though I hope to have shown how Durkheimґs work is valid,but not flawless.
Другие работы по теме:
The Alchemist Essay Research Paper IB Essay
The Alchemist Essay, Research Paper IB Essay: Kokoro by Natsume Soseki “What we are.” — A phrase that causes a number of thoughts to cross my mind. What makes us who we are? From the light of events of Kokoro by Natsume Soseki, I did some research to find an answer to this question. One aspect of all human behaviors is egotism.
Teen Suicide Essay Research Paper Adolescence is
Teen Suicide Essay, Research Paper Adolescence is the time in which people discover their coping mechanisms and which way is most beneficial for them to deal with stress and new situations. These learning experiences can often be difficult as adolescents have very little knowledge and experience in how to deal with these new situations and stress.
Physician Assisted Suicide Essay Research Paper Scott
Physician Assisted Suicide Essay, Research Paper Scott DeBoer DeBoer 1 9-26-2001 Physician Assisted Suicide How could someone wake up every day sick, in constant pain and feeling horrible every minute of existence? This is not a good way to live from anybodies point of view. The time may come when suffering, just is not worth living.
SucideA Essay Research Paper Suicide Solution
Sucide(A) Essay, Research Paper Suicide Solution I’m about to take up a position which is going to be deamed by some,if not all, as a terrible stand to take. As a matter of fact, if anyone wereto agree with me on ths subject, I’d be surprsed. For you see, rather thanarguing from the postion of suicide being an unjustified and inane way todie, I shall argue the other point.
Suicide Solution Essay Essay Research Paper
Suicide…..a serious problem that has no blanket solution. Thebasis of this essay is to write about the solution to a problem. In mycase, the ?problem? is suicide…and in suicide there is no real?solution?. There are many ways to help one who is suicidal, anddifferent precautions, such as: hotlines, counseling, and programs.Medications that you can prescribe to them also can help.
Euthanasia Essay Research Paper Assisted SuicideA great
Euthanasia Essay, Research Paper Assisted Suicide A great deal of debate surrounds the practice of assisted suicide. Lately, laws against voluntary euthanasia have been eased, although serious moral and legal questions still exist. Most opposition of assisted suicide comes from religious groups, including Christianity, Judaism, and Islam.
Assisted Suicide Essay Research Paper Questions concerning
Assisted Suicide Essay, Research Paper Questions concerning the right to end one’s life have long generated storms of controversy. These questions, involving intensely personal views on issues no less profound than the meaning of life and liberty, are unlikely to disappear any time soon. The conservative nature of the medical profession, and the organized opposition of the “right to life” movement, along with disagreement among disabilities rights organizations, perpetuate the controversy.
Euthanasia And Assisted Suicide Essay Research Paper
EUTHANASIA AND ASSISTED SUICIDE In today’s society, euthanasia and assisted suicide is a major discussion. People, who are terminally ill or are depressed, are sometimes looking for a way out. They feel that their only hope is to kill themselves. Other people in the world feel that euthanasia and assisted suicide are morally wrong.
Suicide Essay Research Paper Every year thousands
Suicide Essay, Research Paper Every year thousands of teens die in the United States, not from cancer or car accidents, but by their own hand; they make the choice that they want to die, and they take their own life. Statistics conducted in 1996 reveal that every 42 seconds a teenager attempts suicide and every 16.9 minutes a teenager completes it.
The Apology Essay Research Paper The ApologyIn
The Apology Essay, Research Paper The Apology In The Apology by Plato, Socrates was giving his testimony before he was forced to commit suicide. He was trying to prove that death is better than living without one?s beliefs. He believed that he was innocent, going to a better place, and he was going to die anyway.
Suicide My Thoughts Essay Research Paper I
Suicide: My Thoughts Essay, Research Paper I have known many adolescents who have thought about suicide. People?s reasons for suicide just cannot be legit in most cases. Some reasons are: ?my girlfriend broke up with me? or ?people make fun of me? or how about ?I don?t have any friends?? Whatever the reason for the thought of suicide, there isn?t a valid one, unless we are dealing in euthanasia.
Life And Suicide Essay Research Paper Since
Life And Suicide Essay, Research Paper Since the beginning of time, people have been committing suicide. Self inflicted death, or suicide, can be defined as “choosing the mode, time, situation, or occasion for ending one’s life.” In general, the word suicide has a negative connotation and is looked upon unfavorably.
Suicide Essay Research Paper
“Why do people commit suicide? People usually attempt suicide to block unbearable emotional pain, which is caused by a wide variety of problems. (rockhford).
Euthanasia Essay Research Paper Retired professor and
Euthanasia Essay, Research Paper Retired professor and psychoanalyst Ernest Van den Haag, by defending the right to commit suicide, made an appeal to J.S. Mill?s principle. Van den Haag said that people should have the right to choose as they please, as long as no one else is hurt (Hallock 13). According to the constitution, people have the right to decide death, not the government (Dority 8).
