Jane Tompkins Indians Essay, Research Paper
Whenever you are in any educational situation, you are subject to perspectives and bias of the instructors. In an essay entitled “Indians,” by Jane Tompkins, it discusses how different biases may reflect upon one’s concept of history. It is imperative to realize that when learning, which generally involves someone’s concept of history, we are consequently subject to that person’s perspectives that may be a result of their upbringing.
In the essay Tompkins regarding history, Tompkins says “it concerns the difference that point of view makes when people are giving accounts of events, whether at first or second hand. The problem is that if all accounts of events are determined through and through by the observer’s frame of reference, then one will never know, if any given case, what really happened.”(Pg. 619)
The purpose of this essay is that history is a result of point of view. It is both subject to the biases of the one who presents it as it is subject to the biases of the one who observes it. You can then draw a similar parallel to education. The point is that you learn something you are subject to the educator’s opinion as well as your prejudices regarding the topic. This leads me to one of Tompkins main points of discussion: “What really is the truth?”
As I have mentioned throughout the essay, everything is subject to the opinions and prejudices of the observer. When trying to decipher a fact, or “the truth” you must realize that people may see a particular instance in many different points of view. Tompkins discusses this problem and its relation to the European-Indian conflict of the 17th and 18th centuries. In doing so she quotes a particular source of puritan background who considers the Indians to be brutal savages who raped and tortured their captives. She then quotes someone who is favorable towards the Indians, said that Indians were a highly cultured group of people who helped the European settlers adapt to their new environment.
My point for addressing these two points of view is to illustrate how these two people can have such diverse opinions regarding the same topic. Both of these people are saying the truth, yet when trying to understand the broad point of view you can’t accept either of them as the whole truth. Because of these two people’s bias’ they may have a tendency to neglect certain facts that may be detrimental to the image they where trying to portray. In order to obtain the most accurate “truth” you must take all the different points of view, and while putting aside your personal bias’ and the bias’ of those who are presenting the story, you must then decide for yourself what is believable and what may be lacking important information.
When trying to decipher the truth, there is a close parallel to the “banking” theory. The banking theory is one in which you are subject to the prejudices and beliefs of the educator, and you are just filled with their beliefs. When trying to learn history you are consequently subject to the same prejudices. All you really have to learn from are the sources that you are researching. You are then the same as the student in the banking theory.
When reading this essay it is also important to note that it is not intendedto discourage you from learning from history. If you don’t know what history happened in the past you are most likely subject to it repeating itself. It is imperative that you learn from the what happened in the past. Also, you must learn from the people’s perspectives. This will allow you to see the situation from a variety of different angles. Once you are able see these different points of view, you will consequently be able to learn more about the people who have these views. Consequently, you will be able to filter out such prejudices in the future.
In order to learn anything about the world around you, it is imperative that you take in mind that different people will have these bias’ and prejudices. Therefore when learning from them you may only see one point of view. To learn the whole truth, you must take in as many points of view as possible. This will allow you to possibly filter out the conflicting points of view, and try to realize the common story in all of them. By doing this you will be able to see the closest thing to the truth as possible.
Другие работы по теме:
The Autobiography Of Miss Jane Pittman Essay
, Research Paper In the novel The Autobiography Of Miss Jane Pittman, there were many different stories about JanePittman’s life. In the movie there were not as many stories as the novel, but they were still quite
Jane Eyre Essay Research Paper Vol ICh11Vol
Jane Eyre Essay, Research Paper Vol ICh.11-Vol II 7 Jane?s arrival at the Thornfield Charlotte Bronte?s Jane Eyre displays three types of relationships possessing different purposes. These connections are established at Thornfield after Jane becomes a governess and accepts the position at the estate.
Jane Eyre 8 Essay Research Paper Blanche
Jane Eyre 8 Essay, Research Paper Blanche Ingram: Villain? Blanche Ingram is the most important woman, other than Jane Eyre, in the novel. Arguably, she is the most important antagonist in this book. It is difficult to fathom how an absolutely horrid, conceited, venal, apathetic creature could be so vital to the book; but take her away, the motivation, conflict, and character itself crumbles.
Jane Erye Essay Research Paper Jane EyreMr
Jane Erye Essay, Research Paper Jane Eyre Mr. Edward Rochester is faced with a tough situation. Mr. Rochester is married to Bertha Mason, but he has fallen in love with Jane Eyre. Edward Rochester is a member of the British gentry. His avaricious father tricks him into marrying Bertha Mason, a rich woman with a family history of mental illness.
