Paper
James Smethurst
No portion of Hughes’s literary career has been more commonly
dismissed than that of the 1930s. Even many of Hughes’s admirers compare unfavorably his
writings of the 1930s to his work in other decades. In this view, Hughes’s 1930s efforts
in many different genres–including short and long fiction, poetry, drama, reportage, song
writing–largely sounded over and over the same ham-fisted didactic note, lacking the
lyric humanism and folk wit of his work in the 1920s, 1940s, and 1950s. This asserted
nadir of Hughes’s literary efforts is almost always related to his engagement with the
CPUSA.
That Hughes was, with the exception of Richard Wright, the black writer most identified
with the Communist Left during the 1930s is undeniable. Hughes’s frequent publication of
"revolutionary" poetry in the journals and press of the CPUSA, his activity in
Communist-initiated campaigns such as the drive to free the Scottsboro defendants and on
behalf of the Spanish Republic, his willingness to lend his name to Communist-led or
Communist-influenced organizations (e.g., the John Reed Clubs, the League of Struggle for
Negro Rights, the National Negro Congress, the League of Professional Groups for Foster
and Ford, the League of American Writers), and his public support of the Soviet Union
(including his signing of a statement in 1938 supporting the purges of the Old Bolsheviks
and others by Stalin) all marked him as an open member of the Communist Left–whether or
not he formally joined the CPUSA. As noted in chapter I, Hughes’s Left sympathies
antedated the Great Depression. But it is unquestionably true that Hughes’s participation
in the Left increased astronomically during the 1930s and had a marked impact on the form
and content (to use a favorite phrase of Left cultural critics of that time) of Hughes’s
poetry.
But, in fact, what is formally most interesting about Hughes’s poetry in the 1930s is
that the wide variety of voices, styles, and themes employed by Hughes in the late 1920s
and early 1930s and addressed to equally disparate audiences become largely unified by the
end of the decade in a manner that is crucial to the development of his later work. This
process of unification results in Shakespeare in Harlem (1942) and, ultimately, Montage
of a Dream Deferred (1951), in which formerly distinct addresses and addressees are
combined to imagine a single audience and a single subject. Or, to draw on Bahktin’s
discussion of the novel, if a diversity of speakers and auditors could be said to be
retained by Hughes, this diversity is contained within a single volume in a dialogic
relation rather than in different volumes and journals speaking to different audiences.
The poetic voice that Hughes creates, unlike the voice established in most of the work of
Sterling Brown, is not that of the individual narratorial consciousness, but of a
simultaneously unitary and multiple urban community. While the persona of the
poet-narrator may appear in a poem, as it does in "Air Raid Over Harlem," the
poet-speaker is a liminal figure, who is both inside and outside the community, and whose
only authority is that arrogated by the community. This relatively unified poetic voice,
or collection of voices, bespeaks the existence of a new kind of audience, one which
Hughes had a major part in creating, particularly through his work in the cultural
institutions of the Communist Left. Ironically, despite Hughes’s activity within the
cultural (as well as more strictly "political") organizations and institutions
affiliated with the CPUSA, his poetry frequently received mixed or poor reviews from
left-wing American critics.
The range of addresses and addressees in Hughes’s poetry reached its zenith in the
early 1930s. During this period Hughes largely abandoned the types of poems that had made
his 1927 Fine Clothes to the Jew so notorious in the black press: poems formally
rooted in the secular and sacred musical forms of the blues and gospel music, as well as
in black rhetoric and representing as speaking subjects such "low-life"
characters as prostitutes, gamblers, murderers, drunks, and suicides. Instead Hughes’s
published poems fell into three general categories aimed at three relatively discrete
audiences: "uplift" and comic poems aimed largely at an African-American
audience that was outside the cultural orbit of the CPUSA, and outside the groups of black
intellectuals associated with relatively elite institutions and journals such as The
Crisis and Opportunity in such urban centers as New York, Boston, Philadelphia,
and Washington; "literary" poems (as exemplified by those in the privately
printed collection Dear Lovely Death, which if not "high" modernist were
aimed at an audience that was consciously "literary" and "modern");
and Hughes’s "revolutionary" or militant poems aimed at an audience defined
largely by the cultural institutions of the CPUSA and the Comintern. As we shall see, the
distinctions between these categories and their intended audiences are quite real.
