Big Time Essay, Research Paper
The Over-Specification of Courage
Right in the middle! This is the place Aristotle respects. In the book Nichomachean Ethics, Aristotle does his best to explain what the many virtues of the world are. To Aristotle, the virtue courage is ?a mean with respect to fear and confidence?(68), but more specifically, ?a man who fearlessly faces a noble death and any situations that bring a sudden death?(69-70). This is certainly consistent with his philosophy that all virtues are simply the correct middle between any excess and deficiency. There do, however, arise many complications with the definition of courage. What may seem like courage might not be. Consequently, Aristotle sets the bounds that courage must result from reason, must not be confused with duty, and is only measurable in unexpected situations. If outside these bounds, then actions cannot be classified courageous. Though I feel that Aristotle has for the most part hit true courage on the button, he is wrong to label no action courageous if it is not in his bounds. The trouble with Aristotle?s analysis is that it destroys courage by ruling out any situation where it possibly could exist, by not considering different degrees of emotions that lead to different human decisions, and by not allowing for any form of partial courage.
Aristotle sufficiently argues that the qualities similar to courage aren?t true courage. Duty of citizens is the first of Aristotle?s criticisms. Citizen soldiers are prompted by a ?sense of shame?(72) or ?a sense of fear?(72) and fight either because ?their laws and customs will stigmatize them?(72) or ?they are forced by their superiors?(72). Next, experience is criticized because experienced soldiers ?give the impression of being courageous to others who do not know what is happening,?but when they are inferior in men and equipment,?they are the first to run away?(73). Temper is also criticized because, though it brings about the ability for men to ?turn on those who have wounded them,?they are not guided by reason but emotion?(74-75). Like experience, optimism is not to be confused with true courage because optimists, who ?think they are strongest and will suffer no harm?,(75) will actually turn and run when the unexpected arises. Finally, ignorance cannot be mistaken for courage because the ignorant, like the experienced and optimistic, simply ?give the impression of being courageous?(75). Only under the will of reason and in the complete lack of the presence of duty, experience, optimism, or ignorance can true courage be found.
Aristotle is absolutely right that true courage can only be found within these bounds. If a citizen comes back dead from war, there is the high likelihood that he might not have been acting courageously when he died. He certainly could have been forced by an officer to fight or have been too scared of the stigma that society would put on him to run away. If either was the case, then the soldier didn?t act with true courage. Temper likewise is fair to criticize. Anyone who is terribly consumed by emotion is not acting in the way that their natural reason would guide them. In this sense angry people are not themselves and their actions to not warrant the credit of the label ?truly courageous?. As follows, experience, optimism, or ignorance are also effective issues to argue upon. If someone is charging hard and going beyond what normal men would attempt, then they just might know something the rest don?t. In the case of ignorance, they might not be acting as they truly would. Either way, it can?t be disputed that it would take ?a sudden situation?(75) to see if there was no experience, optimism, or ignorance that gave a man a false expression of courage before the sudden situation arose. Aristotle?s definition of true courage is solid; it truly can only be measured in non-citizens that are in sudden situations and acting with complete reason.
The trouble with Aristotle?s analysis, however, is that he equates true courage with all courage and leaves no room for partial courage. Just because a soldier is a citizen with duties, he still might act very courageously. He might need only to be forced by an officer in only the most extreme of situations. Such would be when the battle is for all practical purposes lost and the enemy out numbers you one hundred to one. In normal and even very difficult battles, this soldier may fight hard and for all the right reasons. I feel this person is not necessarily truly courageous, but he is still very courageous. Further, when a person is acting with emotional anger, they are detached from their true self, but to what degree? Aristotle fails to allow for different degrees of anger that would shift people different degrees away from their true selves. If a soldier were a little bit angry and acted courageously, Aristotle would give him no credit because the utmost reason was not involved. Lastly, where is there a case that, experience, ignorance, or optimism is not present? Undisputedly, there is no soldier devoid of either experience or ignorance. If these invalidate any perception of courage, we will never find any example of courage anywhere. Continuing, in Aristotle?s sudden situations, what do we do? How sudden is sudden? How surprised does a soldier have to be for us to be able to see, that when he doesn?t run away, he is courageous? Aristotle has killed the very issue that he hoped to define. There is nothing left of courage.
