Tradition Essay, Research Paper
The Homeric Poems: Oral or Written Tradition
Homer. A name synonomous with Greek literature and poetry. Some call him the most famous and greatest poet of the Greek society. Known for his “masterpieces” of western literature the Iliad and the Odyssey, Homer’s poems have been passed down through generations and studied by many. But how did the translations, if they are, infact, the true Homeric poems, get to where they are today? Dating as far back as 1120 B.c., the poems may have gone through a dramatic number of changes from their original form. Probably the most important factor in all of this is how they were passed down through the centuries. Scholars of today disagree on the question of whether the Homeric poems were passed down through an oral or written tradition.
In order to mover further into the subject, one must have an understanding of what an oral tradition is opposed to a written tradition. An oral tradition is one of which we know from our remembered knowledge (Kirdk 199). In this case, the telling of the poem from one generation to the next orally would be an oral tradition. A written tradition is one in which knowledge is recorded in some way shape or form of writing, and passed down that way.
Many citizens of early Greek culture possessed very limited literacy. Even at the peak of Greek society, the ability to read and write was far fom universal, and the uses made of that ability, by many who possessed it, were circumscribed (Kirk 1). Most slaves were illiterate, but so were many free-born citizens. Although there were those who could read and write, their ability to understand in-depth material was limited. Thus many had to rely on oral poetry and word-of-mouth tradition.
Not much time passesd when oral tradition began to decline, due to the availability of new writing techniques. These techniques enabled the great poems to be created out of traditional and preliterate material. But it is certainly a problem of how and why the normal range of oral narrative poems was so suddenly and brilliantly transcended. This states that there must have been a fully literate culture, and a steady supply of books. But this was not the case.
It is possible, on the other hand, that some lesser use of the new technique of writing was the detemining factor in the ability to compose such long and complex poems out of pre-existing and much shorter oral songs. Many critics do not accept this however. The huge gap in quality as well as quantity being the main factor.
In essence, the poems belong to an oral culture, whether or not their monumental form owes something to the main poet’s ability to compose witht he help of writing (Kirk 2). These poems were to some extent transcribed orally too; these were works that continued to be knows, erratically and incompletely perhaps “by heart”. Once they were produced, the poems had a stifling effect on their simpler, more typically oral predecessors. The memory of earlier songs and poems were all but obliterated. Among those that contributed to this were the Iliad and the Odyssey. If this was so, then their appearance before the translation from an age of literacy to one of partial literacy seems less strange. Teh polis, or city-state, emerged as the main focus of loyalties that had earlier been directed toward persons and families, toward feudal archetypes that still reflected some of the glow of the heroic world of Homer (Kirk 3).
Emphasis on the oral nature of the Iliad and the Odyssey must be present for the understanding of the poems as poetry, as works of literature in the broader sense, and as vast and erratic forces in the cultural history of the ancient world.
The language of Homer was never spoken by any man (Kirk 4). It is an artifical, poetical construction of phraseology and vocabulary taht originated at different dates over a period of at least 200 and perhaps as much as 500 years (Kirk 4). Some parts of it are highly conventional and consist of fixed or formular phrases. Precicely how far the formular system extended, and wher eit merges with the symbolic and repetitive aspect of all language remains a question; but the need for literate poetry of any lenght to be formular in essence is confirmed by the study both of Homer himself and of surviving oral traditions. The least complex of these traditions and the poorest in expression are also the least formular (Kirk 5). This confirms that formularity increases the powers of the oral singer. This reverses a basic rule of classical literature creation-that the repeated use of fixed or conventional language is incompatible with true originality and poetical or literary power. In this respect, the oral poet behaves quite differently from teh literate one, and makes his own individual contribution above and beyond the level of traditional ways.
The diction of Homer was archaic and yet constantly renewed, and that accounts for the existence side by side of terms and linguistic forms from the Mycenaean dialect of the Achaean heroes, from teh contemporary world of Homer himself and from many anonymous generations between. Kirk believes that the elaboration and careful placing of many of the undeveloped similies must be due to the monumental comoser himself, and cannot be a random procedure inserted along the line.
