, Research Paper
Cause and Effect:
How did Hitler Come into Power?
A dichotomy is a division of two entities into mutually exclusive or contradictory groups. In Viva Zapata, it was mentioned that it?s not the laws that govern men, but men that govern men. There is no dichotomy present here because the two aren?t mutually exclusive at all. A country is only as strong as those who lead it, and the laws that govern it. Without strong and enforced laws, man wouldn?t have power. And without man, the laws wouldn?t have power. But, the people govern the land, and they are by far more powerful than the laws. They can create and destroy laws. They are the ones who enforce the laws. People don?t live their lives by the word of the law, but by the will of the people who make and enforce it.
When the Weimar constitution was enacted, there were several flaws. These flaws eventually led to the rise of Hitler, and the downfall of Germany. After World War II, the constitutions of West Germany, and France were more successful. They had very strong points and allowed for stable governments
The Weimar constitution was written under the guidance of Max Weber. He was a socialist, and tried to give the constitution all of the best aspects of the American constitution(*1). In the Weimar constitution, the president wasn?t named as the head of the government(*2). This task was given to the chancellor, who was a party member. Because the German government was in its infancy, and often deadlocked, parliament didn?t meet that often (*3).
Weber had planned for this, and under Article 48, the president had emergency powers when parliament was not in session. These powers also wound up coming into effect whenever parliament was deadlocked. Some of these powers included in Article 48 were temporary dictatorial powers, defense minister or the chief of the army. The president had the right to interfere with the legislation of parliament, and dismiss the chancellor (*4).
There were a few reasons as to why parliament was never in session. Weber had wanted proportional party representation, and every party had a place, no matter how small they were. Together, there were 28 parties in the German parliament(*5). This prevented clear majorities and the two-party system never formed(*6). And since the Germans wanted to model their constitution after the best qualities in the American constitution, this element should have been present in theirs.
Also many Germans weren?t used to the idea of peacefully resolving conflicts. They relied on the old ways, which involved the president making the decisions. To them, parliament was just ?the game of the parties.? They believed all of the power was in the president and Article 48(*7).
Realizing the benefits of not keeping parliament in session, the presidents would use their power to settle disputes rather than parliament. Article 48 allowed the president to manipulate the system and achieve power. Friedrich Ebert was the first president under the Weimar constitution. He preferred to use his power rather than force parliament to settle their differences(*8). When Hindenburg came along, he used presidential prerogative to appoint and dismiss chancellors. In his last years, there was an almost virtual suspension to parliamentary government(*9). This led to Hitler, who used the process to become a dictator.
But, it wasn?t solely the miswriting of the constitution that caused Hitler to come to power. It had a lot to do with a division of East and West Germany. The Easterners had created war-anxiety (*10), but the Westerners accepted peace (*11). The East, filled with a caste system, hated the West for being so liberal. Uniting these two opposites under such tension was bound to cause disaster.
The ruling class in the East hated the West for being liberal and lacking spirituality (*12). Civilization pulled Germany towards the West, but culture to the East. As Germany pulled to he West, it failed, but it prospered as it went to the East (*13). The Easterners had always ruled Germany, and they were responsible for the war anxiety. But they blamed the Westerners for accepting peace. So, in the eyes of the Easterners, the Westerners became responsible for all the post WW I misfortunes (*15).
Also, the people never believed that Hitler would gain such popularity. Both the Left and the Right completely underestimated Hitler (*16). They believed that his only strength was as a great orator. They wanted to exploit this as much possible in order to increase their own party?s strength (*17).
But Hitler had other plans. As stated in Mein Kampf, he believed that he would become a popular politician (*18). In the fourth chapter, he stated that it was time to take over the East (*19).
But Hitler?s popularity grew. As the left began to surge, the Nazi Party began getting more votes. At first, his support from the student academic population grew, but it was followed by an overall increase (*20). By 1929, it was obvious that the party system was failing (*21). Heinrich Bruning tried to rule by presidential decree based on Article 48, and when parliament disagreed, he disbanded them. As a result, the Nazis and Communists became the 2 largest parties in parliament (*22).
