Julius Caesar Essay, Research Paper
The story
of Julius Caesar’s assassination has been told both historically and
fictionally. Historical sources focus on the facts of the assassination, while
fictionary works focus more on the characters and the drama of the story.
Because of the different purposes of the sources, there are many differences
between the historical and fictional stories. William Shakespeare’s Julius
Caesar adds certain details and dramatic elements to make the story more
interesting and to make the play more enjoyable. Historical sources such as
Roger Bruns’s Caesar and Manuel Komroff’s Julius Caesar present an more
accurate account of the events that occurred on and around the Ides of March.
There are however, because all of the sources are telling the same story, even
more similarities. Reading all of the sources can give a reader an
understanding of not only what really happened and why, but also what the
people involved were probably like. The time
before Caesar’s death has many differences in how events happened rather than
if events happened. Both historical accounts record that Caesar had recently
returned from a long military campaign that sent him to the far reaches of the
Roman Empire. Shakespeare’s account tells of a recent victory over Pompey but does
not say that Caesar returned from a massive campaign. In Komroff’s account, The
conspirators had planned for much longer than the other authors recorded.
Komroff wrote that the conspirators convinced the Senate to offer Caesar the
crown. The conspirators then placed a crown on a statue of Caesar that was
quickly torn down by Caesar’s friends. "Then, a few days later, as he was
riding through the streets of Rome, a crowd of people who had been led on by
the Aristocrats hailed him as King" (Komroff 161-162). The final offer of
the crown occurred before a large crowd of Romans, when a crown was placed on
Caesar’s head he took it off and said "The Romans have no kings but their
gods" (Komroff 162). Caesar refused the title every time because he knew
that the second he did, the people would turn against him. Caesar also knew
that the conspirators were behind these offers and was not about to play right
into their hands. In both Shakespeare’s and Bruns’s works, Mark Antony was the
one who offered the crown to Caesar. He did not do it to harm Caesar but out of
respect for Caesar. The Number of conspirators is the same in both historical
works. Both say that at least sixty men were involved in the conspiracy, most
of them senate members. Shakespeare’s work says that only about eight men were
part of the conspiracy, probably to cut down on the number of actors for the
play. While there are many differences in the time before Caesar’s death, there
are just as many similarities. All three
sources agree that Caesar fought and killed Pompey. Some of the senators were
alarmed at this because Pompey was a Roman and they questioned Caesar’s honor.
Upon Caesar’s return from battle, many celebrations were held. In Bruns’s
account, a series of "triumphs" or extravagant celebrations were held
in Caesar’s honor, one for each of his triumphs. In Shakespeare’s account, a
large celebration was held in Rome in Caesar’s honor. The motive for killing
Caesar is similar in all three accounts. The conspirators were afraid that
Caesar was "ambitious," that he wanted to become king. The
conspirators feared a monarchy because they did not want a heir to gain the
throne, they wanted to maintain a republic where leaders were voted into
office. Many of the conspirators did not trust Caesar, "Yet, Caesar still
provoked in many deep resentment and distrust" (Bruns 102). Because Caesar
was a leader of the people, the conspirators, who were of the aristocratic
class, "hoped to regain control of the government" (Komroff 163). All
of the sources also agree on when Caesar was killed. He was killed on March 15,
the Ides of March. In the
time that Caesar was killed many details are different in the two types of
accounts. In the historical account of Komroff, The conspirators crowded around
Caesar when he was seated at the head of the Senate. The conspirators engaged
in conversation with Caesar, "They talked freely together. Some had favors
to ask. Others had stories to tell" (Komroff 166). Then the conspirators
began to carry out the fatal stage of their plan. A scroll
was then placed in Caesar’s hand and as he unrolled it and began to read its
contents, his toga was suddenly grabbed and torn from his shoulders. He was
stabbed in the throat by a dagger. He rose to
his feet with a cry and caught the arm of the one who struck him. Then he was
stabbed again by another. He looked around and saw that he was surrounded by a
ring of daggers. There was no chance of escape. He lifted the folds of his toga
over his head. The daggers struck him from every side (Komroff 166-167). In
Shakespeare’s account a man named Metellus was petitioning Caesar to repeal the
banishment of his brother. Caesar refused, saying, "…I am constant as
the northern star…" (Shakespeare, 715). The conspirators used this as an
excuse to get closer to Caesar. The conspirators came close to Caesar to plead
for Metellus’ case, first Brutus and Cassius then the rest of the conspirators
joined them as Caesar’s side, all but Casca who was waiting behind Caesar.
