Paper
Age Discrimination Act of 1967
The airline industry has been involved in several age discrimination cases due to their pilot s required retirement policy; which states that pilots must retire at age 60. The airlines main concerns are that the pilots are not physically capable to perform job duties adequately after age 60. It is thought that job performance declines with increasing age. People may become less coordinated and attentive, develop slower reaction times, and may develop degenerative eyesight. The airlines feel that this is putting their company and passengers in danger if pilots over 60 are allowed to fly. The pilots often disagree and state they are as physically fit as younger pilots and have much more experience. One case we can relate this issue to is United Airlines, Inc. v. McMann. McMann joined United Airlines, Inc. in 1944, and continued employment there until his retirement at age 60 in 1973. At the time when McMann was first employed, United maintained a formal retirement income plan it had begun in 1941, in which McMann was eligible to participate, but was not compelled to join. He voluntarily joined the plan in January 1964. The application form McMann signed showed the normal retirement age for participants in his category as 60 years.
McMann reached his 60th birthday on January 23, 1973, and was retired on February 1, 1973, over his objection. He then filed a notice of intent to sue United for violation of the Act pursuant to 29 U.S.C. 626 (d). Although he received an opinion from the Department of Labor that United’s plan was bona fide and did not appear to be a subterfuge to evade the purposes of the Act, he brought this suit to court. McMann’s suit in the District Court seeking injunctive relief, reinstatement, and backpay alleged his forced retirement was solely because of his age and was unlawful under the Act. United’s response was that McMann was retired in compliance with the provisions of a bona fide retirement plan which he had voluntarily joined. On facts as set, the District Court granted United’s motion for summary judgment. McMann argues the term “normal retirement age” is not defined in the plan other than in a provision that “A Participant’s Normal Retirement Date is the first day of the month following his 60th birthday.” From this he contends normal retirement age does not mean mandatory retirement at age 60, and United therefore did not retire him under legal laws. The court ruled that normal means regular or standard, not average, so McMann ending up losing the case and congress continued to regard retirement plans favorably. This argument continues to arise in many airline pilot retirements and the outcome remains the same every time.
Storage Technology Corporation has been involved with similar suits. Two discrimination lawsuits brought against the company four years ago by employees let go in the company s mass layoffs of the mid- 90s. The suits accused StorageTek of targeting older workers and those with actual or potential health problems when it laid off hundreds of workers from April 13, 1993 to December 31, 1996. The suits alleged employees were laid off for reasons such as their age, personal illness or illness of an insured family member. The suits also accused former StorageTek executives of suggesting that employee s lifestyles, including obesity and smoking, would be taken into account in corporate decision-making. StorageTek denied the claims.
StorageTek agreed to settle with a $5 million settlement divided among the 414 members of the class. ERISA, the second suit, did not involve money in its settlement, but StorageTek did agree to revise its policies and training to include non-discrimination on the basis of medical and other benefits. The suit covered 1,266 former employees, including those involved in the age-discrimination suit. As settlement has been reached, the parties will return to court on March 8, 2001 to enter their settlement agreement and close these cases.
KARE 11 TV Station v. Ryther is another example of an age discrimination suit. C. Thomas Ryther was employed at KARE 11 as a sports caster for 12 years until 1991. At 53 years old, KARE refused to renew Ryther s contract and a 33-year-old sports caster replaced him. In 1993, Ryther brings this case to the U.S. district court in Minnesota for age discrimination. Judge David F. Doty instructed the jury that in order to rule for Ryther, he had to prove he was intentionally discriminated against based on age. The jury had to decide if Ryther was protected by the Age Discrimination Act of 1967, which included 3 questions:
1) Was Ryther 40 years of age or older?
2) Was his job performance satisfactory?
3) Did someone younger replace him?
The jury concluded that Ryther was older than 40 and someone younger did replace him. KARE 11 argued that Ryther s dismissal was due to his low ratings based on the market surveys. In 1993, the jury ruled in favor of Ryther and awarded him $717,777. KARE appealed to the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. The court upheld the ruling and increased the award to Ryther in the amount of $1.25 million. KARE 11 tried one last attempt to appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court and they also upheld the $1.25 million age bias award on June 27, 1997.
Age discrimination is becoming more prevalent in the United States. There are widespread beliefs that productivity, job satisfaction and job performance decreases with an increase in age. But there are positive qualities found in aging employees. Job turnover is lower, fewer unavoidable absences and studies prove that job productivity does not decline. In conclusion, the Age Discrimination Act of 1967 was designed to protect individuals against age bias employers. Unfortunately, it does not stop employers completely from discriminating, but at least there is some comfort for older employed Americans.
