Responsibilities Of Anthropologists Essay, Research Paper
Responsibilities of Anthropologists
There is much blindness in the way ?civilized? people first percieve people of other cultures. Often times this blindness can lead to arrogance. Anthropology has been important for hundreds of years, describing unknown cultures and explaining their histories. Unfortunately, not all of the work or research these anthropologists do can be completely accurate. Researchers such as Napolean A Chagnon abuse not only the culture under question, but all those who follow his work. It is difficult to understand why this type of abuse occurs. There are many explinations why, but the most prevelant being the illusion of superiority. Chagnon was a very crafty man who manipulated his surroundings to get the results he desired. Although supposedly researching the formerly unkonown tribe of the Yanomami, Chagnon essentially changed the history of the Yanomami people, in order to collect information about their past. This is an example of anthropologists abusing his or her power, to further their own career. Chagnon got the results he wanted from the start. Chagnon wanted to describe these people as violent and dangerous in order to get more people interested and make himself seem brave by living with these ?wild? tribes. His descriptions were made from his own point of view, which are certainly tainted, and the worst part is that people who read his work have no idea how biased an opinion he might have. Anthropologists have a responcibility to their research, as well as those who learn from it, to be completely objective.
It is disappointing that people get taken advantage of and sometimes led to believe things that make the ?reasercher? seem almost mighty. An area of much debate is whether a researcher should intereact or simply observe. Both could have positive or negative results to the people being studied. An argument can be made that the only truly objective way to research a culture is to only observe, and never interact because interacting could change the way people live. A good example of this is the experience of the Yanomami and Chagnon. Chagnon interacted with the Yanomami and eventually brought war and disrespected many religious beliefs they practiced. This could hardly be called objective. An argument could be made using the ?Deep Play: Notes on the Balinese Cockfight? essay, for the interaction between the researcher and the culture he or she is studying. In ?Deep Play? only the most visual details were available to research, and when the man and wife are introduced to the culture it is then that they are able to make significant conclusions. It is not the point of this essay to determine which method of research is the best or most objective, but rather to state the importance of objectiveness, or lack of objectiveness in Anthropology.
Jane Tompkins, author of ?Indians,? questions the validity of every research, every history book, and every opinion turned fact that has been written. Tompkins believes after researching herself the relationship between the Indians and the settelers, that facts, although seemingly true, has a biased attatched with it. Thinking criotaically about this can lead to the questioning of every thing ever written about history. The difficulty she faced in finding the truth about what happened to the Indians in the hands of the settelers questions the value of what society has been assuming the truth. In almost every history book she read different interpretations of the same story was found. Not only different interpretations, but completely opposite recordings of history. This leads to the question of which research to believe and why. An answer to that question will not be attempted in this essay. Tompkins illustrates the importance of finding the answer that best suits the question, by reading different written works from different perspectives. Tompkins, who was inspired to conduct this research because she was teaching a lecture about the subject for college students, could have easily followed the standard of today?s lectureres and restated the first thing she read about the Indians and Setteler?s relationship. That is the way our educational system works for many of the students today. Students hear what teachers want them to hear, and many teachers validate what they are teaching because they read it in some book claiming to be the truth. The truth is that history might not ever have an accurate description of what happened hundreds of years ago. People might think they do, but proof of this is almost impossible to come by. Even the most reliable source, such as Tompkins example of the writings of a girl taken prisoner by the Indians, can be biased. The writings taken from the prisoner girl seemingly must be true because the girl was actually there, but the perspective she was taking tainted her truths. Tompkins also illustrates the conflicting ideas of first hand evidence of writings of two people describing the same culture. One man describes the Indians as beasts who need to be conquered for their own good, another man describes how wonderful it would be to be captured by them and live with among them. These two very different ideas of Indians illustrate the importance of perspectives and objectiveness. The man describing the Indians as rutheless beasts had his own perpective of possibly not the Indians, but of the situation. These accounts were made by a minister, ?who wishes to convince his readers that the Indians are in need of conversion? (Jane Tompkins Indians, pg 684). Someone who might read this description of the Indians may believe this man because unlike any historian, he was there with the Indians. This does not make his claim true however. It only makes clear the importance of taking into account all information given and deriving the truth from an individual point of view.