King Lear By William Shakespeare 1564
– 1616) Essay, Research Paper Since King Lear’s setting is pre-Christian Britain, some readers chafe under the sort of nihilistic fatalism that colors the characters’ thinking (”As flies to wanton boys we are to the
Research Essay On Teenage Suicide Essay Research
Paper For my Research Essay I chose the subject of Teenage Suicide’, because the rate of suicide is too high and I want to know more about the causes, the ways we can prevent it, and I want to know the warnings made by a suicidal person. Suicide is a form of death in which an individual voluntarily and intentionally takes his or her life.
Dr Kevorkian Essay Research Paper History and
Dr. Kevorkian Essay, Research Paper History and BackgroundDr Jack Kevorkian, a 70-year-old retired pathologist, has devoted most of his life to the campaign for assisted suicide. He has admitted helping more than 130 people to end their lives. To date only 48 have cases been documented, including the assisted suicide documented on 60 MinutesDr Kevorkian was born in 1928 in Pontiac, Michigan, to a family of Armenian immigrants.
Deviance Essay Research Paper Theories of Deviant
Deviance Essay, Research Paper Theories of Deviant Behavior examines various theories and perspectives on conforming and deviant behavior which are products of Western scholarly thought: anomie, functionalism, social disorganization, social conflict, social control, psychoanalysis, status politics, differential association, labeling theory, etc.
Suicide 2 Essay Research Paper Suicide SolutionI
Suicide 2 Essay, Research Paper Suicide Solution I’m about to take up a position which is going to be deamed by some, if not all, as a terrible stand to take. As a matter of fact, if anyone were
Assited Suicide Essay Research Paper If you
Assited Suicide Essay, Research Paper If you had incurable disease that gave you six months to live and you were in incredible pain and were suffering, would you want to hang on for those last moments of torture? Assisted suicide is a very controversial topic. There are many people supporting it and many people opposing it.
Moral Position Essay Research Paper What
Moral Position Essay, Research Paper . What is a moral position according to Mr. Dworkin? Dworkin’s moral position is reasons, foundation theory and self-evident. Moral position has to give good (articulate) reasons for moral position to be valid. Things like prejudices and emotions are not justifiable characteristics for a moral position.
Teen Suicide Essay Research Paper As if
Teen Suicide Essay, Research Paper As if parents did not have enough reasons to worry about their teenage children, what with drugs, drinking, and driving. Now a new concern has appeared within the last several years. I am talking about teenage suicide.
Suicide Essay Research Paper Social Problem Teen
Suicide Essay, Research Paper -Social Problem: Teen Suicide -Social Problem- Any problem that may cause pain and may affect a person?s life. ? Teen Suicide- Intentional and self-inflicted death.
Is Moral Egoism Correct Essay Research Paper
“Is Moral Egoism Correct?” Moral Egoism states that “one never does wrong if one does what’s in one’s own self-interest; it’s always morally acceptable to just look out for number one” (Barcalow, 295). I feel that I should do what is in my own self-interest for the most part, but not for everything, thus making moral egoism incorrect.
Teenage Suicide Essay Research Paper Why is
Teenage Suicide Essay, Research Paper Why is teenage suicide on the rise: In todays stressful society suicide is an issue that teenagers are confronted with in their lives. There are many reasons for the growing number of teenage suicides are
View Of Teen Suicide Essay Research Paper
VIEW OF TEEN SUICIDE For some teenagers, divorce, the formation of a new family with stepparents and stepsiblings, or moving to a new community can be very unsettling and can intensify self-doubts. In some cases, suicide appears to be a “solution.” For example love, like in Romeo and Juliet. Two characters, so madly in love that when their parents wouldn’t bless their relationship that they took their own lives.
Power And Class In The United States
, Who Rules America Essay, Research Paper 1.On Durkheim, Why do the U.S.A have a high suicide rate use Durkheim’s two notions Egoistic and Anomie suicide?
Assited Suicide Essay Research Paper The man
Assited Suicide Essay, Research Paper ?The man who, in a fit of melancholy, kills himself today would have wanted to live had he a week.?(Voltaire) In the U.S. assisted suicide has become all too common. Mr. Jack Kevorkian, otherwise known as Dr. Death, might be the reason for this unethical uprising. Assisted suicide in those who fear they are too old, mentally unstable, or suffering from an incurable illness, doesn?t solve any problems.
Ethical Egoism Essay Research Paper Ethical EgoismLike
Ethical Egoism Essay, Research Paper Ethical Egoism Like all other moral philosophy theories, ethical egoism tries to develop a comprehensive set of rules by which each person should govern their lives. Instead of approaching each daily decision separately and interpreting the correct response, philosophers try and find an overall rule that will guide each person in their daily lives.