Immigration 2 Essay, Research Paper
Immigration has recently become a controversial topic in America. Some feel that immigration is necessary to keep up the diversity in America. In addition, it creates a stronger economic base because immigrants will produce more goods than they use as well as filling in the lower paid jobs we aren’t willing to take. Others, like the right wing republicans, feel immigration is treading on thin ice. Indeed, they state that immigration is responsible for lower standards in our culture as a result of their values brought into our culture. In his article, “Immigrants and Family Values”, Francis Fukuyama, states this is not the case. Fukuyama acknowledges we are suffering from a cultural decline, but immigrants are not the ones responsible for it. Rather, it is the “contemporary elite culture of Americans”(11) that is ultimately to blame.
Fukuyama contends that liberal groups as well as conservatives criticize immigration. For example, the Sierra Club disagrees with immigration because it forces our country to expand economically in addition to just population growth thereby reducing the nation’s resources faster and eventually bringing down the environment. He notes right wing nativist republicans, like Patrick J. Buchanan, feel that the arrival of immigrants to America is detrimental. The conservative view is immigrants foster “lesser desirable cultural values”(1). Buchanan and other right wing republicans insist America’s identity is Christian, European, and Anglo-Saxon. They fear non-European immigration will dilute their own ideals and cultural values with their own. The identity of America is changing, and republicans do not like it.
Buchanan’s idea of America’s identity is an older nativist one. This influx of different cultures to our nation gives rise to a more diverse multicultural state. This causes a negative impact in the eyes of Republicans for they fear the probable loss of votes. It is for these reasons that helped Buchanan take on his current anti-immigration posture. Furthermore Fukuyama observes, “Buchanan has explicitly attacked the notion that democracy represents a particularly positive form of government, and hence would deny that belief in universal democratic principles ought to be at the core of the American national identity”(2). His perception of our nation is largely Anglo-Saxon and founded in Christianity. Fukuyama feels it is the values that lie herein that Buchanan fears will be overtaken by immigration, thus reshaping America’s identity. However, there are other arguments on what constitutes identity in America.
Fukuyama suggests one such argument. Unlike other democracies, American identity means that one prescribes to a set of universal principles. These principles are based on freedom and equality without fear of persecution. These ideas are not based on race or religion. Indeed, the Constitution prohibits the establishment of a national religion, as well as guaranteeing freedom of religion at the same time. Open to all, belief in the Constitution and what it stands for is the basis of America’s identity.
Fukuyama also notes however, that America’s identity goes farther than just believing in its universalistic principles and its Anglo-Saxon heritage. Actually, our nation has only started to uphold these universal ideas in the recent post industrialized years. Granted, democracy is absorbed by those willing to follow its laws, but democracy also has certain cultural values contained within. Fukuyama contends “virtually every serious theorist of American democracy has noted that its success depended heavily on the presence of certain pre-democratic values or cultural characteristics that were neither officially sanctioned nor embodied in law”(3). These characteristics are largely Christian in their nature and have been the foundation for our nation’s “economic prosperity and social cohesion”(3). It is no longer a question about whether immigration endangers these social values. Rather, it is a question about which groups further these values and which groups taint them.
Fukuyama asserts that immigrants coming into our country from Third-World societies are “likely to be poorer, less educated, and in possession of fewer skills than those from Europe, but they are also likely to have stronger family structures and moral inhibitions”(5). In addition, he notes, “immigrants are likely to be a self-selecting group with a much greater than average degree of energy, ambition, toughness, and adaptability”(5). It is these core values that immigrants bring with them that help them achieve their goal of success. Traditional family values are most apparent when looking at immigrants from Asian counties. Fukuyama observes that “mutually supportive family structures have long been credited as the basis for their economic success”(5). Asians typically have larger and more numerous family structures than whites and their rate of divorce are significantly lower. He emphasizes that more importantly they are also engrossed in the importance of quick adaptation, and have not insisted on infusing their own culture into America. While most Americans distinguish the importance and value the social aspects of Asians, Fukuyama thinks “the real fears of cultural invasion surround Latinos”(5).
