Unreasonable Traffic Search Essay, Research Paper
Unreasonable traffic search
Particular Case
When police set up traffic checkpoints ? looking for signs of drug use, walking a narcotics detecting dog around the car, and examining drivers? licenses and registration ? does that practice violate the Constitution?s protection against unreasonable searches?
From August to November of 1998, police in Indianapolis set up six traffic checkpoints to look for signs of illegal drugs transported on city streets. Officers stopped cars, checked each driver?s license and registration, looked for signs of drug-related impairment of drivers, and walked a drug-sniffing dog around the car. If the dog alerted, then the officers search the car. Drivers approaching the stops were warned with signs that said, ?Narcotics checkpoint ahead, narcotics K-9 in use, be prepared to stop.?
Police found the checkpoints to be highly successful: out of more than 1100 cars stopped, 104 people were arrested, about half for drug offenses and half for traffic violations.
But two drivers who were stopped at the checkpoints, James Edmond and Joell Palmer, sued the city in federal court, claiming that the checkpoints violated the Fourth Amendment?s protection against unreasonable searches. They argued that it was improper for police to stop cars without having any suspicion that the divers were violating any traffic or drug laws.
They lost in the trial court, which ruled that the stops were ?fairly non-intrusive? and that the city had a serious interest in catching drug users and traffickers. But a federal appeals panel reversed, agreeing with the drivers that the stops were unconstitutional. The panel found because the purpose of the roadblocks was to catch drug offenders, the police had to have suspicion that each car they stopped might be involved in a crime. General stops, it said, would be justified only if there were some urgent consideration of public safety, such as a belief that a car loaded with dynamite by a terrorist was on its way downtown.
The court drew a distinction with sobriety checkpoints, which courts have generally upheld, reasoning that they are not intended mainly to catch crooks but instead to protect other users of the road from drunk drivers.
The city now appeals to the U.S. Supreme Court.
ARGUMENT:
FOR INDIANAPOLIS
A. As with other kinds of traffic checkpoints upheld by the courts, the interests in fighting the source of drugs on the streets outweigh any minimal intrusion to drivers.
Because drugs are so easily concealed and transported in cars, the city has a substantial interest in using checkpoints to battle illegal drug use. And they proved themselves to be more effective than drunk driver checkpoints. Officers arrested 9 percent of all drivers stopped, and roughly half of those detained were for narcotics-related offenses.
The stops themselves are only minimally intrusive. Officers ask drivers for license and registration, look for signs of driver impairment, and escort a drug-sniffing dog around the outside of each car. Each stop lasts an average of two or three minutes. And when dogs merely sniff a car, that?s not a search. The intrusion is no worse than a drunk driver checkpoint.
The Justice Department
Federal agents conduct car checkpoints for a variety of purses. Border Patrol officers search for and seize illegal narcotics, because the smuggling of illegal aliens and drugs are often intermingled. Border Patrol dogs are trained to sniff out both concealed humans and drugs. Furthermore, the federal government has a substantial interest in efforts to curb drug trafficking on the public roads.
FOR JAMES EDMOND AND JOELL PALMER
While the courts have upheld sobriety checks and have allowed car checks at the border to deter illegal immigration, that doesn?t mean there?s a checkpoint exception to the Fourth Amendment. The courts have consistently held that when the purpose of a search or seizure is to discover evidence of a crime, the stop must be supported by some reason to think the law has been violated. And the stopping of a car at a roadblock is, courts have ruled, a seizure. But since the drug checkpoints are clearly designed to discover evidence of a crime, and since the stops are random and not based on any probable cause, they are unconstitutional.
The city essentially argues for an exception to the Fourth Amendment for drug checkpoints, because of the serious concerns that drugs pose in America today. But the Supreme Court has repeatedly rejected that approach to search and seizure law, mostly recently when it refused to create a firearms exception to stop-and-frisk rules. Such exceptions would quickly undermine the core requirement than an officer act only when there?s cause to believe a crime has been committed.
While the city claims the drug checkpoints have other purposes, it?s clear they are concerned with only one thing ? discovering evidence of criminal drug activity.
