Crisis Management Essay, Research Paper
Crisis Management
Rosa Beth Moss Canter identifies six issues that surface in any crisis. Any or all of these issues will impair the involved organization or persons ability to respond to the crisis at hand. They apply to situations ranging from individual interactions to corporate functions. For the purpose of example, I will identify them in the joint operation of various government agencies in the disastrous takedown of the Branch Davidian complex at Mt. Carmel, TX.
Internal Politics Interfere with Teamwork
The first place this issue arises is when the BATF decided to serve a warrant on David Koresh and his followers en masse and fully tactical, rather than incorporating Jack Harwell, the local sheriff. There had been a lengthy investigation prior to the warrant service, so they must have known that the local sheriff had some level of personal ties (trust) with the commune residents. Proper teamwork at the very onset of the standoff might have avoided the whole incident. Harwell knew these people. He worked and had contact with them regularly. There was already an established trust and familiarity that could ve been tapped for a peaceful resolution, yet was ignored.
Another breakdown of teamwork occurred within the ranks of the F.B.I. after they took over the operation. The wedge of distrust driven between the negotiations team and the HRTs is a somewhat natural development if these two groups are not used properly together. By its definition, the negotiations team is supposed to build trust with the suspects with the eventual goal of peaceful release of the hostages. Conversely, the HRT is designed to eliminate the suspect as quickly and efficiently as possible, thus freeing the hostages. If these two units are working simultaneously to the same goal, there will be a breakdown of teamwork because they will begin to view each other as the enemy. These teams should be used consecutively. The negotiators should have a go at it and if, after an adequate period of time they are unsuccessful, the HRT does their thing. The only way these units should be used in conjunction is for the negotiators to manipulate the suspects into the best positions for takedown. If this is the tac, then they should be fresh, not having spent excessive time bonding with the suspects.
Lack of Communication Across Functions
Often this issue appears as the result of a decaying structure of teamwork. The best evidence of this at Mt. Carmel is, again, within the F.B.I. Once the trust and teamwork between the HNs and the HRTs was splintered, their communications also crumbled. In fact, their lines of communications deteriorated so much that eventually David Koresh (and Steve) became their mediator. HRT was doing things that the HNs didn t even know about until Steve started raving about it. At the same time, the HNs are promising and granting demands of which the HRTs had no knowledge.
Excessive Rules and Bureaucratic Trappings
The multi-facetted machine of the U.S. government is enormous and intricate. From President Clinton to Janet Reno all the way down to the individual agents of the HRTs, there are hundreds of people through which information and orders must flow. We are all familiar with two concepts that make this pyramid structure prone to disaster. One is the grade school gossip game. With each additional mouth in the chain, the word changes minutely. The other is the concept that the more working parts an object has, the more likely it is to break down. Between six different agencies, each with similar goals yet somewhat varied SOPs and the individual opinions and emotions of each agent/soldier involved, it is no wonder that this operation did not go as according to plan.
Stressing Procedures Over Thinking
SOP for almost any tactical unit, military or law enforcement, is that the first goal on scene is to eliminate the threat. Following this procedure means neutralizing the guard dogs (pets) at Mt. Carmel as the initial approach is made. However, thinking would entail realizing that a) the dogs were pets to the Davidians, 2) killing them would certainly be construed as an act of (unwarranted) aggression, and furthermore, maybe there was another way to eliminate the canine threat without lethal force. There is testimony indicating that the first shots fired were to kill the dogs. In such a high-tension situation, gunshots, regardless of at whom or why they were fired, are sure to ignite the situation which it did.
The most obvious disregard for common sense in deference to procedure is the FBI’s treatment of Koresh and his people as if they were standard terrorists/hostages. The recognition of the Davidians as possible martyrs or just plain old nut cases should have changed the direction of attack for both the HNs and the HRTs. You can t negotiate and promise things to Jesus Christ, he already has everything except an audience. You also cannot flex your tactical might on Jesus Christ and expect Him to cower and surrender. He is bulletproof and his people are going to a better place should they die. The F.B.I. standing strictly by procedure (that didn t accurately fit the scenario), almost certainly guaranteed the violent destructive outcome they ended with. Of course, whether or not this was their intention is the conspiracy theory of the 90s.
