US action on International Fishing Disputes
While the United Nations has passed several resolutions and treaties regarding fisheries, the United States has typically refused to ratify such measurers. UNCLOS III, the most comprehensive attempt at a unified body of maritime law, has yet to be given the consent of the Senate. The sticking provisions of this treaty primarily deal with provisions for deep-sea mineral rights. Many US companies have already begun exploration in deep-sea minerals and the UN convention calls for deep-sea minerals to be the common heritage of mankind . This, along with provisions for the required transfer of marine technology, have prompted Senator Helms (Chairman of the Foreign Relations Committee) to oppose this treaty and effectively kill it.
While the US may reject certain provisions of UNCLOS III, they did rush to utilize the provisions of the 200 mile EEZ before the treaty was officially adopted. In 1976 Congress adopted a bill known as the Magnuson Act. This piece of legislation made full use of the concept of exclusive economic zones extending 200 miles to sea. The intent of the law was to bring fisheries within that area back into the exclusive domain of US fishermen. This piece of legislation has been the hinge-pin in most US fisheries regulations since 76 , and was most recently renewed in 1996.
Analysis of US Behavior
If the United States is often the driving force behind the proposal of many treaties such as UNCLOS III, why does the US fail to ratify them? In short, there is not a single area to lay blame. Procedural rules, American ideology, and the relatively increasing autonomy of US legislators all contribute to making passage of comprehensive treaties extremely difficult.
There is a significant procedural and political disconnect between the executive branch which negotiates treaties, and the Senate which ratifies them. The executive branch, here primarily the White House and State Department, have to consider a different group of concerns than the Senate.
The Senate
Senators, come from regions that are much more ideologically divergent than the country as a whole. This leads to a problem, while the national media may not particularly care if 100 lobster fishermen in Maine are upset, local news outlets often do. In this sense, any treaty that has an adverse effect on a small group of citizens is magnified at the state level. A group of 100 voting constituents means a lot in State-wide senate races, where in the national ring their influence is often diluted among the other millions of people who will more than likely not share such a localized concern. In this atmosphere, Senators are much more likely to oppose a bill that has a negative effect on any of their constituents than the executive branch.
Interest groups an NGO s will play a role with Senators but it varies depending on what position the Senator holds and how heavy a presence the NGO or interest group holds in the Senator s home state. If the interest group has a significant constituency within the Senators home state then they will exert more influence over the decisions the Senator makes. However, large interest group or NGO influence can sometimes be negated or at least diminished depending on the Senators position. Most state electorates are very reluctant to toss out a Senator in charge of a major committee or leadership position regardless of what a national group like Green-peace or the National Fisheries Alliance say.
When considering the Senate, one must also consider the often strange and constantly evolving procedural rules. While a treaty is navigating through the dark channels of the various Senate committees and sub-committees, it may disappear and never be seen again. Senator Helms is particularly gifted at making treaties vanish while navigating the Foreign Relations Committee. Because of the rules and other issues of Senatorial courtesy; a treaty can, and often is, killed by a single member or small group in the Senate that would not be able to stop it in an open floor vote. These measures make obtaining the true consensus of the Senate an extremely difficult proposition. Although it should be noted, that many Senators whose seats are up for election in sensitive regions, often enjoy hiding behind the hard-liners in the two respective parties who kill treaties by procedural rules.
In the Senate there is one principal opponent of UNCLOS III and many other UN treaties for that matter. Senator, Jesse Helms has declared that so long as he is in charge of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee UNCLOS III will not see the light of day. Now to fit in some of the pressures that Senator Helms may be feeling
Executive Branch
The executive branch has a much different set of parameters to work in while drafting a treaty. First, since the majority of members in the executive branch serve at the Presidents pleasure, the Commander in Chief can effectively shape treaties to his liking. But the constituency of the President is significantly different from any one member of congress. As was mentioned earlier, even though the negatively effected parties may be in a Presidents constituency, their voice is much less threatening to re-election when it s muted by an additional 275 million. The national press will also typically be less concerned by the local interest stories that those effected constituents comprise.
There is another factor to be considered when dealing with the executive branch. The executive branch is often more vulnerable to political pressure from National interest groups and NGO s. When a President does not take into consideration the needs or desires of these groups he may have to contend with a full scale onslaught during the next election cycle. Even without the propoganda money controlled by these groups, many have constituencies or laborers in many states of the Union. If a group can exert sufficient influence in enough battleground states during the next election, the President may feel a need to bend to at least some of their demands.
Also, the members of the executive branch have to deal more directly with pressure from other global leaders. When other nations have a problem with US policy they do not approach the Senate first. In this regard the President is less insulated from the criticism of foreign officials, he is the figure head of the country and as such takes the first shots fired.