The facts of the oral tradition and the special argument from teh similies have shown that the chances of obtaining consistant and accurate information, with little important interference from later generations are exceedingly remote.
Many of the narrative components, the motifs and themes of the homeric poems are no less formular than their language and phraseology. The singer acquires a wide range of standard incidents that can be varied in length and reference to suit the needs of a chosen situation. The Homeric poems were poetic songs that contained all these elements that have been discussed. Some societies taht are, or were illiterate at one point or another, had no books or writings, and thus used oral tradition to tell the stories. Somwhere along the way, a person might have written the poem down to pass on to other generations. Any way you look at it, the Homeric poems have undertaken both types of tradition throughout the course of time.
Work Cited
1. Kirk, G.S. Homer and the Oral Tradition. Great Britain: Cambridge University Press, 1976
Другие работы по теме:
Homer Essay Research Paper HOMERThere is no
Homer Essay, Research Paper HOMER There is no question that the writer of the Iliad and the Odyssey was one of the greatest poets in the history of Western Europe, but aside from this, very little can be said about him. Ancient Greek tradition, as well as a study of language and the style of the poems indicates that he probably lived and wrote sometime in the eighth or ninth centuries B.C., but no more definite date can be determined.
Before Freedom Essay Research Paper The author
Before Freedom Essay, Research Paper The author of the book is Belinda Hurmence, she is well qualified to write a book such as this which she well demonstrates. She has done many long hours of research on slavery and the affects on the former individual slaves themselves. She has written many volumes on slavery and the opinion of many former American slaves on slavery.
Biography Of Homer Essay Research Paper Biography
Biography Of Homer Essay, Research Paper Biography of Homer (?-? BC) Beyond a few fragments of information, historians and classicists can only speculate about the life of the man who composed the Iliad and the Odyssey. The details are few. We do not even know the century in which he lived, and it is difficult to say with absolute certainty that the same poet composed both works.
Cinematic Aspects Of Cave Art Essay Research
Paper Kristine McCarthy October 1, 2000 Cinematic Aspects of Cave Art by Edward Watchel I think Watchel formed a very good, accurate arguement in saying that cave paintings are cinematic.
A Poem By Judith Smith Essay Research
Paper For every thing there must come a last. A last minute, a last hour, a last month, day, or year. A last drink, a last coke, a last tequila, scotch, or beer.
Cavalier And Metaphysical Poetrys Similarities And Differences
Essay, Research Paper The seventeenth century lyric poems, such as Robert Herrick?s Cavalier poem ?Counsel to Girls,? and Andrew Marvell?s metaphysical poem ?To His Coy Mistress? are similar in many ways; yet also contrast in some aspects. These poems of love and life can be summarized in the quote, ?Gather ye rosebuds while ye may, Old Time is still afyling?? from ?Counsel to Girls.? This quote embodies the theme of Carpe Diem shared in these poems.
Poems 2
Poems – Bright Star And Choose Something Like A St Essay, Research Paper Poems Contrasted “Bright Star” and “Choose Something Like a Star” are two poems very different in form and theme. The theme in “Bright Star” is that when in love nothing is more beautiful than your lover. While the theme of “Choose Something Like a Star” is that humans need to be individuals.
Duffy
’s Poetry – Unusual? Essay, Research Paper The Unusualness of Carol Anne Duffy s Poetry Carol Anne Duffy s poetry like quite a lot of modern poetry is not traditionally written. It does not rhyme and punctuation differs from how it would have been traditionally written. Also sentences do not start and end in orthodox places for example; in Valentine sentences cross lines :-
Death Essay Research Paper Many poems are
Death Essay, Research Paper Many poems are written about death. The two poets William Cullen Bryant and Emily Dickinson were very influential trancendental writers. Bryant writing Thanatopsis
The Lion And The Tyger Essay Research
Paper Of the many poetic works by William Blake, “The Lamb” and “The Tyger” show a large amount of similarity, as well as differences, both in the way he describes the creatures and in the style he chose to write them.
William Blake- The Tiger And The Lamb
Essay, Research Paper Many poems written by the same author often have similar themes. The authors usually believe in something very strongly and their poems usually reflect such a nature. Sometimes poets reflect aspects of their personal life in their poems. In the poems “The Lamb” and “The Tiger”, by William Blake, the poet discusses similar themes in both.
