Essay, Research Paper
Question 4
Describe the anti-semitic person’s attitude toward reason. How does his attitude toward reason reflect or reveal his general attitude toward life, the human condition and even himself? How does his attitude toward reason compare to the attitude of the rational man?
Sartre explains that an Anti-Semite is “impenetrable”, and it is actually something he strives to achieve. By gaining impenetrability, the Anti-Semite strengthens his beliefs because another person is not capable of reasoning with him. Sartre believes the Anti-Semite’s “reason” is based on the passion for hatred that he holds for the Jew. Sartre uses the word “monoideism” to explain the irrational Anti-Semite’s passion which is driven by love for his race and jealousy of the Jew. The Anti-Semite chooses to be impenetrable without consideration of different options.
Sartre believes that the Anti-Semite gains strong conviction because he prefers to be “impervious to reason”. The Anti-Semite’s view on life is distorted by his impenetrability. Through his life, the Anti-Semite believes that his beliefs are rational and even valid. His perception is effected; his hate for the Jew often consumes him. This consumption does not allow him to admit when he is wrong, or even consider other reasoning. His idea of others, besides those that belong to his race, becomes false. He begins to label others as inferior, evil, greedy, etc. These ideas are based on fear and misconceptions. He believes that all Anti-Semitic views are fact with no exceptions. This causes a distorted view on the human condition. Sartre believes that the Anti-Semite views himself as pure, without flaw. On the other hand, everyone else is mentally disturbed, physically incapable, and, as I stated before, evil.
Sartre states that the Anti-Semite differs from the “rational man” because of the rational man’s openness. The rational man is open to all ideas; he strives to gain more factual information to back his views. However, the Anti-Semite remains closed-minded and chooses to be ignorant to the fact that his beliefs are not valid. The rational man seeks information, and does not feel content until his quest for knowledge is over. The rational man is even “hesitant” when he states his ideas, or comes to conclusions. He realizes that there are other views on every subject, and he wants to contemplate over every possible idea that he is able to think of until he reaches his own. The “reasonable man” will even admit when he is proven wrong, and change his view. The Anti-Semite wishes not to change, and claims, even when proven wrong, that his beliefs are still of a valid and true nature.
Sartre believes the actual content of truth frightens the Anti-Semite. The idea of there being other views is ignored by the Anti-Semite. He chooses to remain “innate”. They want to come to a conclusion right away, and consider only the factors that benefit him.
Sartre blames the Anti-Semites ability to ignore reasoning and research on “emotional bias”. Through this emotional bias, he feels at ease because he is in a state of bliss; he feels as though he knows all he needs to know about life.
In conclusion, the Anti-Semite disregards any other ideas besides his own, and those of his “brothers”. Sartre states that the Anti-Semite is irrational, and incapable of being open to different and conflicting views. Sartre, also, states that this impenetrability is based on emotional bias and a passion for hatred. The rational man is able to accept and learn of new ideas, but the Anti-Semite will only consider the ideas that benefit and support his ideas, and he will actual disregard the fact that his ideas are based on stereotypes and racism. The Anti-Semite believes that the Jew is evil, and that it is his responsibility to rid the world of this evil.
Question 5
If it is really true that “existence precedes essence,” and that “there is no difference between the being of man and his being free”, how is it possible for a human being to be oppressed and rendered un-free? If “man is freedom” why must we seek freedom?
To be free, one must, first, be a human being; one must be considered a human being. A little over a century ago, African Americans were not considered human. We were seen as animals, beasts. When the colonial man ventured into Africa, and began to enslave the natives, we were seen a property. We were placed in the same category as cattle. During those times we were seen as property, hence we were “un-free”, both physically and mentally. Now, if one is enslaved physically, he may still be considered free. He has the ability to mentally disenfranchise himself from his current surroundings. However, the slaves were mentally exhausted from constant abuse.
The white men made sure that our oppression would last. They actually made it illegal for slaves to learn. Now, if were beasts, why would they not make it illegal for cattle to learn? They lied to themselves! They knew that if we were enlightened we would be able to overcome oppression. Sartre believed that the “obstruction and rationality of a human being” could be achieved by subduing enlightenment. He also states that, “one cannot turn a human being into something else.” A person can be crippled intellectually, and his or her social consciousness is nonexistent.
Man is free, but some still fight for civil liberties. Some races are still kept down by racism and hatred. The Jew strives for racial equality because the Anti-Semite makes it hard for them to enjoy many fruits and luxuries of simple living. They do not achieve this by monetary means, but by mental and emotional means. The Anti-Semite teaches hate and inequality, which affects other races, also. Through racism and hate, they are able to hold the Jew and others behind. They are, also, able to turn them against one another. They are able to achieve this because we are fighting one another for the civil liberties and ontological freedom that the nation gives us. While we are fighting each other for the respect of the “white man’, we are not respecting ourselves. This is another way of keeping a people “un-free”.