Crime and other social calamities of the Latino immigrant population have created a negative influence on America’s whites. However, Fukuyama acknowledges “the evidence suggests that most Latin American immigrants may be a source of strength with regard to family values, and not a liability”(5). Latino families have a lower rate of female-headed households than blacks. When we accommodate economics into the equation, we find those single-parent households closely approaches whites. Also, different studies indicate Latinos are more probable to belong to families, have greater birth weight children, and attend church more so than blacks or whites. Fukuyama notices “While they [Latinos] are poor and unskilled, they have a work ethic and devotion to family comparable to those of the South and East European immigrants who came to the U.S. at the turn of the century”(7). He goes further and states that it is not the Latino or Asian immigrant culture that brings a decline to America’s cultural identity, but it is the contemporary culture of America that is fostering it.
Fukuyama reveals that old, traditional nativist culture still thrives today but it is covered by an additional elitist culture that tends to contaminate the cultural values of immigrants. He notes, “first generation is willing to work quietly at minimum- or subminimum-wage jobs, the second and third generations have higher expectations as to what their labor is worth”(7). Fukuyama sees the problem as promoting continual multiculturalism. Multiculturalism “is both a Western and an American invention”(8). The origin of multiculturalism can be found as a result of the civil rights movement. The subsequent failure to assimilate found African-Americans taking pride in their own separateness. This resulted in America taking a multicultural posture, although some immigrants didn’t necessarily need it. Chinese and Russian parents believed that direct immersion into English was the best way to learn how to function in American society.
The cultural decay we face is staggering. However, Fukuyama notes it is not the recent immigrants who we should find at fault. The culture and values they bring with them to our country is not responsible for deteriorating our American identity. It is our “contemporary elite culture of Americans”(11) that Francis Fukuyama holds to blame. It is America’s recent idealistic, multicultural views that should be held accountable for changing our society. He believes:
“The real fight ought to be over the question of assimilation itself: whether we believe that there is enough to our Western, rational, egalitarian, democratic civilization to force those coming to the country to absorb its language and rules, or whether we carry respect for other cultures to the point that Americans no longer have a common voice with which to speak to one another”(9).
We must ask this question of our nation as a whole. Is it enough?
322
Другие работы по теме:
Immigration Essay Research Paper I feel really
Immigration Essay, Research Paper I feel really bad for the people who turn to immigration to save their lives. Americans unwillingly use their tax dollars to pay for the salary of illegal immigrants. It is a big problem for people in the US. I feel that immigration is okay, but the problem is illegal immigration.
Eugenics Essay Research Paper In the 1920s
Eugenics Essay, Research Paper In the 1920?s there was a movement, called the melting pot, to solve the social problems of the time with the use of technology. Eugenics is the use of science to solve social problems. A major leader in eugenics at the turn of the century was a man named Davenport. Kallikak studied eugenics too.
Immigrants And The United States Essay Research
Paper IMMIGRANTS AND THE UNITED STATES The Americans now are concerning about migration as well as the nation s economy. The concern is whether the immigrants will contribute to the prosperity of the America society or they just create more problems and difficulties for our society. People also worry about the budget that the nation has to provide for new immigrants.
Changing Cities Essay Research Paper The late
Changing Cities Essay, Research Paper The late 1800’s were a time of changing of immigration, transportation, and government, which in turn changed cities to a drastic amount. Immigration played a big part in changing the culture of the cities into their own unique culture for every city. Transportation let the people still be connected to other cities without having to travel for months to get there.
Controlling Immigration Essay Research Paper With the
Controlling Immigration Essay, Research Paper With the many different groups of people coming to this country in search of a better life. I believe that we should better control Immigration to the U.S.. Since I am born native to the U.S. it is hard for me to say that others are not allowed to come into the U.S. But throughout this report there is evidence why control of immigration is needed.
