Verbal Learning 1
Running head: Comparison of High and Low Similarity Verbal
Comparison of High and Low Similarity Verbal Learning
Retention in College Students
Jenny A. Rosario
Hunter College in
City University of New York
Verbal Learning 2
Method
Participants
The participants were 1 white male and 1 black female ages 21 and 26, respectively. The male participant, who was tested with the High Similarity (HS) condition, knew four languages (Russian, Polish, French and English). The female participant, tested with the Low Similarity (LS) condition, knew two languages (English and French). Although both participants were college students, they varied in the number of years they had been in school, the male was an undergraduate junior and the female was working on her second bachelors. Both participants were honor students.
The final results for this experiment were all of the data pooled from the students in my experimental class. Each student contributed two additional participants to the experiment. These participants were 13 males and 13 females ranging in ages from 15 to 44 years olds (M = 25). Education ranged from 12 years to 23 years of school (M = 15.2). Half of these participants were given the HS task and the other half were given the LS task. As it turns out, the group given the HS task were older (M =27) and more educated (M =16.28) than the group that was given the LS task (M =23 years old and M =14.14 years of education).
Apparatus
Before the experiment, I prepared 11stimuli cards with one of the following nonsense syllable in each: FAP, ZET, KIB, XEL, ROF, GEV, LOZ, BEX, NAJ, WEM and PIV in that order. I prepared a second set of 11 cards I would later use only with the
Verbal Learning 3
participant doing the HS condition. These were paired words where on one side I wrote the pair of words and on the other side I only wrote the first stimuli word. The words were paired in the following manner: DOG-GAK, TAN-XOM, CAR-VUR, BAT-SEJ, WAR-DEH, BUN-KAL, NET-TEG, HOG-XEN, FIN-YEC, GUN-LOF, and PAD-BIW. All syllable words were hand printed on 3Ч5in index cards, 22 cards in all were used. I also prepared, on regular lined paper, instructions and places where each participant could write down any necessary answers, or use as scrap paper for the LS condition. Aside from that, the only other item used was a watch with a second hand to keep track of time.
Procedure
To begin the experiment, I met with each participant (at separate times) in a quiet room where the participant could sit comfortably and concentrate for the experiment. Before we began, I asked each subject to sign an informed consent. Both subjects agreed to the conditions and signed the form. I then sat across from the participant at a table (about 3ft away), asked the subject if they were ready, and began showing them the first list of words. In my HS and LS condition, I displayed each card for 4 sec once and asked the participant to anticipate what the next card would be before I presented it. I manually recorded each of the responses the participant gave me. I continued to repeat the list until the participant successfully predicted the list once.
To my HS participant, I proceeded to show the second list with the paired word-nonsense word. After presenting the list once, I turned the cards over, showed the participant the stimulus word and asked the participant to tell me what the paired word was. In this part
Verbal Learning 4
of the experiment, however, there was a 15min time limit, regardless of whether the participant could memorize the list. Once the 15mins were up, I gave my participant a sheet and asked him to list all the words that he could remember from the original list. As it happened, my participant was able to correctly recall all 11 words, had he been unsuccessful, I would have had to re-teach him the list and record how many trials it took him to relearn it.
To my LS participant, I asked her to list all prime number from 1-100. Because she finished this exercise before the 15min were up, I had her do various addition and division problems using the prime numbers. When the time was up, I handed her a piece of paper and asked her to write down as many words as she could recall from the list she had memorized. Once that was done, and because she successfully recalled all 11 words, I thanked her and informed her that the experiment was over.
Results
The results that follow are based on the information gathered from the whole class. An alpha level of .05 was used for all statistical tests. With that in mind, I found there was no significant difference in the number of trials it took for the HS (M=9.71, SD=4.2) and LS (M=10.43, SD=3.75) groups to learn the words, t (26) = -0.456, p = 0.651, two-tail. Also, there wasn’t any significant difference in the number of items recalled after the distraction period for the HS (M= 9.36, SD=1.67) and LS (M= 9.71, SD=1.28); t (26) = -0.61, p = 0.546, two-tailed. In addition, there also was no significant difference between the HS (M=2.21, SD=1.03) and LS (M=1.93, SD=1.61) in the number of trials it took for them to
Verbal Learning 5
re-learn the original list: t (26) = 0.538, p = 0.595, two-tailed. However, there was a significant difference in education where t = 2.325, p = 0.028, but there was no significant difference for age, t (26) = 1.858, p = 0.075. Both my participants showed no significant difference in savings (both at 100% savings). For the whole group, although the LS (M=78.26) had a higher savings than HS (M=69.92), there was no significance there either with t (26) = -1.002, p = 0.326.