Although in the future anthropology might be somewhat easier because of the advances in technology, the recordings of the world?s history can never be totally accurate. It is important for anthropologists to be carefull to avoid bias in his or her research. It is also very important that when claiming facts one must not include their own perspective, but only the undeniable facts. There are 75 members of the tribe, the weather was 92 degrees, their houses were made of mud, these are example of facts that should be recorded as such. Observations that incude things such as, they are a violent tribe, their nutrition habbits are horrible, their ideas of religion is tainted, are just that, observations, and should not be recorded as facts. An example of this type of abuse in anthropology would be Chagnon?s description of the Yanomami portrayed as facts, but really his own opinion of what he saw. An opinion that was tainted by the meddeling of his own work. Another researcher visited the Yanomami tribe later and concluded very different things about the Yanomami.
Anthropology is vital to the world today, and informs others about cultures that they might not know anything about. It is also very important that anthropologists act responcibly in attaining their information. The responcibility does not solely lie in the hands of the anthropologists, but also there is a responcibility in the readers to determine for themselves what is fact and what is opinion.
Другие работы по теме:
Automotive Enginereing Essay Research Paper As long
Automotive Enginereing Essay, Research Paper As long as there are people there will always be a means of transportation. No matter what kind of mechanical transportation it will fail eventually. Which means there will always be a job that pays good money that is labeled “Automotive Technician.”
Pressuation Essay Research Paper I propose that
Pressuation Essay, Research Paper I propose that every eighteen-year-old should be allowed to legally drink alcohol. There are many reasons that made me think of this idea. First I thought hey, when I turn eighteen there are so many responsibilities and options that I’m going to have to make. The first one was the right to vote.
Computer Engineer Essay Research Paper A computer
Computer Engineer Essay, Research Paper A computer engineer has many job responsibilities. Among these are designing, testing, installing, operating, and applying computers and computer systems as well as their components. They also might find new more efficient ways to solve problems with computers.
Lower The Drinking Age Essay Research Paper
Lower the Drinking Age I think Iowa s drinking age should be lowered to 18. People are legally considered an adult when they turn 18, so they should get the privileges, and have to take the responsibilities of being an adult. The problems our society has with drinking are caused because we look down on people who drink.
Sports To Me Essay Research Paper PERSONAL
Sports To Me Essay, Research Paper PERSONAL ESSAY Participating in athletics gives me an edge. As an athlete, I have learned to interact with many different types of people, work together, and win. Striving for excellence teaches you about your capabilities and how, with practice they can expand. Athletics is the best thing that has ever happened to me.
My Holy Heroine Essay Research Paper My
My Holy Heroine Essay, Research Paper My Holy Heroine When I think of a holy heroine, I think of my mother. What is a heroine? Everyone’s vision is somewhat different. To me, a heroine is someone who I can look up to as a role model. This is why I consider her to be my holiest heroine.
Taking On Responsibility Essay Research Paper Taking
Taking On Responsibility Essay, Research Paper Taking on Responsibility When I was diagnosed with diabetes I had to take on some responsibilities. Lately I had been feeling sick, drinking a lot, and going to the bathroom a lot. So my mom took me to the doctor to see what was wrong. I don?t remember much of it because I was only three years old.
Germany
’s Government: Chancellor Democracy Essay, Research Paper Germany’s Government: Chancellor Democracy Steve Rice Political Science 90 Computer Project
The Glass Menagerie And The Conflict Between
Happines And Responsibility Essay, Research Paper An individual’s right to be happy and its conflict with an individual’s responsibilities is a common personal problem. Many people must make the choice between the two daily. Most people have a set opinion of whether responsibility or happiness should prevail.
Critical Analysis Of Virginia Woolf
’s A Room Of On Essay, Research Paper With a fair amount of confusion and lack of clarity, I was able to collect enough information from Virginia Woolf s book, A Room of One s Own, to end up with the overall theme and point to her work. Woolf s ideas were definitely revolutionary for the 1920 s and are rightfully revisited in our educational efforts in the 1990 s.
Responsibilities Are More Important Than Rights Essay
, Research Paper Responsibilities are more important than Rights Everyone has rights and responsibilities. Rights are things that people are aloud to do. Responsibilities are things that people are expected to do. In this essay, I will be telling you some facts why responsibilities are more important in the society of Waknuk.
Responsibilities Of An American Citizen Essay Research
Paper An American citizen has many responsibilities to keep America and his/her community going. Some of these responsibilities might be -1. Duty : Every citizen has a duty to vote!Reason : As citizens you have the duty to beinformed about the issues and hold an opinionon them that is for the benefit of the wholesociety.
