– Evaluation And Critique Essay, Research Paper
The Turn Of The Screw
Thesis Statement: While ?The Turn of the Screw? initially appears to be a typical ghost
story, progression of the novel exposes the narrator?s ignorance and unfamiliarity of
her position as the narrator moves towards a nervous breakdown.
?The Turn of the Screw?, by Henry James, first appears to the reader as a ghost
story. It is the tale of how a young lady accepts a job as a governess, and how she is to
be in charge of a house resided by two children, Flora and Miles. The young lady (never
given a proper name) instantly falls in love with the two children, and is quite content with
her job. However, some strange and ominous things start to happen. First, Miles is
withdrawn from school, and then the young lady begins to see people where she shouldn?t
be seeing anyone. Upon questioning, Mrs. Grose (the housekeeper) tells the young lady
about two previous residents of the house and their position to the children( 24). She
also tells the young lady that both of them are now deceased. The young lady becomes
convinced that these two apparitions she sees are indeed these two previous residents
(Peter Quint and Miss Jessel.) The rest of the novel is dedicated to showing the young
lady?s despair, and Miss Jessel.) The rest of the novel is dedicated to showing the young
lady?s despair, how she convinces herself that the children are aware of the apparitions,
and how they all together are forming a conspiracy against her. At the climax of the
novel, Flora becomes deathly ill and is taken away by Mrs. Grose, and Miles dies due to
the shock of ?seeing? Peter?s ghost.
In actuality, however, none ever sees, or at least claims to see, these apparitions
that the young lady is so uneasy about. The young lady is the narrator of the story,
and her narration and viewpoint are both very questionable. It seems that what she sees
and even what she thinks she sees are all incomplete, and filled in by her imagination and
her paranoid and jumpy conclusions. When she begins spotting these ?ghosts?, she has no
clue who they are. She first encounters the ?apparition? of Peter Quint, and upon
explanation she tells Mrs. Grose that he appeared ?far from a gentleman.? Mrs. Grose
brings up Peter Quint, but says he always looked like a gentleman, but acted suspicious.
On page 27 of the novel, Mrs. Grose says the following about Peter Quint, ?Quint was so
clever- he was so deep.? It is then and only then that our narrator decides that the person
he saw was ?indeed a gentlemen.? This attitude, this perspective, brought on probably by
the anxiety of the new job, new responsibility, and sheer loneliness, is only fuel to her
conception of these ?apparitions?, which is practically handed to her with illustration by
Mrs. Grose?s steady supply of information.
Another example of the narrator?s presumed fact is how she decides that the
children are in association with the apparitions. She is completely convinced of this. Yet
when she ?encounters? the ghost of Miss Jessel at the beach shore for the first time, Flora
is completely unaware of the ?apparition?s? presence, and actually has her back towards
her. Even more illuminating, about two hours later the narrator tells Mrs. Grose ?The
Children know all that we know – Flora saw!?(30) She is, of course, speaking of Miss
Jessel, and how by this time paranoia has caused her to honestly believe that Flora saw
her, yet it is clearly shown that Flora is too preoccupied with the water and her toys to
even notice Miss Jessel.
The end result of the narrator?s lunacy and anxiety is Flora contracting a deadly
illness and the untimely death of Miles. After the narrator verbally assaults Flora, calling
her a liar ( 70) and accusing her off conspiring with Miss Jessel, Flora becomes deathly ill
and the narrator pleads with Mrs. Grose to take Flora away, thus saving her from the evil
that supposedly resides in Bly. The narrator also says that she will handle Miles, and
spends time with him.
At the finish of the novel, the narrator sees Peter Quint in a window, and attempts
to force Miles to admit that he sees him too. But when poor Miles turns toward where
Peter is, he drops dead from the fright caused by the narrator. Poor Miles heart caves in
as he experiences a fraction of the narrator?s lunacy. Even the last sentence of the novel
displays the narrator?s madness when she says ?…his letter heart, dispossessed, had
stopped.?(88) In my opinion, the only thing possessing young Miles? heart was fear
and insanity, initiated from the governess.
Regarding the criticism and interpretation of this book, of the ones I?ve read, I
agree with Leon Edel?s ?The Point Of View?, which is his take on the novel. He states
essentially the same thing I do, being that the narrator is not stable and not to be trusted.