However, on closer examination Hughes’s general formal strategies, and his sense of the
work of the different types of poems, are not as far apart as they appear.
The largest part of Hughes’s poetic production during the 1930s was his
"revolutionary poetry," often seen as his weakest or strongest work according to
the political bent of the critic. Given the anti-communism that has dominated American
intellectual life since the 1940s, the predominant critical view has been that these poems
are among Hughes’s slightest. (As we shall see, critics associated with the Communist Left
in the 1930s often did not value Hughes’s work much more than the anti-Communist critics.)
Few of these scholars who dismiss Hughes’s work of the 1930s consider the poetry formally
in any specific way. (For that matter, the proponents of Hughes’s revolutionary poems
rarely consider formal questions, either.) All in all these critics seem to accept the
assumption that has been frequently attributed to intellectuals and artists most closely
connected with the CPUSA: that the form of the revolutionary poem is, or should be,
transparent, allowing the clear viewing of the message or "line." This poetry is
seen as beyond form, but somehow filled with an unmediated, and generally false,
meaning–to read one of these poems is to read them all. In short, such poetry is
sloganeering and a slogan, as everyone knows, is inherently uninteresting except perhaps
sociologically.
Such undervaluation of Hughes’s revolutionary poetry misses the sly voice inhabiting
the poems. This voice usually means what it says, but never quite says all that it means
in a straightforward way. Instead it remains elusive through a skillful use of syntactic
manipulation, rhythm, and other formal devices, conveying multiple meanings to multiple
audiences. In this regard, it is ironic that with the plethora of critical discussions of
the trope of the trickster and his or her linguistic polysemy, virtually none examine the
work of Hughes, and certainly none consider his revolutionary poetry in this manner.
Perhaps another way to say this is that there is a lyrical music to much of the 1930s
poetry that requires the same sensitivity to tone and nuance as has been brought to bear
on Hughes’s blues poetry, most notably by Steven Tracy. What has also been generally
missed in Hughes’s revolutionary poetry is the continued connection with modernism
formally and thematically as Hughes, like nearly all other radical poets of the 1930s,
writes quite consciously with the legacy of earlier modernist art and literature in mind.
One of the most interesting things about "Broadcast on Ethipoia," for
example, is the use of thee literary equivalent of the modernist montage: wild shifts of
voice, typography, diction, rhythm, rhyme, line length, stanzaic form and its
interpolation of song, prose items, expressions of mass culture, and sound effects often
occurring simultaneously. Of course, the use of these typically modernist devices was
certainly not restricted to Hughes, but was common among many left-wing poets, including
Kenneth Fearing, Muriel Rukeyser, Joy Davidman, and, as will be examined in the next
chapter, other black writers such as Frank Marshall Davis.
Hughes differed from a number of these Left poets, particularly Fearing and Davidman,
in that Hughes’s work in the 1930s basically argued that popular culture was a field of
contestation with the ruling class, whereas Fearing and Davidman (and novelist Nathaniel
West), like many American intellectuals of the Communist Left, saw mass culture as a
hegemonic web of social control anticipating the later critiques of the Frankfurt School.
Although they did not generally attempt to represent an alternate "people’s"
culture (as did Sterling Brown), Fearing and Davidman drew on mass culture in ways to show
mass culture as an instrument of containment of revolutionary impulses (or genuine human
feeling). In this respect, Hughes is essentially optimistic, even in his most despairing
radical poetry, (such as "Broadcast on Ethiopia"), where Fearing and Davidman
are pessimistic–as are a surprising number of Left poets in the 1930s. Hughes embraced
the aesthetic possibilities suggested by Popular Front ideology very early when many other
Left poets and artists retained a sort of Third Period aesthetic, preferring either
pessimism, as did Fearing and Davidman, or else locating poetic value in
"popular" forms of the "folk" supposedly outside of mass culture, as
did writers Sterling Brown and Don West and the participants of the Left folk song
movement of the Popular Front.