Discussion
Although previous data suggest that significant difference should have been found between both groups (Walker, 1996), I was unable to show that in this experiment. In fact the only place where I did find significant difference was in seeing if my groups matched to begin with. Unfortunately that information did not help. I found that although participants of the HS were more educated then the LS group, they did not performed better at the task in learning, recall or relearning.
In the area of savings, I did find that the LS group had a slightly higher saving, however, not enough for significance and neither were there any difference in age for the two groups. Interestingly, both my participants commented now how they each had terrible memories, yet both showed 100% savings in the recall task.
I decided to divide the participants according to types of jobs, as seen in figure 5 and found that a greater number of participants with ‘trade type’ jobs were in the LS group, but this did not seem to lower their scores as an average.
In figure 1, we see that that shape of the curve is similar to the one shown by Walker (1996). In other words, the average number of errors were low at the beginning
Verbal Learning 6
and at the end of the list but high in-between. My 2nd participant was able to get a low number of errors on certain words in-between due to the types of words they were. For example I noticed that for the 5th word, ROF, she only miss twice. I believe that was due to the fact that it came after XEL which sounds very much like a program which she uses a lot as a secretary. This is an example of the Von Restorff effect. It is highly plausible that ‘XEL’ was not significantly noticeable to the rest of the participants, therefore, they didn’t experience the same effect.
Another interesting note, I think, is that although my 1st participant took 15 trials to learn the original set of syllables, he was able to memorize the second set in just 4 trials leading me to believe that perhaps some students would perform better in a paired-association task.
Finally, in comparing figures 2, 3, and 4, we can see a trend in the direction of the graphs, although not equivalent in shape. Figures two and three are from my two participants and figure 4 is an estimated mean learning curve for all the data gathered. Participant #1 closely follows figure 2, however participant #2’s curve was less predictable (she also admitted after the test that she wasn’t feeling well and that she had a headache).
As a final note I must say that I would not trust some of the analysis done on these data collected since 6 participants were declared to have successfully completed 11 items recalled and then listed as having an ‘x number’ of trials to relearn the task. Obviously there is an error somewhere on the part of the experimenter, unfortunately that most likely had an effect on my results.
Verbal Learning 7
Verbal Learning 8
Figure Caption
Figure 1. Group data of error vs. item positioning
Figure 2. Learning curve for participant #1
Figure 3. Learning curve for participant #2
Figure 4. Learning curve for all 28 participants.
Figure 5. Frequency of participants in different types of occupations.
Bibliography
References
Walker, JT. (1996). Verbal learning. The psychology of learning (pp212-231). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.
Другие работы по теме:
Argument Essay Research Paper Can Only Fear
Argument Essay, Research Paper Can Only Fear Lead to Learning? I agree with Bruno Bettelheim, I think that fear is a very important part of learning. I don t think Children or students will learn unless they have a feeling of fear inside them. Saying that studying and learning should be fun doesn t cut it. Even if something is fun when you do it, you will get bored after a while.
Business Knowledge Essay Research Paper Using Your
Business Knowledge Essay, Research Paper Using Your Business Knowledge 1. Babysitting-I make very good money and it?s a very good learning experience on how to deal and take care of children which is something that everyone needs to eventually learn in life.
Learning Log Essay Research Paper The story
Learning Log Essay, Research Paper The story is based on a man in the coast guard. He is recalling parts of his past. He talks about how he looks forward to Thanksgiving. He is a cook in the coast guard, and his favorite time of the day is when mail call comes. He talks about the two best business words, ?thank you?.
