Many people regard science as absolute, and therefore
what science says, culture follows. There are many examples of science helping culture and society: science has helped society understand the dangers of smoking, skin cancer and improved the quality of life for many people. Despite the advantages of science, there is a negative impact on society due to science. In Emily Martin s essay The Egg and the Sperm, she investigates the notion that women are being unintentionally oppressed and made inferior in the eyes of
science and culture. Benjamin Lee Whorf s assertion that
culture defines language is one of Martin s underlying
themes. Martin carries out this theme to show that the
models that biologists use to describe their data can have
important social efforts (Martin 57). Martin s thesis that
science is perpetuating the sexist stereotypes is
exemplified in many scientific journals.
In Martin s essay, she clarifies Whorf s theory by her
examples of biological journals. Martin follows Whorf s theory that the semantics of the science community and journals do distort the role of women. Martin cites extensive examples and particulars from over fifty journals and books about the role of men and women in terms of reproduction; The descriptions imply that a [female] system has gone awry, making products of no use, not to specification, unsalable, wasted, scrap (Martin 50). Whorf would agree that the language in the journals is reflecting the stereotypes already in place in society. Whorf s view helps to strengthen Martin s thesis by showing that, if culture defines language, then women are portrayed in a male dominant culture as wasteful and inferior. Martin asserts that the imagery keeps alive some of the hoariest old stereotypes about weak damsels in distress and their strong male rescuers (Martin 57). Whorf also alleges that ill-used language can cause behavior…[of]…hazardous forms (Whorf 152).
One of Martin s paramount objections is the marked contrast between the two sex s reproductive cycle. It is difficult to understand how impartial scientists and other professionals can refer to the male process as [a] remarkable cellular transformation, mature, amazing, and remarkable and the female process as ceasing, dying, and losing when written about in the same literature. When viewed in an objective light, none of the texts [express] such intense enthusiasm for any female processes (Martin 50). Martin uses this to illustrate how science is reflecting existing stereotypes.
In the same way that Martin sees the imagery of science keeping alive stereotypes, Kuhn sees science as perpetuating existing paradigms. Kuhn defines a paradigm as an enduring group of adherents…[that is] sufficiently open-ended to leave all sorts of problems for the redefined group of practitioners to resolve (Kuhn 50). Scientists, under Martin s thesis are working to make the biological process fit the existing stereotypes that are in place. In trying to make the biological process fit existing stereotypes, the scientist s language in turn is reflecting the cultural stereotypes. Whorf contends that …the real world is to a large extent unconsciously built up on the language habits of the group (Whorf 151). To get the most unbiased depiction of the reproductive process the world that scientists working must have a revolution.
Martin suggests ways of revising the bias in the medical journals by accrediting women with the production of the egg cells and men with the degeneration of germ cells. Martin gives examples of three such revisionists in her essay. The three revisionists revise the description of the reproductive process by giving the egg more of a role in reproduction. But, now the scales are being tipped in the other direction, the female is now an aggressor. Even though the new account gives the egg a larger role and a more active role, taken together they bring into play another cultural stereotype: women as dangerous and aggressive (Martin 56). According to Martin and Whorf, the new revised models that scientists are using are still reflecting old cultural stereotypes that the scientists were trying to remove.
Martin closes the topic of sperm and eggs by noting that the reason for the problem is caused by metaphors used to describe the scientific process, specifically the biological reproductive process. Waking up such metaphors, by becoming aware of their implications, will rob them of their power to naturalize our social conventions about gender (Martin 57). By removing the underlying stereotypes from the scientific study, the negative affects of language on culture will be reduced.
Works Cited
Martin, Emily . The Egg and the Sperm.
Whorf, Benjamin Lee. Language, Thought, and Reality, ed. John B. Carrol. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1964.
Kuhn, Thomas S. The Structure of Scientific Revolutions. Chicago University of Chicago Press, 1962.
Другие работы по теме:
What Is Science Essay Research Paper What
What Is Science Essay, Research Paper What is Science? Several dictionary definitions of science in Merriam-Webster’s Collegiate Dictionary define science as a system of knowledge about a specific topic. The systems come from systematic, or precise, observations of natural events; a random example would be the study of the movement of a caterpillar.