While the modernist literature of the 1920s has often been opposed to the proletarian
literature movement of the 1930s, to a large extent the older Left writers and readers
associated with journals such as New Masses saw themselves as proceeding out of
modernism, particularly in matters of form. Thus Hughes, in part, made use of a sort of
pastiche or montage technique to reach an audience of the Left intelligentsia brought up
on literary modernism. As in the case of "Broadcast on Ethiopia," it could
argued that the coupling of modernist form and generic modernist sentiment
("Civilization’s gone to hell") with the specific content of the poem was in
itself a sort of assessment of "high" modernism, perhaps referring to Pound’s
engagement with Italian fascism. Of course, reflecting Hughes’s abiding interest in drama,
many of the effects that seem modernist on the page can also be seen as instructions for
oral performance in which the different voices would not seem so disruptive as on the
printed page. Even so, the poems Hughes wrote and read for primarily African-American
audiences in the early and middle 1930s, particularly southern black audiences, were more
formally conservative than the "revolutionary" poetry. As seen above, the poetry
Hughes wrote for southern African-American audiences in the early 1930s shared thematic
concerns, and even broad formal strategies, with his "revolutionary" poetry. But
where simultaneous voices existed, they were more explicitly labeled in such a way as to
reduce the experience of fragmentation or dislocation than was the case with his
explicitly "Left" work.
From The New Red Negro: The Literary Left and African American Poetry, 1930-1946.
Copyright ? 1999 by Oxford University Press.
Другие работы по теме:
Langston Hughes And His Significance As A
Black American And As A Poet. Essay, Research Paper Langston Hughes was famous for his poetry, which helped to fuel the civil rights movement. His poetry also earned him fame but he still seemed to remain financially disabled. He didn’t get much recognition for his poetry until after he died.
Langston Hughes Essay Research Paper Poetry in
Langston Hughes Essay, Research Paper Poetry in Motion – Langston Hughes Langston Hughes was a poet that lived from 1902-1967. He was a very distinguished poet of the Harlem Renaissance, the great out pouring of african-american art. The poetry of Langston Huges is very different, yet it held the reader’s attention.
Langston Hughs Essay Research Paper He
Langston Hughs Essay, Research Paper ? He was called ? Shakespeare in Harlem,? The blues poet, the ?Simple? man on the street, The voice of Black Harlem ? (Tolson 1) Possessing qualities unlike any other, Langston Hughes believed that there was no difference between the common experiences of Black America and his own personal experiences. ?His life and work were enormously important in shaping the artistic contributions of the Harlem Renaissance of the 1920 ?s ? (Tolson 1) Hughes wrote vividly about the life, luxury, and hardships of the poor black working class.
Shattering The Darkness Essay Research Paper SHATTERING
Shattering The Darkness Essay, Research Paper SHATTERING THE DARKNESS In the poem “As I Grew Older ” by Langston Hughes, a young man is thinking about his goals and that he cannot achieve them because of racial prejudice. The theme of the poem is that prejudice is used to keep people from accomplishing their dreams.
DickinsonS And HugheS Poems Comparison Essay Research
Paper Emily Camberg Reading Poetry 124L Paper One 11/8/99 After reading both “Tell All the Truth but Tell It Slant” by Emily Dickinson and “Harlem” by Langston Hughes, I determined that the main difference between the two poems is both poets’ use of diction. Dickinson makes use of abstract diction in her poem, using words like bright, delight, superb, and dazzle.
Sythesis OrwellHughesMilgrim Essay Research Paper DecisionsMany people
Sythesis, Orwell,Hughes,Milgrim Essay, Research Paper Decisions Many people find it difficult, if not impossible, to defy the unspoken tradition of modern authority. Stanley Milgrim s Perils of disobedience shows that an otherwise sensitive, good-natured citizen can easily be transformed into a tool, and perform actions that one would never do if given enough time to reflect.
Lagston Hughes Essay Research Paper Mother to
Lagston Hughes Essay, Research Paper Mother to Son In Langston Hues poem Mother to Son, strong poetic elements are used to express the feeling he has about the past, present, and future as an African American. Although all the elements in this peaice of work do not stand out, they due exist. They help Hughes bring his message across both subtly and strongly, all depending on how, Mother to Son, is interpreted.
Langston Hughes Essay Research Paper What was
Langston Hughes Essay, Research Paper What was the dream that brought our ancestors to America? It was rebirth, the craving for men to be born again, the yearning for a second chance. With all of these ideas comes the true American dream Freedom. This is the condition in which a man feels like a human being. It is the purpose and consequence of rebirth.