I think that he sums it up the best when he says ?The reader must establish for himself the
credibility of the witness; he must decide between what the governess supposed and what
she claims she saw?( 233). I couldn?t agree with that more, considering that the careful
and analytical reader can argue just about any ?ghost? sighting our narrator has had, just
based upon the narrator?s description. Also on 233, Edel states ?The governess?
imagination, we see, discovers ?depths? within herself. Fantasy seems to be a reality for
her.?(233) When Edel says this, he is referring to the fact that the governess schematically
worked out this huge plot in her mind, and thinks that the plan is ominously set up for the
children to be taken away by Quint and Jessel.
On the other hand, Eric Solomon completely caught me off guard with his
interpretation entitled ?The Return of the Screw.? It went a completely different route
and put the blame on Mrs. Grose, something I hadn?t even considered. While some
interesting aspects were brought to my attention, I don?t believe that this is in the least bit
true. To me his interpretation seems like a work of literature in itself, like Solomon is
re-defining the entire story. In his frame, Mrs. Grose is the guilty party, and her motive is
that she wants young Flora and Miles for herself. Solomon says (on 238) ?Motive?
Love and ambition. Mrs. Grose has already risen from maid to housekeeper- why not
to governess? Her obstacle is this young lady…?. While he does present a reasonable
argument had some interesting points, I personally believe that this reading is nonsense
and that the author possibly has read way too many mystery novels.
Edna Kenton?s interpretation is not a very opinionated one, but rather states that
there is more to the novel than just your basic ghost story. On page 209, Kenton says
this about The Turn of the Screw ?He would have his own private ?fun? in its writing…
but he would put about this centre, not only traps set and baited for the least lapse of
attention, but lures…? Speaking of the theme of the story, she remarks ?when the reader
comes face to face at last with the little governess and realizes that the guarding ghosts
and children are only exquisite dramatizations of her little personal mystery acting out her
story in her troubled mind.?(210) This was by far my favorite quote, as it completely
describes the truth in the novel.
Martina Slaughter offers her summary of Edmund Wilson?s repeated
criticism of The Turn of the Screw. Slaughter says that, in agreement with Wilson, Peter
Quint was in actuality a character created by the governess? own sexual desires, inspired
by her ?crush? on the Uncle of the children. Slaughter is also quick to point out ?sexual
references? in the novel. These examples are ?Quint on the tower; Miss Jessel at the
lake; Flora?s toy boat, which she created by pushing a stick into a small flat piece of
wood.?(212). I think that both Slaughter and Wilson are trying to draw something that
just isn?t there. While their imagination is quite impressive, I think that if you took any
novel ever written, you could find twice as many ?sexual references?, which in my opinion
are merely coincidence, if that at all.
Finally, Mark Spilka essentially agrees with Slaughter and Wilson, referring to
Miss Jessel?s hallucinations as ?sexual ghosts?(248). I think that Spilka got way ahead
of himself on this one, and once again used the power of imagination, ironically similar to
the way Miss Jessel used hers in the novel. I think that this interpretation was
unnecessary, and while it isn?t my position to state fact on this novel, that Leon Edel and
Edna Kenton were dead on with their interpretations, and that The Turn of the Screw isn?t
much deeper than that.
Другие работы по теме:
Science Producing Quicksand Essay Research Paper Quicksand
Science: Producing Quicksand Essay, Research Paper Quicksand Goal: To see if I can make quicksand and to see how it works. Apparatus: Plastic aquarium, plastic tubing (make sure that a portion of it is able to fit around the output of the chemical lawn sprayer), Plexiglas, cardboard, brass tubing, 2 hose barbs, 2 connectors, chemical lawn sprayer, plastic jug (to hold the same amount that the sprayer will), gas shut off-valve, small plastic cup, silicon sealer, epoxy, marker or pen, razor, wood, tape, scissors or knife, rocks, fine sand, sandpaper, drill, waterproof tape, jigsaw (or another saw that can cut Plexiglas), heavy object, string.
ShakespeareS Social Themes In Taming Of The
Screw Essay, Research Paper Greg Graziani 03-05-01 English 283 sect. 08 McLaughlin Shakespeare’s Social Themes in Taming of the Screw Shakespeare’s Taming of the Screw is widely viewed as a comical play. But are the views and topics that are expressed really intended to be funny or are they more of a serious concern of Shakespeare’s that women are mistreated? Throughout this paper I will try to explain that the perspective that Shakespeare is showing is one of concern over sexism and the treatment of women.
