Executive summary
This paper explains and evaluates ?Reclaiming Shareholders Power? an article that appeared in Financial Analysts Journal for May-June 1997 edition. This article was written by Victor F. Morris, which gives the readers an overview about shareholders power and a conduit proposal.
This critical analysis consists of several sections : introduction, relevance of article to course content, analysis of the logic and completeness of the author?s argument, analysis of the strengths and weaknesses of the article, logical basis of agreement or disagreement with the key issues in the article, and a brief conclusion. Bibliographic support was obtained from Internet sources and the text book for MC 556. Moreover, this article is well organized, and supported by facts that shareholders are trying to improve their power in a company by making some changes in the company.
Introduction
In one corporation there is a separation between the owners and the management, and the owners in the stockholder?s meeting elect all of the company?s directors. After all of the directors have been elected by the stockholders, the company?s directors would pick managers to help the directors to run the company on a daily basis operation. The purpose of a company to hire managers is to give the stockholders return on their investment and create stockholder wealth maximization in the future. The stockholder wealth maximization usually reflects on the company?s stock price in the market. The higher the company?s stock price in the market, the wealthier the stockholders, because of the capital gain that is reflected in the stock price.
However, this article of ?Reclaiming shareholder power? written by Victor F. Morris illustrates that the owner of a company should have more power than the managers within a company. The author of this article argued that a corporation has a lot of power since a company controls all of its retained earnings by not distributing all of the company?s income to the shareholders. Thus, he also comes up with a conduit solution that could reclaim shareholder power where the retained earnings have to be distributed to the shareholders, and by doing so, a double taxation can be avoided for the company?s earnings.
Relevance of the Article to Course Content
The article ?Reclaiming shareholder power? is directly related to the Management of Finance course, MC 556. This article describes subjects we have already discussed in the class such as maximizing shareholders wealth, dividend, depreciation, and distribution to shareholders. The syllabus also explains that by the end of this course we have to understand the ethical issues facing the financial institutions at this moment. We also have to understand that managers within the organizations must satisfy the stockholders? return on investment. Because the stockholders always consider an opportunity cost where they can invest elsewhere and earn enough money as a return on their investment. This article mentioned who should take control and have the power to determine the direction of a company.
Logical Analysis of the Author?s Presentation
The author of this article argued that shareholders should have more power in determining the direction of a company. He also wants a solution of how to get a balance between shareholders and the company. This article gives some solution such as the conduit solution to apply in the organization to make shareholders have enough power in a company. Under the conduit solution, the author explains that all of a company?s benefits should be distributed to the shareholders according to what they have invested in a company. By implementing the conduit solution, the author also mentioned that a company?s earnings would not get a double taxation since he also mentioned in the article that people pay taxes not corporation. If all of a company?s earnings were distributed to shareholders, the shareholders would receive more money that distributed through dividend. The company?s earnings would be taxed based on the individual?s taxes not company?s taxes. Moreover, the conduit solution would avoid what the author believes and what happens today as a double taxation. However, management within the organization do not like what the author mentioned as the conduit solution. Because companies would be forced by shareholders to distribute the company?s earnings through a dividend pay out. The company?s retained earnings are part of the company?s capital structure. If retained earnings should distribute to shareholders, the company?s cost of capital would be high and the internal rate of return would be less. As a result, the company?s management would disagree with the conduit solution because they would lose their power within the company.
The author?s argument is logical in terms of maximizing shareholders? wealth and power. However, the author fails to see from the company?s stand point and the company?s capital structure. Although the conduit solution that the author represented above in terms of maximizing shareholders? wealthy is important to consider, the author should also understand the purpose of holding money for a company. The company can use retained earnings for speculation, investment, and precautionary as to make company has a lot of power.
Analysis of the Article?s Strengths and Weaknesses
Strengths
1. This article is effective in describing shareholder power that leads to maximizing shareholders wealth. This article also gives an overview of how shareholders would get power within the organizations.
2. The author does not only give his own opinion, but he also provides some hard facts that help readers understand the content of the article. The author also gives other people?s opinions in this article which is good, because by supplying outside opinions, it helps the article look strong and seem more credible.