We should examine the events right before Hitler came to power. He used his oratorical gifts to get Bruning out of power. He used sly and cunning techniques to take over the Prussian government. Hitler?s approval rating doubled and he received 37.2% of the vote (*23). Eventually he became a chancellor, and the two other Nazis in parliament also held important positions. They now had the ability to use Article 48 (*24).
On that date, Germany couldn?t turn back. Within a week, Hitler issued a decree that allowed the government to ban public meetings and newspapers. This was to break up any non-Nazi organization (*25). He then enacted the ?Emergency Decree,? which gave the Nazis permission to ban freedom. This gave Hitler everything he needed to make a totalitarian state (*26). But these lasted only until 1945. Hitler then brought in the Enabling Act, which gave the administration the right to legislate and change laws. It also transferred the power from the president to the chancellor (*27).
Now we see how Hitler was able to come into power using the Weimar Constitution. Article 48 was a big flaw, which guided him right into power. But, the major flaw wasn?t Article 48, but the basis for the entire constitution. It was made while Germany was suffering from internal problems, and those weren?t taken into consideration. It also didn?t account for very minute details, which is why 28 parties were in parliament. While on the outside it appeared to be a very well written document, it never stood up to the test.
The post WWII constitutions of West Germany, and France were more successful than the Weimar Constitution. Constitution making is a thankless task. But, constitutions matter and are necessary. Weimar failed because it had a clumsy constitution (*28).
The constitution of West Germany was a masterpiece in comparison to the Weimar (*29). It was called the Federal Republic, and it succeeded because it had a balanced formation (*30). It had a proportional representation system, which meant no party could form a homogeneous government. Most importantly, big decisions couldn?t be pushed through, especially unpopular measures made by powerful inter-party lobbies (*31).
Konrad Adenauer wrote the Federal Republic, and he believed in the free market economy. It also encouraged trade unions, which Hitler had destroyed (*32). Basically, Adenauer had tied West Germans economically, politically and militarily to culture (*33). He had a fondness for France and realized that Germany?s future lay in France?s hands (*34).
In 1958, de Gaulle wrote the new constitution for France. It contained direct universal election of the president (*35). This president had strong powers, but he also had a symbolic role (*36). It was determined to be the clearest, consistent, and most skillfully balanced constitution France had ever seen. It focused on only two parties; thus voters wouldn?t make some unambiguous choice. The executive could pursue parties consistently, and the head of state was given a direct mandate by bypassing the parties (*37).
The French constitution was so well written that 23 years went by before there was a change in government philosophy (*38). Even after a socialist was elected President, the constitution continued to work smoothly. This showed just how well it was written, and it showed that it would be around for a while (*39).
Basically, without a strong constitution and government, countries collapse. The weak constitution and unbalanced government of Germany allowed Hitler to seize control. He knew how to manipulate people and how to motivate them into giving him what he wanted. Once everyone had learned form their mistakes, strong and stable governments formed.
People make constitutions. They are changed and manipulated and interpreted by people. This proves that man governs man, not laws. A man wrote the Weimar Constitution. A man wrote the Federal Republic. The laws of a nation are determined and written by a man, and a constitution is just a piece of paper to out them on.
List of Works Cited
1. Paul Johnson, Modern Times, (revised edition, 1991), p.110
2. Paul Johnson, ibidem, p.110
3. Paul Johnson, ibidem, p.110
4.Germany?s First Democratic Constitution colby.edu/personal/rmscheck/GermanyD2.html.