Epics Essay Research Paper In order to
Epics Essay, Research Paper In order to be considered an epic, there are certain qualifications and standards that a piece of literature must meet. The themes and motifs incorporated in these stories are universal and the plot lines are both historical and entertaining. These epics are long poems that were originally expressed orally and later transcended into written works.
Chinese Poetry Essay Research Paper Although the
Chinese Poetry Essay, Research Paper Although the Chinese poetry I encountered was relatively short, their significant was not at all compromised. It did not matter that these poems were written hundreds of years ago they felt relevant to me. They reminded me of what should be a priority of life, finding inner peace.
Is My Papa S Waltz Really About
And Abusive Father Essay, Research Paper My Papa s Waltz is by Theodore Rothke it is about a childhood memory written later in his lifetime. Theodore Rothke s dad was an alcoholic drunk. Theodore Rothke went through a period where he was depressed and mentally unstable. Theodore Rothke was fascinated by the nature of the world; many of his poems were about this subject.
Marlowe And Raleigh Essay Research Paper LoveThe
Marlowe And Raleigh Essay, Research Paper Love The two poems written by Raleigh and Marlowe are interesting. Marlowe s poem, The Passionate Shepherd to His Love, basically propositions a woman to sleep with a man, where Raleigh s, The Nymph s Reply to the Shepherd, responds negatively. Marlowe s poem is a Shepherd asking a nymph for favors.
Iliad By Homer Essay Research Paper ILIADThe
Iliad By Homer Essay, Research Paper ILIAD The Iliad is an epic poem written by Homer .Homer is traditionally believed to be the author both of the Iliad and the Odyssey , the two major epics of Greek antiquity. It is believed that Homer was a blind bard and dictated the epics. Nothing further is known about Homer as an individual , and in fact it is a matter of controversy whether a single person can be said to have written both the Iliad and the Odyssey .Linguistic and historical evidence , however , suggests that the poems were composed in the Greek settlements on the west coast of Asia Minor sometime in the second half of the 8th century BC
Gilga 2 Essay Research Paper The epic
Gilga 2 Essay, Research Paper The epic of Gilgamesh was found in the mid nineteenth century, written on over twenty five thousand clay tablets. After much studying and deciphering, this ancient Sumerian epic has finally been translated, though many of the tablets have not been found. it appears that all the most important elements of the story probably existed as separate poems when they were first written.
Two Poems By Emily Dickinson Essay Research
Paper Emily Dickinson wrote many poems in her lifetime. She writes two of my favorite poems. They are: “I heard a Fly buzz when I died” and “Because I could not stop for Death”. They both have similarities and differences from each other.
Fatboy Essay Research Paper Through my knowledge
Fatboy Essay, Research Paper Through my knowledge of Wordsworth s poetry I understand what he has written and the hidden messages he has encrypted into his poetry. It is remarkable on how he structured his poems, what language, what inspirations and themes he wrote about. In The Solitary Reaper and Strange Fits Of Passion I Have Know Wordsworth has combined the feelings and emotion of the human body and mind into a themes that runs through the veins of all or most of his poems, NATURE, and his sister LUCY.
David And Legend Essay Research Paper The
David And Legend Essay, Research Paper The legend of David and Goliath is a very familiar one to many people. It is an oral legend that has been told from one generation to the next. It has been mostly assumed to be a fictional story. The question is how do we know it is fiction. This is the problem historians have when using the tool of oral bards or legends.
The Jaguar And The Pike Essay Research
Paper Topic: ?The Jaguar?, ?The Pike? and ?Hawk Roosting? by Ted Hughes Compare the three poems, their similarities and differences, their aim and intention. Describe
Two Communication And Technology Reflection Essay Research
Paper SENIOR PORTFOLIO SECTION TWO COMMUNICATION AND TECHNOLOGY REFLECTION The choices that I make in High School are very important. I know if I do not handle everything I need to, it will not be a good thing when I do not participate in the graduation.
