, Research Paper
The Truth About Physics and Religion
Many people believe that physics and religion are separate entities.
They claim that physics deals only with the objective, material world, while
religion deals only with the world of values. It is obvious, from these, and
from many other comparisons, that conflicts have arisen between physics and
religion. Many are convinced that the two fields completely oppose each other,
and are not related in any ways. Many people, who follow a particular religion,
feel offended by the claims that physicists have made, while physicists believe
that religion has no basis in reality. I will show, however, that these
conflicts are founded on a misunderstanding, and that there is no division
between physics and religion. I will also prove that the misunderstanding lies
in the parables of religion and in the statements made by physicists.
Furthermore, I will show that only physicists can really know the truth of
physics, and only religious followers can know the truth of that religion;
everyone else has to take it on faith.
Many people believe that physics and religion are entirely separate.
They claim that physics is only concerned with discovering what is true or false,
while religion is concerned with what is good or evil. Scientists appear to
agree that ?physics is the manner in which we argue about the objective side of
reality.? Religious followers, on the other hand, agree that ?religion is the
way we express the subjective decisions that help us choose the standards by
which we live.? Although these definitions seem to be contrasting, an important
element remains absent, an element that must first be considered before religion
and physics can be compared.
Those who think that religion has no basis in reality also believe that
there is an ?obvious? separation between the two fields. They think that
religion is a jumble of false assertions, with no basis in reality. Paul Dirac,
a physicist, once said:
The very idea of God is a product of the human
imagination. It is quite understandable why primitive
people, who were so much more exposed to the
overpowering forces of nature than we are today,
should have personified these forces in fear and
trembling. But nowadays, when we understand so
many natural processes, we have no need for such
solutions.
Dirac, and those who think the same way, however, fails to consider the
essential element that has caused many to misunderstand the relationship between
physics and religion. What they fail to realize is that religion uses language
in quite a different way from science. The language of religion is more closely
related to the language of poetry than to the language of science. The fact
that religions have, throughout the ages, spoken in parables and images, simply
means that there is no other way of understanding the reality to which they
refer. But I strongly believe, however, that religion is a genuine reality.
Neils Bohr once said:
The relationship between critical thought about the
spiritual content of a given religion and action based
on the deliberate acceptance of that content is
complementary. And such acceptance fills the
individual with strength of purpose, helps him to
overcome doubts and, if he has to suffer, provides him
with the kind of solace that only a sense of being
sheltered under an all-embracing roof can grant.
In this sense, religion helps to make social life more harmonious; its most
important task is to remind us, in the language of parables and images, of the
wider picture that we live our lives.
Dirac, like many others who share his thoughts, thinks that religion is
entirely based on faith. But, because of his ignorance to the meaning of the
word ?faith?, he has developed many incorrect beliefs and assumptions. Faith is
defined as ?the belief in something, with strong conviction and confidence.?
What many fail to realize, however, is that faith is just as essential an
element of physics as it is of religion. The reason why many fail to realize
this, is because of the common misconception that physics is a self-regulating
machine which automatically produces information when the crank of scientific
method is turned. Very little faith would be required, of course, for the
operation of such a machine. But physics, as many of us have experienced
through experiments, is not at all like that. The experimenter usually finds
nothing resembling the smooth, ordered, lawful behavior depicted by the
textbooks. What he finds instead are error-filled and highly questionable
results. William Pollard, a physicist, once wrote:
Scientific research is a tough and unrelenting business.
Only those who enjoy a firm and unshakable faith that
the universal principles will always hold true can
become successful. Without such an abiding faith, it is
simply not possible to become a part of the physics
community.
Consider. for example, this common claim: ?anyone can demonstrate the truths of
physics for himself, but the tenets of religion have to be accepted blindly on
faith.? How many people, for example, can demonstrate to their own satisfaction
that the mass of the earth is 5.98 x 1024 kilograms, or that the charge on a
proton is + 1.60 x 10-19 coulombs. A long, hard educational process is required
during which a person must freely submit himself to a rigorous discipline, and
strongly desire and believe in its outcome. Consequently, the truth follows
that only by becoming a physicist can he possess the capacity to demonstrate the
truths of physics to his own satisfaction. Likewise, only those who become
serious followers of a religion can know the truths of that religion. In both
cases, everyone else must take it all on faith.
Another way in which science and religion are frequently contrasted is
in terms of the personal and impersonal. This contrast is based on the belief
that science is a dispassionate, completely detached activity in which the
process of knowing is independent of the involvement or participation of the
knower. In contrast to this, religious knowledge is thought to be deeply
personal, since it comes only through the passionate involvement and commitment
of the believer in that which he knows. Many believe that religion affects both,
our actions and our emotions, as opposed to physics, which does not. The fact
is, none of these statements can be validated unless the person saying it has
endured and committed himself to both physics and religion. A sincere and hard-
working physicist will feel the personal affects of physics on him, whereas
others will not. Similarly, a dedicated and determined follower of a religion
will feel the personal affects of that religion on him. Others, again, will not.