Nature And The Human Soul Essay Research
Paper Langston Hughes uses nature in several dimensions to demonstrate the powerful struggles and burdens of human life. Throughout several of Langston Hughes poems, the sweeping imagery of the beauty and power of nature demonstrates the struggles the characters confront, and their eventual freedom from those struggles.
Symbolism In Langston Hughes
’ “On The Way Home” Essay, Research Paper Although race is a constant theme in Langston Hughes’s writings, critics note his ability to write about essentially racial themes while delineating the
The Theme For English B Essay Research
Paper In the poem “Theme for English B,” by Langston Hughes, he talks about the African American struggle for equality. The poem starts off with a professor giving his students a paper to write about whatever subject they want. The instructor says to th students, “let that paper come out of you then, it will be true.” In the paper, Hughes explains everything that comes from his heart, just like his professor wanted him too.
Theme For English B
– Different, But The Same Essay, Research Paper In the poem, Theme for English B, Langston Hughes points out that we are often reluctant to admit that our similarities are often more common than our differences. Even though he is colored, he is still just like his white instructor in many ways. The colored man may appear to be different from the white man on the outside, but we are all the same on the inside.
The Harlem Renaissance And Langston Hughes Essay
, Research Paper Humanities 1020 November 29, 2000 The Harlem Renaissance and Langston Hughes The Harlem Renaissance was a great and powerful era in black history, ?It was an African American cultural movement of the 1920s and early 1930s that was centered in the Harlem neighborhood of New York City? (?Harlem Renaissance?).
Comparison Of Langston Hues Peices Essay Research
Paper The short story ?Thank You, Ma?am? and the poem ?Mother to Son?, both by Langston Hughes are similar yet differ in many ways. In the following paragraphs I will explain the similarities and the differences.
Life Of Langston Hughes Essay Research Paper
James Langston Hughes was born February 1, 1902 in Joplin, Missouri to parents James Nathaniel and Carrie Mercer. He attended Columbia University and was a member of numerous organizations including the Authors Guild and Omega Psi Phi. His career as a poet, novelist, short story writer, playwright, song lyricist, radio writer, translator, children?s book author, and lecturer included 35 published plays, 1 screenplay, 2 operas, 3 songs, and numerous amounts of poetry, prose, and other literature.
Blackness Essay Research Paper BlacknessWhat is it
Blackness Essay, Research Paper Blackness What is it to be black? What is it to be white? Why are so many people looking to fit under a color s stereotype? To be born black is no longer the only factor or standard of blackness. Langston Hughes is a highly celebrated and commended author of the Harlem Renaissance.
Theme For English B Essay Research Paper
In the poem “Theme for English B”, by Langston Hughes, Hughes talks about the African American struggle for equality. This is a common subject for Hughes. In many of his poems he speaks about blacks and the injustices that they face. Another common subject for Hughes is the town, Harlem, which is also mentioned in “Theme for English B.”The poem starts off with an instructor giving his students a paper to write, the instructor says to the student, “let that page come out of you-Then, it will be true.” The poem is continued as the paper that Hughes is writing.
The South Essay Research Paper The South
The South Essay, Research Paper The South The South has many objects associated with it, to where it is considered either a beautiful place or very disturbing. In The South , Langston Hughes describes his feelings of the south from the point of view of a black man who
Visions And Voices Essay Research Paper Visions
Visions And Voices Essay, Research Paper Visions and Voices The biographical film of Langston Hughes is both informative and entertaining. It approaches Hughes s life with insightful observations from the people that personally knew him. The film goes into detail on his family background and early life before his poetic success, and continues through his life in Harlem, his literary achievements, and legacy.
Biography Of Langston Hughes Essay Research Paper
Langston Hughes was born in Joplin, Missouri, in 1902. His father, who had studied to become a lawyer, left for Mexico shortly after the baby was born. When Langston was seven or eight he went to live with his grandmother, who told him wonderful stories about Frederick Douglass and Sojourner Truth and took him to hear Booker T.
Dreams Deferred Essay Research Paper Dreams DeferredThe
Dreams Deferred Essay, Research Paper Dreams Deferred The poem, A Dream Deferred, by Langston Hughes, accurately and descriptively portrays the attitudes of African American people during the mid 1900 s. Hughes expresses the possible responses of African Americans to their dreams being deferred by means of metaphors and similes.