Science And War Essay Research Paper Schopenhauer
Science And War Essay, Research Paper Schopenhauer had an understanding of the Will, which has to separate parts. The Will to Life and Human Will. The Will to Life, was the over all striving that
Apply The Budget Surplus To Science Essay
, Research Paper For years, everyone has opined on what to do with the budget surplus: fund new educational programs, cut taxes, and so on. Science needs the money. In some technologies, we are beginning to fall behind other countries. We must not allow this to happen. Everyone reaps the benefits of science; increasing funding for research programs would only enhance these benefits.
Chaos Making A New Science Essay Research
Paper Chaos: Making A New Science Chaos by James Gleick presents to its readers the idea of a new science. Gleick shows this new science as a deviation of old conventional science; which gives rise to new ideas and new ways to look at old problems. In order to make his point; Gleick traces the lives of many different scientists throughout history.
Multi Strand Science Essay Research Paper NAME
Multi Strand Science Essay, Research Paper NAME: DUE DATE: YEAR 12 MULTI-STRAND SCIENCE Choose ONE of the following local industries and prepare a resource management case study for that industry.
Point Of No Return (An Essay On
Opression) Essay, Research Paper Oppression is a serious issue in our society today, although it may be less serious than in the past. Having to deal with sexism and the current generation gap in the 90’s makes the lives of teenage girls harder than it should be. Throughout history we have seen groups of people have to deal with oppression.
Women And Sexism Essay Research Paper 2
Women And Sexism Essay, Research Paper “We [women] are, as a sex, infinitely superior to men.” Elizabeth Stanton (prominent woman suffragist) – (excerpted from
Acculturation And Assimilation Essay Research Paper Acculturation
Acculturation And Assimilation Essay, Research Paper Acculturation and Assimilation Culture deals with thoughts, norms, and productions of a certain people. These modes are communicated among humans and not passed down genetically. Therefore, culture is the base from which the study of acculturation and assimilation use to trace similarities with other cultures.
Starting Again Essay Research Paper Start AgainStarting
Starting Again Essay, Research Paper Start Again Starting a new life in another country can be extremely stressful. To adapt to a different culture, to lack of financial support and absence of the family can be a very threatening situation.
Religion Is Important Essay Research Paper I
Religion Is Important Essay, Research Paper I think culture, religion, ethnicity is very important in one’s life. They should know where there from and who they are. Everyone comes from somewhere around the world, even if they were born in another country, they still
Sexism In Advertising Essay Research Paper The
Sexism In Advertising Essay, Research Paper The sun is setting as the lone cowboy stands leaning against a wooden post and gazing out over the fields. He has been hard at work all day, and only now as the evening approaches does he allow himself a moment s rest. The forward tilt of his hat shadows one half of his lined, ruggedly handsome face.
ERASE How I Can End Racism And
Sexism In My School Essay, Research Paper What Can I Do to End Violence, Racism, and Sexism in My School Violence, racism, and sexism, some of the most used things in the school.
Woman Warrior Essay Research Paper In her
Woman Warrior Essay, Research Paper In her autobiography, The Woman Warrior, Maxine talks-story about how she grew up surrounded by the Chinese culture but went to American schools. How her mother told her stories of herself as a shaman and of Fa Mu Lan when Maxine brought home good grades. How she was put down by the Chinese sexism and rebelled from it.
Epic Essay Essay Research Paper What an
Epic Essay Essay, Research Paper What an epic says about its culture is that that was the way they lived like in the Epic of Gilgamesh, Faerie Qveene, and Iliad (Comical Version). The three are epics from their own time and culture they are the same in some ways and different in other ways.
Philosophy Of Science Essay Research Paper When
Philosophy Of Science Essay, Research Paper When I was a young student I never thought of science as being significant enough to have a personal philosophy on the subject. However as a future teacher I have realized that it is a subject of great importance which needs to be contemplated. When I began to think about what science is, I realized that science is in our everyday lives and all around us.
Definition Of Culture Essay Research Paper Definition
Definition Of Culture Essay, Research Paper Definition of Culture Culture, a term that entails everything and everyone in our society today, is used to describe the relationships that people?s traditions, actions, arts, and styles share throughout the world in different places, times, and ages. Culture can be described as the actions, arts, beliefs, institutions and all other products of human work and thought.