A number of the contrasts which are frequently made between physics and
religion are seen to be either wrong or irrelevant through careful analysis.
Einstein, himself, believed that God was somehow involved in the immutable laws
of nature, and that there is no split between physics and religion. What is and
always has been our mainspring is faith. To have faith always means: ?I decide
to do it, I stake my existence on it.? When Columbus started on his first
voyage into the West, he believed that the earth was round and small enough to
be circumnavigated. He did not merely think this was right in theory?he staked
his whole existence on it. There’s an old saying: “I believe in order that I
may act; I act in order that I may understand.” This saying is relevant not
only to the concepts of physics and religion, but also to the entire life we
live.
Другие работы по теме:
Histories Maladies Essay Research Paper It seems
Histories Maladies Essay, Research Paper It seems these days that our world’s history is becoming more and more misconstrued and misused. Everywhere you look or read about history, someone has made a massive blunder. Facts become fiction and fiction fact. And it’s always done so to someone or some group’s benefit.
Enrico Fermi Essay Research Paper Enrico FermiBy
Enrico Fermi Essay, Research Paper Enrico Fermi By: Fernando-3-C ?Enrico Fermi was an Italian-American physicist and Nobel laureate, known for achieving the first controlled nuclear reaction (Encarta 98).?
Fear And Religion In Lucretius Essay Research
Paper Religion is one of Lucretius favorite topics to argue against in his poem On the Nature of Things. What religion does to man and the fear of the life after death that is instilled on the living is unjust per Lucretius. For while the nature of the gods must necessarily of itself enjoy immortality, the life of men lay foully groveling, crushed beneath the wait of a Religion.
Truth Essay Research Paper What evidence of
Truth Essay, Research Paper What evidence of truth do you need to except a clam, be it moral, religious, philosophical, ect. Do you distinguish between these, if so why and how?
Religion Essay Research Paper ReligionReligion is a
Religion Essay, Research Paper Religion Religion is a set of practices and beliefs that allow human beings to search for the meaning of life and the purpose of their existence. These common practices set the foundation for such beliefs to have validity. Every individual must wonder why he/she exists on earth.
Religion 2 Essay Research Paper What is
Religion 2 Essay, Research Paper What is Religion? From the moment you take your first breath, you are besieged with strange sensory data pouring into your newborn self. You immediately begin to discriminate this data to find meaning in what would otherwise be a meaningless world. Sadly, we are not born enlightened, but born into what appears to be complete confusion.
Reason For Existence Essay Research Paper Existentialism
Reason For Existence Essay, Research Paper Existentialism was born against Age of Reason in order to reject abstract thinking and absoluteness of reason. Existentialists have claims and evidences to support their idea. They are trying to find absolute truth without absolute thinking because of this they will look for the truth all the eternity.
Truth Or Lie Essay Research Paper January
Truth Or Lie? Essay, Research Paper January 31, 2000 Truth or Lie ….??? The truth should be told most of the time. I do not think however that lying should be put out of our mind because sometimes lying is the only option we have. Lying can be a good thing and a bad thing. Depending on the situation we should analyze it and find out if telling the truth would inflict more harm or lying would.
Aristotle 2 Essay Research Paper Aristotle s
Aristotle 2 Essay, Research Paper Aristotle s Life Aristotle (384-322 BC) was a Greek philosopher, educator, and scientist, and was also one of the most influential thinkers in Western culture (World Book 663). Through his writings, Aristotle considered, summarized, criticized, and helped to further develop many of these traditions from which he had learned from Plato, his teacher.
Buddism Essay Research Paper Buddism is of
Buddism Essay, Research Paper Buddism is of the world`s fasting spreading religion. At this time there 313 million buddist in Asia. And aproximatly 500 thousand in North America. Buddism is the is not just a religion, but a way of life. It is a religion that helps the people that beleive in it to, search the deepest recuses
Hot Lez Sex Essay Research Paper What
Hot Lez Sex Essay, Research Paper What is Truth and the best way to obtain it according to Ancient Scientists? In general, truth is anything that is correct of nature. The truth is in existence yet is not understood/known until it is uncovered. (Bruce Foltz WHGC lecture “What is truth?”)
Thesis Is There A God Or Is
He(?) An Illusion? Essay, Research Paper Thesis: Is There a God or is He(?) an Illusion? An illusion is one’s own interpretation and perception of someone or something.
Momentum Lab Conclusion Essay Research Paper Momentum
Momentum Lab Conclusion Essay, Research Paper Momentum has an integral part in the field of physics. However, many people do not know the importance of momentum in everyday life or even recognize it. The truth is that we use momentum in just about every activity that involves motion. When we drive a car we use the principles of momentum to realize how much cushion space we need or how much stopping distance is needed when going a certain speed.