5. Professor Sviedrys
6. Paul Johnson, ibidem, p.110
7. Paul Johnson, ibidem, p.110
8. Paul Johnson, ibidem, p.110
9. Paul Johnson, ibidem, p.110
10. Paul Johnson, ibidem, p.110
11. Paul Johnson, ibidem, p.110
12. Paul Johnson, ibidem, p.110
13.Paul Johnson, ibidem, p.110
14. Paul Johnson, ibidem, p.110
15. Paul Johnson, ibidem, p.110
16. Paul Johnson, ibidem, p.282
17. Paul Johnson, ibidem, p.282
18. Paul Johnson, ibidem. p.136
19. Paul Johnson, ibidem, p.136
20. Paul Johnson, ibidem, p.281
21. Paul Johnson, ibidem, p.281
22. Paul Johnson, ibidem, p.283
23. Paul Johnson, ibidem, p.283
24. Paul Johnson, ibidem, p.283
25. Paul Johnson, ibidem, p283
26. Paul Johnson, ibidem, p.283
27. Paul Johnson, ibidem, p.283
28. Paul Johnson, ibidem, p.590
29. Paul Johnson, ibidem, p.583
30. Paul Johnson, ibidem, p.586
31. Paul Johnson, ibidem, p.586
32. Paul Johnson, ibidem, p.586
33. Paul Johnson, ibidem, p.586
34. Paul Johnson, ibidem. p.586
35. Paul Johnson, ibidem, p.595
36. Paul Johnson, ibidem, p.595
37. Paul Johnson, ibidem, p.595
38. Paul Johnson, ibidem, p.595
39. Paul Johnson, ibidem, p.595
Другие работы по теме:
Nazi S Essay Research Paper Nazi sThere
Nazi S Essay, Research Paper Nazi s There were many circumstances in Germany that led to the one party state. In 1918 military positions collapsed and the abdication of the Tsar was a reality. Who became the
Adolf Hitler Essay Research Paper Hitler was
Adolf Hitler Essay, Research Paper Hitler was one of the most, if not the most cruel man to ever walk the face of the earth. His belief of the superiorority of the “Aryan” race made him hate all others. He believed that the slaws to the east should be made work for the German people. He thought of blacks as being “Sub-human”.
An Insightful Look Into The Propaganda Video
Essay, Research Paper The audience is filled with many boys that are interested in seeing Adolf Hitler. They wield drums and other musical instruments to celebrate his arrival. There is a mass amount of excitement shown as the leader Hitler comes out to greet the people. He gives the boys a speech and then leaves waving at the people.
Holocaust Essay Research Paper Hitler and the
Holocaust Essay, Research Paper Hitler and the Nazi Party gained power in Germany in 1933 and lost power in 1945 — only 12 years. And yet, by the end of the Hitler regime, the world had been plunged into a global world war, Europe was in shambles and nearly 30 million died. Among the dead were over SIX MILLION Jews — men, women and children –who were systematically and efficiently slaughtered for no other reason than that they were Jews.
Response To The Nuremberg Laws And
Nazi Racial Ideology Essay, Research Paper Reponse to : The Nuremberg Laws and Nazi Racial Ideology The Nuremberg Race Laws of 1935 deprived German Jews of their rights of citizenship, giving them the status of “subjects” in Hitler’s Reich. The laws also made it forbidden for Jews to marry or have any relations with Aryans or to employ young Aryan women as household help.
Joseph Stalin And Adolph Hitler Essay Research
Paper 3-2-98 Joseph Stalin and Adolph Hitler Once lived the two most horrible people on earth. Both of those people were leaders of a country and both of them killed millions and millions of people just to rise to power. Their names are Adolph Hitler and Joseph Stalin.
Adolph Hitler Essay Research Paper ADOLPH HITLERHitler
Adolph Hitler Essay, Research Paper ADOLPH HITLER Hitler was born on April 20, 1889, at 6:30 P.M in the small Austrian village of Braunau, just across the border from German Bavaria. A World War I hero Hitler eventually became the leader of the Nazi party. He was responsible for the biggest mass murder the world has known.
Hitler Essay Research Paper Hitler ResponseI think
Hitler Essay, Research Paper Hitler Response I think that the American propaganda differs from the German propaganda because it allows people to be more open-minded and choose a side more freely. German Propaganda doesn t allow people to make a free choice. It is a forced choice the put upon the people.
