Paper
Bethel School District vs. Fraser
This case involved a public high school student, Matthew Fraser who gave a speech nominating another student for a student elective office. The speech was given at an assembly during school as a part of a school-sponsored educational program in self-government. While giving the speech, Fraser referred to his candidate in what the school board called “elaborate, graphic, and explicit metaphor.” After his speech, the assistant principal told Fraser that the school considered the speech a violation of the school’s “disruptive-conduct rule.” This prohibited conduct that interfered with the educational process, including obscene, profane language or gestures. After Fraser admitted he intentionally had used sexual innuendo in the speech, he was told that he would be suspended from school for three days, and his name would be removed from the list of the speakers at the graduation exercises.
Fraser’s father brought action against the school board in the United States District Court for the Western District of Washington. He alleged the suspension and punishment were a violation of his son’s First Amendment right to freedom of speech. The father sought injunctive and monetary damages under 42 U.S.C. of 1983. The district court awarded the student $278 in damages, $12,750 in litigation costs and attorney’s fees, and ordered the school district not to prevent the student from speaking at the commencement ceremonies.
The school district appealed the decision, arguing that the speech had a disruptive effect on the educational process. The school district said it had an interest in protecting an audience of minors from indecent speech in the school. The school board believed it had the right to control language that was used during a school-sponsored activity. The Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit affirmed the judgment of the district court.
The district court found the disruptive-conduct rule unconstitutionally vague and broad, and that withdrawal of the student’s name from the graduation speaker’s list violated the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment because the rule did not mention such removal as a likely sanction. The court made the case that nothing in the Constitution forbids the states from insisting that certain forms of expression are unfitting and subject to sanctions. (Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District, 1969) The court affirmed that students do not “shed their constitutional rights to freedom of speech or expression at the schoolhouse gate.”(Tinker) If the student had given the same speech off the school premises, he would not have been penalized because government officials found his language inappropriate. (Cohen v. California) The court found that the language used by the student was far from the “obscene” speech, which the court held is not protected by the First Amendment. (Ginsberg v. New York, 1968, Roth v. United States, 1981). The speech was found not to be disruptive to the education process. The school district failed to bring in a sufficient amount of evidence to convince that the educational process was disturbed.
The Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit affirmed the judgment of the district court, holding the student’s speech equivalent to the armband in Tinker. The court of appeals made it clear that the student’s speech was not prohibited by any disciplinary rule that the school had in effect. Although the speech contained a sexual metaphor that undoubtedly might have been offensive to some listeners in some settings, the court of appeals again stated there was no evidence that students found the speech to be offensive.
The case was appealed to the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court stated that the rights of students in public school do not coexist with the rights of adults in other settings. The Supreme Court found Fraser’s speech offensive to both teachers and students, and especially insulting to teenage girls. The First Amendment does not prevent school officials from deciding what is vulgar and lewd speech. Given the school’s need to be able to impose disciplinary sanctions for a wide range of unanticipated conduct disruptive of the educational process, the school disciplinary rules need not be as detailed as a criminal code that imposes criminal sanctions. (Arnett v. Kennedy, 1974) The student was given enough warning that his speech could subject him to disciplinary actions. The judgment of the Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit was reversed.
1. www.uwosh.edu/faculty_staff/petronic/pages/pap-1.htm
2. inst.augie.edu/~hlfranke/freechoice.html
3. lrs.ed.uiuc.edu/wp/censorship/filtering/individual.htm
4. www.tentler/StudentsRights.htm
Другие работы по теме:
Abortion Essay Research Paper A Plan for
Abortion Essay, Research Paper A Plan for a Homework Center The school board came up with an idea of making the school day two periods to give students time to do homework in a homework center. The idea of extending two classes is a good one. There are a lot advantages and disadvantages.
Self Esteem Essay Research Paper I compare
Self Esteem Essay, Research Paper I compare my face to the most beautiful girl in the school. I compare my personality to the sweetest girl in the school. I compare my socialization rate to the most popular girl in the school.
