Summary: My God, it’s full of cliches! (with apologies to the writers of 2010)
A good cast, some impressive special effects, and an experienced astronaut providing technical advice. What could have gone wrong?
Let’s start with the script. It combines every possible sci-fi cliche (look for these movies as they appear in M2M: 2001 and 2010 in a big way, Dune, The Abyss, Apollo 13, Close Encounters of the Third Kind, to name only a few) in a melodramatic, hokey script. Granted, there’s a really good cast hiding in this movie somewhere, but with the script they’re given, they didn’t stand a chance.
If, by some chance, you can overcome the dialogue and the contrived, overdone attempts at drama and suspense, you’re still faced with the background music. Constantly. It never stops. It would be one thing if it were a traditional John Williams score, but this sounds like it was composed when someone threw their cat on the keyboard and let it run free. Remember the score to the original “Terminator”? Mozart compared to this.
The upside: the special effects were not too bad. The technology (ships, Mars hab) portrayed was impressive. I saw the movie with a sneak preview audience of a lot of NASA and aerospace people, and everyone agreed. The shots of the Mars landscape and some of the storms (you see them in the previews) are pretty cool, but nothing we haven’t seen before. On the other hand, I won’t go into the CGI aliens–that would be too much of a spoiler–but let’s just say that Marvin the Martian would have done just as well. Oh, and I didn’t realize that Mars would look so much like Utah…
But all in all, eye candy is only eye candy. Mission to Mars tried to be many things on many levels–action/adventure, quasi-romance, hard sci-fi–and failed at all of them. Save your $8 and go rent 2001 instead. Gary Sinese, what were you thinking?
Mission To Mars boasts a very impressive visual style. Brian DePalma takes his camera and turns it all around in space and gives you the feeling that you’re actually floating around in a Mars bound spaceship. Mars hasn’t looked this good since Total Recall and the sandstorms that occur on Mars are quite spectacular. There are two scenes that really work. The first deals with the first Mars expedition and the ensuing calamity that causes a second mission to the angry red planet. The second good scene is one in which the rescue team has to abandon their ship and try to make it to an orbiting supply vessel. Those scenes, however, are bookended by scenes that go on too long. These scenes are filled with dialogue that goes nowhere. The point is made in the first few lines, but the writers deemed it necessary to have the actors spout it out at every given second. With a cast like Gary Sinise, Tim Robbins, and Don Cheadle, you’d think you’d have it covered. To their credit, they give it all they’ve got, and they do manage to have some fine moments. Too bad they were hampered with lines that didn’t move the story forward. Brian DePalma’s mastery of the visual medium makes for some interesting visuals and he of course borrows things from 2001, Close Encounters of the Third Kind, and Star Wars. Mission To Mars has some interesting ideas, but ultimately, the climax left me feeling cheated. I wanted more. Mars is an alien planet that holds many mysteries. From that thought you can cook up any number of scenarios that are frought with danger. Overall, two really good scenes, some good visual effects and a great production design are hampered by many bad scenes supplied by a weak script that gives good actors some really bad lines.
Summary: Solid sci-fi with Hitchcockian cinematic feel
As a long-time aficionado of “hard” science fiction, both in print and on film, I am mystified at the intensity of negative reviews that have accreted around MISSION TO MARS. Consider the typical criticisms that hard-core fans level at screen sci-fi:
1. “It’s all special effects, and the plot is not ‘character driven.’” Well, this film is all about characters and their very human emotions: wonder, love, loss, frustration, gratitude. If this movie had been any more character-driven, it would have been a Bergman flick.
2. “The writers obviously don’t understand science or simply cheat on the scientific angle to squeeze the budget or get around plotting difficulties.” Again, it seems to me that the producers spared no expense to give good, rock-hard science here. The shots in the Mars-bound spaceship were incredible. One-upping both Stanley Kubrick on centrifuge shots, and APOLLO 13 on free-fall shots, de Palma incorporated both reference frames seamlessly. It’s a brilliant piece of cinematography, directing, and editing.