Informal Essay On The Turn Of The
Screw Essay, Research Paper Informal Essay on “The Turn of the Screw” A young gentleman named Miles died yesterday. There are many mysteries surrounding his death. His sole protector and guardian, the Governess of Bly, claims that supernatural forces overtook the child. After the autopsy, I found her accusations to be nonsense.
Turn Of The Screw
– Real Ghosts? Or Not? Essay, Research Paper In the short story The Turn of the Screw by Henry James, what is seen may not necessarily be the truth. This raises the important question, “Are these ghosts real or just seen through the eyes of the governess?” There are many pieces of information in the story that lead the reader to believe these ghost are real, but at the same time there are others that question the truth, and I adjure you to believe.
Turn Of The Screw By Henry
James Essay, Research Paper Turn of the Screw by: Henry James After reading The Turn of the Screw , by Henry James, I was left with many unanswered questions. The two main questions are, are the ghosts in the story real, or are they just figments of the narrator s imagination? When I read though the essays of criticism, I took a stand on one particular argument.
The Governess Is Deluded The Children Are
Merely Innocent Victims Essay, Research Paper Literary criticism on The Turn of the Screw has been divided into 3 groups, concerning the plot. The first is to take the novel at face value, and say that it is a ghost story, that the children are possessed by the ghosts. Others have said that it is a psychological drama that plays upon some of Freud?s theses – the ghosts are hallucinations of a sexually repressed girl who has been given a sudden boost in responsibility, and her madness corrupts the beautiful.
Archimedes Essay Research Paper ArchimedesArchimedes was born
Archimedes Essay, Research Paper Archimedes Archimedes was born in 287 BC in Syracuse, a Greek seaport colony in Sicily. Archimedes’ father was Phidias. He was an astronomer; this is all we know about his father and we learn this from Archimedes’ work, The Sandreckoner. Archimedes was educated in Alexandria, Egypt.
In A Clutch Essay Research Paper IN
In A Clutch Essay, Research Paper IN A CLUTCH In the old biker days before the modern age Yuppie bikers, who buy outrageously priced new Harleys and then pay to have tons of chrome accessories added to them. We actually built and maintained our Harley-Davidson Motorcycles ourselves. No two bikes were the same everyone added their own personal touch to their bike.
The Scooby Doo Theory The Governess
’ Sanity And Early Ghost Appearances Essay, Research Paper The Scooby Doo Theory: The Governess’ Sanity and Early Ghost Appearances in The Turn of the Screw
Archetype Myths In Turn Of The Screw
Essay, Research Paper The Archetypal Myth in Turn of The Screw In one surface reading of Henry James’s Turn of the Screw, the governess appears to be a victim of circumstance. Some critics however, say that she is not without blame in the turn of events that characterizes the story. They claim that leading to her demise are certain character flaws, such as envy and pride.
Turn Of The Screw Is An Allego
Essay, Research Paper The Turn of the Screw Henry James The Turn of the Screw is an incredibly complicated and hard to understand story; it hints at much, but explains little. The fact that the story is open to so many interpretations is, in some ways, the point of the story. The Turn of the Screw is a classic example of the Gothic novel, which depends on a sound concept of evil.
Turn Of The Screw Essay Research Paper
The Turn of the Screw The novel, The Turn of the Screw, is written by Henry James. The characters in this novel are the governess, Miles, Flora, Mrs. Grose, Quint, and Miss Jessel. The apparitions in The Turn of the Screw are real.
The Turn Of The Screw Essay Research
Paper The Symbolic Color of Black in The Turn of the Screw In The Turn of the Screw by Henry James, black clothing worn by the ghosts of Peter Quint and Miss Jessel foreshadows evil and darkness throughout the novel. Throughout the novel, James creates a character that is “in the dark.” The phrase “in the dark” means to be without knowledge.
Archimedes Essay Research Paper Archimedes
Archimedes Essay, Research Paper Archimedes Archimedes is by far one of the most important Greek mathematicians and inventors of all time. He came up with a theory of buoyancy, made an accurate estimate for pi, and made great advancements in the field of geometry and warfare. He also invented the Archimedes screw, (which is still used today) the compound pulley, and the catapult.