"Speak, hands, for me!" (Shakespeare 716). This was Casca’s cry as he
dealt the first blow to Caesar. The others then set upon Caesar and all but
Brutus stabbed Caesar. Caesar tried to fight the conspirators but when he saw
Brutus about to stab him he surrendered. "Et tu, Brute? Then fall
Caesar!" (Shakespeare 716). The historical account says that the
conspirators were already right next to Caesar but the fictionary account says
that the conspirators needed an excuse, Metellus, to creep up to Caesar.
History records that Caesar was stabbed 23 times, fiction says that Caesar was
stabbed "thirty and three" times or 33 times. The differences during
Caesar’s death show the different purposes of the author but the similarities
show the reader the facts of the story. In all of
the accounts Caesar receives warnings about his death. The same soothsayer who
warned him the first time warned him again with the phrase, "Beware of the
Ides of March" (Komroff 166). Caesar ignores this warning and heads on to
the senate. Artemidorus hands Caesar a scroll with the names of the men in the
conspiracy and the details of the plot. Caesar places the scroll in a pile of
petitions that he was to review at the senate thinking that it was another
petition when it was really a scroll that could have saved his life. "If
thou read this, O Caesar, thou mayest live; if not, the Fates with traitors do
contrive" (Shakespeare 711). History and Fiction also agree that Caesar
fell dead at the base of a statue of Pompey, the one whom Caesar had conquered
and killed. The time after Caesar’s death was a dramatic time in Roman history.
Because of the already tense situation, few things needed to be changed for
Shakespeare’s play. In
Shakespeare’s account Brutus spoke to the Roman people and for a time they were
sided with him but in Komroff’s record the people did not side with the
conspirators at all, in fact they were against the conspirators. On the night
of Caesar’s death, the conspirators met to talk and scheme. Their plan that had
seemed so perfect the night before had fallen apart and they had lost the
support of the people that they needed so desperately so as not to seem like
senseless murderers. In Shakespeare’s story, the conspirators spoke to the
people only hours after Caesar’s death and after Antony turned the people
against the conspirators they were forced to leave right away and did not even
have time to meet that night because they were all either fleeing or dead.
There are many more similarities in the time after Caesar’s than differences. Immediately
after Caesar’s death was a time of panic and fear. The senate, after seeing the
murder of Caesar, was panicked and they ran from the senate house in fear that
they were next. The conspirators surrounded Caesar’s body and raised their
hands in victory proclaiming that "Liberty is now restored" (Komroff
167). In both accounts the conspirators address the Roman people to try to gain
their support and approval. When Mark Antony speaks to the people he rallies
them against the conspirators. He shows the people Caesar’s body and
Shakespeare wrote that Antony even pointed out the place that each of the
conspirators stabbed Caesar to give the people a picture of the murder. Antony
read Caesar’s will to the people to make the people feel personally involved in
the situation. The people were so riled by Antony that they began to march
through the streets of Rome calling for the death of the conspirators.
Shakespeare wrote that the mob even killed a man who had the same name as one
of the conspirators. This goes to show how angry the people were and how hungry
they were for revenge. In all of the accounts the conspirators were hunted down
and killed, thus avenging the murder of Julius Caesar. When
Shakespeare presented the story of Julius Caesar’s death he made it entertaining
because, as a playwright, it was his job to present a story in an entertaining
fashion. He added elements that may or may not have had any part in what
actually happened. Historical authors like Komroff and Bruns have to make their
works historically accurate to give readers the real story. They do not have to
make history sound exciting by adding elements or by developing characters.
Because these authors had different purposes so they wrote the story from
different perspectives. This causes differences in the story’s development and
the effect it leaves on a reader or viewer.
321
Другие работы по теме:
Caesar Essay Research Paper Julius Caesar was
Caesar Essay, Research Paper Julius Caesar was one of the most famous men of antiquity, who was dictator of Rome and “a man of letters”. Gaius Julius Caesar was born on July 12, 100 B.C. His family, the gens Julia was ancient and patrician, but at the time it was only beginning to reemerge. Caesar could not feel safe in Rome while Sulla was still alive.
Cleopatra 2 Essay Research Paper CleopatraOne of
Cleopatra 2 Essay, Research Paper Cleopatra One of the most popular pharos of Egypt has to be King Tut, The youngest ruler of Egypt. However, one of the most interesting is without-a- doubt Cleopatra. One of the intriguing parts about her was her son Ptolemy Caesar. Ptolemy Caesar, (The son of Julius Caesar), was one of main factors in the fall of Rome.
William Shakespeare 2 Essay Research Paper William
William Shakespeare 2 Essay, Research Paper William Shakespeare’s play, The Tragedy of Julius Caesar, is mainly based on the assassination of Julius Caesar. The character who was in charge of the assassination was, ironically, Marcus Brutus, a servant and close friend to Julius Caesar. What would cause a person to kill a close friend? After examining Brutus’ relationship to Caesar, his involvement in the conspiracy, and his importance to the plot, the truth can be revealed that Brutus kills his close friend for the love of Rome.