Atmosphere of Insecurity and Fear
The internal structures of the U.S. government and military agencies lend themselves to the idea of Shit rolls down hill. Add to that the concept of always finding a scapegoat that is prevalent in U.S. politics and society and you have a natural atmosphere for creating insecurity and fear. From the team leader who follows procedure over thinking to cover his own ass from the rules and bureaucratic trappings all the way up to the President who pretends to have no knowledge of what was going down (he fears the people). Primary example of this is when the two big-cheeses, Janet Reno (AG) and Byron Sage (SSRA-FBI) start playing the blame game and responsibility tag as to who gave the go-code and on what (false?) information that decision was made. Once the two top shots start dodging bullets, the example is set. Leadership has spoken by action and testimonies begin to change, videotapes disappear, and conspiracy theories start to bloom.
This issue of insecurity and fear also has a physical aspect to those in the trenches (or tanks). The insecurity of charging in only to find your support (tactical or righteous) pulled from under you and the very real fear, which was extinguished for several agents, of death. This issue, in both aspects, leads to the final issue prevalent in crisis situations.
People Try to Hide Problems and Resist Change
Janet Reno says she was told by the F.B.I. that the children were being (sexually) abused. Byron Sage says he never gave her that information. The BATF claims that Koresh and his group were reclusive and dangerous suspects in a federal investigation for possession of illegal firearms. Nine days before the raid, two undercover agents visited the compound to engage in target practice with Koresh and two other men. They fired both AR-15s and assorted handguns to include the sharing of the agents personal weapons. This report was buried for years after the incident. Koresh informs the FBI that once he finishes writing his explanation of the Seven Seals, he would come out peacefully. The FBI already had an assault plan finalized. Whether Koresh was lying (probably) or not doesn t matter, what does is that when the FBI submits the op plan to Reno for approval, no mention is made of the offer to surrender. The wheels were in motion and to change course would cause possible embarrassment for the FBI.
There will be crisis as long as humans walk the earth. We create most of it and, ironically, our survival as individuals and as a species depends on how well we resolve our own snafus. We have an endless history of examples of poor leadership in dealing with crisis; however, there are a few we can look to as inspiration. The resolution of the Grenada hostage crisis by the USMC would (of course) be an example of proper planning, action and leadership. A good leader, and we are all potential leaders, will know the SOPs, have a well-conceived plan, and yet be flexible enough to react to unforeseen changes. It is not enough to prepare for and resolve the crisis; we must also prepare for these six issues that would prevent us from reaching our goals.
Другие работы по теме:
Cuban Missile Crisis Essay Research Paper Ever
Cuban Missile Crisis Essay, Research Paper Ever since the Soviet Union defeated the United States in the Cold War by launching ?Sputnik? into orbit first, they thought that they had the ?upper-hand?. Soviet intelligence therefore thought they had superior intercontinental missiles. They would soon find out that they were evenly matched by the United States.
Gilgamesh Vs Ecclesiastes Essay Research Paper Ecclesiastes
Gilgamesh Vs Ecclesiastes Essay, Research Paper Ecclesiastes vs. Gilgamesh In both of these stories, there is a spiritual crisis that awaits being noticed. I think that in both of these stories, there is an underlying theme that death has the final say in our lives, and that there is not really much that we can do about it.
Cuban Missile Crisi Essay Research Paper The
Cuban Missile Crisi Essay, Research Paper The Cuban Missile Crisis is one of the most tense and scariest periods in our nation’s and the world’s history. The world was literally on the brink of nuclear annihilation. Once again the different ideologies of the United States of America and the Soviet Union had led them to confrontation only this time it could have had much more serious consequences.
The Cuban Missile Crisis 2 Essay Research
Paper The Cuban Missile Crisis The Cuban Missile Crisis of October 1962 is the closest the world has ever come to nuclear war. The Soviets had installed nuclear missile silos in Cuba, just 90 miles off the coast of the United States. U.S. armed forces were put at their highest state of readiness. Soviet field commanders in Cuba were authorized to use nuclear weapons if invaded by the U.S.