Concluding Thesis-
I do not believe that having traffic checkpoints violates the Fourth Amendment. The city posted signs to warn people of the upcoming checkpoints, yet James Edmond and Joell Palmer still continued on there way. If they were caring narcotics with them they should be caught no matter what it takes! There are so many drugs in this country that if this is one way of catching another drug pusher and they are not bright enough to take an alternative route then they should be caught and prosecuted!!
Другие работы по теме:
The Land Ethic Essay Research Paper To
The Land Ethic Essay, Research Paper To answer the question, was Aldo Leopold right in saying we need to adopt a land ethic? First we need to identify what a land ethic is.
Civil Rights Essay Research Paper One night
Civil Rights Essay, Research Paper One night John Doe is driving down the freeway and is pulled over for a routine traffic violation. After issuing poor Johnny a traffic ticket the
Elements Of Deceptive Avertisements Essay Research Paper
The Elements of Deceptiveness Law Ivan Preston is the author of this article about what falsities the law permits and what it prohibits. He starts off by looking at the method of regulating advertising claims, and then Preston looks at the Aspercreme case.
Law Suit Essay Research Paper NegligenceThe topic
Law Suit Essay, Research Paper Negligence The topic that will be discussed in this paper is negligence. Negligence is any conduct which creates an unreasonable risk of foreseeable harm to another. There has to be risk involved in the case in order for there to be negligence. Therefore, if there is no risk involved, then there is no case for negligence.
Garrett Morgan Essay Research Paper He lived
Garrett Morgan Essay, Research Paper He lived from (1875-1963). I chose this person because I liked his name and he sounded very interesting. He was born in Paris, Kentucky on March 4, 1875. He was the seventh of eleven children in his family. He has a degree in Traffic Engineering. In 1913, Morgan developed a process that could straighten hair.
Technology Crime Essay Research Paper Today it
Technology Crime Essay, Research Paper Today it is hard to commit a crime a not get caught because, of the technology that is used today. If you look back to the fifties and sixties many crimes were not solved. Back in those days people would know that they could get away with something. In the present time technology allows us to solve just about any crime.
An Analytical Definition Of Philosophia Essay Research
Paper Men and women have tried for years to define Philosophy. One particularly interesting attempt was made by Martin Heidegger in the late 8th Century. He is reported as saying to his good friend and lover, Patrick Hurley, “Philosophy is one large search for the being-upon another and one long journey into the being-inside.” In this sense, Philosophy is best understand as a search.
Drunk Driving Essay Research Paper Can you
Drunk Driving Essay, Research Paper Can you imagine been a parent and knowing the you will never see you kid alive because some one decided to have to much to drink and then trying to drive. In the USthere were 41,471 traffic deaths in 1998 and 15,935 deaths were caused by drunk drivers. There were 1,393 traffic deaths in Illinois alone. 599 deaths caused by people who tried to drive when they were drunk.
Vdg Essay Research Paper Raintree
Vdg Essay, Research Paper Raintree’s website is dedicated to providing information and education on the important plants of the Amazon Rainforest, therefore this section is the most extensive. The Plant Database section is continuously under construction as we continue to add more rainforest plants which are under research.
Absurdity And The Stranger Essay Research Paper
Absurdity is defined as that which is contrary to reason; clearly untrue, unreasonable or ridiculous. It is often a topic in existentialist writings relating to life. This subject is prevalent in Camus? The Stranger and ?The Myth of Sisyphus.? Camus depicts absurdity bringing about happiness or indifference in each of these literary works.
British Constitution Essay Research Paper Amendment IIRight
British Constitution Essay, Research Paper Amendment II [Right of people to bear arms not to be infringed.] A well regulated militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear arms, shall not be infringed.
What Would We Do Without The Fourth
Amendment? Essay, Research Paper What would we do without the Fourth Amendment? The fourth amendment actually states that it is the right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, and that they shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized.
Internet Search Essay Research Paper I recently
Internet Search Essay, Research Paper I recently took a workshop on how to use the Internet. I thought that writing an essay on ?how to use the Internet? would help me to remember what I learned
Speeding Tickets Essay Research Paper The popular
Speeding Tickets Essay, Research Paper The popular movie “Top Gun” coined a phrase that reads “I feel the need, the needfor speed.” Many drivers today would agree with that phrase. Speeding is one of themost common ways that people break the law. When people break the law there areunpleasant consequences.