Другие работы по теме:
Gold Fish And The Fisherman Essay Research
Paper The Gold Fish And The Fisherman Once upon a time there was an old man named `Ko’. Ko was a fifty-year old fisherman. He liked children very much but unfortunately he and his
A River Runs Through It
– An Essay For, Essay, Research Paper A River Runs Through IT This family is strong and close. The sense of interdependence is very great in this family. One member’s feelings affect the rest. For example, when Norman was frustratated with his father’s teachings early in the movie, Paul felt this because he wanted to go fishing with his brother, but could not because Norman had not finished his work for the day.
River Runs Through It Essay Research Paper
Analytical vs. Factual A River Runs Through It, by Norman MacLean, is totally unlike most autobiographies. Most autobiographies are similar to excerpts form an encyclopedia. They are factual and straightforward, but that is all that they are. They do not possess a depth. Norman MacLean makes his autobiography unlike most autobiographies, which focus on what happened in the life of the individual, in that he makes it a kind of analysis of his life.
Huck Finn Essay Research Paper Huck Finn
Huck Finn Essay, Research Paper Huck Finn Huck has a grim attitude toward people he disagrees with or doesnt get along with. Huck tends to alienate himself from those people. He doesnt let it
Haiti Essay Research Paper Globalization is not
Haiti Essay, Research Paper Globalization is not in the favor of poor countries like Haiti and only works to benefits the rich countries. I believe if they really wanted to help the Haitian people, they would help the peasants to get assistance from the government and other international organization that would give them appropriate technology such as fertilizers, tractors so they can increase productivity.
Ocean Fisheries Essay Research Paper Most people
Ocean Fisheries Essay, Research Paper Most people are familiar with the problems of the blue whale, efforts to save endangered sea turtles, and the many tragic tales of dolphins dying in tuna
The Old Man And The Sea Book
Review Essay, Research Paper “The Fish” “The Old Man and the Sea”, by Ernest Hemmingway, is a tale of an unlucky fisherman who strives to succeed in the face of adversity. The fisherman, Santiago, lives in a tired, old fishing community on the coast of Cuba. He has fished all of his life. To him it is a passion. Santiago lives in a small shack next to the harbor.
Nick And The River From Hemingway
’s “Big Two-Hearted River” Essay, Research Paper Nick and the River by Kirk Wintermute In Ernest Hemingway’s short story “Big Two-Hearted River,” there are very few obvious relationships. But the
Iroquois Essay Research Paper The Iroquois
Iroquois Essay, Research Paper The Iroquois The Iroquois is a tribe of the Eastern Woodland indians. The Iroquois is one tribe that is seperated into five groups. These groups are called , Seneca ,
Land Mines Essay Research Paper Land mines
Land Mines Essay, Research Paper Land mines greatly contribute to the danger of international security because they are used as military weapons. Because land mines have caused great destruction there has been an effort from international and non-governmental organizations to ban mines and clear areas infected with them.
Scholarship Essay Research Paper 7500 scholarshipBy David
Scholarship Essay, Research Paper $7,500 scholarship By David Johnson On September 30, 1999, Charles Johnson won a $7,500 scholarship from the Department of Agriculture at Washington State University for being Central High School’s number one student.
Chinese Kites Essay Research Paper The Kite
Chinese Kites Essay, Research Paper The Kite: China, Fifth/Fourth Century BC. Two kitemakers, Kungshu P’an who made kites shaped like birds which could fly for up to three days, and Mo Ti (who is said to have spent three years building a special kite) were famous in Chinese traditional stories from as early as the fifth century BC.
Destiny Is Not Always Easy Essay Research
Paper Destiny Is Not Always Easy Sometimes the things we are meant to be, aren’t the things that are easiest for us. In Old Man and the Sea this becomes very true for Santiago. Fishing is extremely hard for him, lines cutting his hands, countless hours waiting for a fish to jump. He was born to do this, it is his destiny, and it’s not easy.
Steller Sea Lions Essay Research Paper SAVING
Steller Sea Lions Essay, Research Paper SAVING STELLER SEA LIONS In Alaska the Steller sea lions and the many other wild life there are diminishing. People ride on the ferry to get where they are going but to also see the wildlife. The sea lions are battling with the fishing industry to survive. The fishing industry is not the only factor affecting the wildlife in Alaska, but it play the largest role and contributes to the many effects that affect the life and could lead to a solution to control the problem.
The Marshall Decision Essay Research Paper Who
The Marshall Decision Essay, Research Paper Who: Donald Marshall (a Mikmaq fisherman), Native and non-native fisherman, Supreme Court of Canada and Herb Dhaliwal (minister of Fisheries and ocean).
SALMON Essay Research Paper Salmon
SALMON Essay, Research Paper Salmon They are naturally distributed throughout most of the northern hemisphere from the temperate zone to beyond the Arctic circle. Now is limited in a few rivers in eastern Maine and Canada. Pollution, impassable dams near the mouths of river, over fishing, destruction of spawning grounds through deforestation, and loss of young in power plant turbines have all contributed to the loss of this fish.