Cuban Missle Crisis Essay Research Paper StartThe
Cuban Missle Crisis Essay, Research Paper Start The Cuban Missile Crisis of October 1962 was one of the turning points of the Cold War between the United States and the Soviet Union. At that time the two superpowers came close to war, possibly with nuclear weapons; after it, both countries began to seek ways to adjust to each other, in particular, to prevent the use of nuclear weapons.
Psychotherapy Vs Crisis Intervention Essay Research Paper
Psychotherapy, also known as crisis counseling, is an organized conceptual framework, which uses multiple psychological theories to assist an individual towards problem resolution. This type of therapy / counseling may be appropriate after crisis intervention since the goal of psychotherapy is problem resolution and the goal of crisis intervention is problem management.
What Leads To Intervention A Case
Study Of Intervention During The Bush Administration Essay, Research Paper What Leads to Intervention?: A Case Study of Intervention During the Bush Administration
The Aids Crisis Essay Research Paper The
The Aids Crisis Essay, Research Paper The AIDS Crisis AIDS is an epidemic that has been treated like every other plague in history. Because it is human nature to be afraid of what one cannot control, people are invariably afraid of disease and infection. Moreover, the fear is escalated many times over in that the disease starts controlling the person who it has infected.
Compare And Contrast The Different Speeches Of
Brutus And Anthony Essay, Research Paper Brutus and Anthony are completely different characters, and they speak differently. They both make speeches at Caesar’s funeral because each needs to influence the people to get them on their side. The whole country is in crisis after Caesar’s murder. The strange thing was that Anthony was at the funeral with the permission of Brutus, which was a mistake which Brutus made.
The Impeding Crisis Essay Research Paper An
The Impeding Crisis Essay, Research Paper An Impending Crisis The Missouri Compromise provided for the admission of Maine into the Union as a free state, the admission of Missouri into the Union as a slave state, and the removal of slavery north of Missouri. Importantly, this compromise reaffirmed the principle established in the Northwest Ordinance that Congress could, if it chose, prohibit slavery in the territories.
Global Crisis Essay Research Paper In times
Global Crisis Essay, Research Paper In times of global crisis, is it reasonable to expect that nation-states will put aside rivalries and join together to deal with the crisis?
Cuban Missile Crisis Essay Research Paper Cuban
Cuban Missile Crisis Essay, Research Paper Cuban Missile Crisis The Cuban Missile Crisis of October 1962 was the closest the world has ever come to nuclear war. The crisis was a major confrontation between the United States and the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics. The confrontation was caused by the Soviets putting missiles in Cuba, just 90 miles off the coast of the United States of America.
Thomas Paine Essay Research Paper Thomas Paine
Thomas Paine Essay, Research Paper Thomas Paine: Propaganda and Persuasion Thomas Paine, often called the ?Godfather of America? was an eighteenth century writer who used propaganda and persuasion techniques to motivate Americans in the fight for freedom from Britain. In one of several editions of his pamphlets titled The Crisis, Paine used several propaganda and persuasion techniques including over generalization, either/or fallacy, bandwagon appeal, parallelism, analogy, repetition, anecdote, and loaded language.
French Revolution Essay Research Paper The French
French Revolution Essay, Research Paper The French Revolution began on 1789. It is the most darkest period of France s history, blended with confusion and chaos which many innocent victims were killed or
East Asia Crisis Essay Research Paper A
East Asia Crisis Essay, Research Paper A large economic downturn in East Asia threatens to end its nearly 30 year run of high growth rates. The crisis has caused Asian currencies to fall
Freedom And Rights Essay Research Paper Freedom
Freedom And Rights Essay, Research Paper Freedom and Rights How would you feel if your individual rights and freedoms were stripped from you during a national crisis? In many countries, the people s individual rights and freedoms are supposed to be protected by the government. But, in some cases, those individual rights and freedoms were taken away from the people during a national crisis.