Elisabeth And Other Poems Essay Research Paper
A Review of Elisabeth and Other Poems Elisabeth and Other Poems reflects the many aspects of life, including relationships with family members and other loved ones, religion, and hardships of growing up. Many of these poems explore difficult experiences, such as a battle with Cancer, as well as the sentiments of being a minority in a fairly unaccepting society.
Homer And His Writings Essay Research Paper
Homer and His Writings “A hero is one who is born illegitimately, out of the fear of the prophecy of his future greatness, is abandoned by his father, is save by animals or others and raised by a lowly couple, fights wars, returns home triumphant, defeats his persecutors, frees his mother, becomes king, founds a city, and dies young (In Quest of the Hero vii).” Homer took this theory to heart in his writing the Odyssey.
Trench Poetry And Recruiting Poetry Essay Research
Paper In 1914 the press started to publish war poems again. During the Boer War poems had been printed to encourage recruiting or to inform the public about how the war was progressing. A lot of the early poems at the start of the First World War werenґt very well written. There was a lack of recruitment later on in the war and so recruitment poems started to be printed again.
Homeric Hero Essay Research Paper The Iliad
Homeric Hero Essay, Research Paper The Iliad outlines and explains the qualities of a ?Homeric Hero?. The Homeric hero strives to be the best among his peers. His goal is to achieve the greatest glory in order to earn the highest honor from his peers, his commander, and finally from his warrior society. This is because honor is the Greeks? main ambition in life as well as in the afterlife.
Hamlet Essay Research Paper Homer The
Hamlet Essay, Research Paper Homer The Homeric poems are a representation of reality- nature, animals, and men. We may reach Homer by inquiring into the picture he gives us– by seeing how true and imaginative it is. One researcher, Paolo Vivante, concludes that By Homeric imaginatition I mean that sympathetic insight whereby objects and events were first rendered by the poet in significant and revealing outlines (1).
Various Works Of Ee Cummings Essay Research
Paper Various Works of EE Cummings Edward Estlin Cummings, famously known as E. E. Cummings, had a very unique way of writing his poetry. The way his poems were written are what many critics admire most. He brushed aside the rules of English and allowed his art to shine through. He lived from 1894 to the year 1962.
Lyrical Poems Essay Research Paper Lyrical poems
Lyrical Poems Essay, Research Paper Lyrical poems on the other hand can be compared to a painting in which society is depicted, but has also been done so in a manner which serves the authors/painters point of view or their own personal agenda. The painter is not painting still life, but instead an abstract portrait of society through which the reader must filter fact from opinion.
Comparing Two Poems Essay Research Paper Topic
Comparing Two Poems Essay, Research Paper Topic: compare and contrast the two poems. The two poems Package for the Distant Future and The Song of the Whale differs mainly in their subject matter and the way they evoke different feelings and images and also the style and presentation of the poem. Coincidently both poems contain the themes of death and caring for the environment, which the writers feel strongly about.
Carl Sandburg Essay Research Paper Carl Sandburg
Carl Sandburg Essay, Research Paper Carl Sandburg was unique compare to many other poets. All of the poems that he wrote were short and straight to the point. You would not find any poems that he
Sonnet 1 35 75 Essay Research Paper
Sonnet 1, 35, & 75 Many of Spencer s are based the subject of love. The poet Spencer has written many poems on love but his contain a different twist. His poems are about love but in the end some weird twist of fate happens were it doesn’t work out. There is always something that goes on where the girl doesn t like him it just wasn t meant to be.
John Updike Essay Research Paper John Updikes
John Updike Essay, Research Paper John Updike?s poems are written in a very peculiar style. Unlike most poets, Updike?s poems seem to tell a story, rather than depict a singular emotion. This is due to the fact that many of Updike?s poems deal with simple, yet focused topics. Updike masters the use of vivid language to produce powerful images in the minds of his readers.
Oral Tradition Of Indians Essay Research Paper
Conflict Between the Oral Tradition and the Written Form in The Lone Ranger and Tonto Fistfight in Heaven The oral tradition of passing along history, information and stories of culture have been around since the beginning of time. In many cultures today, oral traditions are still the main means of passing down knowledge and history.