Over the course of time, every race has known some form of slavery. Every one of those groups overcame their enslavement because they found ways of learning. Once a man is enlightened, he realizes his right to live as everyone else does. Freedom is first realized mentally, and then achieved physically. Sartre believed that humans are automatically free. However, if others, as well as himself, do not consider one human, then that person is “un-free”. People seek freedom today, however, it is a different freedom”. The freedom people seek today is freedom from racial inequality, and freedom from those irrational minds.
Question 3
Why does Sartre consider Anti-Semitism to be a passion rather than mere opinion or an idea protected by the “right of free opinion”? What kind of passion is it? Does Sartre’s description of Anti-Semitic passions suggest any similarity to the racial antagonisms often found in the United States?
Jean-Paul Sartre considers Anti-Semitism to be a passion because anyone who dislikes or hates another person simply based on general conceptions that convey a certain overall description of that person or race as evil and greedy has to be passionate about his or her views. Sartre states, that an “opinion cannot be argued” because it is a belief carried on by a person or group. One must accept the fact that other people feel differently regarding the same subject. He believed the “opinions” of an Anti-Semite can be argued hence, it is not truly an opinion. Of course, these are Sartre’s beliefs.
Sartre believed that Anti-Semite’s beliefs are based on external causes, such as occupations and stereotypical personalities of Jewish people. The Anti-Semite draws statistical information on Jews, and compares the differences. The Anti-Semite, also, views such details as annual income of Jews and draws a conclusion that Jews are greedy.
Sartre, also, believes that the disturbed Anti-Semite actually has a passion for hatred; this hatred is directed towards the Jew. Sartre states, “ordinarily, this type of emotion is not very pleasant”. Sartre suggests that the Anti-Semite actually loves to hate. Generally, if you love something, you possess a passion to protect that object. So, the Anti-Semite will protect and defend his view of the Jew. Only a sick individual is capable of loving and embracing hatred. That hatred for the Jews is a driving force behind the Anti-Semite’s “passion”. An opinion is logical, but the Anti-Semite’s passion is not. The Anti-Semite expects people to accept and respect his “opinion”, but they are unable to respect another’s view.
I believe Sartre suggests similarity to the racial and antagonisms found in the United States. If the Anti-Semite dislikes the Jew because of external reasons as I stated before, then he must feel negatively towards such races as the Chinese and African American. The same type of racism the Jews face from the Anti-Semites, the African Americans face from any other race in America. The Anti-Semite believes he is superior, and that means he believes he is superior to any other race, also. Sartre remembers a comment stated by an Anti-Semite; “you see, there must be something about the Jew, they just upset me physically.” If one were to compare a Jew to an Anti-Semite, both physically and mentally, one would find it difficult to distinguish them. However, African Americans and Asians differ considerably, so they must upset the Anti-Semite tremendously. The Anti-Semite in America does not just discriminate against the Jews, but anyone outside of their race.
In conclusion, Sartre believes that the passion an Anti-Semite holds for hating the Jew could not be an opinion. According to Sartre, an opinion is reasonable and forthright. The Anti-Semite’s reasons for disliking a Jew are based on economic fear and beliefs of past Anti-Semitic leaders. The same hatred an Anti-Semite holds for a Jew, can be compared to a racist’s views on African Americans and other minority groups; the Anti-Semite’s beliefs and hatred, however, are more focused.
Christian Seymour
Midterm Essays
March 9, 2001
Dr. Robert E. Birt
Philosophy 220: Ethics and Values
MWF 4:00 p.m.
Bibliography
Sartre, Jean-Paul. Existentialism and Human Emotions. Kensington: New York, 1985.
Anti-Semite and Jew. Schoken Books: New York, 1995.
Fanon, Frantz. Black Skin, White Masks. Grove Press: New York 1967.
34d
Другие работы по теме:
Социалистический коллектив пациентов
(нем. Sozialistisches Patientenkollektiv) — экспериментальный психотерапевтический коллектив, созданный доктором Вольфгангом Губером в клинике при Гейдельбергском университете.
Жан-Поль Готье
Жан-Поль Готье́ (фр. Jean-Paul Gaultier; родился 24 апреля 1952) — французский модельер, во многом определивший облик высокой моды 1980-х и 1990-х гг., президент собственного модного Дома и компании Jean Paul Gaultier S.A.
The Good The Bad And The Existentialist
Essay, Research Paper The Good, the Bad and the Existentialist The beliefs of an existentialist say that the choices we make throughout our lives all dictate who we are. As viewed by well known existentialist philosopher Jean-Paul Sartre, ?The inescapable condition of human life is the requirement of choosing something and accepting the responsibility for the consequences.? Existentialism aside, it is widely accepted that we, as humans, live our own lives and are free to make decisions for ourselves.