3. “There’s nothing new here. This was all covered by Heinlein/Asimov/Clarke/Dick by the end of the 1950’s.” Well, I’ve got news for you: _all_ literary plots and themes have been covered at some point in the past. Even Shakespeare borrowed shamelessly from earlier works. Actually, there’s plenty that’s new in MISSION TO MARS. The Hitchcock method of continuous panning so beloved by Brian de Palma is used to great effect here–the first sci-fi film to be so shot. For comparision, take a peek at de Palma’s previous effort, SNAKE EYES, to see the same technique.
Although I consider MISSION TO MARS to be a top-notch science fiction film, beautiful to look at and listen to, I certainly can’t give it a perfect ‘10.’ While the physical science is good, the biology is substandard. The ending is relatively weak, but I can’t judge the whole book by its last chapter. I give it a solid ‘8′, and I recommend it for theatrical viewing.
Другие работы по теме:
Venus Aphrodite Essay Research Paper In the
Venus (Aphrodite) Essay, Research Paper In the begining, there was Chaos. From Chaos and Mother Earth came the first race of Greek deities, the Titans. These first gods were ruled by Saturn, who had received the prophesy that his son will over throw him. Well, he ate all his children save one, the one his wife, Mother Earth (Gaia) placed on an island.
Mars And Venus United By Love Essay
, Research Paper ?Mars and Venus United by Love? by Paolo Veronese is done in the Renaissance style of painting. This is done in this style, because Poalo Veroneses was a Renaissance painter as well as his teacher Titan.
Bartolomeo Manfredi Essay Research Paper The first
Bartolomeo Manfredi Essay, Research Paper The first artist I have chosen is Bartolomeo Manfredi (1582 – 1622). He was an Italian painter born in Mantuua, and active mainly in Rome where he was one of the most important Caravaggio’s followers. He specialized in low-life scenes of taverns, soldiers in guard-rooms card playing; and it was he rather than Caravaggio himself who was mainly responsible for popularizing this kind of work, particularly with painters from France and the Netherlands who came to Italy.(1)
Future Plans Essay Research Paper Scholarship Essay
Future Plans Essay, Research Paper Scholarship Essay”Did life exist on Mars?”"What would it take to build a spaceship that could travel at the speed of light?”"When will the moon be colonized?”These are just some of the questions that wander through my mind all day. Fascinated by the secrets of the universe, I yearn to uncover mysteries.
Red Star Vs. Room With A View
Essay, Research Paper The differences in views of women’s roles in society differ from E.M. Forester’s A Room with a View and Bogdanov’s Red Star, is what I believe to be a response to economic class in each society. I say this because in the society on Mars all persons were working towards a common goal and pull their resources together, which is a more conceivable of an idea that a group peasants would do than the middle class.
Mars Exploration Essay Research Paper Mars has
Mars Exploration Essay, Research Paper Mars has been a place NASA and other organizations have wanted to conquer after the Apollo missions. It has been several decades since anyone has sent anything to Mars. Lately though Mars has been the main focus to space engineers and scientists. This is because in 1989 President George Bush called for a manned mission to Mars (Sky & Telescope).
Pluto Essay Research Paper Pluto repeats an
Pluto Essay, Research Paper Pluto repeats an anomaly when compared with the terrestrial planets (Mercury, Venus, the Earth and Mars) or the giant planets (Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus and Neptune). This icy world is more like a huge asteroid or the satellites of the outer planets; it has even been suggested that Pluto was a satellite that escaped from Neptune’s pull.
Manned Mission To Mars Essay Research Paper
Final Draft For hundreds of years the Red Planet, Mars, has fascinated people. Today it appears as if we re on the brink of exploring, or rather learning to explore, this great mystery. However, though the desire to explore Mars exists, an actual mission will take more than just will and reasons; it will require new technology, time, manpower and money.
Ulysses Essay Research Paper The Ulysses Mission
Ulysses Essay, Research Paper The Ulysses Mission is the first spacecraft to explore interplanetary space at high solar latitudes. Ulysses is both a study of the European Space Agency (ESA) and the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) of the USA. The spacecraft and spacecraft operations team is provided by ESA, and the launch and the spacecraft, radio tracking, and data management operations are provided by NASA.