Другие работы по теме:
Discrimination Essay Research Paper Fred L Pincus
Discrimination Essay, Research Paper Fred L. Pincus, author of “From Individual to Structural Discrimination”, is arguing that discrimination is still present among many individual and institutions. The reason why it is not unlawful, according to Pincus, is because the discrimination is so subtle and in some cases it is not done intentionally.
Pregancy Discrimination Essay Research Paper Pregnancy DiscriminationThere
Pregancy Discrimination Essay, Research Paper Pregnancy Discrimination. There are many issues to consider in pregnancy discrimination. The well-being of the child, the well-being of the mother, employer/employee relations, as well as gender issues. There are however several State and Federal laws that protect people against pregnancy discrimination.
Descrimination Essay Research Paper discrimination1 The
Descrimination Essay, Research Paper discrimination 1. The federal government attempted to use many laws to protect the rights of the newly freed slaves, such as the Civil rights Act of 1866, which gave African Americans the right
Discrimination Essay Research Paper Most people think
Discrimination Essay, Research Paper Most people think the United States is a good place to live, however the United States has more discrimination problems then any other nation. By eliminating, or reducing discrimination the United States would make living here pleasant for all of its residents. As a result, stopping discrimination would, make people feel safe to be then selves, allow an equal opportunity for everyone, and expand U.S culture.
Racism Essay Research Paper The understanding of
Racism Essay, Research Paper The understanding of prejudice can lead to us removing of racism and discrimination in our country. Stereotyping, or forming a set of characteristics thought to be common to all members of a certain group, leads to prejudice influencing the observer to be part of a group rather than an individual.
Racsim Essay Research Paper Racism is a
Racsim Essay, Research Paper Racism is a very big issue. I think most people say things without realising they are being racist. This doesn t excuse their behaviour but most people
Sex Religion Discrimination Essay Research Paper The critical
Sex+Religion Discrimination Essay, Research Paper The critical issue in this case is whether Farm Fresh Food, Inc. acted lawfully by denying employment to Jennifer Brand. Farm Fresh Foods further claim that Ms. Brand failed to establish a prima facie case of discrimination based on sex or religion. Furthermore, they claim that even had such case been established, Farm Fresh decision to deny employment to Ms.
Do White Males Have Anything To Fear
From Affirmative Action Essay, Research Paper Do white males have anything to fear from Affirmative Action? Affirmative Action can be defined as policies used in the United States to increase opportunities for minorities by favoring them in hiring and promotion, college admissions, and the awarding of government contracts.
Discrimination Essay Research Paper When people think
Discrimination Essay, Research Paper When people think about discrimination, they usually associate it with prejudice and connect it with race and gender. But discrimination can take another form. For example, a person can gain an unfair advantage at a job interview by being attractive or by being able to talk about something that has nothing to do with the job, like sports.
Defining Racism And The Difficulties Of Proving
Discrimination Essay, Research Paper Defining Racism and the Difficulties of Proving Discrimination Our group is taking the position that the perception of the criminal justice system as being racist is a myth. Since this assertion can be interpreted in many ways, it is necessary to specify what it means and does not mean.
Discrimination Against Gays Essay Research Paper discrimination
Discrimination Against Gays Essay, Research Paper discrimination against gaysAbout ten percent of the population is homosexually oriented and discriminated against. Discrimination denies lesbian and gay individuals or couples rights in today’s society. Problems that homosexuals face on a daily basis are employment in the military, encountering issues being a couple, and acceptance among others.
Sex And Work Essay Research Paper Sex
Sex And Work Essay, Research Paper Sex and Work Women have made some strides in overcoming harassment and discrimination, but there is still a long way to go. When a corporate meeting is taking place, before the meeting, all the guys will be sitting around telling their little stories, until a woman walks in.
Light Vs Dark Essay Research Paper Light
Light Vs. Dark Essay, Research Paper Light vs. Dark Today we watched a movie in class on light skinned black people and dark skinned black people. The movie was based on the discrimination between the two colors. There are many tones of blackness and according to the movie there is a battle between the different shades of who is the dominant shade.
Discrimination Extinct Or Is Essay Research Paper
” Discrimination: extinct, or is it?” Who says discrimination doesn t exist in present day? Newspapers, television, and people all around us are methods of seeing that discrimination occurs everyday of our lives. There might be those people who say that it is extinct, but then again, do they come in contact with people outside their own race? Discrimination is something that is here with is for as long as we live.
Inequality On Women Essay Research Paper How
Inequality On Women Essay, Research Paper How USA differs from the world in discrimination.Discrimination may be defined as a treatment or consideration which is based on class or category rather than individual merit. People around the world discriminate between classes to their own certain extents.
