Russia's bid to join the World Trade Organisation (WTO), filed in 1993, has been the longest accession saga in the history of the world trade body. Yet now, after bilateral deals with the US and the European Union that secured their support for the membership bid, Russia looks set to join the pantheon of rules-based global capitalism at some point next year.
This is welcome news. Russia would benefit from being part of the WTO club. Its exports will not get much of a boost because they are dominated by the hydrocarbons and minerals (representing more than two thirds of total exports) and they are already traded at zero or very low tariffs. But Russia will benefit from lower prices of imported consumer and industrial goods, and, hopefully, from an increase in foreign direct investment (FDI).
If the Kremlin also decides to follow the WTO rule book, membership will help to constrain Russia's erratic trade policy, especially its regular descents into protectionism. Naturally, that would be of value for exporters to Russia (and for importers of Russian goods, too, as Russia regularly uses export taxes), but the biggest beneficiary would be Russia itself. The biggest casualty of protectionism is always the country that imposes such measures.
Other countries would benefit from Russian WTO membership through a reduction in tariffs - average tariffs will go down from 12-14 percent to around 8 percent - and from an improvement in their predictability. The sectors that will benefit specifically from a reduction in tariffs are civil aircraft, construction, agricultural and scientific equipment, and medical devices.
Russia will need to introduce greater transparency (and less discrimination) in its system for product standards, licenses and other so-called non-tariff barriers (NTBs). Moreover, sectors dependent on intellectual property, such as chemicals and biotechnology, will benefit from having recourse to the WTO's accord on intellectual property rights (TRIPS) to discipline Russia's shambolic IPR policy. Finally, foreign banks and insurance firms will be granted bigger opportunities to do business in Russia.
But there are also risks and downsides to having Russia as member of the WTO. The biggest risk is that the Kremlin will simply disregard rulings against Russia in the dispute-settlement system, the backbone of the WTO. As the WTO itself cannot enforce rulings that require policy change in a country, the system requires that countries respect the authority of the dispute-settlement body and that bigger and more powerful countries avoid playing power games with smaller nations over rulings.
The case for respecting rulings is simple: it is in everyone's interest that countries adhere to agreed rules. The weakness is the same as for all systems that depend on enlightened interest for a common good: some may free ride on the system in the belief that it benefits them, at least in the short term. And if some are free-riding, others will follow. And the system will unravel.
This risk is underlined by Russia's recent history of flaunting international agreements (and, as in the case of the Energy Charter Treaty, withdrawing from agreements) in the belief that no one would have the courage to fight the Kremlin to the bitter end.
Russian membership will also add a new layer of difficulties for WTO negotiations, like the current Doha Round. Russia will be part of the protectionist wing of the membership and will resist in areas that are central to world trade today and in future, like freeing up services trade, cutting red tape that prevents trade, and limiting the freedom to subsidize domestic firms at the expense of foreign competitors.
It will also enforce the opposition to addressing "old" issues, like reducing or eliminating tariffs on consumer and industrial goods. Russia's manufacturing sector is weak - it only represents 6-7 percent of Russia's export - and suffers from the Dutch disease: the heavy reliance on hydrocarbon exports have pushed the real exchange rate to such a degree that the manufacturing sector has suffered. Many industries are saddled with old Soviet technologies, and they survive on subsidies and border protectionism.
There are positive signs that Russia is keen to change its economic model. The new Kremlin rhetoric on modernization and the privatization plans suggest that energy and state-based economic authoritarianism is on a downward trend. The new dawn in its membership bid for the WTO is also a good sign. But the signs are far too few to be upbeat about Russian economic policy. Like before, optimism over the WTO accession can soon shift to pessimism. The old model is entrenched in the Kremlin economic psyche and there are many powerful figures that dislike the idea of being constrained by international agreements or increased foreign competition. President Medvedev has now secured the support from the US and the European Union for its WTO bid. Now he needs to take the fight with Kremlin colleagues and oligarchs. That may become a far bigger problem.
Fredrik Erixon is director of the European Centre for International Political Economy (ECIPE), an economic think tank based in Brussel
s
Другие работы по теме:
Intergovernmental Vs Supranational Essay Research Paper Intergovernmental
Intergovernmental Vs. Supranational Essay, Research Paper Intergovernmental vs. Supranational The European Union of today has been described as an intergovernmental organization by some scholars and a supranational organization by others. But which one is it in reality? The answer to this question is very trivial.
Rationalism Essay Research Paper Discuss How Rationalism
Rationalism Essay, Research Paper Discuss How Rationalism Changed The World Between 1650 – 1750 Many changes took place between 1650 and 1750. There was territory expansion as European countries started colonies in the Americas. Political changes took place as well, as people began to rise up against the government.