3. The author is qualified to write about this topic since he is a certified financial analyst that knows a lot about the situations.
4. The article is not too wide or too narrow, since the author was focused enough on the topic and he also gives solutions to consider.
Weaknesses
1.The author only writes the problem from the shareholders? stand point. He just wants to increase the wealth of the shareholders without considering what is going to happen with companies if the conduit solution is exercised.
2.The author seems to have other purposes in writing this article so that the readers think that the author is right about what he presented and argued in this article.
3.The author only gives the negative impact to the shareholders about what currently happens in the company and he also blamed the current tax law that have been applied to the company?s earnings.
Logical Basis of Agreement and Disagreement
The author of the article was trying to bring back the shareholders power within the organizations, but managers within organizations would not feel comfortable with this issue. This argument seems to be logical if we look at it from shareholders stand point of view. The author of this article gave a good explanation about the conduit solution that would benefit to shareholders. He tried to give clear picture about the conduit solution and how it would benefit shareholders. The author explained that management should not always authorize the company?s retained earnings, since shareholders were able to get such retained earnings and invested to the most profitable investment. But, management may not like such ideas.
According to Robert Monks and Nell Minow, people who run a company should consider shareholders? accountability within the organization (1996). They also mentioned that ?corporate stakeholders and constituents benefit most when management devotes its loyalty, energy, and competence to maximizing the value of the enterprise?. However, we have to realize that in one company both management and shareholders should get same or equal benefits. There should be some sort of balance in getting benefits for both management and shareholders in one company and that would benefits the stakeholders and the whole society.
However, from this article, Peter Rona who is an unknown writer that the authors brought into their article was disagreed with the author of the article. He said that, only the management and the board would benefit in managing a company, and shareholders should have nothing to do with it. From his statement above, Rona believed that the board and the management are people who really understand about the company since they understand what happens in the organization. Thus, shareholders should not be involved in managing the company since they do not understand the situation in the organization.
Conclusion
In conclusion, different from the article above, the conduit proposal may not be such a good idea for a company. Because, the conduit proposal would only benefit the shareholders themselves without considering the board and the management within a company. The conduit solution would also make people within the organization reluctant and have no energy to operate a company in a good way. They would feel that shareholders only think about themselves without regarding the people who make them wealthy as a result of the company?s performance that leads to the high price of the company?s stock in the market. However, maximizing the shareholders value is so important to consider since it?s the purpose of a company.
Moreover, management within the organization whose understand the company?s performances not shareholders, and management know how to allocate its money. The company also need capital from the retained earnings to get a return from its own cost of capital without using outside sources that can increase the company?s cost of debt. Finally, from a legal perspective, if shareholders have power in the organization, that would be considered a sole proprietorship in term of power and distribute the money.
Другие работы по теме:
Stocks 2 Essay Research Paper Stocks are
Stocks 2 Essay, Research Paper Stocks are shares in a company. When you invest in a company’s stock or buy its shares, you own part of a company as demonstrated
Apa Crit Essay Research Paper APA Critical
Apa Crit Essay, Research Paper APA Critical Analysis: Teaching Students How to Learn Vol. 31, No. 6, June 2000 In ?Teaching Students How to Learn? it showed the correlation between high-achieving students and their self monitoring in classes. The article goes on to say that unlike high school, college students do not have the regulation in their classes.
Developing A Reward Strategy That Delivers Shareholder
And Employee Value Essay, Research Paper Developing a Reward Strategy that Delivers Shareholder and Employee Value The New Competitive Context: Today business faces the biggest and most difficult times ahead. With the ever changing moods and directions that business is taking almost daily, it is impossible to have a strategy set in place.
Letter To Shareholder Essay Research Paper March
Letter To Shareholder Essay, Research Paper March 5, 1998 Ms. Mary Ruiz 321 Orange Way Green Valley, Ca 90272 Dear Shareholder: This year has been an exciting and profitable one at Nomad. As a shareholder, let us tell you about our recent successes and the challenges we expect in the coming year and beyond. This letter summarizes the high points of the year and provides valuable details about our work in individual areas of the organization, including finance, communications, quality assurance, and travel.