Discrimination Essay Research Paper Discrimination You
Discrimination Essay, Research Paper Discrimination You see it everyday, people treating each other as though we are not all equals. As though we are not all human. Discrimination! Whether it is on the street or on the job, you see it everywhere. There is discrimination against the mentally and physically challenged, against people of different cultures, and people of the opposite sex, just to name a few.
Affirmative Action Reverse Discrimination Essay Research Paper
Affirmative Action = Reverse Discrimination We are all aware that discrimination took place over 50 years ago. What some might not be aware of is that because of the actions of our ancestors, we, white males, are held responsible and are penalized because of these actions. Affirmative action is a way to help minorities in sex and race to get accepted into colleges or get hired for jobs while the white males suffer from what took place over 50 years ago.
Supreme Court Bakke Essay Research Paper BakkeI
Supreme Court Bakke Essay, Research Paper Bakke I do not wish to reverse history and go back to the period of time, where discrimination was present and influential in every aspect of our society. However, I do wish to make sure that while making sure that the once oppressed minorities do not have to endure the discrimination ever again, the rights of persons such as myself are not violated in the name of doing the supposed higher good.
On Aids And Moral Duty Discrimination
Goes On Essay, Research Paper The two essays I read were On Aids and Moral Duty by Willard Gaylin and Discrimination Goes On by Robert H. Cohen. On Aids and Moral Duty says that HIV positive individuals have a moral responsibility to let others know they are HIV positive to protect innocent people from unknowingly contracting the virus.
Equality Essay Research Paper Equality
Equality Essay, Research Paper Equality I have a vision, that all people be treated equally. Race, religion, sex, age, and other petty differences should not mater. Every one has a rite to me
The Definition Essay Essay Research Paper The
The Definition Essay Essay, Research Paper The Definition of the Discrimination The psychological meaning of the word discrimination is the ability to see and respond the differences among stimuli. IN other words, discrimination is the process when one group putting them over the other. This is a traditional meaning, which have been existed from the long time ago until now.
Sexual Harassment Essay Research Paper Sexual Harassment 2
Sexual Harassment Essay, Research Paper Sexual Harassment, a form of unlawful sex discrimination. Under federal law in the United States, sexual harassment is unwanted verbal or physical behavior of a sexual nature that occurs in the workplace or in an educational setting under certain conditions. Such behavior is illegal if it creates an environment that is hostile or intimidating, if it interferes with a person’s work or school performance, or if acceptance of the harasser’s behavior is made a condition of employment or academic achievement.
Discrimination In The Work Pla Essay Research
Paper Discrimination in the Work Place Discrimination can be expressed in many different ways, which no matter what can be very hurtful to a person. Discrimination itself means making a distinction in favor of or against, a person or thing based on the group, class, or category to which that person or thing belongs rather than on individual merit (definition 2).
Discrimination In The US Essay Research Paper
Discrimination Discrimination in the U.S., I think has dramatically changed since the 1940’ s-1960. Black Americans have gained the right to eat at public lunch counters, vote, ride public buses, and attend public schools. There still is some racism in the United States. In this essay I am going to tell you some examples of racism that I have heard of.
Adoption Discrimination Essay Research Paper Adoption Discrimination
Adoption Discrimination Essay, Research Paper Adoption Discrimination In a world today, where nothing is no longer black and white people still view it as that and make ignorant decisions. Discrimination doesn t just lurk around dark corners, it thrives in the every day lives of all human beings. Adoption discrimination is just one of the injustices trapping innocent people.
American Dream Essay Research Paper scribes the
American Dream Essay, Research Paper scribes the defeat of the American dream, and that the American ideals differ with the actual social conditions that exist in society. For the American constitutions stands for the freedom, and equality among people, but the truth of the matter is that social discrimination still exists and the grouping among the classes can never be overcome.
Discrimination In USA Essay Research Paper The
Discrimination In USA Essay, Research Paper The 1920?s were a period of economic boom in USA, but most of all, of discrimination. There were two groups who, apart from remaining out of the economic boom, were discriminated and suffered poverty. These people were Blacks and Immigrants.
Racism Essay Research Paper RacismWhat is racism
Racism Essay, Research Paper Racism What is racism? Racism is the mistreatment of a group of people on the basis of race, colour, and religion. The term racism may also mean a blind and pointless hatred, envy or prejudice.
Sexism Essay Research Paper SexismSo what exactly
Sexism Essay, Research Paper Sexism So what exactly is sexism? Sexism is the belief that rights and roles in ones society should be governed by ones sex. Historically, sexism has been male-driven and
Aids In Africa Essay Research Paper Dear
Aids In Africa Essay, Research Paper Dear, Dr. Feedlebom of ?Conspiracies and Cover ups? magazine. I would like to share with you some information concerning the Aids epidemic in Africa. HIV, which causes