Adolf Hittler Essay Research Paper Hitler
Adolf Hittler Essay, Research Paper Hitler’s Early Years: Adolph Hitler was born in Braunauam Inn, Austria on April 20,1889. He was the son of a minor customs official and a peasant girl. Hitler was never an educated man, he didn’t even finished high school and because of his lack of talent, Hitler was rejected from the Academy of Fine Arts, which he applied to in Vienna.
An Extended Abstract Defintion Of
‘Power’ Essay, Research Paper Power is many things. It is the ability to control people in their sayings and/or actions. It is the ability to get whatever you want. Power is a necessary component in any society,
Nazis In German Society Essay Research Paper
The Nazi s perceived the Jewish community and other non-Aryan groups deviant and outsiders of the German society. If you were a true German, Adolph Hitler believed you should hate these people with a vengeance. The Jewish community made up a great percentage of Germany at the time Hitler and his totalitarianism began to make face.
Machiavelli Vs Arendt Essay Research Paper Tales
Machiavelli Vs. Arendt Essay, Research Paper Tales There are some similarities between Machiavelli’s, “Qualities of the Prince,” and Arendt’s, “Ideology and Terror.” Hannah Arendt’s piece deals with governmental leadership using totalitarianism as its backbone. Machiavelli’s piece deals with how a prince should properly keep his power over the country in which he rules.
Did Appeasement Make War More Or Less
Likely Than: Essay, Research Paper In my opinion, the war was going to happen anyway, and appeasement did not make it any more likely than either the weakness of the League of Nations or Hitler’s desire to be a world dominator. Appeasement did mean, however, that the war took place on a much larger scale than it would have if something had been done earlier.
During The Time Leading Up To World
War Ii Essay, Research Paper During the time leading up to World War II, there were two leaders who were on rival sides, the men were Adolph Hitler and Joseph Stalin. These men were each dominate in their rise to power. These two leaders were similar in the ways that they achieved their objectives. Their success was mostly identified by their new ideas and strong political stances.
Path To Power Essay Research Paper Filling
Path To Power Essay, Research Paper Filling three high-level voids caused Adolph Hitler to rise to power as the totalitarian dictator of Germany. With his country in the ferment left from World War One, groups
Joseph Stalin The Most Infamous Leader Essay
, Research Paper In 1879 on Dec 21 Joseph Stalin was born he ended up dying in 1953 on March 5th. That was only the begging. He grew up and had become one of the undisputed leaders of the USSR from 1929 till his death.
The Life Of Hitler Essay Research Paper
Early Life Adolf Hitler was born April 20 1889, in the Austrian town of Braunau am Inn. The son of Alois, a customs offical, and Klara Hitler. Adolf’s father died in 1903 which
Hitler Essay Research Paper The book Mein
Hitler Essay, Research Paper The book Mein Kampf (My Struggle) was written by Adolf Hitler before World War II (1933). Hitler was an evil genius, which wrote of how he felt about racial elements and how he felt they were differently situated. Hitler also wrote of the importance of propaganda, and the correct use of the lies propaganda creates.
Hitler As A Youth Essay Research Paper
Hitler s Childhood Adolf Hitler was born on April 20, 1889, in a small Austrian village called Braunau-am-Inn. Adlof was born a sickly child, his mother, Klara, watched over him night and day. Klara Hitler protected young Adolf from her short-tempered husband, Alois. Adolf grew into a thin, dark-haired, blue-eyed boy with an angular face (Twisted 63).
Hitler Youth Movement Essay Research Paper I
Hitler Youth Movement Essay, Research Paper I thought the most interesting aspect of the Hitler Youth movement was the beginning of it all, when the numbers were small to when the organization held a lot of power. The years 1933-1938 were the most influential of the youth movement. These years determined what the organization would become and how much power they would hold.