Petroleum Crisis Essay Research Paper Everyone wants
Petroleum Crisis Essay, Research Paper Everyone wants appliances such as toasters, microwaves and fridges to be cheap even though they are rich, but what about the poor people or so called middle class. What will they do if the prices are too high to afford? Petroleum is something that we all need to go from place to place, anyways most of us do; four to five years ago, when I first came to Canada, the gas prices were quite low, but in the past 2-3 years, it is still increasing up to date.
Iran Essay Research Paper 1Politics Power and
Iran Essay, Research Paper Politics, Power, and U.S. Policy in Iran, 1950-1953 1 by Francis J. Gavin On 19 August 1953, elements of the Iranian army, acting on orders from the Shah and
Asian Economic Crisis Essay Research Paper For
Asian Economic Crisis Essay, Research Paper For the last few decades, Asia had been the world’s economic miracle, achieving remarkable rates of growth and building high-quality manufacturing industries in just about anything and everything. However, since the struggle with collapsing currencies and plunging stock markets beginning in 1995, the Asian Economy has become weak.
Rape Crisis Center Essay Research Paper Prof
Rape Crisis Center Essay, Research Paper Prof. Musa Box 1176 Case Study: Ch 10: Submerging the emergent culture Rape Crisis Center The Rape Crisis Center (RCC) has experienced some problems with the shift of management. The former director, Anne, was a team member, very relaxed, ran open-agenda meetings, and made decisions after discussions.
WHAT CAUSES A CRISIS Essay Research Paper
Title of Paper : crisis Grade Received on Report : 92 WHAT CAUSES A CRISIS? Such a question may at first seem unanswerable because there are so many different kinds of unpleasant situations into which we humans can get ourselves. In one word, however, the
Us Affairs Essay Research Paper The US
Us Affairs Essay, Research Paper The U.S. plays a major role in most of the international affairs because the U.S. is considered to be a powerful nation. The Economy of America is strong, and the military power is one of the biggest in the world. There was a Persian Gulf War back in 1991 when the U.S. attacked Iraq.
The Iraq Crisis Essay Research Paper The
The Iraq Crisis Essay, Research Paper The Iraq Crisis The recent military action against Iraq by the USA and Britain has plunged the world closer to large-scale war than we have been since 1945. The question is, why have the USA instigated such actions?
The Graduate Essay Research Paper In the
The Graduate Essay, Research Paper In the movie The Graduate, the main character Ben returns home from college and encounters a psychological crisis in the sense that he doesn t know who he is or what he wants. This is due in large part to his smothering parents. Though it may seem like he is a free man and entitled to do as he wished, it is much the contrary.
Asian Economic And Financial Crisis Essay Research
Paper Asian Crisis The crisis began in Thailand in July 1997 and spread to Indonesia, the Philippines and Malaysia, then to Hong Kong, Korea and Japan. Financial systems in Thailand, Korea and Japan all came under intense strain, but nowhere as destructively as in Indonesia, which by early 1998 had become the worst-affected victim.
Asian Crisis Essay Research Paper The continuing
Asian Crisis Essay, Research Paper The continuing Asian economic crisis that began in mid-1997 ranks as Asia’s second biggest event since World War II. The crisis suddenly halted the region’s unprecedented three decades of rapid economic growth.
Asian Crisis Essay Research Paper Asian Crisis
Asian Crisis Essay, Research Paper Asian Crisis The financial crisis that erupted in Asia in mid-1997 has led to sharp declines in the currencies, stock markets, and other asset prices of a number of Asian countries. It is hard to understand what these declines will actually do to the world market. This decline is expected to halve the rate of world growth in 1998 from the four percent that was projected pre-crisis to an estimated outcome of about 2 percent.
Identity Crisis Essay Research Paper Identity Crisis
Identity Crisis Essay, Research Paper Identity Crisis: The Teenage midlife crisis By Erica C. Bowman There are many issues that face today?s teenagers. Probably one of the most common is the issue of individualism or identity. The teenage years harbor some of the most confusing and impressionable years in the life of any human being.