America And Imigration Essay Research Paper History
America And Imigration Essay, Research Paper History 53 Spring 2000 Immigration/Migration America and Immigration When reading two articles that are decades apart, one sees that the nation?s, as a whole, opinion has changed about immigrants. In an article from 1905 the South wanted immigrants because they were cheap labor.
Illegal Immigration In The US Essay Research
Paper Illegal immigration in the U.S. is a major concern to the government to the government and it s citizens. This was not a major concern until lately in the past twenty years. There has been an alarming increase of illegal immigrants in the U.S. A debate has arisen over the amount of action that has been exerted on the behalf of the national government to control the amount of illegal immigrants in the country.
Illegal Immigrants Essay Research Paper Illegal immigrants
Illegal Immigrants Essay, Research Paper Illegal immigrants from the country of Honduras will find out later this year if they will be allowed to stay in the U.S. as illegal immigrants. With the Clinton Administration switching over to the Bush Administration the answer is not clear of whether or not they will be allowed to stay in the country after July 5, 2001.
Canadian Immigration Essay Research Paper
For a long time Canada has been a multi cultural country, and because of this, ourcitizens are more socially and globally aware of what s going on around them. Canada sImmigration Act and system helps our country be more culturally diverse, it increases economicgrowth, and it makes Canada a safer place to be.
Immigration Essay Research Paper Obsessivecompulsive disorder has
Immigration Essay, Research Paper Obsessive-compulsive disorder has a dramatic effect on a person’s life. The obsessions and compulsions cause marked distress because they take at least an hour each day, and can significantly interfere with the person’s normal routine, occupational functioning, or usual social activities or relationships.
Immigration Essay Research Paper What could be
Immigration Essay, Research Paper What could be more captivating than an oasis in a desert with green foliage, cool fresh water, and succulent fruits? An oasis is a paradise to a fatigued, dehydrated, and hungry person who must survive in the desert. The United States is the oasis, the paradise to immigrants who live in other countries in undesirable conditions.
Immigration Essay Research Paper Thesis 2
Immigration Essay, Research Paper Thesis – The economic aspect of America was changed drastically due to the wide spread increasse of immigration. Immigration is a form of migration that signifies the intention of a person to settle permanently in a new country. Since the beginning of time, people have been traveling from place to place, looking for the “perfect” home.
Increase Immigration Into Canada Essay Research Paper
Increase Immigration into Canada Good afternoon ladies and gentlemen. As we all now we are all gathered here today to debate, argue over a bill concerning an increase in immigration. We may not all be on the same side. But personally I am for
Immigration In Canada Essay Research Paper IMMIGRATION
Immigration In Canada Essay, Research Paper IMMIGRATION IN CANADA Canada should support immigration as it isneeded and should be encouraged. Most Canadians forget,they are descendants of immigrants. In this essay thefollowing will be discussed : – need for immigrants – the myths about immigrants – illegal and inadmissible immigrants.
Immigration 2
Immigration’s Role In The Development Of The United States As A Nation Essay, Research Paper In the beginning of our country, the first people to settle in the United States were immigrants. They
Should Immigration Laws Be More Restrictive Essay
, Research Paper Should Immigration Laws Be More Restrictive? In any public place nowadays we can see people of different races everywhere mostly begging or asking us to buy things we usually do not want. Should immigration laws be more restrictive? Many people say this phenomenon is irreversible and that our future is that of a multiracial, multiethnic society regardless of whether laws are changed or not.
The Jewish American Family Essay Research Paper
The Jewish American Family Historical Background The settlement of Jews in America is an old one. Jews have been in America since the colonial period, though they began arriving in large numbers only one hundred years ago. The immigration of Jews to America occurred in three major historical waves involving people from three national locations:
Immigration Essay Research Paper In the early
Immigration Essay, Research Paper In the early 1900 s, America was looked upon as being The land of Opportunity. Immigrants looked to the United States as a place where they could begin to rebuild their lives with a fresh new start. America soon began to be called the melting pot of the world. Immigrants were no longer Irish, French, or German.