Adolf Hitler A Psychological Look At What
He Did Essay, Research Paper Adolf Hitler A psychological look at what he did Adolf Hitler is known for his single-handed massacre of 6 million Jews. He is also known for being a lunatic and, for lack of a better term, completely out of his mind. I, however, believe there is a different reason. That is what I will present to you in this paper, a possibility of a different reason of why Hitler did what he did.
Hitlers Completion Of Pwer In 1933 Essay
, Research Paper Hitler became Chancellor of Germany in January 1933 but Hitler did not have the absolute power he desired as the Nazi Party were in a coalition government with the German Nationalists. The Nationalists had nine out of the twelve ministers in power whereas the Nazis only had three. The two Nazi ministers were Herman Goering, Minister of the Interior of Prussia, and William Frisk, Minister of the Reich and Hitler was Chancellor.
Hitler Essay Research Paper Mein Kampf
Hitler Essay, Research Paper Mein Kampf! Adolf Hitler would say. Adolf Hitler should be the Person Of the Century. Hitler has changed the world. He caused technology to evolve. Adolf was the
Hitler Essay Research Paper ADOLF HITLER
Hitler Essay, Research Paper ADOLF HITLER’S RELIGIOUS BELIEFS AND FANATICISM People often claim that Adolf Hitler believed in Atheism, Humanism, or that his religion involved ancient Nordic pagan mythology . None of this is true though. Although one of Hitler’s henchmen, Alfred Rosenberg , did undertake a campaign of Nordic mythological propaganda, Hitler and most of his men did not believe in it .Many American books, television documentaries, and Sunday sermons that preach of Hitler’s “evil” have eliminated Hitler’s god for their Christian audiences.
Factors In The Rise Of Hitler Essay
, Research Paper The rise of Adolph Hitler contained many key factors that allowed him to become the powerful dictator of Germany that we remember him as today. These factors range from the mindsets of the people around him to the economical factors of the day. Without each of these important conditions, Hitler’s rise to power might have been a much slower, or for that matter, inexistent, process.
The Rise To Power Of Hitler And
Mussolin Essay, Research Paper Even though the governments of Adolph Hitler and Benito Mussolini were both Fascist governments, there were still some aspects that were not quite the same in them. Some of these include their use of violence or the extent of their racism and nationalism. There were still some similar aspects in both of them however, such as they both came to power during times of economic unrest (The Great Depression).
How Did The Nazi Party Get So
Big? Essay, Research Paper Hitler’s Nazi party came to power almost entirely because of accidents. In 1929 the American Stock Market crashed, a powerful symbol of the growing
Fascisms In Germany And Italy Essay Research
Paper Oliver Bleich Mrs. Howell Modern European History 5/22/00 Fascism in Germany and Italy Germany and Italy rose up under new leaders with a new type of governing policy. However, the same policies that caused growth lead to eventual collapse of these nations. Fascism grew because of extreme nationalism, fear, and governmental control.
Hitlers Germany Essay Research Paper One reason
Hitlers Germany Essay, Research Paper One reason the people of Germany accepted Hitler’s orders willingly and without question was beause it was what they wanted to hear. At the time the depression
Hitlers Consolidation Of Power Essay Research Paper
When Hitler came to become chancellor in January 1933 his powers were relatively weak. Hitler had been appointed chancellor by the president, Hindenberg. Hindenberg had the power to appoint any chancellor he wishes, and can get rid of Hitler at any time. This means that Hindenberg controlled all of Hitlerґs power.
To What Extent Was Hitler
’s Success In Coming To Power Due To The Depression? Essay, Research Paper Hitler became chancellor in January 1933. By March he had full dictatorial power. There is no doubt that the impact of the depression on the German people gave way to the rise of Hitler. It was the single most important factor of Hitler’s coming to power, however it wasn?t the only factor.
Hitler Essay Research Paper Hitler came to
Hitler Essay, Research Paper Hitler came to power the legitimate way, through participating in elections. True he broke or bent a few rules and cheated and lied but probably no more than any other politician. It is common belief that had Hitler come along at another less desperate time for Germany, history would have played itself out very differently.