’s Essay, Research Paper
You can hardly own a computer today and not know about MP3 files. MP3 is shorthand for Moving Picture Experts Group (MPEG) 1 Layer 3. It is a compression technique that makes large files smaller for easier storage and downloading. They are widely used and have become very popular recently, especially with the emergence of the file-sharing program Napster. This file-sharing program allows people to trade music files over the Internet for free. This brings up problems with Intellectual Property (IP) and copyright laws. IP is the generic descriptor of the work product of authors and inventors. In the United States, intellectual property is protected by copyright, patent, trademark, and trade secret law.
The Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) filed a lawsuit against Napster in December 1999. The association, which represents the major U.S. record companies, is seeking up to $100,000 in damages for each copyright-protected song allegedly exchanged illegally using Napster software. No music trades actually take place on computers owned by Napster. Nor does the company monitor users to see whether they are trading copyrighted material; however it does warn users that MP3 files could be illegally copied and that distributing such material is illegal. Napster believes it is covered under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA). The DMCA was specifically designed by congress to give a safe harbor to Internet Service Providers (ISP) so they are not liable for their users activities. It does not matter whether the ISP has any knowledge of user misuse or not.
Napsters only alleged liability is for contributory or vicarious infringement. You cannot have contributory or vicarious without having some underlying infringement. When Napster users engage in noncommercial sharing of music noncommercial copying of music Is that an activity of copyright infringement? Napster attorney, David Boies says no, because this type of noncommercial consumer copying is recognized as Fair Use under common law theories and doctrines, under the Supreme Court s criteria. Fair Use is the use of a copyrighted work for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, scholarship, or research as permitted under 17 U.S.C. sec. 107.5 The Audio Home Recording Act (AHRA) directly states that noncommercial copying by consumers is lawful. The 9th circuit court in RIAA vs. Diamond Multimedia Systems, in 1999, read the act as saying all noncommercial consumer copying is lawful. The word all was the opinion and interpretation of the court. The defense appeared to suffer a blow when the U.S. Copyright Office chimed in on the case, in a brief, co-submitted with the civil division of the Justice Department and the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office. The government’s brief argued that Napster’s service is not protected by the Home Recording Act, in part because the Act does not apply to music that is copied using PCs and hard drives. Napster attorney David Boies, in a brief statement, called the government’s position “incorrect.”
According to the 1984 decision in Sony vs. Universal Studios, Napster cannot be held responsible if some users engage in copyright infringement because Napster unquestionably involves substantial non-infringing uses. In the Sony case the entertainment industry tried to stamp out VCR s. The Supreme Court ruled that even though VCR s were predominantly used to copy copyrighted materials, because there were substantial uses that didn t infringe copyrights, they could not find that Sony was guilty of contributory or vicarious infringement. The recording industry tries to argue that it should be which use of the technology predominates, but this has never been the law. In the Sony case it was clear that more than 80% of the use was copyright infringement and this did not make a difference. There are non-infringing ways, which Napster is used. One way, in the Sony case the Supreme Court ruled that there did not have to be any actual substantial non-infringing uses. It only said that the technology merely had to have the capabilities of substantial non-infringing uses. Another way, the 9th Circuit Court said, space shifting, where a listener copies songs that they already own, onto more portable media. The last non-infringing way to distribute music is if the music is not copyrighted at all, the copyright has been lost, or whose copyright holder does not object.
The 9th Circuit Court has made it clear that if copyright holders use their copyrights for anti-competable purposes to try to gain control over something they do not control directly through their copyrights that is copyright misuse. Boies believes that the RIAA has set out to control the Napster Media. They have written documents saying they want to shut Napster down and then take over the technology. They have pooled 90% of the copyright on music. Those kinds of activities constitute copyright misuse and if they are engaged in copyright misuse, they cannot enforce their copyrights making their whole argument worthless. This copyright misuse may even bring a case against the RIAA. While the Napster case has many sides to argue from, most of the ones in this paper are for Napster. This is only one case of the legality of MP3 s others include, MP3 and Gnutella. There are others but these are the major ones. Look into the news to keep up to date with what is going on with the future of these sites.
Другие работы по теме:
What is E-Commerce?
There exists no exact definition of e-commerce. Generally it is described as any kind of business transaction where information is exchanged electronically.
Why Did Hitler Come To Power In
1933? Essay, Research Paper Noakes and Pridham have called the August-December period of 1932 ?the crisis months? in the ?Nazis struggle for power?. However, there are also many other
Abortion Essay Research Paper ConceptionI believe that
Abortion Essay, Research Paper Conception: I believe that life begins at the ending of the first trimester through the pregnancy. I consider it a human when there is a beating heart and a brain that is functioning. A beating heart to me represents that there is life, and that there is signs of growth, while still in the mother’s womb.