China And Singapores Economy Essay Research Paper
Small countries with no natual resources usually have to fight harder than most to survive. Singapore has taken a carefully-planned approach to economic development- a global warehousing and distribution centre for the Asia-Pacific region. Along with these, Singapore’s entrepot trade in rubber, petroleum products, spices, timber, manufactured goods and machinery has grown over the decades.
Cuban Economy Essay Research Paper Although the
Cuban Economy Essay, Research Paper Although the Cuban economy may be thought of as to some as a complete failure, the command system structure can still be an effective way of creating a
African Empires4 Essay Research Paper The Ancient
African Empires4 Essay, Research Paper The Ancient African Empires were very advanced for there times, they were advanced before any European contacts. Each Empire had its similarities and its differences but none of the empires were exactly the same, but they were all advanced Empires for their time. Even though many people believe that Africa was nothing until the Europeans stumbled upon the land they are very mistaken.
Problems Resulting From The Fall Of Communism
Essay, Research Paper The collapse of communism in Eastern Europe and in The Soviet Union has presented an array of new opportunities but also problems for much of this region. Although, with this collapse the opportunity
America Is Not Benefited By The Fall
Of Euro Essay, Research Paper America Is Not Benefited By the Fall of the Euro “99 in the year ’99, is becoming more and more of a reality”- announced Michael Rosenberg, the director of the research center of international currencies of the Deutsche Bank, last week. Using this formula, Rosenberg emphasized the probability that in 1999 the value of the Euro may fall to 99 cents.
Wwi And Wwii Essay Research Paper Large
Wwi And Wwii Essay, Research Paper Large scale nationalistic values arose in 19th century Europe. This was a time when the majority of the political systems favored liberalism, a belief that there should be a free market economy and also people were rewarded because of their talent not there inherited privilege.
European Union Essay Research Paper Turkey and
European Union Essay, Research Paper Turkey and the European union Let us begin this by looking at what the EU wants from Turkey. The criteria for EU membership adopted by the Copenhagen European Council in June 1993 require that a candidate country has achieved stability of institutions guaranteeing democracy, the rule of law, human rights, and respect for and protection of minorities; has a functioning market economy as well as the capacity to cope with competitive pressure and market forces within the Union; and has the ability to take on the obligations of membership, including adherence to the aims of political, economic and monetary union.
American Education A Disgrace Essay Research Paper
America?s educational infrastructure is the embodiment of all social programs plagued with fundamental flaws. All one must do to come to this concise conclusion is to view the many aspects of America and its international federalism. After all, education is the platform for success on all levels.
Brazil Essay Research Paper BRAZILBrazil is often
Brazil Essay, Research Paper BRAZIL Brazil is often viewed as the economic giant of the Third World. Its economy and territory are larger than the rest of South America?s, and its industry is the most advanced in the developing world. Brazilian foreign debt is also the Third World?s largest. The problem of foreign debt has plagued the Latin American economies since the 1960s, when foreign borrowing was the only way for Latin American nations to sustain economic growth.
The Protestant Reformation Essay Research Paper AP
The Protestant Reformation Essay, Research Paper _______________ AP European History Period 4 The Protestant Reformation The Protestant Reformation changed the course of European history very strongly, and rapidly. This paper will talk about what exactly the reformation did to Europe, in terms of social, political, and philosophical impacts.
Underlying Causes Of Wwi Essay Research Paper
There were many underlying causes for World War I in Europe, but many believe that there were a few main causes. These causes where national pride among various European people, an increase in European armed forces, Imperialism and the formation of military alliances. Nationalism- The French revolution and the Napoleonic era spread throughout Europe the belief that people of the same ethnic origin, language and political ideals had the right to independent states.
Mne Essay Research Paper A major player
Mne Essay, Research Paper A major player in the international political economy is the multinational corporation or multinational enterprise as these structures of economy are commonly referred to. These are business or firms that hold offices and/or major production facilities in two or more different countries.
Influence Of Colonialism In Africa And Latin
America Essay, Research Paper The institutions of imperialism and colonialism have shaped the face of growth and development of the social, political, and economic forces in Africa. As outlined by Boahen, the extent of the ?influence? that these institutions asserted varies and has both positive and negative aspects.
Euro In America Essay Research Paper On
Euro In America Essay, Research Paper On January 1,1999, the world witnessed a change never seen before: eleven nations of the European Union fixed their currencies to each other and established the world?s first common currency, the Euro. The creation of a single European currency will be the most important development in the international monetary system since the adoption of flexible exchange rates in the early 1970.