Oh Really Essay Research Paper Oh Reallyyou
Oh Really? Essay, Research Paper Oh Really, you think i am a lark, the dogs they run and bark, but when i say to them, shut up shut up shut up, you say to be nice to them,
ROTC Entrence Essay Essay Research Paper entrance
ROTC Entrence Essay Essay, Research Paper entrance essay For almost as long as I cn remember, I have been interested in th military. Influenced by such movies as “Patton”, and by my dad’s interest in military history, my
Aviation Web Essay Research Paper Learning Journal
Aviation Web Essay, Research Paper Learning Journal 6 Brian Glon Avs.120 11/8/99 308-86-3431 In today’s society it is very important to be well informed. With the Internet at our disposal this task becomes very simple. Information is the life -blood of the aviation industry. The more you know, in this field, the better your odds of being successful.
Space Program Essay Research Paper Should Money
Space Program Essay, Research Paper Should Money be spent on the Space Program? I think that tax dollars as well as government money should go to the space program. I feel this way because the more we learn about space in general, the more technological advancements we will acquire in the years to come. If you think about everything we have learned as a result of space travel in the past 40 years alone, than just to think of what we could learn in the next 40 years to come.
Music Worlds Essay Research Paper There are
Music Worlds Essay, Research Paper There are many types of harassment but in this article we will be visiting verbal harassment. Once a student hits middle school they experience new situations. One situation happens to be the harassment from other students. For some this is difficult, they have never had groups of kids laughing and making jokes about them.
Body Language Essay Research Paper Among the
Body Language Essay, Research Paper Among the many ways of communicating with one another may ultimately be the way we use our voice; but it is in body language, the non-verbal means of communication, do we then come to the realization that “actions do speak louder than words.” This saying is ever so evident in the way teen or young adult couples display their feelings for eachother.
Clasical Conditioning Essay Research Paper Classical ConditioningWe
Clasical Conditioning Essay, Research Paper Classical Conditioning We can see learning taking place all the time, but there is no simple explanation of the process. Psychologists have examined four types of learning; one of these is classical conditioning or response learning. Classical conditioning is the easiest kind of learning.
Learning Styles Essay Research Paper LEARNING STYLESPeople
Learning Styles Essay, Research Paper LEARNING STYLES People not only learn at different rates, but also in different ways. Some people want everything written down, others prefer to listen. Some prefer small group settings rather than large group discussions; others like to listen to a lecture and translate it into pictorial doodles in a notebook.
Learning Experiences Essay Research Paper Learning is
Learning Experiences Essay, Research Paper Learning is something that takes place everyday. Each student learns in a different way and various speeds. Teachers are an important tool for students learning. Therefore, they must create a comfortable environment for their students.
Cheating Essay Research Paper CheatingI believe that
Cheating Essay, Research Paper Cheating I believe that cheating is a terrible thing to do and will hurt you in the long run. When you cheat on a homework assignment, quiz, or test, you are only cheating yourself. You should be honorable enough to take a bad grade and admit that you don’t know everything.
Interpersonal Communication Essay Research Paper Interpersonal CommunicationInterpersonal
Interpersonal Communication Essay, Research Paper Interpersonal Communication Interpersonal communication, in my opinion, is the exchange of information verbal or non-verbal between two or a small group of people for the purpose of getting a feedback and sharing information. Interpersonal communication is not interpersonal if it involves too many people.
Holocaust Essay Research Paper The Holocaust In
Holocaust Essay, Research Paper The Holocaust: In Memory of Millions Response Paper I have always known the holocaust to be one of the worst events in all of history. I remember learning all about it in history class in the ninth grade and being appalled by all the horrors that were shown to us. We learned all about the intense persecution of the Jews, how they were forced into terrible concentration camps where they either worked or were killed, and how the Germans just walked around beating on them and destroying every part of their lives.
Sexual Harassment 3 Essay Research Paper Is
Sexual Harassment 3 Essay, Research Paper Is sexual harassment against men recognized in today s workplace? Unwelcome sexual advances, requests for sexual favors, and other verbal or physical conduct of a sexual nature constitutes sexual harassment. When submission to or rejection of this conduct affects an individual’s employment, unreasonably interferes with an individual’s work performance or creates an intimidating, hostile or offensive work environment, the harassment should be reported.
