Just Some Bad Logic
The Battle For Medical Marijuana in The War on Drugs is an article written by William E. Stempsey debating over why the dispute against the legalization of medical marijuana is just bad logic. The article is clearly for the legalization of marijuana for medicinal purposes and gives several opinions on why opponents of this issue are incorrect with their arguments. Stempsey argues three main points in this article and I feel that all three contain fallacies. I oppose legalization for medicinal uses because I feel that it is just a cover for outright legalization. Many promoters deceitfully claim that their only goal is to help the seriously ill but there are legitimate prescription drugs out there that can already accomplish the same task.
The issues of pain relief and legalization are distinct and separate. The nausea-relieving, appetite-stimulating properties of marijuana can be and is reproduced in pill form. On the other hand, taking those pills may not be as pleasant or as effective to a patient when compared to lighting up a joint . Stempsey claims that marijuana s medicinal effectiveness has been proven by the thousands of patients who have used it illegally. He then asks, Should it matter whether the relief of nausea and pain is the result of some scientifically proven direct chemical action of marijuana or is the result of a marijuana-induced euphoria? But then again, why should we subject such people to the more than 400 toxic chemicals found in street “pot”? Though the medical profession has not been as responsive as it should have been in relieving pain and other symptoms of those suffering from major diseases, that is no reason to leap to legalization of mind-altering drugs. Stempsey insists, Marijuana has been so effective in many cases that people have been willing to risk imprisonment in order to obtain this relief. But what about all those hundreds of thousands pot smokers out there? Are they not willing to risk imprisonment in order to obtain that same relief, or does that just not prove how effective marijuana really is?
Opponents against legalizing by prescription argue that legalization will without a doubt lead to the extensive use of marijuana recreationally and make it effortless for the general public to acquire. Stempsey derides this argument by saying, The availability of drugs on the streets is not a function of the availability of prescription drugs. Morphine and other narcotics are available at present only by prescription, and there is no widespread abuse of these drugs. Stempsey doesn t realize though that morphine and these other narcotics can only be acquired through a pharmacy and, unlike marijuana, cannot be grown in one s backyard or smuggled in from, say, Mexico. Marijuana is already so easy to obtain and if it were to be legalized for medicinal purposes, people would not perceive the drug as bad as it is today and therefore its use would further increase.
In Stempsey s final point, he argues against the claim that marijuana is a gateway drug, meaning that it opens up a path to more serious drugs, and that children would get the wrong message if medical marijuana were to be legalized. He gives the statistic that 17 percent of current marijuana users said they had tried cocaine, and only 0.2 percent of those who had not used marijuana had tried cocaine. I think this statement really does contradict his argument on how it is not a gateway drug because it clearly states that people, who have not used marijuana, have not used cocaine. And frankly, I ask how would legalizing medical marijuana at all decrease the number of people who try cocaine? It wouldn t; if anything the number would go up.
Concerning the message being sent to children on medical marijuana, Stempsey concurs with the question from a Boston Globe columnist, Ellen Goodman, “What is the infamous signal being sent to [children]…if you hurry up and get cancer, you, too, can get high?” If I were a child, I d be thinking, If it s alright for sick people to get high, then what s so bad about it? I ll tell you what s bad about it: No drug should ever be used for recreational purposes and by giving in and legalizing medical marijuana, all the time and money spent on trying to control this country s drug problem will go straight down the drain, or shall I say, up in smoke.
Bibliography
Stempsey, William E. The Battle For Medical Marijuana in The War on Drugs. America, April 11, 1998: p14
Другие работы по теме:
Cognition Essay Research Paper 10 What are
Cognition Essay, Research Paper 10) What are some other key biases that influence judgement? Judgement seems to be influenced by a variety of things each have their own implication on judgement. Overconfidence serves as a bias on judgement. Fischhoff, Slovic, and Lichtenstein, in 1997, tested this idea.
Experiment
#1 Essay, Research Paper Title:Logic Gates Objective:To analyze and become familiar with the operation of TTL Logic Gates. Equipment:Digital Trainer
Romeo An Juliet Essay Research Paper hi
Romeo An Juliet Essay, Research Paper hi i need an essay about a character in romeo and juliet that demonsrtated maturity. in a well developed multi pagraph essay and say why you think the character’s maturity was greater than the other characters in the play.