Jane Eyre 7 Essay Research Paper In
Jane Eyre 7 Essay, Research Paper In Charlotte Bront Jane Eyre, the main character faces many struggles. One of the struggles she faces is the temptation to run away with the man she loves and be his mistress or to marry a man who offers her the contrary where it would be a legal and highly respectable marriage but with no genuine love.
Jane Addams Essay Research Paper Founder of
Jane Addams Essay, Research Paper Founder of Hull-House in Chicago, first president of the Women’s International League for Peace and Freedom, and co-winner of the 1931 Nobel Peace Prize, Jane Addams was a dedicated crusader for
Miss Jane Pittman Essay Research Paper Book
Miss Jane Pittman Essay, Research Paper Book #1 In book 1 it started out by the Secesh and the Yankees having a big war. Then Tracey met this Yankee named Brown and he helped free the slaves. Then Brown gave Tracey the nickname Jane. The slave owner freed Tracey (Jane) and all the other slaves. Once the Proclamation papers were signed the slaves headed up toward Ohio.
Plains Indians Essay Research Paper During the
Plains Indians Essay, Research Paper During the 1800s, the Plains Indians were finally overcome by the white man. Several factors contributed to their downfall. In descending order, these included the near extinction of the buffalo, disease, tribal wars, and their naivete.
Emily Jane Bronte Essay Research Paper Emily
Emily Jane Bronte Essay, Research Paper Emily Jane Bronte Emily Jane Bronte remains a mystery. Very little is known about her. There is little information, and much of what we have is contradictory. She is the author
Indian Movement Essay Research Paper Why were
Indian Movement Essay, Research Paper Why were the Indians forced off their land? a) Land Struggles b) Clash of Cultures Throughout the 1800s America was greatly expanding. As more settlers arrived, more were moving farther and farther west. At this time there were already natives living throughout the land that would one day make up all 50 states.
Jane Eyre Essay Research Paper Jane EyreJane
Jane Eyre Essay, Research Paper Jane Eyre Jane Eyre was originally a book, by Charlotte Bronte. It has now been made into a movie. There are two versions of the movie the BPC version, which is the British version and the American version. Both movies are very good and tell the story different. The British version is more like the book.
Jane Eyre Essay Research Paper Jane EyreAfter
Jane Eyre Essay, Research Paper Jane Eyre After reading the novel Jane Eyre, I found that a lot of things that happened to her would have been different if she had been attractive. Obviously her treatment by Mrs. Reed and company would have been improved. She would have been considered delicate, and people would not have abused her.
False Representation Of Native Americans Essay Research
Paper Marie Maffei Dr. Jordan College Writing II February 4, 2001 Bias History While researching the early relations between the American Indians, and the first European settlers, Jane Tompkins found that the way history was recorded seemed to mislead her. In her essay “ ‘ Indians’: Textualism, Morality, and the problem of History,” Tompkins found that the historians put prejudice facts, and looked down upon Native Americans.
Iroquois Essay Research Paper The Iroquois
Iroquois Essay, Research Paper The Iroquois The Iroquois is a tribe of the Eastern Woodland indians. The Iroquois is one tribe that is seperated into five groups. These groups are called , Seneca ,
Jane Eyre Essay Research Paper Jane EyreCharlotte
Jane Eyre Essay, Research Paper Jane Eyre Charlotte Bronte 407 pages Setting: England, Early 1800s Point of View: First person Jane Eyre, the main character, is sent out of the drawing room by her Aunt, Mrs.
Jane Eyre Vs Well I Have Lost
You. Essay, Research Paper Comparison Between: Jane Eyre and the poem “Well, I Have Lost You”… I believe that there are many parallels between the book: Jane Eyre and the poem “Well, I Have Lost You”. For example, in the poem, the author says, “I have lost you; and I lost you fairly; In my own way, and with my full consent.” The author tells of a woman who loved a man dearly, and unfortunately, because of that love, had to leave him.
Jane Eyre EssayIndependence Essay Research Paper Jane
Jane Eyre Essay-Independence Essay, Research Paper Jane Eyre, a novel written by Charlotte Bronte, is about a young girl named Jane that struggles to discover her identity. Jane’s a girl who is “unhappy, very unhappy”(23). She grows up with relatives that treat her unfairly because her diseased family was not wealthy.