Caliban Essay Research Paper CalibanEnglish9Through Prospero s
Caliban Essay, Research Paper Caliban English9 Through Prospero s verbal and physical abuse, the enslaved Caliban is unjustly portrayed as a vicious and subhuman beast. Prospero has no feelings for Caliban. Therefore he thinks that Caliban was put on earth for work. Additionally Prospero just thinks he makes fires and does work for him so people should not have sympathy for him. ” We cannot miss him.
Different Learning Styles Essay Research Paper In
Different Learning Styles Essay, Research Paper In our English class we took a test on what kind of learning style characteristics we have. Learning the different style writings that I have helped me discover mor of what I’m about. When people learn more about their learning styles, they can take what they have learned and turn it toward your job, but mostly just toward life in general.
1984 Irony Essay Research Paper THE IRONIES
1984 Irony Essay, Research Paper THE IRONIES OF 1984 The novel 1984, by George Orwell, has many examples of irony throughout it. The two major types of irony: verbal irony and situation irony, are demonstrated again and again in this novel. In the following essay I will discuss these types of ironies and give examples of each from the book.
VerbalEmotional Abuse Essay Research Paper Verbal and
Verbal/Emotional Abuse Essay, Research Paper Verbal and Emotional Abuse Verbal or emotional abuse is a very serious matter that millions of people suffer from each and every day. This kind of abuse is very hard on both the abuser and the victim because of the devastating results it has on the people?s emotions and everything they do.
Personal Phiosophy Essay Research Paper Personal PhilosophyAs
Personal Phiosophy Essay, Research Paper Personal Philosophy As defined by Webster s Dictionary, a teacher is one who instructs, directs, and disciplines other individuals. This definition is correct, however, teaching encompasses much more. A teacher is an integral part of the learning process of a child.
An Essay Analysis Of Learning To Read
? Essay, Research Paper Summary and Purpose ?Learning to Read? depicts how Malcolm X teaches himself to become more than a street hustler. His mere dislike of his lack of writing ability, and his envy of a fellow inmates?(Bimbi) book collection motivates him to become a better writer. Bimbi was his initial motivation.
Douglass Essay Research Paper DouglassIn Frederick Douglass
Douglass Essay, Research Paper Douglass In Frederick Douglass? writings I learned that his physical struggles and his writing as resistance are nearly parallel. When Douglass is living in Baltimore with the Auld family, Mrs. Auld began to teach him the alphabet. After this was discovered by Mr. Auld, the teaching ceased, and Douglass was carefully watched to be sure that he was not reading when alone.
Blah Essay Research Paper For my senior
Blah Essay, Research Paper For my senior thesis, I will be conducting further research on my project, and the idea from which my project came. This research will include different experimental approaches and setups, the outcomes of these new schematics, and the way in which the project was originally approached.
College Is About Learning Essay Research Paper
College is about learning. It’s not as simple as learning whatever it is that’s being taught in your required gen-ed classes, though. It’s about learning how to listen, how to speak, how to think. Learning who you are, who your friends are, the type of people you want as friends. Learning how to trust your innermost feelings, and how to find those feelings in the first place.
Cats And Dogs Essay Research Paper Dogs
Cats And Dogs Essay, Research Paper Dogs and Cats When you compare cats and dogs their differences definitely out number their similarities. Dogs and cats are two of the most popular pets in the world but they are very different animals. Obviously, dogs and cats are two different types of species, but their differences stretch far beyond this simple fact.
Child Abuse Essay Research Paper Child AbuseIn
Child Abuse Essay, Research Paper Child Abuse In this country the problem of child abuse is very serious. Child abuse can happen to almost any child. The abuser and the child may seem
Computer Violence Essay Research Paper Violent Computer
Computer Violence Essay, Research Paper Violent Computer Games A lot of adults say violent computer games make you violent. I disagree. When you are mad you can take out your anger while playing that game. Lots of kids I know have violent computer games and none of them are violent. Pretty much everything in this world has violence in it.
The World Essay Research Paper In an
The World Essay, Research Paper In an important speech, oral delivery is key, ingredients to oral delivery are tone, volume, rate, enthusiasm and clarity, how