Spear Fishing Essay Research Paper Cause or
Spear Fishing Essay, Research Paper Cause or Effect SPEAR FISHING Free dive spear fishing is a very enjoyable sport. This great outdoor sport is a perfect way to keep the body very healthy. It can effect the body in many positive ways. It works as a great cardiovascular exercise; a great way to relieve stress; and a delicious way to get the proper nutrients the body needs to stay healthy.
Learning To Flycast Essay Research Paper The
Learning To Flycast Essay, Research Paper The great outdoors is a provider of a vast variety of ways to relax. These methods can range from camping to hiking to even snow skiing. Though the most effective way to escape from the world and into nature is through fly-fishing. Fly-fishing can place you in the middle of a peaceful stream but yet on the outskirts of a developing world.
LifeS Simple Pleasure Essay Research Paper Life
Life?S Simple Pleasure Essay, Research Paper Life’s Simple PleasureWhen I was a young man, just moved out of the house, I remember going salmon fishing with a few of my buddies. It was a very competitive outing where whoever caught the biggest fish was the winner. In those days I don’t think I ever really slowed down enough to see what fishing was doing for me.
Poetry Rhonda Goes Fishing Essay Research Paper
Poetry: Rhonda Goes Fishing Uncle Marcus comes rapping on your bedroom door one Saturday morning. Says he got a can full of worms and your cane pole, just like old times. Unc, what you better have is some coffee! He
Intewrnationl Day Essay Research Paper International DayInternational
Intewrnationl Day Essay, Research Paper International Day International Day was a day where the students from foreign country’s get to share there pride in there country and culture and that’s exactly what they did. This international day was the first one I’ve ever attended and I will attend them from now on.
My Uncle Essay Research Paper My UncleOn
My Uncle Essay, Research Paper My Uncle On a hot day in the Summer time, my uncle died in the hospital in Truman, in the town which he had grown up in. My uncle was a common man who spent his days
Fishing Essay Research Paper My Fishing TripI
Fishing Essay, Research Paper My Fishing Trip I had the greatest experience of my life this year during August 7-10. I was spending my day just as usual taking it pretty easy. I was on the way to see my Grandma when I happened to run into one of my good friends so we stopped and got a little lunch. Just as soon as we sat down to eat I got a call from my old boss, and he was asking if I would like to go to Florida to go deep sea fishing.
Instructions For How To Cast A Fly
Fishing Rod Essay, Research Paper How To Cast A Fly Rod Most people think of fishing as going down to the local creek or jetty and soaking a few prawns or throwing a few lures around. However there is a more fun and often more productive method called flyfishing.
Physics Of Fly Fishing Current Event Essay
, Research Paper The Physics of Fly-fishin What does it take to launch an ultra-light fishing line over 200 feet? A little physics and a lot of feel for the fishing rod, that s what. The trick to doing good is to have the thinner, end of the line, land on the water first then the fly. The end of the line cushions the fly, having the effect that a fly is landing on the water, not a piece of nylon string.
Lincoln Application Essay Essay Research Paper Now
Lincoln Application Essay Essay, Research Paper Now is a time to make decision in life that will help me succeed in the future. The decision is to choose the right high school that will help me meet my goals and prepare me for college. A school that can train and give me all the tools I need to be an international business.
Vice President Of Personnel Fun
& Games International Essay, Research Paper 9 Warwick Rd. Stratford NJ 08084 1/24/01 Ms. Paula Hougen Vice President of Personnel Fun & Games International
New England Colonies Essay Research Paper The
New England Colonies Essay, Research Paper The New England Colonies The New England Colonies were made up of Massachusetts, Rhode Island, Connecticut, and New Hampshire. Massachusetts’s founders were John Carver, William Bradford, and John Winthrop and they founded it in 1620. One of the reasons Carver, Bradford, and Winthrop founded Massachusetts was for religious freedom.
International Students Essay Research Paper International Students
International Students Essay, Research Paper International Students on Campus There are many International students that attend East Texas University. There are Hispanics, Russians, and Chinese that attend this institution. I talked to Mario and he said that East Texas really helps the International students in many ways.
Us Affairs Essay Research Paper The US
Us Affairs Essay, Research Paper The U.S. plays a major role in most of the international affairs because the U.S. is considered to be a powerful nation. The Economy of America is strong, and the military power is one of the biggest in the world. There was a Persian Gulf War back in 1991 when the U.S. attacked Iraq.
International Relations Realism Essay Research Paper In
International Relations: Realism Essay, Research Paper In the discipline of International Relations realism, which developed as a reaction to idealism during the Cold War, has become the dominant school of thought . Realism makes power the currency of international politics. Realist argue that by accumulating power states can ensure the security of the population within the state.
Fly Fishing Essay Research Paper A Fly
Fly Fishing Essay, Research Paper A Fly Fishing Adventure This fishing expedition is one of the most memorable fly fishing experiences that I have ever had in my lifetime. I will never forget it and will treasure it always.
Fly Fishing Essay Research Paper There are
Fly Fishing Essay, Research Paper There are six main elements of fly fishing; a fly rod (usually around 9 feet long), a fly reel (a round shaped real with a 1:1 relative ratio), a fly line