Julius Caesar Essay Research Paper William Shakespeare
Julius Caesar Essay, Research Paper William Shakespeare writes the Tragedy of Julius Caesar. This tragic play is based on historical facts of the life of Julius Caesar. It displays the events before his death such as his conquest over Pompey’s armies and his coronation to be king and after his death. Furthermore, this play describes the minds and motives of Caesar’s assassins.
Julius Ceaser Essay Research Paper 2
Julius Ceaser Essay, Research Paper “Alas, thou hast misconstrued everything!”-Titinius “That one cry?might well serve as an epigraph for the whole of Julius Caesar.”-Marjorie Garber
Julius Caeser
– Brutus Essay, Research Paper Was Brutus a man of principle or a hypocrite? After reading the play Julius Caeser by William Shakespeare, I would conclude that Brutus was a man of principle and honor. Brutus, a servant and close friend to Caesar, has a strong relationship with Caesar but a stronger relationship with Rome and its people.
Julius Essay Research Paper There have been
Julius Essay, Research Paper There have been many great leaders in our history, one of who is Julius Caesar. Julius Caesar was born a leader and died a leader. From his uprising
Essay
#2 Essay, Research Paper Castilla, Sebastian English II Pre-Ap/Honors Ms. Mays 5 February 2000 Essay #2 In Act I, scene ii of The Tragedy of Julius Caesar, Cassius delivers two very important monologues. Throughout these important speeches he uses rhetorical techniques and employs an appeal to Brutus? logic to make his persuasive speech effective.
Julius Caesar Essay Research Paper In the
Julius Caesar Essay, Research Paper In the play Julius Caesar Shakespeare give up hints about what is going to happen though out the rest of the play. He uses foreshadowing in the use of his characters names. For instance Julius Caesar was born Julius but earned the name Caesar after many triumphs over his stellar career.
Caesar 4 Essay Research Paper English10B6299
Caesar 4 Essay, Research Paper English10B 6-2-99 2* Who is Brutus? In Shakespeare s play of “Julius Caesar” Brutus was a conspirator that favors Rome and it s high status. He is a very honorable man. Brutus is a character that has a lot of pride for Rome and would not let anyone change the way everyone looks at it s royalty.
Julius Caesar Essay Research Paper Julius CaesarThere
Julius Caesar Essay, Research Paper Julius Caesar There are a lot of examples of supernatural in the play Julius Caesar . In this play we see signs of the supernatural from the Soothsayer, Calpurnia, which is Caesar s wife, and Caesar s ghost after his death.
Julius Caesar Theme Essay Research Paper In
Julius Caesar Theme Essay, Research Paper In the Shakespearean tragedy Julius Caesar was written to inform the audiences about the assassination of Julius Caesar. Julius Caesar is the main character of the story. He is also the character that treasures friendship the most. Friendship is the center of any orderly world.
Julius Caesar Essay Research Paper Julius CaesarJulius
Julius Caesar Essay, Research Paper Julius Caesar Julius Caesar was born on July 13th in 100B.C. His full name is Gaius Julius Caesar, which was the same as his father?s name. Julius Caesar was the most famous Roman general and was one of the most influential political and military leaders in history. He helped establish the vast Roman Empire.
Julius Caesar As A Tragic Hero 2
Essay, Research Paper Julius Caesar As A Tragic Hero In Julius Caesar William Shakespeare illustrated Caesar as a tragic hero by showing that he was a noble man of high rank, by showing that he was a historical figure with a tragic flaw which lead to his downfall, and by showing that Caesar accepted his fate of death & achieved honor and respect in his death.
Julius Caesar By William ShakespeareA Essay Research
Paper Julius Caesar by William ShakespeareSome tragedies are classified as classical tragedies and they may contain a tragic hero. This is true in William Shakespeare s Julius Caesar in which Brutus is the tragic hero. The play Julius Caesar contains many characteristics to classify it as a classical tragedy.
Julius Caesar Essay Research Paper Born in
Julius Caesar Essay, Research Paper Born in Rome on July 12 or 13, 100 BC, Caesar belonged to the prestigious Julian clan; yet from early childhood he knew controversy. His uncle by marriage was
Marcus Brutus Character Analysis From Julius Caesar
Essay, Research Paper Marcus Brutus character analysis, from Julius Caesar William Shakespeare’s play, The Tragedy of Julius Caesar, is mainly based on the assassination of Julius Caesar. The character who was in
Julius Caesar Essay Research Paper Larren San
Julius Caesar Essay, Research Paper Larren San Pedro Julius Caesar Julius Caesar is a Shakespearean tragedy about the hunger for power. William Shakespeare explained the tragedy through the character development of hatred and envy. Caesar s life was cut short because several men around him looked at him to power hungry and weak.
