12 Angry Men Essay, Research Paper
12 Angry Men This essay will compare & contrast the protagonist/antagonist’s relationship with each other and the other jurors in the play and in the movie versions of Reginald Rose’s 12 Angry Men. There aren’t any changes made to the key part of the story but yet the minor changes made in making the movie adaptation produce a different picture than what one imagines when reading the drama in the form of a play. First off, the settings in the movie are a great deal more fleshed out. In the play, the scene begins with the jurors regarding the judge’s final statements concerning the case in the courtroom and then walking out into the jury room. In the movie, the audience is placed in the role of the invisible casual observer, who for perhaps the first 5 minutes of the movie, walks throughout the court building passing other court rooms, lawyers, defendants, security officers, elevators, etc. Not able to remember much about this particular part of the movie, I believe this introductory scene’s purpose was to either enhanced the realism of the setting by emphasizing the court building’s efficient, business like manner or to provide a timeslot in which to roll the credits for producer, director, stars, etc. The settings aren’t only built upon through use of scenery and extras in the movie. Invisible and distant in the play, we see in the movie the judge, bailiff, those witnessing the trial and most importantly of all- the defendant. This is an important change because in the play, we are free to come up with our own unbiased conclusions as to the nature and identity of the defendant, whom we only know to a be a 19 year boy from the slums. Seeing his haggard and worn face in the movie changes all of that, yet for better or worse, it engages the audience deeper into the trial as they surely will sympathize with him and can gain some insight into why, later, Juror 8 does so as well. Of final note in this summary of points concerning the differences in setting, the jurors all mention the heat wave affecting the city when they begin, and as it agitates them, it serves to heighten the tension between each other and their resentment or other feelings towards jury duty. Oh- also lastly, I think we can infer that the movie takes place in Manhattan, New York City. Which jurors are from which boroughs is easily obvious and yet I’m hesitant to say that the defendant could be from any of them- slums were persistent in those times. Concerning the characterization of the cast and their conflicts with each other, the movie holds true to the play’s guidelines. For the most part, each character I saw in the movie matched up with the picture my mind’s eye had painted whilst I was reading the play. One thing irked me however: all the jurors seemed at least 10 years older that I had imagined them. For instance, I had seen Juror 8- the protagonist of the play and Juror 3- his rival, the antagonist as being perhaps 30-ish or so and spirited and vibrant in their arguments. While somewhat vibrant they were, their age made them seem to come across as being more stubborn and grumpy (at least in, Juror 3’s case) than lively. Even Juror 2- the meek, weak and timid-spoken one, I thought would be so because of the age disparity between him and the older (and thus, supposedly- wiser) jurors. Yet he is portrayed as such a man but balding and smoking a pipe. His voice, however, fit nicely to its role. The conflicts in the movie, while also being more fleshed out than in the play, did match up essentially but there was one point- I thing just before Juror 8 asks for the diagram of the apartment- that the movie’s directors took the liberty to take dialogue from later in the play and put it there, greatly confusing me and hampering my ability to follow along. In analyzing the differences in the antagonist’s and protagonist’s relationship with each other and the other jurors, it too held to the play’s guidelines with the various alliances and verbal sparring making sense in light of each juror’s moral alignment and personality. There was one difference, a minor or major one depending how it was viewed. Detached from the ending, Juror 3 being more humanely portrayed in the movie than in the play was a minor change. Seen in relation to the movie’s ending, Juror 3’s inner conflicts and humanness is a very a major change. Finally the endings are to be discussed. Here, the play and the movie are obviously very different. The director with his poetic license makes a very obvious change only hinted at subtly earlier on and the impact it has on the audience’s conclusions at the end of the movie and the differences between that and those garnered at the end of the play are great. He tells us that Juror 3 was an abusive and uncaring father who, because he caused him to run away, has not seen his son- very similar to the defendant- in over 2 years. Ah, now we can see where his biases stem from: past negative experiences with his son, the rebellious nature of which justifies the execution of the defendant. Yet at the very end of the movie we sympathize with Juror 3 just as we did with defendant. We see his brutish, sadistic demeanor is just a facade, and at one point he too was an innocent father who simply made wrong choices. I think that the change in the ending was for the better because it clarified Juror 3’s motives greatly. The play’s ending did not- one got the feeling that Juror 3 was simply pressured into voting not guilty. We come away from it with a greater feeling self-satisfaction at the resolved trial. So, save for, but also including the ending, the changes made in the move adaptation of Rose’s play, “12 Angry Men”- the enhanced setting, great character casting and tense conflict and resolve- only served to enhanced it’s quality and make it enjoyable to watch.
Другие работы по теме:
Twelve Angry Men Essay Essay Research Paper
Jack Lemmon was a very persuasive speaker, using the methods of speech called logos and pathos, he convinced his audience (11 angry men) otherwise. He was capable of changing 11 men’s minds, which seemed to be sure about their decisions.