No Exit Essay Research Paper
Sartre believed that one day man happened, or occurred, and after this anomalous event man?s life took meaning. With this theory, Sartre articulated the premise that "existence precedes essence". Through this assumption, Sartre evolves further ideas in which a human can gain a greater understanding of human nature and responsibility.
Pauls Letter To The Galatians Essay Research
Paper Paul’s Letter to The Galatians When Paul attended the Jerusalem Conference, a decision was made that gentiles would be allowed to become Christians without becoming Jews first. Paul defended the
Les Miserables Essay Research Paper Throughout peoples
Les Miserables Essay, Research Paper Throughout peoples lives they will be influenced due to other people and events. In the book Les Miserables by Victor Hugo, Jean is influenced by three different people. The first influence on Jean was by the bishop. Another influence on Jean was Cosette. A third influence on Jean was Javert.
Sarte Essay Research Paper Sartre which we
Sarte Essay, Research Paper Sartre, which we place among atheists, stress that central concern of philosophy is human existence. He says that human being is a special kind of consciousness (being-for- itself). Everything else is matter (being-in-itself). He believes that human being has no God-given essence and is absolutely free and absolutely responsible.
Antisemitism And Sartre Essay Research Paper In
Anti-semitism And Sartre Essay, Research Paper In Sartre’s Anti-Semite and Jew, he makes reference to the notion that anti-Semitism arises not against individual Jews, but against the ” idea of the Jew.” That is to say that the Jew is recognized only as a member of a group associated with fear and disgust, not as an individual capable of being anything but the stereotype of the Jew.
Comparison Of Miss Jean Brodie Dead Poets
Society And The Tr Essay, Research Paper Paul B. Campano These three works share numerous similarities. The most obvious of these is their character’s desire and commitment to instructing and teaching youth. Miss Jean Brodie dedicated a major part of her life to “her girls”. She would have done anything to help them.
Existentialism Essay Research Paper Existentialism has been
Existentialism Essay, Research Paper Existentialism has been defined as a philosophical movement or tendency, emphasizing individual existence, freedom and choice that influences many diverse writers in the 19th and 20th centuries. The philosophical term existentialism came from Jean Paul Sartre, a French philosopher.
Sartre Essay Research Paper Jean Paul Sartre
Sartre Essay, Research Paper ?Jean Paul Sartre has been described as one of the most controversial of modern French playwrights, and his work is also known extensively outside France.?
No Exit Essay Research Paper In his
No Exit Essay, Research Paper In his play, No Exit, Jean-Paul Sartre examines basic themes of existentialism through three characters. The first subject, Garcin, embraces existentialist ideas somewhat. The second character, Inez, seems to fully understand ideas deemed existential. Estelle is the third person, and does not seem to understand these ideas well, nor does she accept them when they are first presented to her.
No Exit And Existentialis Essay Research Paper
Jean-Paul Sartre’s portrayal of Hell in No Exit is fueled with dramatic irony, implemented in order to amuse the reader. Sartre’s illustration of Hades is very psychological, and instead of Satan agonizing you,
What Is Existentialism Essay Research Paper From
What Is Existentialism? Essay, Research Paper From what I understand reading Jean-Paul Sartre’s work the Existentialism is philosophy that places emphasis on individual existence, subjectivism, and freedom of making choice.
Reader Response Theory And The Restrictive Nature
Of Freedom Essay, Research Paper During the mid twentieth century, the literary community witnessed the descent of the New Criticism and the emergence of the reader response movement. The reader response movement sharply contrasts the theories of New Criticism in that it focuses on the importance of the reader in the creation of the literary experience.
Anti-Semitism In 2
Anti-Semitism In “The Merchant Of Venice” Essay, Research Paper Anti-Semitism in”The Merchant of Venice” Anti-Semitism in “The Merchant of Venice” Throughout the play, “The Merchant of Venice” William Shakespeare portrays anti-Semitism through many of his characters. Audiences today may interpret the play to be offensive, where as people of Shakespeare’s time would have accepted the play as part of everyday life.
Sartre Essay Research Paper John Paul Sartre
Sartre Essay, Research Paper John Paul Sartre is known as one of the most influential philosophers of the twentieth century. He wrote many philosophical works novels and plays. Much of his work is tied into politics. The essay Existentialism is a Humanism is just one of his many works. Existentialism is a Humanism is a political essay that was written in 1945.