Cheers A Semiotic Analysis By Berger Essay
, Research Paper Cheers : A Semiotic Analysis by Berger In Arthur Asa Berger s essay, he conducts a semiotic analysis of the comedy television show Cheers. In his analysis of the show he points out many characteristics that refer to semiotics. Even though one could not agree with all of his findings, many of them are reasonable.
Waterford Crystal A Case Analysis Essay Research
111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
Kive Essay Research Paper
# a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y Grapes of Wrath, The – Book Summary and Analysis Grapes of Wrath, The – Book Analysis Grapes of Wrath, The – Joads’ Journey Great Expectations – Powerful Themes in the Novel
Technology Factor Analysis Essay Research Paper The
Technology Factor Analysis Essay, Research Paper The main function of my project is to provide a means by which I can measure progress.? It will therefore have to provide resistance when it is used, and have an indicator,
Long Term Analysis Essay Research Paper Analysis
Long Term Analysis Essay, Research Paper Analysis by a Long Term Creditor The interest a long term creditor is currently receiving is 5.6%. A long term creditor could receive as much as 22.7% working somewhere else in the same industry. So, currently the industrial average is giving 17.1% more interest than workingat Cameco Corporation, which is quite a big difference.
Anaylsis Paper Essay Research Paper Analysis Paper
Anaylsis Paper Essay, Research Paper Analysis Paper 1 The EIA predicted Midwestern Illinois families to be spending as much as 40% more on heating this year compared to last year because of higher natural gas prices. The increase in price is largely due to the reduction of natural gas supplied.
Physics Lab Essay Research Paper III ResultsAnalysisMy
Physics Lab Essay, Research Paper III. Results/Analysis: My lab partner and I worked diligently in this experiment to be as accurate and as precise in our measurements and calculations with the technology provided. In part one of the experiment, we calculated the amount of force on the planet at the closest distance to be approximately 18 F.
Antony Speech Analysis Essay Research Paper Emotional
Antony Speech Analysis Essay, Research Paper Emotional Speech Analysis William Shakespeare?s ?Julius Caesar? is a well-written stage play. Shakespeare included many good speeches in his plays; one of the best was the one delivered by Antony. Antony?s speech came very shortly after Julius Caesar?s death, and the city was in much chaos.
Antony Analysis Essay Research Paper Antony Analysis
Antony Analysis Essay, Research Paper Antony Analysis Short Essay The beauty of William Shakespeare s writing does not lie in his actual writing, but the themes in which his plays suggest. Almost all of his plays can be connected to a higher theme, one that most people can relate. In the play, Antony and Cleopatra, the theme of manipulation runs ramped.
Get In Essay Research Paper Click Here
Get In Essay, Research Paper Click Here If YOU Have Friends! Can’t find the paper you need? Try Collegiate Care Comparing Casablanca to 1984 Charlie Parker at Storyville
Changes In Writing Essay Research Paper Changes
Changes In Writing Essay, Research Paper Changes in Writing My last day of high school was January 21, which was my first day at UWM. I graduated early from high school and decided to jump right into college. I was not too worried because I figured that I would catch on. I came into English 102 and found out what an analysis paper was.
The Old Man And The Sea An
Analysis Essay, Research Paper The Old Man and The Sea: An Analysis I read this book for the first time in high school and I remembered it just as well as if I had read it yesterday. As I read it again I remembered some of the
Special Relativity Essay Research Paper ESPECIALLY 2
Special Relativity Essay, Research Paper ESPECIALLY … … of Hardy’s Poems as Seen through the characters” is a study concerning Hardy’s capability of presenting irony of situation in his poetry. The analysis deals …
Vision Essay Research Paper Literary analysis Vision
Vision Essay, Research Paper Literary analysis: Vision Out of the Corner of One Eye. The main character of “Vision out of the Corner of One Eye “, a short story by Luisa Valezuela, goes through a complete one hundred-eighty degree change over the course of the story.