The One Thing In Society That Makes
Me Angry Essay, Research Paper There are many reasons why teens are sad. When a teen recieves a “D” on the report card, he or she can get depressed. When a shcool football team loses a game, this makes the teen sad also. The thing that bothers me most about society is school bullying.
Bad Temper Essay Research Paper My father
Bad Temper Essay, Research Paper My father Khalid has a very bad temper. First of all at home he yells at everybody specially me. One day when I was taking a shower he knocked the door real hard. In a angry way asked me to get my butt out of the rest room quickly. So I came out of the rest room in a hurry. Another time my mom had made pancakes and omelets.
12 Angry Men Essay Research Paper A
12 Angry Men Essay, Research Paper A persons surroundings can influence him. In “12 Angry Men” by Reginald Rose a young mans life is held by twelve men with contrasting views.
Twelve Angry Men Essay Research Paper In
Twelve Angry Men Essay, Research Paper In the story “Twelve Angry Men”, Reginald Rose shows how making one’s own decisions is one very important aspect in life. He also showed that one’s decisions should
Essay On Essay Research Paper My Sharkskin
Essay On Essay, Research Paper My Sharkskin Suit My Sharkskin Suit explained a child who wanted a sharkskin suit because they were very popular and not a lot of people had them in his neighborhood. Ed s father bought him the suit and gave it to him on Easter Sunday. Ed thought the first place he could wear it was church.
Taking Fate
’s Hand Essay, Research Paper Angry red welts mar the paper Not unlike those that cover my body And those that scar my mind I am my own victim The pen strokes bring me more pain
Twelve Angry Men Essay Research Paper 1
Twelve Angry Men Essay, Research Paper 1. The evidence presented in court was pretty strong. A woman said she saw the boy kill his father from across the train tracks through a window. A man in the apartment below the boys said he heard the boy say ” I am going to kill you, ” and then hear a body hit the ground. After that the man ran to the door and said that he saw the boy running down the stairs.
Jane Eyre Essay Research Paper Jane EyreJane
Jane Eyre Essay, Research Paper Jane Eyre Jane Eyre was originally a book, by Charlotte Bronte. It has now been made into a movie. There are two versions of the movie the BPC version, which is the British version and the American version. Both movies are very good and tell the story different. The British version is more like the book.
Abuse Can Rewire Kids
’ Brains Essay, Research Paper Abuse Can Rewire Kids? Brains This article discusses the detrimental effects that abuse can have on a child?s neurological activity. Children who are abused physically and psychologically show vehement neuronal excitation when observing pictures of angry faces. Children who are not victims of abuse do not experience such outrageous levels of neurological arousal when shown pictures of angry faces.
Anti Racist Essay Research Paper I totally
Anti Racist Essay, Research Paper I totally agree with that statement. The way that I have been brought up and how my parents have raised me. I am against all of those organizations. Now why would you want to be a racist? I can’t see how any person or group of people could be so angry at someone that they could beat them up based just on the persons color or religious background.
Beowulf Essay Research Paper 2
Beowulf Essay, Research Paper “Beowulf” Beowulf had a lot of anger in his battles. He used the rush of energy to conquer his most horrid opponents. I will show a few things in these paragraphs. Beowulf’s anger helped in his battles, hurt him in his battles, and fueled him to fight the battles. His anger is a source of winning and losing.
Candide Essay Research Paper CandideThe Enlightenment eighteenth
Candide Essay, Research Paper Candide The Enlightenment eighteenth century was the age of reason. This age involved the scientific method and was the understanding of the workings of the universe. This is when man began to question various aspects of life such as science religion and philosophy. People believed that Gods no longer were really a thought because gods don t make storms, aren t angry and now it s a force of nature.
Angry Horseman Essay Research Paper Book Report
Angry Horseman Essay, Research Paper Book Report on THE ANGRY HORSEMEN Title of Book : The Angry Horsemen Author of book: Lewis B. Patton Main setting of book: The main settings of the book were Johnny Toothaker’s ranch,
The Beach And Us Essay Research Paper
As angry waves crach on the sandy plain, Gulls fly as they escape the falling sea. Clouds form above to add the threat of rain, It’s vendetta clear to set it’s bombs free.
12 Angry Men Essay Research Paper Every
12 Angry Men Essay, Research Paper Every man put on trial is considered innocent until proven guilty. In 12 Angry Men this theory can almost be considered false to the jurors involved in this murder case. But one man can be credited with sticking to the innocent until proven guilty theory that most likely saved a man?s life.
Curly
’s Wife–Of Mice And Men Essay, Research Paper Curley s wife in Of Mice and Men is given a fairly one-dimensional portrayal throughout the novella, as her character stays, for the most part, enigmatic. The most obvious example would be her lack of a name. She is continually referred to as a possession of her husband and without a name she becomes almost insignificant.