Natures Haters Essay Research Paper English The
Natures Haters Essay, Research Paper English- The Plague and The Stranger Albert Camus Every year when light hits my window a little bit earlier than regular and the smell of dew on grass is fresh every morning the birds from hell wake me up at five o’ clock. The stupid little critters got to chirp their way into my dreams and bother me.
Poem Black And White Essay Research Paper
My colorful world filled with black and weight, Seems to turn gray has skies turn bright, The sun no longer orange, But round in its big boring wonder, I turn around to use more than a frown,
Ben Is Late Essay Research Paper Ben
Ben Is Late Essay, Research Paper Ben is Late, based on a true recollection Cathy Robinson It?s eight in the morning and all the mechanics are standing in the shop ready to go to work, except Ben. There was more work then all the mechanics could do and it was going to be a very busy day.
Daisy MillerTurn Of The Screw Essay Research
Paper Henry James does an extraordinary job in establishing innocence in two distinguishable scenarios. Henry James, author of The Turn of the Screw and Daisy Miller uses somewhat of a superficial approach in using youth and beauty, in order to institute innocence. This is the basis for conflict in the stories.
The Characterization Of Lady Macbeth Essay Research
Paper The Characterization of Lady MacBeth Characterization is the noted change or continual development of a character as a plot unfolds. In William Shakespeare’s tragedy MacBeth’s character takes a complete turn from the beginning of the play until her last seen. Lady MacBeth plays a very bold and manipulative character.
Why Limp Bizkit Is Not Heavy Metal
Essay, Research Paper Why Limp Bizkit Is Not Heavy Metal If a person were to view any classic talented Heavy Metal band, it would be apparent that, the band, Limp Bizkit, is in no way resembling a Heavy Metal band. Limp Bizkit is clearly a Rap band and not a Heavy Metal band. First, the band members behave like Rappers.
Ode To Boys Essay Research Paper We
Ode To Boys Essay, Research Paper We like them But do they like us The ones we do never fuss They don’t stop in And we wonder why We stress, we bitch We sometimes cry
Henry James Essay Research Paper Asesyan 1Son
Henry James Essay, Research Paper Asesyan 1 Son of the religious philosopher henry James, Sr., and brother of the psychologist and philosopher William, Henry James was born in New York City, April 15, 1843. His early life was spent in America; on and off he was taken to Europe, especially during the impressionable years from twelve to seventeen.
Morbid Satisfaction Essay Research Paper Even in
Morbid Satisfaction Essay, Research Paper Even in her first glimpse of Miles, the governess in Henry James’s Turn of the Screw feels instant adoration and affection for the boy who she describes as innocent, at least by outward appearance. As she grows to know Miles, she develops not only an attachment towards him, but an obsession as well.
Technical Description Essay Research Paper My technical
Technical Description Essay, Research Paper My technical description is on my dependable Coleman flashlight. The Coleman flashlight is a hand-sized plastic flashlight, easily portable, which will fit into most automobile glove compartments. The Coleman flashlight has an overall length of 6 inches.
How To Change Oil In Your Car
Essay, Research Paper Jovon Moore English 110, order paper Mrs. Reeher 04-06-00 How to change oil in your car Many people may think changing the oil in your vehicle is a difficult and lengthy procedure. In fact, it?s not that tough if you follow a few basic steps. Draining the oil, placing the oil pan in the right place and putting on the new filter, shouldn?t be to hard after following these easy steps.
Computer Building Essay Research Paper The computer
Computer Building Essay, Research Paper The computer is a commonly used machine in today’s society. Building the right system is important factor to having a stable running PC. Knowing what you need the computer for, the parts inside the computer, and installing all the components correctly is also very important to this process.
Procedure Essay Building Your Own Pc Essay
, Research Paper Building Your Own PC In the following paragraphs I will be instructing you step by step on how to build your own PC (Personal Computer). It is recommended that you have general knowledge on computers. This means that you need to know what the different parts are and what they do.
Huck Finn Essay Research Paper Throughout Huck
Huck Finn Essay, Research Paper Throughout Huck Finn, Huck and Jim develop a special relationship despite the rest of the communities’ views. Three examples of this are: how Huck doesn’t turn Jim in when his conscience says he should, how Huck frees Jim from jail, and Huck deciding he would rather go to hell than lose Jim’s friendship.