I would be very upset with Aristotle?s definition of courage if I were a soldier. He would give me no credit where it could certainly be due. True I may not act with complete reason, I may have a little experience and optimism, but in most cases, I would certainly ?fearlessly face a noble death?(69). Aristotle has located his prized ?mean between confidence and fear?(68); he has found true courage. It unfortunately it exists nowhere in the real world. Ironically, Aristotle has defined courage by its extreme, and extremes are the very thing that Aristotle sought to gain the most distance from upon the outset of his argument. Aristotle has remarkable reasoning, but look at where it has left him. How dismal to only be called courageous if one ?endures and fears the right things, for the right reason, for the right motive, in the right manner, and at the right time?(70).
Другие работы по теме:
My Well Essay Research Paper I am
My Well Essay, Research Paper I am not yet sure of my thirst. I am in desparate need of water though. The source from which my water flows has been poisoned with abuse and hatred.
Editha Essay Research Paper DO YOU HAVE
Editha Essay, Research Paper DO YOU HAVE TIME? I knelt to pray but not for long, I had too much to do. I had to hurry and get to work For bills would soon be due. So I knelt and said a hurried prayer,
Abortion Essay Research Paper A Plan for
Abortion Essay, Research Paper A Plan for a Homework Center The school board came up with an idea of making the school day two periods to give students time to do homework in a homework center. The idea of extending two classes is a good one. There are a lot advantages and disadvantages.
April Morning Essay Essay Research Paper I
April Morning Essay Essay, Research Paper I think that some of the reasoning behind Moses Cooper letting Adam fight in the war was that Adam was no longer a small child like his brother
My Poetical Side Essay Research Paper I
My Poetical Side Essay, Research Paper I just thought I?d unleash My poetical side. ?Cause in everyday life I live to hide. Need something of freedom From time-to-time.
Life Essay Research Paper You have been
Life Essay, Research Paper You have been ready to move on for quite some time But maybe not so ready to let go Of all that you know (Your friends, your family, and all the sweet memories)
The Myth Of Time Sumosaki Vs Enigma
) Essay, Research Paper Give me some time to think. You pressure me with your hourglass. Your concept, I am not supposed to believe in. But I am not given choices.
Herodotus Essay Research Paper Herodotus Essay Herodotus
Herodotus Essay, Research Paper Herodotus Essay Herodotus of Halicarnassus was born about 484 B.C. he died 60 years later. For the time he lived in this age was very old though by today’s standards it is not. The reason why his age was so outstanding was in his time the average man live for maybe half that because of the harsh living conditions.
Goals Essay Research Paper Jonathan drlasEssay 4This
Goals Essay, Research Paper Jonathan drlas Essay 4 This is my first work on this paper. My goal that I?am going to incorporate in my paper is a money goal. I want to save up 3,000 dollars before I leave for school. I leave on the 15 of august so there is a little over two months that I have to achieve this goal.
Critical Thinking Essay Research Paper Critical thinking
Critical Thinking Essay, Research Paper Critical thinking would be important to the well being of our society for many reasons except for the fact that hardly anyone ever uses it. If people used critical thinking all the time society would be a very different place. People would actually think about what they were going to say and what it means before they said it.
Days Work Essay Research Paper I woke
Days Work Essay, Research Paper I woke up on a day with , the sun ,and my dog laying with this feet on my bed. I got up and got dressed and went down the steps.te some
School Essay Research Paper School Where
School Essay, Research Paper School! Where did they come up with that name? I guess because it rhymes with lame Now this rhyme you read will be quite corny Please don’t get upset, mad, or horny
Time Travel Essay Research Paper The Twins
Time Travel Essay, Research Paper The Twins Paradox uses Einstein’s Theory of Special Relativity to explain that time travel is possible. Let’s say two twins are on Earth. They are both twenty years old. One leaves in a spaceship. She is gone for sixty years. When she returns the twin that remained on Earth is eighty years old, she on the other hand appears to be about thirty.