Commentary On Langston Hughes Essay Research Paper
Commentary on Langston Hughes Poem: Let America Be America Again According to a poem written by Langston Hughes tilted Let America Be America Again, he addresses the plight of America. He focuses his attention on the deferred dreams of those who dare to believe in the principles of equality and opportunity.
Salvation Essay Research Paper In the reading
Salvation Essay, Research Paper In the reading Salvation by Langston Hughs, there are many different underlying themes. There is the thought that even though it may be safer to be non-confrontational, it is not always the best approach. The adults wanting the children to be saved , portrays this. Being “saved”, involves an inner peace that results in a faith in a higher power.
Langston Hughes Essay Research Paper LANGSTON HUGHESBibliographyIn
Langston Hughes Essay, Research Paper LANGSTON HUGHES Bibliography In 1902, Langston Hughes was born in Joplin, Missouri. He grew up in many different places such as Kansas, Illinois, and Ohio. His birth given name was James Mercer Langston Hughes. Later he dropped the first two names. Mary Patterson Leary Carrie Mercer Langston Hughes, Langston s mother, was a schoolteacher.
Langston Hughes Essay Research Paper Bryan SnyderFebruary
Langston Hughes Essay, Research Paper Bryan Snyder February 19, 2001 Prof. Castro English 220 Langston Hughes The writing style of Langston Hughes is best described as reflective of the lyric style and format of the blues, a musical genre that became popular in America at approximately the same time as his poetry.
Langston Hughes Essay Research Paper Langston Hughes
Langston Hughes Essay, Research Paper Langston Hughes: Poetry to the People I had been a writer who wrote mostly because, when I felt bad, writing kept me from feeling worse; it out my inner emotions into exterior form, and gave me an outlet for words that never came in conversation.
Langston Huges Essay Research Paper Langston Hughes
Langston Huges Essay, Research Paper Langston Hughes Langston Hughes was born on February 1, 1902 in Joplin, Missouri. His father was James Nathaniel and his mother was Carrie Mercer Langston Hughes. His grandfather was Charles Langston, an Ohio abolitionist. As a young boy he lived in Buffalo, New York, Cleveland, Ohio, Lawrence, Kansas, Mexico City, Topeka, Kansas, Colorado Springs, Colorado, and Kansas City, Kansas.
Langston Hughes Essay Research Paper Fields 1When
Langston Hughes Essay, Research Paper Fields 1 When writing, one may take into consideration his or her surroundings such as living environment and for family and friends. One may reflect on experiences from the past and present. All these things together form the writer s style. Because of traveling overseas and living in Harlem, Langston Hughes used illustrative words and different musical rhythms in his poems and stories to show the life of Negroes.
Are People Obedient Essay Research Paper ARE
Are People Obedient Essay, Research Paper ARE PEOPLE OBEDIENT? By Queron Thompson Does everyone in society go against what they believe in merely to satisfy an authority figure? Stanley Milgram?s ?Perils Of Obedience? expresses that most of society supports the authority figure regardless of their own personal ideals.
Dream Deferred Essay Research Paper The poem
Dream Deferred Essay, Research Paper The poem, “Dream Deferred”, which was written by Langston Hughes in 1951 , described the trials that minorities in that time period underwent. Hughes uses heavy symbolism and imagery in this poem. The dream he discussed in the poem was futile at the time of his writing of the poem.
Langston Hughes Essay Research Paper Triple P
Langston Hughes Essay, Research Paper Triple P s Extra Credit The Negro Speaks of Rivers by Langston Hughes is an amazing epic poem showing the depth of a person s soul. It actually gave me the chills while reading it. It is
Poetry Paper 2 Essay Research Paper The
Poetry Paper 2 Essay, Research Paper The Journey Through Life Langston Hughes poem The Negro Speaks of Rivers presents an African-American man describing his personal experiences and the history of his race. In many of his works, Langston Hughes uses nature in several dimensions to demonstrate the powerful struggles and burdens of human life.
Negro Speaks Essay Research Paper The Negro
Negro Speaks Essay, Research Paper The Negro Speaks of Rivers The poem The Negro Speaks of River , written by Langston Hughes, speaks loudly of the creativity of black people who have in essence have a rich history beginning from the dawn of civilization. Langston Hughes was born in 1902 and past in 1967,and was the first writer to make a living off of his writing, during the Harlem Renaissance.