Religion Vs Astronomy Essay Research Paper Religion
Religion Vs Astronomy Essay, Research Paper Religion and science have always been in direct competition with one another. The ultimate goal of science is to prove the inexistence of God with facts, while the existence in God is simply based on belief and faith. While 95% of the people living on Earth believe in a superior being of some sort, some might say that religion clouds the minds of otherwise logical individuals and makes it impossible for them to pursue the truth of the Universe.
The Birthmark Essay Research Paper Nathaniel Hawthorne
The Birthmark Essay, Research Paper Nathaniel Hawthorne wrote a time of great change in America. In the mid-nineteenth century, Americans began to experience a shift in focus from the once stringent religious outlook to a more scientific view of the world and its natural wonders. Americans, however, did look at these new scientific discoveries with much hesitation, questioning their long-term effects on society as a whole.
Miller Spring Essay Essay Research Paper Miller
Miller Spring Essay Essay, Research Paper Miller Springs Essay My science class and I went to Miller Springs to learn about sediments and nature a few days ago. The good and bad sides of the trip I will explain below.
Magic Vs Science Essay Research Paper Magic
Magic Vs. Science Essay, Research Paper Magic vs. Science What is magic and science? These two subjects have been around for several hundred years and many controversies have come about when the
Cross Cultural Psychology Essay Research Paper Psychology
Cross Cultural Psychology Essay, Research Paper Psychology is a science with abounding applications. It pertains to nearly all aspects of human life and behavior. It reveals mysteries about people, and culture as well. Psychology plays a large role in the field of Anthropology, a field devoted piecing together the puzzle of cultures around the world.
Religion And Science Essay Research Paper Religion
Religion And Science Essay, Research Paper Religion and Science Is Science and Religion really such an adversary? I believe that it is a very touchy subject, in which it can go either way. Some people may claim that science and religion are two very similar subjects, while other may view it as two very different subjects of life.
Volcanoes Essay Research Paper My Report is
Volcanoes Essay, Research Paper My Report is on Volcanoes. For a starter, I have a lay out of the plan for my report. Also I would like to follow a volcano in it’s path. Right now here is part of my report.
Culture Of Poverty Essay Research Paper Culture
Culture Of Poverty Essay, Research Paper ?Culture of Poverty? The ?culture of poverty? was introduced or was popularized by Oscar Lewis while studying poor families in Mexico and Puerto Rican families San Juan and New York. The theory maintains that culturally based attitudes or predisposition such as ?present-mindedness? and ?obsessive-consumption? are the major barriers to economic mobility for many of the poor.
Sexism Essay Research Paper Sexism in the
Sexism Essay, Research Paper Sexism in the world today The battle of the sexes is obvious everywhere and is applies to anything. From athletics to the military, men and women struggle to beat the other, but I find it to be
Sexism 2 Essay Research Paper SexismThe Webster
Sexism 2 Essay, Research Paper Sexism The Webster s Dictionary defines the term sexism as Discrimination by members of one sex against the other, especially by men against women based on the assumption that on sex is superior . This definition implies that people can discriminate against one another by saying or doing something that is not fair to the opposite sex.
Sexism Essay Research Paper Sexism has always
Sexism Essay, Research Paper Sexism has always been a problem in Western society. It has been a problem that many people overlook, simply because they think it does not actually exist! However, sexism is present in our current society today, and is proved perfectly by Alleen Nilsen in her quote stating, ?Anyone living in the United States who listens with a keen ear or reads with a perceptive eye can come up with startling new insights about the way American English reflects our values.? Every society has certain common beliefs regarding the ways each sex should behave.
Sexism Essay Research Paper The consequence of
Sexism Essay, Research Paper The consequence of sexism is as bad for men as for woman. Explain. When most people think of sexism, they think of it only against woman. Although in reality, sexism is equally shared among men and woman.
Sexism Essay Research Paper SexismSo what exactly
Sexism Essay, Research Paper Sexism So what exactly is sexism? Sexism is the belief that rights and roles in ones society should be governed by ones sex. Historically, sexism has been male-driven and