Press Censorship Essay Research Paper There are
Press Censorship Essay, Research Paper There are many kinds of censorship within our school system. Such as press Censorship, we aren’t aloud to express freely among our school?s newspaper nor
Freshman Yearimbas Essay Research Paper I remember
Freshman Yearimbas Essay, Research Paper I remember walking into South Brunswick High School on the first official day of high school freshman year. It was like nothing out of the ordinary. I had already been in the school all summer. I was there every day for summer football practice with coaches: Homman, Simmons, and Harding.
Cellphones At School Essay Research Paper Cell
Cellphones? At School? Essay, Research Paper Cell phones should be banned from rural schools. There is no reason for them in rural schools, they are a distraction, and finally they could aid in violent
Better School Environment Essay Research Paper In
Better School Environment Essay, Research Paper In order to create a safer school environment through positive peer pressure, you have to have at least two variables. That way, in case one doesn?t work, you can always resort to the second, or even third method if needed. The first way could be to have a popular club dedicated to promote nonviolence, and the other way could be to always discuss having a safer school environment with the students.
Destruction Of 1St Amendment Rights In Our
Schools Essay, Research Paper Destruction of 1st Amendment Rights In Our SchoolsIn 1787 our forefathers ratified the constitution of the UnitedStates of America, which contains the most important document toany American citizen, the Bill of Rights. The first amendment of theBill of Rights states:Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment ofreligion, or prohibiting the establishment thereof; orabridging the freedom of speech; or of the press; or the right ofthe people peaceably to assemble, and to petition thegovernment for a redress of grievances. these freedoms (commonly called the freedom of expression) are ofthe most important rights in a truly democratic society.
Violence In Schools Essay Research Paper There
Violence In Schools Essay, Research Paper There is definitely a problem with school violence today. The last six years have shown us that violence in our school society is more common
Woodstock Essay Research Paper WoodstockWoodstock was a
Woodstock Essay, Research Paper Woodstock Woodstock was a microcosm of the 60 s era reflecting the music, sexual activity and attitudes of the youth. The three days of peach and music introduced some of the greatest songs and musicians of all time. The concert also exposed new experiences for the youth in attendance such as drugs, and ideas (sexual behavior and behavior towards authority and old ideas).
Getting In Essay Research Paper The most
Getting In Essay, Research Paper The most significant experience of my life is yet to come. The most meaningful experience of my life must be the transaction from high school to college. My high school years
A School Visit Essay Research Paper A
A School Visit Essay, Research Paper A School Visit Are you interested in motorcycles? How about a woman who is not only a policewoman, but knows how to ride and use a motorcycle that goes up to 100 miles per
Education Essay Research Paper In to day
Education Essay, Research Paper In to day’s society education is becoming more and more important. The children of today need education to get good jobs and keep up with this fast paced modern society. Nobody ever explained this to my teachers through. High school was the worst. THe teachers at my school were losers and dinn’t know what they were doing.
Public Vs Private Essay Research Paper In
Public Vs Private Essay, Research Paper In the world today many parents ponder the thought whether private schools are better than public schools. They decide what would be better for their children. When they do this they ponder many different things like what would be academically better for my son or daughter or which would be safest and some people even would send their son or daughter to a school just for athletics.
Open Campus Essay Research Paper Open campus
Open Campus Essay, Research Paper Open campus is something every student dreams of. I had the experience to be in a highscool with open campus. The open campus, allows us to walk around the schoolarea. It includes bigger breaktime. We young teenager are not put in prison anymore. There are no more hallpasses.
School Essay Research Paper School Where
School Essay, Research Paper School! Where did they come up with that name? I guess because it rhymes with lame Now this rhyme you read will be quite corny Please don’t get upset, mad, or horny
High School Vs Middle School Essay Research
Paper High School vs. Middle School A Comparative Essay There are two distinctive differences, that make high school much more difficult, when you make the jump from middle school to high school: you have to work much harder and you get more freedom as a reward. High school is far more involved and it is more difficult than middle school.