Space Colonization Essay Research Paper SPACE COLONIZATION
Space Colonization Essay, Research Paper SPACE COLONIZATION My five minute essay topic is space colonization. There are three places that I know of that the human race has thought of colonizing . They are: The largest asteroid that is orbiting in our solar system, the Moon and Mars.
David Hume Essay Research Paper In reading
David Hume Essay, Research Paper In reading the ideas of David Hume, I have came to believe that he was telling us the miracles don?t exist. They are sort of a ?Mission impossible.? We
Spender Essay Research Paper The Martian Chronicles
Spender Essay, Research Paper The Martian Chronicles, written by Raymond Bradbury, is a book that discusses s what might happen if Earthmen were to try to colonize Mars. There were four expiditions by Earthmen to Mars. The first three expiditions were destroyed by martians who were jeolous or who were afraid of being colonized .
Martian Chronicles
– Why The Humans Were Wrong Essay, Research Paper ?Why did you do it?? the captain asked. Jeff Spender quietly laid the pistol at his feet. ?Because I?ve seen that what these Martians had was just as good as anything we?ll ever hope to have. They stopped where we should have stopped a hundred years ago?? (64) In the Martian Chronicles by Ray Bradbury, Spender realized the truth before the rest of the crew.
Starting All Over Essay Research Paper Starting
Starting All Over Essay, Research Paper Starting All Over Martian Chronicles Ray Bradbury Ray Bradbury?s the Martian Chronicles is a futuristic story about space travel, invasion and planet colonization. Analyzing characters in this twenty-eight-chapter novel is extremely difficult because every chapter includes different characters, which are oriented to form the plot.
2001 Space Odyssey Essay Research Paper There
2001: Space Odyssey Essay, Research Paper There are many scenes that take place in a book, some are more important than others. In the book I read over the summer, ?2001: Space Odyssey? by Arthur Clarke. A few of the scenes were very important and without them the book would have been a waste. Here are three examples of importance in scenes from my book.
Mars Polar Landing Essay Research Paper A
Mars Polar Landing Essay, Research Paper A momentous occasion has been bestowed upon us. The Mars Polar Lander will try to reach its destination of Mars? southern polar ice cap. The Lander was presumed to touch down on Friday December 3, 1999. It was launched from Cape Canaveral Air Force Station Space Launch Complex 17 on January 3, 1999 and hopefully it has finally reached the surfaces of Mars.
Personal Mission Statement Essay Research Paper I
Personal Mission Statement Essay, Research Paper I believe that the following statements are very true for my personal mission statement. Hear both sides before judging. This statement most people should remember. So often people judge and say what they are thinking at the spur of the moment before really thinking the situation over and hear other sides before speaking.
Police Academy Essay Research Paper Police Academy
Police Academy Essay, Research Paper Police Academy: Mission to Moscow (1994) 1/2 This movie succeeds on only one mission — the mission to suck. That’s the only way to describe the seventh Police Academy movie. It sucks, so much so that previous entries in the series look like classics in comparison. I can’t say I didn’t expect it to be this bad, because once I saw the copy on the back of the box that read, “Kicking butt-ski! Making you laugh-ski! The Academy is back-ski!” I knew it wouldn’t be up for any Oscars.
Mars Mission Essay Research Paper The planet
Mars Mission Essay, Research Paper The planet Mars has always been interesting to me, because it is such a big mystery to everyone. It is important the astronomer today learn more about Mars for one day that could be our home planet . Space exploration has always been huge, what problem there might be, how long it would take, and what would make it safe.
Life Essay Research Paper Both violent and
Life Essay, Research Paper Both violent and non-violent resistance are major themes in the movie The Mission. Even tough the Jesuits are peaceful of God they used both violent and non-violent resistance in this story to stand for what they believe in. Violent protest is aggressive and commanding while non-violent resistance is truly standing up for something.