Julius Caesar Essay Research Paper Julius Caesar
Julius Caesar Essay, Research Paper Julius Caesar was a great military power. Much of Rome praised Caesar and triumphed at his victories and accomplishments. However, there were many dissatisfied Roman men and women that felt Caesar was too powerful and ambitious for his own good. Caesar’s growing power resulted in Marcus Antonius offering him the Crown of Rome three times, and all three times Caesar refused the crown.
Julius Caesar A Dead Man
’s Party Essay, Research Paper JULIUS CAESAR: A Dead Man?s Party In Shakespeare?s Julius Caesar, the character of Caesar remains a active force throughout the play, even after his assassination. Caesar is
Julius Caesar Jealousy Essay Research Paper Julius
Julius Caesar: Jealousy Essay, Research Paper Julius Caesar: Jealousy Jealousy causes many of the characters in The Tragedy of Julius Caesar to commit dangerous and foolish acts. Cassius’ jealousy drives him to kill
Julius Caesar Character Analysis Essay Research Paper
Julius Caesar In Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar, the title character’s three prominent characteristics, that he displays for the short time while in the novel, are his egotistical attitude, his intelligence, and foolish courage. During the second scene of the first act, we get an idea of what kind of man Caesar believes himself to be when Anthony declares “When Caesar says ‘Do this’, it is perform’d.” This lets us known that Caesar believes his word to be higher than any other persons, this was probably caused by the inflation of his ego.
Julius Caesar Essay Research Paper How Betrayal
Julius Caesar Essay, Research Paper How Betrayal Led to Downfall in Julius Caesar In the play, The Tragedy of Julius Caesar, William Shakespeare shows how friends often betray each other. Julius Caesar is about to be crowned king of Rome, when some well-known Romans decide that it is not a good idea for this to happen.
Downfall Of Julius Caesar Essay Research Paper
Sheena Deans Mr. Mason 3rd Period May 1, 2000 Report: Julius Caesar It can be concluded that the death of Julius Caesar was self inflicted due to his sense of pride , stubbornness, and naivity.
Julius Caesar Essay Research Paper Julius Caesar10044
Julius Caesar Essay, Research Paper Julius Caesar 100-44 BC Born in 100 BC, Gaius Julius Caesar became one of the most famous and remembered Romans of all time. His parents were Gaius Caesar and Aurelia. Julius Caesar’s most famous
Julius Caesars Women Essay Research Paper Portia
Julius Caesar`s Women Essay, Research Paper Portia and Calpurnia are the two main women in the story of Julius Caesar. They had two totally different parts in the story. One was kind of a servant wife and
Gaius Julius Caesar Essay Research Paper Gaius
Gaius Julius Caesar Essay, Research Paper Gaius Julius Caesar Julius Caesar was a Roman general. He had an adopted son called Octavian (known as Augustus) who later participated n a plot to kill him. “Veni,
Julius Caesar Essay Research Paper Julius CaesarDo
Julius Caesar Essay, Research Paper Julius Caesar Do you ever wander where the leap year was all started? While Julius Caesar took over the government as a dictator, he presented many contributions and achievements. One of them was adopting a new calendar based on the Egyptian year of 365 1/4 days. Many people believed that Julius Caesar was a tyrant who meant to end the republic and make himself king, although, I believe he was a very beneficial dictator who should have remained a leader.
Julius Caesar Essay Research Paper Julius CaesarVeni
Julius Caesar Essay, Research Paper Julius Caesar Veni, vidi, vici. ?I came, I saw, I conquered.? These are the words of the man who changed the course of Greco-Roman history, Julius Caesar (Bernard 34). Julius Caesar
Julius Caesar 5 Essay Research Paper Julius
Julius Caesar 5 Essay, Research Paper Julius Caesar William Shakespeare s play, Julius Caesar, is mainly based on the assassination of Julius Caesar. The various men who happened to object to his assassination had different personal desires for their actions. Depending on each of their actions, words or even tone of voice they may misrepresent them and may be misinterpreted.
How Were Women Treated In Julius Caesars
Time Essay, Research Paper Essay: How Were Women Treated in Julius Caesar’s Time? By: Andrew MillardWe are always striving for equality between the sexes. For many years women were seen as being less than men, and inferior to them. This is shown simply by one history-altering incident. The incident that I’m referring to is when the women were finally allowed to vote.