Genocide Essay Research Paper GENOCIDEThe word genocide
Genocide Essay, Research Paper GENOCIDE The word ?genocide? has not been in existence for a very long: it was the jurist Lemkin who coined it between the two world wars. The thing itself is as old as humanity and there has never been a societ whose struture has preserved it from committing this crime.(Jean-Paul Sarte)
Selfconsciosness Sartre Dostoyevsky Essay Research Paper In
Self-consciosness Sartre Dostoyevsky Essay, Research Paper In both Notes From the Underground, by Fyodor Dostoyevsky, and the play No Exit, by Jean-Paul Sartre, we see that the characters have lost that state of comfort with or acceptance of one’s self that is apparent only before interaction with other people.
Emotion A Comparison Between William James
’ And Jean-Paul Sartre’S Points Of View Essay, Research Paper What is an emotion? William James and Jean-Paul Sartre present two different arguments regarding what constitutes an emotion. This paper will explore William James’ analysis of emotion as set out in his 1884 essay . It will attempt to discover the main points of his view, and then present Sartre’s rebuttal of this view taken from his essay on emotions .
Bad Faith Essay Research Paper
“…No fate, no bad luck, no excuses, simply man, his choices, and the situation in which he finds himself…” -Anonymous The concepts of existence and human freedom have been presented by Jean-Paul Sartre in his book entitled Being and Nothingness. However, Sartre also presents other related concepts, such as bad faith which has been referred to as a device that protects us from the anguish of realizing that we are freer than we like to think we are.
Les Miserables Essay Research Paper Les MiserablesIn
Les Miserables Essay, Research Paper Les Miserables In Victor Hugo s Les Miserables Jean Valjean goes through many difficult struggles and finds the much needed influence to help him. There are three characters who influence Jean: Bishop Bienvenu, Cosette, and
Sartre Simplified Essay Research Paper Jean Paul
Sartre Simplified Essay, Research Paper Jean Paul Sartre was born in Paris, France on June 21, 1905. When Sartre was fifteen months old, his father died and Sartre was sick with enteritis. When Sartre was well again, his mother took him to live with his grandparents in Meudon. As a kid, Sartre was given everything and always was treated like a kid.
JeanPaul Sartre Essay Research Paper Ask most
Jean-Paul Sartre Essay, Research Paper Ask most Americans who Jean-Paul Sartre is and you will most likely get a frowned look. According to journalist, Richard Eyre, in this country, Sartre is perhaps as unfashionable as loon pants. That is in part because Sartre, albeit a great French philosopher, didn?t have a poster status.
Jean Sartre Essay Research Paper JEANPAUL SARTRE
Jean Sartre Essay, Research Paper JEAN-PAUL SARTRE Jean-Paul Sartre is a French philosopher, novelist, play-write, and journalist. He is mostly recognized for his leadership in French Existentialism. After questioning his own ideas he gave up his own ideas, and started to support Marxism. Existentialism was the ideology that he is mostly known and supported for.
No Exit By JeanPaul Sartre Essay Research
Paper No Exit By Jean-Paul Sartre Sartre’s most popular play is undoubtedly the one-act drama No Exit, which is a discussion of such familiar negative existentialist themes as bad faith, self-destruction, and the impossibility of interpersonal relationships. It is in this play that Sartre’s famous line, “Hell is other people,” occurs.
JeanPaul Sartre Essay Research Paper JeanPaul Sartre
Jean-Paul Sartre Essay, Research Paper Jean-Paul Sartre and Existentialism Jean-Paul Sartre . . . the name is one of the most popular in modern philosophy. But who was he? What did he write and what were his works about? What was his role with regard to Existentialism? What is Existentialism, really? What life influences affected the person as whom he became famous? How would Sartre assess various social topics that we face today? What are the problems with Sartre’s view of Existentialism and existence in general? These are the questions addressed in the following pages of this brief dissertation.
The Merchant Of Venice Essay Essay Research
Paper William Shakespeare s The Merchant of Venice contains many examples that insult Jews because they were the minority in London in Shakespeare s time. Although many parts of the play could be interpreted as offensive in modern times, Elizabethan audiences found them comical. The majority of London s population at the time was anti-Semitic because there were very few Jews living there.
St Paul Essay Research Paper 1 25
St. Paul Essay, Research Paper 1. (25 Points) Discuss Paul?s background, conversion and some of his views/teachings that may have made him different than the Apostles in Jerusalem.
Paul Essay Research Paper Paul was always
Paul Essay, Research Paper Paul was always an insecure individual. His insecurity was a direct result from the lack of attention he received from his father, and love from his deceased mother. He grew up with minimal support from his father. Paul was never encouraged to do what he was interested in. For instance, when Paul s was at school and was interested in stocks, his father did not encourage his abilities to play the stock market; rather he pulled Paul out of school.
Character Sketch For Shiloh Essay Research Paper
Character sketch for Shiloh Character Sketch In Bobbie Ann Mason s story Shiloh she presents the character of Norma Jean as having a strong personality but an emptiness deep within. Norma Jean is presented as