Atlantis Blasts Off Essay Research Paper Atlantis
Atlantis Blasts Off Essay, Research Paper Atlantis Blasts Off With Science Lab Space shuttle Atlantis blasted off Wednesday with the most expensive and pivotal piece of the international space station: a $1.4 billion science laboratory.
Mars Essay Research Paper LANDING ON THE
Mars Essay, Research Paper LANDING ON THE RED PLANET Who would have ever dreamed about a spacecraft, sponsored by The United States, landing on the surface of Mars for a second time? That dream became a reality on July 4, 1997. This date marked a famous leap for NASA. The Pathfinder sent back astonishing facts and countless pictures and analyses.
Captain Ahab Essay Research Paper Captain AhabIf
Captain Ahab Essay, Research Paper Captain Ahab If you ever saw Captain Ahab in a dark alley, you’d probably turn and run the other way. His scarred body and wooden leg are just a couple of characteristics that show who he is. Ahab is the captain of the whaling ship Pequod, and their mission is to go on a trip and bring back as many whales as possible.
Doug Quail Of David Hume Essay Research
Paper Who is Doug Quail? Doug Quail changes his personal characteristics, but his perceptions and mental ideas make him the same person. A person?s identity is based on the way in which he or she perceives self- impressions or encounters certain experiences. For example, a person might interpret an impression of something completely different from someone else.
The Earth Essay Research Paper THE EARTH
The Earth Essay, Research Paper THE EARTH The Earth’s Place In Space: Despite its own special conditions,the Earth is in some ways similar to the other inner planets the group of planets
Propulsion TechnologyFido Essay Research Paper The FIDO
Propulsion Technology/Fido Essay, Research Paper The FIDO rover is JPL’s advanced technology rover that supports both current and future robotic missions on the surface of Mars. In particular, the FIDO rover conducts mission relevant field trials that simulate mission operations scenarios and validate rover technology in the areas of rover navigation and control, instrument placement, remote sensing, scientific data collection, intelligent behaviors, telemetry processing, data visualization, and mission operations tools.
Martian Chronicles Essay Research Paper Martian ChroniclesThe
Martian Chronicles Essay, Research Paper Martian Chronicles The Martian Chronicles, written by Ray Bradbury, is about man’s journey to Mars in 26 loosely connected stories. Each story tells a different perspective of the new frontier and Bradbury’s view on humans. The book begins with Earth facing war and man sending rockets to Mars in search of a new life.
Near Earth Objects Essay Research Paper Near
Near Earth Objects Essay, Research Paper Near Earth Objects What are NEOs? Where do they come from? Do they pose any real threat to Earth? Can they provide viable space resources? All of these questions are now
The Mission Essay Research Paper The MissionThe
The Mission Essay, Research Paper The Mission The film The Mission is set in 1750 and it depicts hostility between the Jesuits, the Catholic Church, the Guarani Indians, and groups of Portuguese and Spanish slave traders. Yet, as I will demonstrate in this essay, there was good reason for the majority of the conflicts that went on.
Capture The Satellite Essay Research Paper It
Capture The Satellite Essay, Research Paper It was late in the evening when two astronauts approached the spinning 3,000 pound satellite. They reached out to grab the lost satellite and bring it safely back to the U.S. space shuttle. This may sound like a clip out of a recent science fiction movie, but this is the story of the lost SPARTAN satellite.The SPARTAN satellite was sent up in the U.S. space shuttle.
CocaCola Essay Research Paper CocaCola CompanyFrom our
Coca-Cola Essay, Research Paper Coca-Cola Company From our heritage to our mission to the people who bring our products to thirsty consumers, The Coca-Cola Company is a part of lives everywhere. That is the mission statement of the Coca-cola company, and so far as the world knows it that Coca-Cola has been successful to accomplish that mission over and over again.
My Opinion On Life On Mars Essay
, Research Paper My personal opinion I always wished that I would live long enough to witness the discovery of alien life on another planet. I guess a genie somewhere in this small world heard me and granted my wish, well sort of anyway.