College Essay Essay Research Paper It would
College Essay Essay, Research Paper It would be conventional to choose a parent, family member, friend, or teacher as a significant source of influence in ones life. However I am not conventional or at least I try not to be. I am very open-minded and observant. My personality and work exhibit eclectic-laden themes drawn from a chaotic world of sources in which I perceive.
Conservation Essay Research Paper Child DevelopmentFour year
Conservation Essay, Research Paper Child Development Four year old Nicolas, six year old Thomas, and eight year old Jamie were the subjects for all the following experiments. First, the experiment will be stated and performed, the reaction will follow second, and then a conclusion. All children were uninformed of what and why this was taking place.
Oh Really Essay Research Paper Oh Reallyyou
Oh Really? Essay, Research Paper Oh Really, you think i am a lark, the dogs they run and bark, but when i say to them, shut up shut up shut up, you say to be nice to them,
Essay
#2 Essay, Research Paper Castilla, Sebastian English II Pre-Ap/Honors Ms. Mays 5 February 2000 Essay #2 In Act I, scene ii of The Tragedy of Julius Caesar, Cassius delivers two very important monologues. Throughout these important speeches he uses rhetorical techniques and employs an appeal to Brutus? logic to make his persuasive speech effective.
Transcendentalism Essay Research Paper I believe in
Transcendentalism Essay, Research Paper I believe in the mystical idea of transcendentalism, but I do not consider myself a full transcendentalist because I also have faith in logic and reason. I feel that I have the characteristics of being a transcendentalist, such as being one with nature and being self-reliant.
What Is Calculus Essay Research Paper What
What Is Calculus Essay, Research Paper What is Calculus? A definition found of calculus in a dictionary was this; a method of computation or calculation in a special notation (as of logic or symbolic logic). The historical perspective of calculus is that people had a problem in finding areas and finding tangent lines.
St Thomas Aquinas Essay Research Paper What
St. Thomas Aquinas Essay, Research Paper What is the Best Way to Prove God? A Comparison of St. Thomas Aquinas St. Thomas Aquinas is one of the greatest theologians that has ever been. He recognized that there
Logic
– Features Of Argumentation Essay, Research Paper Features of Argumentation The logic of everyday argumentation should be based upon common data or information that is accepted by everyone. A warrant need to be used in order to relate the evidence that is presented in an argument to the claim that is being made.
George Boole Essay Research Paper George Boole
George Boole Essay, Research Paper George Boole was a mathematician in the 19th century. He helped establish modern symbolic logic and created algebra of logic, which they now called Boolean algebra. Boolean algebra is basic to the design of digital computers that we use today.
The Folly Of Logic The Freedom Of
Truth Essay, Research Paper Logic can very often restrain us from recognising the truth when it is presented to us. Allow me to begin by asking a question.
The Logic Behind The Assertion Essay Research
Paper The Logic Behind the Assertion In Martin Luther King Jr.?s ?Letter from Birmingham City Jail,? he argues the commonly believed assumption that activating our rights as human beings precipitates violence. Even though these actions may be nonviolent, those individuals who have tried to bring about the truth have been condemned because their quests were believed to be a disturbance among society.
College Essay Essay Research Paper Everyone has
College Essay Essay, Research Paper Everyone has strengths and weaknesses but as a child, it?s hard to deal with your weaknesses. It?s not until you grow up and realize that you have to use your strengths to overcome your weaknesses. Combining logic with technology can be a useful tool. For me it was the way to overcome my disability.
The Similarities And Differences Of Jonathan Edwards
And Patrick Henry Essay, Research Paper The Similarities and Differences of Jonathan Edwards and Patrick Henry convey theiThere were many similarities and differences between speech styles of the early 1700’s and the late 1700’s. Speakers were known to use persuasive techniques in these time periods to influence their audience’s opinions.
Nature In Emerson Essay Research Paper Analogy
Nature In Emerson Essay, Research Paper Analogy of Nature Ralph Waldo Emerson explores the intricate tie amongst nature, man, and language. His function is to define reason and understanding through nature. Emerson uses the analogy between mans life and the transformation he finds through his soul. He changes the idea of logic and reason, but its meaning remains similar.