Life Altering Essay Research Paper He was
Life Altering Essay, Research Paper He was on the basketball team and I was the statistician. We were two high school students doing our job for the team. He didn?t know me, and I didn?t know him. Then one day he walked into my Spanish class. I was frightened to death to talk to him, so I wrote him letters and started giving them to him during the passing period.
School Uniform Essay Research Paper School UniformThroughout
School Uniform Essay, Research Paper School UniformThroughout the Japan, numerous school boards have been attempting to standardize the clothing that students wear. The school superintendents who are in favor of uniforms will argue that the children who wear them will experience many benefits. I disagree with this idea.
Trip To Mother Bethel Methodist Episcopal Church
Essay, Research Paper I thought the field trip to Mother Bethel Methodist Episcopal Church was a great experience. I enjoyed it a lot, infact, I am thinking about revisiting the church again. There were a lot
School Ties Essay Research Paper School Ties
School Ties Essay, Research Paper School Ties Brendan Fraser has evolved considerably in the few months between his admirable new film, “School Ties,” and his debut as a cave dude in “Encino Man” — not that the movies really differ much thematically. Both turn on a teenager’s driving need to win over his crowd, to fit in with the cool kids — be he an unearthed Cro-Magnon, or as in this case, a Jewish quarterback who wins an athletic scholarship to a prestigious New England prep school in 1955.
Dawn Fraser Essay Research Paper DAWN FRASERDawn
Dawn Fraser Essay, Research Paper DAWN FRASER Dawn Fraser grew up in the suburb of Balmain, a dockside industrial suburb in Sydney. She was the youngest of eight children, and suffered from anaemia, asthma and other chest complications. She learnt to swim at the age of five and two years later, Dawn Fraser swam for a professional body.
Dissenting Opinion In Bethel S Essay Research
Paper Frankly, my dear, I don’t give a damn. When I was a high school student, the use of those words in a public forum shocked the Nation. Today Clark Gable’s four-letter expletive is less offensive than it was then. Nevertheless, I assume that high school administrators may prohibit the use of that word in classroom discussion and even in extracurricular activities that are sponsored by the school and held on school premises.
Math Essay Research Paper Math seems to
Math Essay, Research Paper Math seems to be one of my stronger subjects. All through elementary school, junior high school, and high school, I have always shown strong points in mathematics. Majority of the time, math was a class that I did not mind going to. I definitely did not find it boring because you are always doing something.
Lincoln Application Essay Essay Research Paper Now
Lincoln Application Essay Essay, Research Paper Now is a time to make decision in life that will help me succeed in the future. The decision is to choose the right high school that will help me meet my goals and prepare me for college. A school that can train and give me all the tools I need to be an international business.
Money In Schools Essay Research Paper I
Money In Schools Essay, Research Paper I think that money is a key factor today in American schools. For instance, if you take a kid who has been going to a wealthy school, and a kid who has been going to a deprived school, test show that the student from the wealthy school is more likely to succeed, on top of graduating high school.
So You Are Going To High School.
. Essay, Research Paper So You Are Going To High School. I am going to explain to my little cousin what to expect from high school; how the social scene is different, what you have to do to graduate, and what some of the perks of being an upper classman are.
Time Essay Research Paper Time is of
Time Essay, Research Paper Time is of the essence! Be on time! Time to go to school! We are running out of time! You may not realize it, but our lives are controlled by time. From the time we get up to the time we go to bed we are its slaves.
Cell Phones Essay Research Paper As part
Cell Phones Essay, Research Paper As part of school policy, cell phones are not permitted on school grounds. This rule must be abolished. Students who are in after school activities need cell phones to contact parents.
Miller V State Of California Law Brief
Essay, Research Paper The articles that were written in the high school newspaper, Spectrum , were blatant stories of misconduct amongst the students. When a student walks on the school ground their parents