A Moment Essay Research Paper A moment
A Moment Essay, Research Paper A moment exists in what we call time. Time in itself, is a figment of our imagination. The only part of time that actually exists is the present moment. All other moments become memory or expectation, leaving them to be non existent. In truth, the present moment is the only part of time that can be experienced by the six senses.
Sbs CORE Program Essay Research Paper My
Sbs C.O.R.E. Program Essay, Research Paper My name is BRIAN MCGHEE. I am 24yrs old. The reason I want to be in SBS-C.O.R.E. program is that I think the program has what I need in order for me to receive my bachelor’s degree. One of the things I have trouble with is understanding things the first time. It has always taken me a little longer.
Teen Smoking Essay Research Paper There are
Teen Smoking Essay, Research Paper There are many factors that author use in each of their stories to help the reader imagine what the setting look likes. In Pat Conroy, the author describes how the air smells and what the land looks like at different times of the year. This is some of the things that he gives you to help image the setting of the story.
Slow Dance Essay Research Paper S L
Slow Dance Essay, Research Paper S L O W D A N C E: *BR* *br* Have you ever watched kids*br* on a merry-go-round*br* Or listened to the rain*br* slapping on the ground?*br**br*
Trip To Hospital Essay Research Paper Trip
Trip To Hospital Essay, Research Paper Trip to the hospital My trip to the hospital was ok it was required but I still went and I found out that when you go to the hospital. It isn?t just some place that when you go ijn you sign papers it a place that saves live.
InClass Writing Essay Research Paper Inclass Writing
In-Class Writing Essay, Research Paper In-class Writing or Homework Desks and paper rattle while time slowly tics away from the clock. This time these distractions do not bother you because you are finishing one of your most well written papers. In-class writings are great because they include many positive opportunities.
Thoughts Essay Research Paper Dear God I
Thoughts Essay, Research Paper Dear God, I come to you not in a time of need, but in a time of worry, Dear God, all I see around me now is greed, and yet, Who am I to point a finger at others, when I know deep inside,
Life Is Like Essay Research Paper Life
Life Is Like Essay, Research Paper Life is like a car. When it?s new, it usually works all right. As time drives by, it breaks down and needs repairs. Life is like a leaf. In its youth, it
Dinquent Essay Research Paper When things go
D|inquent Essay, Research Paper When things go wrong, When things don’t go the way you wanted, You know it’s the right time To call it quits. He or she wouldn’t know what you have in mind,
Time Essay Research Paper Time is of
Time Essay, Research Paper Time is of the essence! Be on time! Time to go to school! We are running out of time! You may not realize it, but our lives are controlled by time. From the time we get up to the time we go to bed we are its slaves.
Those Hands Essay Research Paper Those hands
Those Hands Essay, Research Paper Those hands they do so much they cook, clean and take care of us. As the ring sits on the finger it glimmers in the light as she works. The hands turn the
WHAT YOU MEAN TO ME Essay Research
Paper WHAT YOU MEAN/MEANT TO ME WHEN I SEE YOU WALK BY, WHEN YOU DON’T STOP TO SAY HI, ALL I CAN DO IS SIT BACK AND SY, FOR I CAN’T FORGET THAT TIME, THAT TIME WHEN YOU MADE ME CRY,
The Playground Essay Research Paper I have
The Playground Essay, Research Paper I have a friend I used to know who had a playground where we would go The times we had are fresh in my mind but they are from another time
Bull Rider Essay Research Paper I can
Bull Rider Essay, Research Paper I can remember my first time to ride a bull All of the thoughts in my head were nice and full The sight of the beast below me was scary
How To Writing A Research Essay Essay
, Research Paper How To Writing A Research Essay The toughest part of the essay, for me, was taking all the information I had gained and reduce it to a mere few pages essay. After all, quality is better