Jane Eyre Independence Essay Research Paper In
Jane Eyre: Independence Essay, Research Paper In Charlotte Bronte s famous book Jane Eyre, a girl was portrayed that was growing up around the turn of the nineteenth century. Jane was an orphan with no family or friends. She was mistreated and misunderstood by the people around her. Jane seemed doomed for a life of failure, until she decided to go against all odds and stand up for the life of success she deserved.
Austen Jane 2
Austen, Jane “Pride And Prejudice” Essay, Research Paper Jane Austen’s intricate novel exhibits dry, subtle humor. She paints her genteel and refined characters with a
Indians Essay Research Paper In her argumentative
Indians Essay, Research Paper In her argumentative essay, Jane Tompkins, an avid reader and researcher of the European-Indian relationships, delves into one of the most perplexing aspects of studying history in our world. Because we are such a diverse society–continuously prioritizing the fight for our own causes, there is much room left for the entrance of cultural subjectivity and perspective.
Defining History Essay Research Paper In the
Defining History Essay, Research Paper In the document, “Indians: Textualism, Morality, and The Problem of History,” Jane Tompkins examines the conflicts between the English settlers and the American Indians. After examining several primary sources, Tompkins found that different history books have different perspectives.
Ways Of Reading And Jane Tompkins Essay
, Research Paper In the book, Ways of Reading, the authors Bartholomae and Petrosky outline what they describe as a “strong reader”. They characterize the attributes that collectively contribute to this title and then talk about the relations between a strong reader and a strong writer. The perspectives that Bartholomae and Petrosky discuss on ideas and textual analysis are very interesting and in point of fact remind me of the thought process of which I use when analyzing a reading.
Berger And Tompkins Essay Research Paper John
Berger And Tompkins Essay, Research Paper John Berger’s writing “Ways of Seeing” is a look into the world of art. Throughout his composition, he gives his opinions on various topics about art. Jane Tompkins essay “Indians: Textualism, Morality, and the Problem of History” is a look into the world of history.
Responsibilities Of Anthropologists Essay Research Paper Responsibilities
Responsibilities Of Anthropologists Essay, Research Paper Responsibilities of Anthropologists There is much blindness in the way ?civilized? people first percieve people of other cultures. Often times this blindness can lead to arrogance. Anthropology has been important for hundreds of years, describing unknown cultures and explaining their histories.
Jane Austen Essay Research Paper Jane AustenJane
Jane Austen Essay, Research Paper Jane Austen Jane Austen was born in 1775 in Stevenson, England. It was there were she started writing her first novel First impressions which was renamed Pride and Prejudice . She wrote it when she was only 14 years old. She and her Father turned it in to the publishers but they rejected it.
Jane Eyre Essay Research Paper The ambiguity
Jane Eyre Essay, Research Paper The ambiguity of Jane Eyre with respect to gender and class actually makes it more interesting to read. It struggles with sensitive subjects, and sometimes it fails to defy societal convention. But its failures are often as interesting as its successes. It doesn’t pretend to offer an ultimate truth of personal freedom.
The Historical Value Of Black Robe Essay
, Research Paper The novel, Black Robe, by Brian Moore is a story about a young Jesuit priest sent into the wilds to convert a remote tribe of Huron Indians before the oncoming winter closes his window of opportunity to reach them. The reader is shown what everyday life is like in a long since past world when the Indian still roamed and controlled the Americas.
Jane Eyre Essay Research Paper Jane EyreIn
Jane Eyre Essay, Research Paper Jane Eyre In the novel Jane Eyre by Charlotte Bronte, we are introduced to Jane, the orphan protagonist of the story. When the novel first begins, she is an isolated, powerless ten-year old living with an aunt and her cousins whom do not like her. Jane feels alienated from the Reed family; therefore she spends much of her time alone.
Jane Eyre Essay Research Paper Jane Eyre 2
Jane Eyre Essay, Research Paper Jane Eyre of Charlotte Bronte?s Jane Eyre, develops drastically within the first few chapters of the novel. Her environment was a major influential factor in Jane?s development.
Uncle Tom
’s Cabin Essay, Research Paper Tompkins, Jane P. ?Sentimental Power: Uncle Tom?s Cabin and The Politics of Literary History?. Glyph 2 (1978) This essay is an incredible wealth of knowledge for someone who wants to write a paper on why Uncle Tom?s Cabin is so significant. The author had actually lived in Harriet Beecher Stowe?s half-sister?s basement ?during a difficult time? in her life (501).