Drug Legalization Essay Research Paper Legality Although
Drug Legalization Essay, Research Paper Legality, Although it is clear that society is unhappy with current efforts to stop illegal drug smuggling, illegal drug use and distribution, no one seems to know what should be done. With drug use and drug related crime on the rise, some Americans argue that current drug law is too easy on drug offenders.
Euthanasia Essay Research Paper EuthanasiaBecause our medical
Euthanasia Essay, Research Paper Euthanasia Because our medical technology has improved so much, we are literally able to postpone death. People suffering from incurable diseases or injuries that would have died are being kept alive on machines. Because of this, people have argued for years over the legality of euthanasia.
MDMA Essay Research Paper The popular rave
MDMA Essay, Research Paper The popular rave drug, MDMA (3,4-methylenedioxymethamphetamine) or ecstasy, has had a fascinating history dating from the 1910s to the present. This designer drug was originally used as a diet pill and later in psychotherapy. The recent use of MDMA recreationally has increased interest and research on the drug and its effects on humans.
Dedicated To One Task Essay Research Paper
As the Human Race enters the new millenium we have created a somewhat organized and affective society. This society consists of many states that govern their people by allowing them to go about their daily activities and providing them services without a large amount of chaos interfering in their lives “Human beings usually do not venture out of their caves (or the modern counterpart) unless there is a reasonable probability that they can return safely.” (Lowi & Ginsberg, 12) Whether a particular government is very constricting or very helpful to the citizens, humans flock into political societies in order to concentrate on their allowed freedoms instead of anarchy in which legality and a right of ownership are non-existent.
Concepts Of Calvin Klein
’s Advertising Essay, Research Paper A Look into Calvin Klein s Advertisements As a seductive young man looks into a camera a raspy voice, off camera, whispers, You got a real nice look. How old are you? Are you strong? You think you could rip that shirt off? That s a real nice body. You work out? I can tell. No, it s not straight out of a steamy romance novel, though it could be.
Sewall
’s Reponse To Mather Essay, Research Paper Sewall s Response to Mather s The Negro Christianized Cotton Mather and Samuel Sewall clearly disagree on the legality of slavery. For Sewall, it is most important that slaves be given the same freedom as all men; for Mather, it is most important that slaves be Christianized and given the opportunity of eternal light through the grace of Jesus Christ.
Legal Vs Illegal Essay Research Paper Legal
Legal Vs. Illegal Essay, Research Paper Legal vs. Illegal (Napster vs. Music Industry) The issues that will be slugged out in federal district court in San Francisco sound a little too pop culture to be all that serious. How many music CDs are people buying these days in record stores throughout the nation because of Napster? Is the technology that Napster uses legal? Napster is, of course, the wildly popular file-sharing service whose 20 million users have downloaded some half a billion songs–most copyrighted for free.
Assisted Suicide 2 Essay Research Paper An
Assisted Suicide 2 Essay, Research Paper An advocate of assisted-suicide, Dr. Kevorkian, has recently been convicted of 2nd degree murder for an assisted-suicide and faces up to 25 years. Kevorkian claims to have assisted in over 130 suicides since 1990. Three earlier juries have acquitted him, and a mistrial was declared in his fourth case.
Arendt
’s Eichmann In Jerusalem Essay, Research Paper Arendt’s Eichmann in JerusalemThe enthusiastic efforts of all those that have spent their time in the pursuit of former Nazis that successfully evaded capture by the authorities that tried their compatriots at Nuremberg state their reasons generally to be a pursuit of justice.
Mp3 Audio Essay Research Paper What is
Mp3 Audio Essay, Research Paper What is the hottest buzzword around the Internet today? What topic has replaced sex as the most searched for term on the web? The answer to both of these questions is MP3 audio.
Morality In America Essay Research Paper The
Morality In America Essay, Research Paper The reading by Johnson starts out with a married lady by the name of Katherine Watkins complaining of rape by a black slave. Throughout the remainder of this section, depositions are given by other black slaves and people who claim to have witnessed the occurrence.
American Government And Politics Essay Research Paper
American Government and Politics The founders of this country wanted a government with have power, but they didn t want a government with too much of it. To accomplish this they wrote ways to limit the government s use of power. By doing this they also enable the citizens of he country to remain free and not have to worry about the government have too much power.