Marie Curie Essay Research Paper Marie Curie
Marie Curie Essay, Research Paper Marie Curie is the most famous woman of physics. She has been recognized for her work with Nobel Prize awards in both physics (1903) and chemistry (1911). She got a late start with her education obtaining her license in physics in 1893 and the corresponding degree in mathematics in 1894.
Ralph Waldo Emerson
“Self-Reliance” Essay, Research Paper The piece we were assigned to was a part of an essay Emerson did on self-reliance? He starts out by explaining that whether or not we act as individuals all depends on asking ourselves how much self-trust we have, or how much confidence we have in ourselves. When you really think about it, individuality is honestly not something we desire to subject ourselves to, because being an individual can lead to other people not accepting you, hating you, or accusing you of being self-righteous, disrespectful, a rebel, a freak, and so on.
Physics Lab Essay Research Paper III ResultsAnalysisMy
Physics Lab Essay, Research Paper III. Results/Analysis: My lab partner and I worked diligently in this experiment to be as accurate and as precise in our measurements and calculations with the technology provided. In part one of the experiment, we calculated the amount of force on the planet at the closest distance to be approximately 18 F.
Zoroastrianism Essay Research Paper The Arab world
Zoroastrianism Essay, Research Paper The Arab world is now dominated by one strong and fierce religion. But, during the dynasties of such nobles as the Achaemenids, a truly noble and proud religion appeared;
Physics On The Internet Essay Research Paper
Physics on the Internet (1) Internet web sites: *ecw.virtualave/avis/ This site has some spectacular aerial wrestling movies. This part of the site is dedicated to death defying wrestling moves. Most of these moves are from the top rope, cage, or cell.
Perception Essay Research Paper All perception of
Perception Essay, Research Paper All perception of truth is the detection of an analogy; we reason from our hands to our heads. This statement can be interpreted in many ways but I m going to try to analyze this from the Judaic point of view. According to the Biblical text also known as Torah everything that a person perceives has meaning and can be referred back to the Torah.
John Bardeen Essay Research Paper Bardeen John
John Bardeen Essay, Research Paper Bardeen, John 1908-91, American physicist; b. Madison, Wis. He was known for his studies of semiconductivity and other aspects of SOLID-STATE PHYSICS. The first
Religion Vs Astronomy Essay Research Paper Religion
Religion Vs Astronomy Essay, Research Paper Religion and science have always been in direct competition with one another. The ultimate goal of science is to prove the inexistence of God with facts, while the existence in God is simply based on belief and faith. While 95% of the people living on Earth believe in a superior being of some sort, some might say that religion clouds the minds of otherwise logical individuals and makes it impossible for them to pursue the truth of the Universe.
Are Science And Religion Compatible Essay Research
Paper The relationship between Science and Religion can be explained from two distinct points of view. Some would argue that scientific explanations are the only means of explaining our existence, while others would argue that religion and the story of creation found in Genesis I and II provide a sufficient account of the worlds conception.
Science Vs Religion Essay Research Paper SCIENCE
Science Vs. Religion Essay, Research Paper SCIENCE VS. RELIGION One of the most important dichotomies that make us stop to think is religion and science. A dichotomy that started in the renaissance, a period when people started questioning, looking to other horizons, other than religion. Before this period the church held back all previous writings that compromised the power of the church.
Religion Vs Science Essay Research Paper
“Science vs Religion” The question as to whether or not religion belongs in a science classroom is a very complex and difficult question. Religion can be looked at from different angles,
Religion Or Run Essay Research Paper Religion
Religion Or Run? Essay, Research Paper Religion or Run? Religion has been around for thousands of years. Throughout history, religion has made an impact on the decisions people make everyday. People have even gone as far as sacrificing their lives for their religion. There have been countries formed over religion, so too have there been wars started.
Truth And Belief Essay Research Paper Truth
Truth And Belief Essay, Research Paper Truth and Belief James is a believer in the pragmatic theory of truth. He draws a relationship between the good and the true. The true is not an separate entity from good, but is one of the species of good.
Religion Or Cult Essay Research Paper When
Religion Or Cult? Essay, Research Paper When Does a Religion Become a Cult? When Does a Cult Become a Religion? I think that religion and cults are closely related. However, there can be many noticeable differences. In order for a religion to become a cult, it needs to develop into a negative form of expression.
Religion And Science Essay Research Paper Religion
Religion And Science Essay, Research Paper Religion and Science Is Science and Religion really such an adversary? I believe that it is a very touchy subject, in which it can go either way. Some people may claim that science and religion are two very similar subjects, while other may view it as two very different subjects of life.
Atomic Physics Essay Research Paper subject
Atomic Physics Essay, Research Paper subject = physics title = Atomic Physics papers = Please put your paper here. ATOMIC PHYSICS Atomic Physics- is the study of atomic matter.
The Physics Ofkites Essay Research Paper The
The Physics Ofkites Essay, Research Paper The Physics of Kites Kites are such interesting items. They are toys for many and learning tools for others. To really understand them, one must take into account some laws of Physics. Physics supplies the answer for exactly how a kite can fly and manuever in the air.