Immigration Essay Research Paper ImmigrationI am driving
Immigration Essay, Research Paper Immigration I am driving my car and trying to get to Miami. I get lost. I stop at a gas station because I need someone to direct me in the right direction. I end up in a city called Hialeah where there are very few English speaking people. The people that are there only speak Spanish.
Imigration Essay Research Paper Immigration EssayBy Shawn
Imigration Essay, Research Paper Immigration EssayBy Shawn Curtin1-31-99 Immigration is one of the most talked about issues today. Immigration has two sides a positive side and a negative side. In my report I will tell you about five points against immigration. My first negative point is that our economy is on the slide. 300,00 legal immigrants enter out country each year.
Immigration Facts Essay Research Paper 1 Some
Immigration Facts Essay, Research Paper 1. Some of the immigrants who came to the US between the Civil War and WWI include the Irish, Germans, Italians, Polish, Jews, Chinese, Japanese, and Koreans. Groups such as the American Protective Association, the Immigration Restriction League, and the notorious Ku Klux Klan discriminated against these groups.
Immigrants Essay Research Paper Are Immigrants A
Immigrants Essay, Research Paper Are Immigrants A To the U.S? Immigrants are not a burden to the U.S. Therefore, we shouldn’t stop all immigration . Immigrants are hard workers and are not causing unemployment for
History Of Korean 2
History Of Korean & Chinese Immigration Essay, Research Paper The first immigration of Koreans to the North Americas happened in the early 1900??s near the year 1902. They came to America to work on the sugar plantations in Hawaii.
Chinese Immigration Essay Research Paper
“The Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882 was the first significant law restricting immigration into the United States. Those on the West Coast were especially prone to attribute declining wages and economic ills on the despised Chinese workers. Although the Chinese composed only .002 percent of the nation’s population, Congress passed the exclusion act to placate worker demands and assuage prevalent concerns about maintaining white “racial purity.”
Immigration To Canada Essay Research Paper Early
Immigration To Canada Essay, Research Paper Early immigration to Canada was generated by a network of emigration agents who were salesman who advertised to Canada?s attraction?s to prospected immigrants. They targeted wealthy farmers, agricultural laborers and female domestics, preferably from Great Britain, the United States and Northern Europe.
To Welcome With Open Arms Essay Research
Paper Many Americans have skewed notions about immigration, and those perceptions influence decision in Washington and presidential candidates on the campaign trail. Some people think immigration is out of control; a few suggest that it should be stopped altogether. The problem is that many people have illegal immigration and legal immigration mixed up.
Immigration The Maker And Breaker Of America
Essay, Research Paper There are many issues concerning the immigration into America by peoples of other races and cultures, and a hundred more opinions to go with them. At the time of the largest immigration boom into this country, between 1880 and 1920, many people thought of immigration as a negative thing.
World Population Essay Research Paper During the
World Population Essay, Research Paper During the last hundred years the population of the Arab world was doubled more than ten times. This was mainly due to the improvement of health care, education, employment and immigration to the big cities, and sometimes other countries. This change in the population caused a lot of as the number of people is much more than the resources available for them.
Immigration 3 Essay Research Paper Analysis of
Immigration 3 Essay, Research Paper Analysis of a Disagreement over Immigration The authors of the 3 articles on immigration reform all seem to agree that the 1990 immigration law is inadequate, but they agree on little else. They find different impacts on the workforce, positive and negative. And they differ sharply over whether recent levels of immigration help or hurt the economy: one writer suggesting higher levels of immigrants and the other two suggesting a reduced level.
Immigration Essay Research Paper The simple dispute
Immigration Essay, Research Paper The simple dispute for immigration issues in Wausau became a complex dilemma after the major migration of the Hmong Asians. People of Wausau did not clearly understand the meaning of Immigration and all of its complexities.