The Problem Of Online Casino Essay Research
Paper In our society today, computer technology plays an important role in many forms of entertainment, especially in the field of online casino. As technology advances, net gambling is becoming more and more popular. While its popularity is skyrocketing, ambiguity surrounds its legality. Although most states allow some form of gambling activities, many states seek to prohibit online gambling because of the potential for fraud over the Internet, children’s access to gambling sites, an increase in gambling addictions, and the need to preserve state revenues generated from legally enforced (and state-run) gambling operations.
What Is Bioethics Essay Research Paper Bioethics
What Is Bioethics? Essay, Research Paper Bioethics encompasses every ethical question relating and pertaining to medicine and the health of living things. Everything from pediatrics to nursing, from euthanasia to birth-pain killer, from the debate of abortion to the law of malpractice is covered by the term bioethics.
Another Computer Essay Essay Research Paper The
Another Computer Essay Essay, Research Paper The Computer Underground. The beginning of the electronic communication revolution that started with the public use of telephones to the emergence
Death Penalty In The US esp Texas
) Essay, Research Paper The death penalty has been used for centuries all over the world. In biblical times, the “Eye for an Eye” rule was common amongst the people. If one killed someone else, then they in turn would be killed. Keep in mind that these people were very religious and societies back then were more barbaric.
New Jersey V TLO Essay Research Paper
Name of the case and year it was decided X New Jersey v. T.L.O. (1985) The constitutional amendment V or section theeof Xwhich the court is interpreting X 14th amendment
Democracy
– Religion In English Essay, Research Paper “…prefers a democracy to any other system, on account of its comparative advantages, and not on account of its perfection. He knows it has evils;
Abortion Essay Research Paper Page 1 of
Abortion Essay, Research Paper Page 1 of 7 Many have argued over the legality of abortion. Pro-life activists believe that every child conceived should be born. They also believe
Ethical Dilemna Essay Research Paper Jim PolakGroup
Ethical Dilemna Essay, Research Paper Jim Polak Group #3 Ethical Problem 4/1/96 During my high school years, I had to make many decisions. Some of these decisions came easily to me, like what clothes to wear to school. Some of them took more thought, like what classes I should take during the upcoming semester.
Toxic Cities Essay Research Paper Executive Summary
Toxic Cities Essay, Research Paper Executive Summary: I am evaluating solutions to reduce the proliferation of chemical and radioactive industrial carcinogens that threaten human health nationally and globally. I am specifically concerned with the toxic health effects on minority and low-income communities.
Drug Lealization Essay Research Paper Drug legalization
Drug Lealization Essay, Research Paper Drug legalization is a hotly debated topic in today s society. Proponents of this plan state that it will put drug dealers out of business and take away the rebellious allure that causes many young people to take drugs. This theory could not be farther from the truth. If illegal drugs were legalized, drug dealers would be brought to the forefront of one of the fastest growing industries in history.
Pro Chioce Abortion Essay Research Paper Pro
Pro Chioce Abortion Essay, Research Paper Pro Choice Abortion Abortion is a very controversial issue. In order to understand the issues pertaining to abortion, you must first understand the definition and the stages of abortion. The controversy primarily revolves around the legality and the morality of abortion.
What is E-Commerce
There exists no exact definition of e-commerce. Generally it is described as any kind of business transaction where information is exchanged electronically.
Weber And Legitimacy Essay Research Paper Recently
Weber And Legitimacy Essay, Research Paper Recently, the president of Russia, Boris Yeltsin, has been extremely ill. Because of this, other government officials must take a greater role and have greater responsibility than they already have. One such government officials that has a had greatly expanded role is Prime Minister Yevgeni Primakov.
The Legalization Of Drugs Essay Research Paper
The legalization of drugs; a risk not worth taking Arguments concerning the repeal of the 18th amendment, drug prohibition, have not changed much over the last seventy years; the questions are the same, the concerns are the same, and the policy is the same; the way it should be. Both sides are in a constant battle over the legality of drugs: Proponents of drug prohibition insist that the effects on society would be disastrous- wide-spread addiction, increased crime – Opponents of drug prohibition insist that drug legalization would allow society to prosper – potency control, crime reduction, tax revenues.
Journal Review
– Incoherence Of The Moral “Ought” Essay, Research Paper Robert Fish THE INCOHERENCE OF THE MORAL ‘OUGHT’ Journal Report The Incoherence of the Moral ‘Ought,’ a journal article by Duncan Richter, is an analysis of a paper by Elizabeth Anscombe entitled, “Modern Moral Philosophy.” In this analysis, Mr. Richter is only concerned about Anscombe’s second thesis, which states as follows: