Paper
Proportions of Numbers and Magnitudes
In the Elements, Euclid devotes a book to magnitudes (Five), and he devotes a
book to numbers (Seven). Both magnitudes and numbers represent quantity,
however; magnitude is continuous while number is discrete. That is, numbers are
composed of units which can be used to divide the whole, while magnitudes can
not be distinguished as parts from a whole, therefore; numbers can be more
accurately compared because there is a standard unit representing one of
something. Numbers allow for measurement and degrees of ordinal position
through which one can better compare quantity. In short, magnitudes tell you
how much there is, and numbers tell you how many there are. This is cause for
differences in comparison among them.
Euclid’s definition five in Book Five of the Elements states that ” Magnitudes
are said to be in the same ratio, the first to the second and the third to the
fourth, when, if any equimultiples whatever be taken of the first and third, and
any equimultiples whatever of the second and fourth, the former equimultiples
alike exceed, are alike equal to, or alike fall short of, the latter
equimultiples respectively taken in corresponding order.” From this it follows
that magnitudes in the same ratio are proportional. Thus, we can use the
following algebraic proportion to represent definition 5.5:
(m)a : (n)b :: (m)c : (n)d.
However, it is necessary to be more specific because of the way in which the
definition was worded with the phrase “the former equimultiples alike exceed,
are alike equal to, or alike fall short of?.”. Thus, if we take any four
magnitudes a, b, c, d, it is defined that if equimultiple m is taken of a and c,
and equimultiple n is taken of c and d, then a and b are in same ratio with c
and d, that is, a : b :: c : d, only if:
(m)a > (n)b and (m)c > (n)d, or
(m)a = (n)b and (m)c = (n)d, or
(m)a < (n)b and (m)c < (n)d.
Though, because magnitudes are continuous quantities, and an exact measurement
of magnitudes is impossible, it is not possible to say by how much one exceeds
the other, nor is it possible to determine if a > b by the same amount that c >
d.
Now, it is important to realize that taking equimultiples is not a test to see
if magnitudes are in the same ratio, but rather it is a condition that defines
it. And because of the phrase “any equimultiples whatever,” it would be correct
to say that if a and b are in same ratio with c and d, then any one of the three
instances above, m and n being “any equimultiples whatever,” are true. Likewise,
as stated in proposition 4, the corresponding equimultiples are also in
proportion. It would be incorrect, however; to say that equimultiples are taken
of the original magnitudes to show that they are in same ratio. The two
instances coexist. Furthermore, if there is any one possibility of taking “any
equimultiple whatever,” and not having any one of the above three instances come
true, then the instance is not that of same ratio, but rather that of greater or
lesser ratio as is stated in definition 7, Book 5.
In Book Seven, number replaces magnitude as the substance of ratios and
proportions. A number is a multitude composed of units. Definition 20 states
that “Numbers are proportional when the first is the same multiple, or the same
part, or the same parts, of the second that the third is of the fourth.” Thus,
there are three instances of numerical proportions:
same multiple- 18 : 6 :: 6 : 2
same part- 2 : 4 :: 4 : 8
same parts- 5 : 6 :: 15 : 18.
Compared to the definition of proportion in Book 5, this one is much less
complex and more easily comprehended because using numbers is more exact and
concrete. First of all, there is no taking of equimultiples of the antecedents
and consequents of two ratios. This is because the taking of equimultiples is a
necessary condition when it is only possible to say that one magnitude is
greater, lesser, or equal to another. With numbers, however; there is a more
specific relationship. Two is less than five by three units. It is necessary
to state by how many, which then limits the comparison. For instance, in the
example above of “same multiples,” one can see that eighteen is three multiples
of six and that six is three multiples of two. Thus, the phrase “?.. alike
exceeding, alike equal to, or alike falls short of?” is replaced with “??same
multiple, same part, or same parts?.”
Numbers are representations of magnitude. They are more easily compared, but
the proportion of numbers is fundamentally the same as that of magnitudes, since
a proportion is generally a similarity between ratios. A proportion of numbers
is therefore included in the proportion of magnitudes as a specific case.
Другие работы по теме:
Numbers And Artificial Intelligence Essay Research Paper
All of us when introduced to the real world learn to count things or ideas. It’s number, which gives us happiness, sorrow, jealousy or pain. Our love and hatred depend on some numbers and our expression and reaction related to all abstract or real ideas surely depend on some numbers, which are natural numbers.
The Three Basic Laws Of Chemis Essay
, Research Paper John Dalton was born in 1766 and died in 1844. Around 1803 he developed the first atomic theory of matter. He was a meteorologist and was very important to study of chemistry. Dalton discovered the three basic laws of chemistry. The law of conservation of mass, The law of definite proportions, and The law of multiple proportions.
Galaxies Physical Properties Essay Research Paper SummaryWe
Galaxies: Physical Properties Essay, Research Paper Summary We were given a photograph of a number of galaxies. In order to locate a particular galaxy a series of numbers were laid out vertically and a series of letters were laid out horizontally. We were also given a magnifying glass with a built in scale to measure the length of the galaxy in millimeters.
Lesson Plan Essay Research Paper Goal
Lesson Plan Essay, Research Paper Goal: To understand numbers, ways of representing numbers, relationships among numbers, and number systems. To create and use representation to organize, record, and communicate mathematical ideas.
Nutrition Essay Research Paper Nutrition and Diet
Nutrition Essay, Research Paper Nutrition and Diet Project My average calorie intake per day was 1531.8. My caloric need per day was 3326. My intake is supposed to be way more than what it is. This is really surprising to me. The average percentage of carbohydrates, fat and protein is in the chart below. DAY FAT CARBS PROTEIN SUGAR1 20% 34% 20% 25%2 10% 73% 17% 0%3 21% 47% 13% 19%4 18% 52% 15% 16%5 20% 48% 17% 15% These numbers are around what I should have.
Aids Essay Research Paper Engl 118 April
Aids Essay, Research Paper Engl. 118 April 14, 1996 I. Introduction Thesis- Practicing safe sex is essential in a world where diseases like AIDS exist. II. Body
Euclid Essay Research Paper Euclid of Alexandria
Euclid Essay, Research Paper Euclid of Alexandria is thought to have lived from about 325 BC until 265 BC in Alexandria, Egypt. There is very little known about his life. It was thought he was born in Megara, which was proven to be incorrect. There is in fact a Euclid of Megara, but he was a philosopher who lived 100 years before Euclid of Alexandria.
Ritalin Essay Research Paper Ritalin is a
Ritalin Essay, Research Paper Ritalin is a drug used to quell HYPERCATIVE children and perk up the inattentive. Six times as much ritalin was used in 1995 than in 1990
Hunger Essay Research Paper Income Poverty
Hunger Essay, Research Paper Income Poverty The latest global numbers The World Bank just updated its estimates of the number of people living in poverty to 1996 and 1998, using 1993 Purchasing Power
Imaginary Numbers And The Microwave Oven Essay
, Research Paper Imaginary numbers have had a great effect whether direct or indirect on the microwave oven. Although the concept has come out of left field, there is still a plausible explanation for their influence on the microwave oven. The fact remains that complex numbers have much less direct relevance to real-world quantities than other numbers do.
Absolute Value Functions Essay Research Paper Absolute
Absolute Value Functions Essay, Research Paper Absolute Value Functions (y=a|x-b|+c) In an absolute value function “a” represents the slope of the equation. The slope is counted up or down, then both left and right thus producing the function’s “V” shape and its symmetry. If a*0 in the equation, then the “V” has and upward direction, but if a*0 then the “V” has a downward direction.
A Thousand Acres Essay Research Paper Just
A Thousand Acres Essay, Research Paper Just set back for a moment and think about a thousand acres, that s an area of land of almost mythic proportions. Just as the changes the people had to go through in this book. In this book the author takes material possessions and other tangible entities and identifies the characters through it.
My Fuck Life Essay Research Paper Each
My Fuck Life Essay, Research Paper Each piece was marked with four numbers: the first indicated which span; the second, noted which row of stones; and the last two indicated which position in that
Where Are They In The Periodic Table
? Essay, Research Paper Thanks to Doc Brown of ChemHelp.Net for these great chemistry revision notes. Check out his site for more! Selected Elements of The Periodic Table (name, symbol and atomic numbers 1-38 &
A Comparrison Of Multi-Valued Orientation And Two
Valued Orientation Essay, Research Paper Multi-valued orientation and two valued orientation are two completely different thing. THey compare in only one way. This is the fact that they both have values. It could be said that a contrastment of the two would be more useful than a comparison. Two valued orientation is for extremists.
Errors Essay Research Paper Absolute Errors Since
Errors Essay, Research Paper Absolute Errors Since no measurement is exact, there will always be the possibility of an error. Numbers are often rounded off to a certain number of significant figures or
Cheating Essay Research Paper Students of all
Cheating Essay, Research Paper Students of all ages have been caught cheating. Recent news reports that cheating among students has risen to ?epidemic proportions?. Cheating is a contagious behavior that can be corrected through home, school, and national levels of intervention.
Blue Whale Essay Research Paper The Blue
Blue Whale Essay, Research Paper The Blue Whale The blue whale or balaenoperta musclus is the largest animal to ever have lived on Earth. Whalers have reported this whale to being over 100 feet long and weighing over 150 tons!
Life Expectancy Essay Research Paper Life expectancy
Life Expectancy Essay, Research Paper Life expectancy today has expanded in historically unprecedented proportions, greatly increasing the numbers of people who survive over the age of sixty-five. The instances of medical problems associated with aging, such as certain kinds of cancer and heart disease, have increase, giving rise to great consideration, both in research and in programs, for accommodating this increase.
Jim Morrison Essay Research Paper Jim MorrisonAmerican
Jim Morrison Essay, Research Paper Jim Morrison*****American singer and songwriter, born in Melbourne, Florida, and educated at the University of California at Los Angeles. In 1966, he formed a group called the Doors with Ray Manzarek, John Densmore, and Robbie Krieger. The group became known for its extravagant performing style, combining sensual movements and a hard-hitting sound, amplified to huge proportions.
Beowulf An Epic Hero Of Epic Proportions
Essay, Research Paper Beowulf: An Epic Hero of Epic Proportions Beowulf is “the strongest of the Geats — greater / and stronger than anyone anywhere in this world” (ll.110-111). Even though he is famous for his massive strength,
The Golden Ratio Essay Research Paper The
The Golden Ratio Essay, Research Paper The Golden Ratio and Our World Leonardo of Pisa, better known as Fibonacci, was born in Pisa, Italy, about 1175 AD. He was known as the greatest mathematician of the middle ages. Completed in 1202, Fibonacci wrote a book titled Liber abaci on how to do arithmetic in the decimal system.
Just Learning Art Essay Research Paper Right
Just Learning Art Essay, Research Paper Right now in life Drawing I am working on the structure of the human anatomy. Our teacher wants us to feel the structure through gestures and get the proportions correct. We have just finished working on the Human skull, have worked with the whole figure, and now we are moving on towards the hands and feet.
Poison Essay Research Paper PoisonA Game Instructions
Poison Essay, Research Paper Poison A Game Instructions: Start off with ten counters. Each team will take a turn, taking one or two counters each time. The team that must take the final counter, also known as the poison counter, loses.
Euclid Father Of Geometry Essay Research Paper
Euclid The Father of Geometry Very little is known of the father of geometry, also known as Euclid. Records show that he lived somewhere around 300 B.C., but that date is sketchy. He was a Greek mathematician and is probably best known for his work Elements. Since little is known about the personal life of Euclid, it is difficult to do a biography on him.
Infinity Essay Research Paper The mathematical notion
Infinity Essay, Research Paper The mathematical notion of infinity can be conceptualized in many different ways. First, as counting by hundreds for the rest of our lives, an endless quantity. It can also be thought of as digging a whole in hell for eternity, negative infinity. The concept I will explore, however, is infinitely smaller quantities, through radioactive decay
Infinity Essay Research Paper It
Infinity Essay, Research Paper It’s a tough question, because the word “infinity” can mean different things in different contexts. In mathematics, whether or not a certain concept exists can depend on the context in which you ask the question. If you want
Infinity Essay Research Paper The concept of
Infinity Essay, Research Paper The concept of infinity has been evaluated many times throughout history. Only recently, in the nineteenth century, has major progress evolved in the field. The chapter “Beyond Infinity” answers the questions, “what is mathematics and why should I study it?” by reviewing several mathematician’s theories of infinity.
Dna Four Bases Essay Research Paper In
Dna Four Bases Essay, Research Paper In the early 1950’s, the structure of DNA had become a crucial puzzle, following the discovery that DNA and not protein was the “transforming” principle. The puzzle was more intriguing because of the challenge of figuring out how a polymer composed of only 4 different “letters” could encode for a polymer such as proteins that are composed of 20 different letters.
Pascals Triangle Essay Research Paper The arithmetic
Pascals Triangle Essay, Research Paper The arithmetic triangle was developed in 1653 by Blaise Pascal. He named this triangle after himself and today it is known as Pascal’s Triangle. It is an arrangement of certain whole numbers in a triangular pattern.
Untitled Essay Research Paper Blaise Pascal was
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Blaise Pascal was born at Clermont on June 19, 1623, and died in Paris on Aug. 19, 1662. His father, a local judge at Clermont, and himself of some scientific reputation, moved to Paris in 1631, for two main reasons, to prosecute his own scientific studies, and to carry on the education of his only son, who had already displayed exceptional ability.
Table Patterns Essay Research Paper Table Patterns
Table Patterns Essay, Research Paper Table Patterns Q1. For the first part of this investigation into table patterns I am going to see what happens when you add the two numbers in opposite corners of