The Logic Of Evaluation Essay Research Paper
The Logic of Evaluation Along with questions there are answers, most questions must be evaluated before arriving to those answers. Usually when I am asking a question I go through a mental process of evaluating the question at hand before giving what I considered to be the most accurate answer.
Macbeth Essay Research Paper A struggle is
Macbeth Essay, Research Paper A struggle is present in every tragedy, as a person tries to overcome their flaws and fit the mold of their ideal. William Shakespeare plainly defined a good man in the play “Macbeth”. This goal by it’s definition is a difficult one for any man to achieve. Prudence and logic, temperance and patients, as well as the vindication of honor are Shakespeare’s defining characteristics of a good man.
Macbeth 3 Essay Research Paper MacbethA struggle
Macbeth 3 Essay, Research Paper Macbeth A struggle is present in every tragedy, as a person tries to overcome their flaws and fit the mold of their ideal. William Shakespeare plainly defined a good man in the play “Macbeth”. This goal by it s definition is a difficult one for any man to achieve. Prudence and logic, temperance and patients, as well as the vindication of honor are Shakespeare s defining characteristics of a good man.
Electronics Logic Probe Essay Research Paper LOGIC
Electronics- Logic Probe Essay, Research Paper LOGIC PROBE SUMMARY Logic Probe is one of the basic troubleshooting tools for common electronic logic circuits (TTL circuits). Almost all video game circuit boards are built using TTL chips. These chips will occasionally fail and the Logic Probe is a tool that affords us a look into what may be failing, and it s a very handy measuring device used to determine output logic levels.
Mathemtical Logic Essay Research Paper Mathematical logic
Mathemtical Logic Essay, Research Paper Mathematical logic is something that has been around for a very long time. Centuries Ago Greek and other logicians tried to make sense out of mathematical proofs. As time went on other people tried to do the same thing but using only symbols and variables. But I will get into detail about that a little later.
Clinton Essay Research Paper Whether or not
Clinton Essay, Research Paper Whether or not to have the trial be held in public or private, symbolizes the trial. A simple question that is answered by common sense, made to just prolong a trial that serves no purpose, but to explain the bungling of two parities walking in the dark. At this stage in the proceeding there is nothing left to deliberate, no posturing left to do.
Argument About The Exist Of God Essay
, Research Paper Argument About The Exist of God The following paper will provide a sound argument in favor of the existence of God. By demonstrating that an Atheist world cannot account for the
Chaucer Reaction Paper Essay Research Paper I
Chaucer Reaction Paper Essay, Research Paper I’m really not sure how a lot of things I took away from Cheryl Brown’s Lecture related to the Canterbury Tales, but they are worthy of reaction nonetheless. I wonder really if we are limited in the English Language with a word like “love” that can mean so many different things.
Hindu Scripture Essay Research Paper Hindu Scriptures
Hindu Scripture Essay, Research Paper Hindu Scriptures are classified into: Shruti (meaning “heard”), Smriti (meaning “remembered”), and Nyaya (meaning “logic”). These classifications are based on the origin of the Scripture. Shruti scripture is thought of as something which was heard directly from God, while Smriti scripture refers to what was written down and remembered.
Hamlet Movie Essay Research Paper The movie
Hamlet Movie Essay, Research Paper The movie of Hamlet was an excellent, as far as book-movies go. I believe it was produced with focus, reason, and logic. The characters were also portrayed with
Logic Is Not Practical Essay Research Paper
LOGIC IS NOT PRACTICAL Who needs logic? Logic is but an entrapment ? a false sense of security to let us rest easy at night. Countless numbers take solace in the world in which
Contrasting Apollo
& Dionysus Essay, Research Paper Contrasting Apollo & Dionysus In Greek mythology, Apollo and Dionysus are nearly opposites of one another, and as with many opposites, life would not operate just quite right
Computer Tech Essay Research Paper Common Network
Computer Tech Essay, Research Paper Common Network Architectures There are many different types of networks used today that could be evaluated. I would like to take a brief look at three main types of networks, the host-based network, the client-based network, and the client-server network. I would like to look at both the advantages and disadvantages of each type.
Early To Bed Essay Research Paper Early
Early To Bed Essay, Research Paper Early to Bed ?Early to bed early to rise makes a man healthy wealthy and wise,? is one of the most widely quoted proverbs from Benjamin Franklin’s Poor Richard’s