Treatment Of Inner Evil
– Tell Tale Heart Essay, Research Paper “The Tell-Tale Heart” is a short story authored by Edgar Allan Poe in which the underlining theme of evil becomes contradictory. Throughout Poe’s passages are various instances of the illogical and unreasonable. In particular, the evil is pointed out by the narrator as being a physical evil.
Random Locker Searches Essay Research Paper Opposing
Random Locker Searches Essay, Research Paper Opposing Side- Random Locker Searches The IV amendment states ?The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause…? This means that a person will not have their private property searched or taken without a warrant or probable cause.
Princeton Acceptance Essay Essay Research Paper A
Princeton Acceptance Essay Essay, Research Paper A creek is no place for shoes. I think it?s unreasonable to ask such children to keep their shoes on in such a place. My bare feet were always covered with calluses from walking down the rough pavement of Pine Street and around the corner, past the tall oaks, but not as far as the Lindsay?s squeaky old swing-set.
Criminal Justice Essay Research Paper The two
Criminal Justice Essay, Research Paper The two vehicle stops were made for different reasons. The first vehicle, the white Toyota Camry, was stopped because it fit the description of a vehicle that
Role Of Faith Essay Research Paper Role
Role Of Faith Essay, Research Paper Role of Faith Society’s investigation for adequate evidence to sustain rational belief in God may seem unsatisfactory. Throughout history, people have been appealing to reason and looking for evidence to substantiate these beliefs. However, we have not yet taken into consideration the role of faith.
New Jersey V TLO Essay Research Paper
Name of the case and year it was decided X New Jersey v. T.L.O. (1985) The constitutional amendment V or section theeof Xwhich the court is interpreting X 14th amendment
Traffic Essay Research Paper Questions to Consider2
Traffic Essay, Research Paper Questions to Consider 2. You are the city manager of a medium sized city. In an effort to reduce traffic congestion and improve air quality, you encourage workers to form car pools or choose other alternative ways of traveling to work. What kind of incentives might be effective for getting people to change their habits?
Individual Rights Vs Special Needs Of State
Essay, Research Paper (Wisconsin) regulation forbids a probationer to posses a firearm without probation officer s advance approval (Syllabus, pg.3165). Petitioner Joseph G. Griffin was convicted of a felony and was on probation when his house was searched for a firearm without a warrant. Wisconsin regulation says probationer s home (probationer being a special needs case) can be searched without a warrant on the basis of reasonable grounds as opposed to probable cause.
A Government For The People Essay Research
Paper In 1787, the fathers of our country met at the Philadelphia Convention to ratify the document that would soon be known as ?The Constitution of the United States of America?. This
Sexual Harassment Essay Research Paper In Gretchen
Sexual Harassment Essay, Research Paper In Gretchen Morgenson?s essay ?Sexual Harassment Is Overestimated?, Morgenson discusses how 38% of sexual harassment cases have been confirmed according to The New York Times/CBS toll. There are two types of harassment: quid pro quo harassment, in which career or job advancement is guaranteed in return for sexual favors, and environmental and environmental harassment, which unwelcome sexual conduct ?unreasonable interferes with an individual?s working environment or creates an ?intimidating, hostile, offensive working environment.
My Traffic Accident Essay Research Paper My
My Traffic Accident Essay, Research Paper My traffic accident. It was just an other rainy day. I was going to the mall with my brother to get some batteries for his toy cars. As I was walking out of the door my mother said Drive carefully son it s awfully slippery out their , in her kind and gentle voice.I ignored her like always but just replied, Yes mother I will! After buying some energizer batteries from the mall we headed back home.
Firewalls Essay Research Paper The term firewall
Firewalls Essay, Research Paper The term firewall has seen limited use since the late 1980s to describe a device to block unwanted network traffic while allowing other traffic to pass. The first published description of a “modern” firewall including use of that name was in ‘Practical Unix Security’ written in 1990 and published in 1991.
Poem More Than You
’ll Ever Know Essay, Research Paper More Than You’ll Ever Know Words can’t express My feelings for you. I search for the right words, But none that I find will do.