European Colonization On Africa Essay Research Paper
Back in early African history, Europeans colonized and infiltrated African civilizations in order to make a profit and to be known as a superior nation. By doing this, European colonists ?messed up? the traditional African lifestyle. African?s were willing to let the colonists join them, but the Europeans went too far when they took over governments and tried to rule over the Africans.
Global Economy Essay Research Paper Global economy
Global Economy Essay, Research Paper Global economy is as same as a boat waving and fluctuating among the tides and waves of an ocean in this turmoil international situation, which is characterized by wars her and there, peace process taking place in every part of this world, environmental issue and its implication with the emissions of industry coupled with the depletion of natural resources, the international alliances such as the European Union, eastern countries after the previous soviet Union and its system, the African Union, the middle east countries and their geographical situation and ideologies, and many other factors to mention.
Our Political System Essay Research Paper Our
Our Political System Essay, Research Paper Our Political System Government Institutions and Public Policy By definition, any government is the individuals, institutions, and process that makes and enforces the rules of society. Government has the responsibility to provide for public good, police powers, public services, taxes, and most importantly, to protect the power of the people.
Modernization Vs Dependency Essay Research Paper MODERNIZATION
Modernization Vs. Dependency Essay, Research Paper MODERNIZATION VS. DEPENDENCY The modernization perspective is behavioral or microsociological the primary focus is on individuals or aggregates of individuals, their values, attitudes, and beliefs. The dependency perspective, by contrast, is structural or macrosociological its focus is on the mode of production, patterns of international trade, political and economic linkages between elites in peripheral and central countries, group and class alliances and conflicts, and so on. (Valenzuela & Valenzuela, 1978)
Moscow 4
Moscow Nowadays Moscow is the capital of Russia. It's the largest city of the country. The population of the city is over 10 million. Moscow lies in the valley of the Moskva river. Moscow is a political, administrative, economic, industrial, educational and cultural centre of the Russian Federation.
Should Canada And The Us Trade Essay
, Research Paper Should Canada and the US trade with China? With all the civil rights abused in China, should the Canada and the US be trading with them? In the view of one side, we should not trade with China because of these abused rights. It is thought that if we stop all trade with them, we will have an impact on their economy and they will at least cut down on their civil rights abuses in order to regain our trade and economy.
Economic And Monetary Union Of Europe Essay
, Research Paper ECONOMIC AND MONETARY UNION OF EUROPE The main reason for creating a European Market was the growing international competitiveness. In the mid of the eighties the European countries recognized that in the long run the national economies alone won?t be able to compete against countries like the US, Japan and the new industrial centers in East Asia.
Government Essay Research Paper 2 We know
Government Essay, Research Paper 2. We know that the fundamental difference between ancient political science and modern political science has to do with the relationship of the individual to the state. For Aristotle, a person was an inherently political animal. For modern political philosophers (social contract theorists), individual rights existed prior to the formation of government.
International Law Essay Research Paper MA IN
International Law Essay, Research Paper M.A. IN INTERNATIONAL AND COMPARITIVE LEGAL STUDIES A world that is fast becoming an even smaller place involves an immense amount of changes in terms of policies, outlook and perspectives. This change affects every individual in every country in some manner or the other
American Economy In Today
’s World Essay, Research Paper American Economy in Today’s World It is often wondered how the superpowers achieved their position of dominance. According to time magazine, to be a superpower, a nation needs to have a strong economy, an overpowering military, immense international political power, and related to this, a strong national ideology.
Us Affairs Essay Research Paper The US
Us Affairs Essay, Research Paper The U.S. plays a major role in most of the international affairs because the U.S. is considered to be a powerful nation. The Economy of America is strong, and the military power is one of the biggest in the world. There was a Persian Gulf War back in 1991 when the U.S. attacked Iraq.
European Union Essay Research Paper The European
European Union Essay, Research Paper The European Union is a union of fifteen independent states bases on the European Communities that was founded in 1993 in order to enhance political, economic and social co-operation.
Eu And Usa Essay Research Paper What
Eu And Usa Essay, Research Paper What does a coherent and unified European community (now known as the European Union) mean to the United States? Is it a threat, a competitor, or a partner? Or is it the three combined together? I think it is the three combined together. Depending on the situation, whether economically, politically, or military, the European Union has acted as a threat, competitor or a partner to the United States.
KYIV
Kyiv is the capital of Ukraine. It is a large political, industrial, scientific and cultural centre. Its population equals nearly 3 million people. Kyiv is situated on the Dnieper, the longest river in Ukraine.