Business Ethics Essay Research Paper Frank tries
Business Ethics Essay, Research Paper Frank tries to refute Friedman, as Arrow previously did. Frank considers the one responsibility that Arrow ignores, that the action that the CEO of a company takes in self interest, and may also be socially responsible. Friedman offers cloaking. Repeated interaction, the use of paying on time, all look socially responsible but they are not.
Bureau Of Alchohol Tobacco And Firearms Essay
, Research Paper THE BUREAU OF ALCOHOL, TOBACCO AND FIREARMS The Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms(ATF) was founded in 1972, established as a separate agency inside the U.S. Treasury Department. Before this
Description Of Mom Essay Research Paper There
Description Of Mom Essay, Research Paper There are those that come in to our lives and leave a special gift in our hearts. There are also those who are nothing but a passing memory. As for me, the person that has given me a special gift is my mother.
FullTime Students Vs Part Time Students Essay
, Research Paper Full-time vs. Part-time Students There are many similarities and differences between full and part-time students. Each student is trying for the goal of educating themselves to become more successful in life. As students begin their education there is a sense of motivation and eagerness.
My Paper Essay Research Paper 895 Mae
My Paper Essay, Research Paper 895 Mae Lynn Drive Fenton, Missouri 63026 March 4, 2000 Mr. John Smith Director of Central Service St. Mary?s Hospital P.O. Box 656
Business Ethics Essay Research Paper As an
Business Ethics Essay, Research Paper As an editor of a weekly magazine, there are many responsibilities. Upper management recently came to the editor and told him that sales have dipped dramatically. He was also told, that if things do not turnaround soon, heads will roll. Along comes a story that he knows is ethically wrong, but will sell many magazines.
Role Of Women In The 19Th Century
Essay, Research Paper Role of Females In the nineteenth century women were perceived in many different ways. Two noted nineteenth century writer were john Stuart Mill and Henrik Ibsen. Even though most of their stories were greatly different they did share the common thought that women are their own people and should be free.
Federal Government Essay Research Paper How does
Federal Government Essay, Research Paper How does the constitution divide power between the national government and the states? The constitution did not give the national government or the states total supremacy. Instead, power was distributed. The national government was given certain express powers, while some powers were reserved to the states.
Parents 4 Essay Research Paper ParentsTeenagers are
Parents 4 Essay, Research Paper Parents Teenagers are under more stress than any other age of people in the world, especially those who are seniors. There are so many things to do, to think of, making major life decisions, and keeping up with the trust and responsibilities expected from our parents. I’m not sure if it is the time that have changed or if my parents do not remember what it is like to be a teenager.
Poems By Robert Frost And Leonard Cohen
Essay, Research Paper Have you ever wondered what makes two places the same, but in two totally different areas? Throughout the poems Stopping by the Woods on a Snowy Evening by Robert Frost, and The Bus by Leonard Cohen, there are many similarities that take place. These similarities are the life in cities and towns, the escape into nature, and the consequences of such escapes.
Woman And Equal Opportunities Essay Research Paper
Woman in the sixties have had many different roles than woman in the nineties. Life for woman has changed dramatically, to their advantage throughout the years. Today woman have gained many new rights and responsibilities, and now have equal opportunities as men.
Letter Of Application Essay Research Paper Please
Letter Of Application Essay, Research Paper Please accept this letter in application for the Admission Counselor position currently available within your school. My resume is enclosed for your review and I believe you will find that my qualifications meet your expectations.
Management Plan Essay Research Paper Section of
Management Plan Essay, Research Paper Section of a Marketing Plan Management and Organization Plan General Manager-Anah Smith Anah smith is leading Home Cookin? with over 9 years of leadership and managerial experience in all different aspects of business. She has received her BS at the University of Evansville with an emphasis in entrepreneurship.
Working In High School Essay Research Paper
Having a job in high school gives me an edge. As an employee, I have learned to interact with many different types of people, work together, and learn the value of a dollar. Being employed is one of the best things
Emerson Essay Research Paper When I received
Emerson Essay, Research Paper When I received the criteria for this essay I knew that writing this would be a personal challenge to myself. My motivation and interest in being a journalist is so vast that I knew that I would have trouble squeezing it all into a mere 500 word essay. In addition, I would have to list my experience in journalism.