Euro Essay Research Paper Tax breaks promised
Euro Essay, Research Paper Tax breaks promised by France and Italy to lorry drivers who mounted fuel price protest blockades in the summer looked to set to cause controversy among EU finance ministers meeting in Brussels today (19 January). The concessions are illegal under EU competition law and upset some of the countries? EU partners who were angry that the French and Italian governments gave in to the protesters.
12 Angry Man Essay Research Paper Twelve
12 Angry Man Essay, Research Paper Twelve Angry Men Sometimes in life your professions reflect on your personalities. Twelve Angry Men is an example of where this occurs. Twelve men are brought together in
Twelve Angry Men Essay Research Paper May
Twelve Angry Men Essay, Research Paper May 20, 1999 Twelve Angry Men In the film Twelve Angry Men, I believe justice was served. Without juror number eight, however, the outcome most assuredly would have been different. The subtle force and confidence that he displayed allowed the narrow minds of the other eleven jurors to be broadened.
Tyger And Lamb Essay Research Paper The
Tyger And Lamb Essay, Research Paper The Tyger and the Lamb In order to look at William Blake’s poem “Tyger! Tyger!” one must also look at “The Lamb.” The lamb and the tyger show the two contrary states of the human soul with respect to creation while asking what kind of god could make both. Blake’s questioning of God reflects the influence of the Enlightenment period.
Poetry A Poison Tree Essay Research Paper
A Poison Tree I was angry with my friend: I told my wrath, my wrath did end. I was angry with my foe: I told it not, my wrath did grow. And I water’d it in fears, Night & morning with my tears;
12 Angry Men Essay Research Paper Twelve
12 Angry Men Essay, Research Paper Twelve Angry Men The play ?Twelve Angry Men?, By Reginald Rose, is a play about 12 jurors that in an uncomfortable room have to discuss a life and death case about a boy that is accused or killing his father. the jurors do not really know eachother to talk to and wish they were anywhere but in that jury room.
Twelve Angry Men Essay Research Paper Twelve
Twelve Angry Men Essay, Research Paper Twelve Angry Men This play is about twelve jurors who are to decide the verdict of a 19 year old boy who is accused of killing his father. The jurors go into a room with the foreman to talk about the case and decide on a verdict. The vote has to be unanimous either guilty or not guilty for the case to end.
12 Angry Men Essay Research Paper English12
12 Angry Men Essay, Research Paper English: 12 angery men essay 2000-07-15 12 Angry Men Paper The jury member I chose to do my paper on was Mr. Davis (the member who voted not guilty first), because he used many task messages, did not allow physical factors to affect his decisions, and was a successful emergent leader at some points in the case.These three points made Mr.
Hamlet Essay Research Paper Hamlet In Lesson
Hamlet Essay, Research Paper Hamlet In Lesson 19 of the videotape ?Literary Visions?, the actor performs two interpretations of the monologue, ?To be or not to be?. As said in the video, there are many ways that an actor can choose to interpret that particular speech in Hamlet. Many actors relish the opportunity to perform Hamlet, because of that particular speech.
Divorce Essay Research Paper FAMILY CONFLICT is
Divorce Essay, Research Paper FAMILY CONFLICT is a struggle resulting from the opposition functioning of mutually exclusive impulses, desires, or tendencies. In other words, it is a big disagreement or situation that a family occurs.
Greek Gods 2 Essay Research Paper Greek
Greek Gods 2 Essay, Research Paper Greek Gods Zeus is the king of all the gods. Zeus had to kill his father who eats Zeus s brothers and sisters, so that he can free them. He than had to marry his sister Hera. He was not always with Hera, but with mortal women. Hera the wife of Zeus is always jealous of Zeus sneaking of to another women and gets angry all the time.
Echo Essay Research Paper Echo was a
Echo Essay, Research Paper Echo was a nymph who lived in the forest. She romped and played with all of her fellow nymphs. One day she came across a beautifull man named Narcissus. At first she was scared of him, but soon grew quite attached. The gods looked down upon an infatuated Narcissus with disdain. They sentenced him and his new love to horrible fates.
Use Of Force Essay Research Paper The
Use Of Force Essay, Research Paper The Use of Force illustrates very well the feelings and emotions of a normally rational person, who, for any reason, is subjected to a situation that causes
The Change Essay Research Paper EssayIn this
The Change Essay, Research Paper Essay In this essay I am supposed to discuss a project or activity that best represents me. I thought about this for a while, and I decided I would talk about my piano lessons. My parents didn?t make me take them, and I didn?t take them because it was “just something to do.” There is a lot behind the story.
Medicare Essay Research Paper How To Fix
Medicare Essay, Research Paper How To Fix Medicare Is The Greatest Challenge. This Issue Is A Very Important One That Will Eventually Come Under Fire As We Approach That Year 2001 When Medicare Is Projected To Go Bankrupt. This Issue Might Not Be Resolved And We Could Be Seeing The End Of Medicare. I This Issue Will Get Solved Some How The Taxpayers Will Pay Medicare Out Of Trouble.