Athlete Dying Young Essay Research Paper The
Athlete Dying Young Essay, Research Paper The Critical Analysis & Summarization of "To An Athlete Dying Young", by A.E Housman This poem is telling the reader that you can not
Recycling Essay Research Paper There are many
Recycling Essay, Research Paper There are many ways we can conserve our resources, but one of the major ways is recycling. In an encycopedia recycling is defined as “the recovery and reprocessing of waste materials for use of new products.” Websters dictonary defines recycling as “a process (as liquid bodywaste, glass or cans) in order to regain material for human use.” There is actually two broad types of recycling, internal and external.
Antigone Essay Research Paper Analysis on the
Antigone Essay, Research Paper Analysis on the conflict men v. women found in Antigone Many conflicts can be found within various plays. In Sophocles’ Antigone one of the many conflicts found is men versus women. The king of Thebes, Creon, has a problem with women. But not only the king, Ismene, Antigone’s sister as well refers to herself and her sister as being inferior to men.
Immigration 3 Essay Research Paper Analysis of
Immigration 3 Essay, Research Paper Analysis of a Disagreement over Immigration The authors of the 3 articles on immigration reform all seem to agree that the 1990 immigration law is inadequate, but they agree on little else. They find different impacts on the workforce, positive and negative. And they differ sharply over whether recent levels of immigration help or hurt the economy: one writer suggesting higher levels of immigrants and the other two suggesting a reduced level.
Othello Act 5 Analysis Essay Research Paper 2
Othello: Act 5 Analysis Essay, Research Paper Othello: Act 5 Analysis Iago’s intelligence causes the self destruction of Othello. He appears to be the most intelligent person in the play, Othello, by the way he acts and
Analysis Of A Newspaper Articl Essay Research
Paper 131-81 Analysis of The Union Racket There is an article in the April 24,2000 issue of The Detroit News called The Union Racket . This article explains how the International Brotherhood of Teamsters currently stands with its lawsuit against its former president. Though the essay dose communicate many useful points, is dose a poor job of not meeting the seven failure requirements for any writing as established by Orwell.
Arrest Analysis Essay Research Paper Arrest
Arrest Analysis Essay, Research Paper Arrest: – An arrest is the act of depriving an individual of his liberty by legal authority. This is to inform you the two procedures of arrest. The procedures of arrest are warrant and non-warrant.
Soil Analysis Report Essay Research Paper Soil
Soil Analysis Report Essay, Research Paper Soil Analysis Within the next few paragraphs, I will tell you all about the soil sample I collected and did tests on. I got some soil from out of one of my mom’s gardens. This one had a lot of flowers from Florida. This is a summary of what all I did to work on finding everything about my soil.
An Analysis Of From Silence To Words
Essay, Research Paper An Analysis of From Silence to Words: Writing as Struggle Through this essay, Min-zhan Lu depicts the struggles she faced growing up in China while speaking English. I feel the paragraph that best exemplifies this struggle is one found on page 239. In this one paragraph, Lu expresses her fear of losing command over the two languages that she speaks, English and Chinese.
A Critical Analysis Essay Research Paper A
A Critical Analysis Essay, Research Paper A Critical Analysis of Evelyn Waugh’s “Bella Fleace Gave a Party” In the introduction to “Bella Fleace Gave a Party”, extensive background is revealed to help the reader understand the times in which the character lived. It is a time of enormous change in the political and social structure of these people’s lives.
Robert Bunsen Essay Research Paper Robert Wilhelm
Robert Bunsen Essay, Research Paper Robert Wilhelm Bunsen s name was famous for a a few discoveries in the field of chemistry. For example you might recognize Bunsen from the lab device, the Bunsen Burner . He also helped invent the spectroscope and discovered spectrum analysis. And at the beginning of his career, he discovered that iron oxide is an antidote for arsenic.
How To Writing A Research Essay Essay
, Research Paper How To Writing A Research Essay The toughest part of the essay, for me, was taking all the information I had gained and reduce it to a mere few pages essay. After all, quality is better