Kant And Utilitarianism Essay, Research Paper
In the story, The Ones Who Walk Away From Omelas, two points of view are
introduced. The Kantian point of view is contrasted with the Utilitarian point
of view. In the story there is a city named Omelas, in which a single child
suffers so that the community may live with great happiness. Most of the
community accepts the fact that one child must suffer for happiness to exist.
However, the odd citizen becomes so disgusted with the fact the child is allowed
to suffer that they leave Omelas for good. In this essay, one character will be
a Utilitarian and another character will be Kantian. The two characters will
debate the issue of sacrificing one person for the good of the community, and
they will answer the question, ?Would you walk away from Omelas?? The first
character is named Sandra, and the other is named Ben. Finally, this essay
assumes that Omelas is a unique city on the planet earth. Ben: I went to look at
him yesterday. Sandra: Who did you go look at? Ben: You know? him, the one
locked up in the basement of the old church. I finally got up enough courage to
go and see what the sacrificed one really looks like. Sandra: I don?t like how
he is just called the sacrificed one. I?m sure he must have a name. Everybody
has a name?that?s just part of what make us a person. Ben: What do you
mean!? He needs no name. Why would he need a name? Nobody is allowed to talk to
him, because that might give the impression that we actually care about him. You
only need a name if you interact with other people, just like how when I talk to
you I call you by your name. I will never talk to the sacrificed one. Sandra:
Never? But that doesn?t show any respect for him? he must deserve at least a
little respect. Every person on Earth deserves respect, even the sacrificed one.
Ben: He doesn?t deserve any respect. Giving him respect could jeopardize all
that me and you have. His pain allows us to live with such joy. Our parents
lived like this, and their parents lived like this. It is almost like happiness
is a tradition in Omelas. Sandra: Sure, Omelas has always sacrificed a child in
order to achieve happiness for the community, but why doesn?t the rest of the
world also do this. If it is such a good idea, why too doesn?t every city on
the planet adopt this method? Ben: Every other city is ignorant to the benefits
that are achieved through a sacrifice. I feel that the world would be a much
better place if everybody lived such as we do. Our life is a life of constant
utopia. Sandra: I think that the world doesn?t adopt our idea about
sacrificing because they feel that it is morally wrong. Quite frankly I would
have to agree with the rest of the world. How would you feel if someone you
loved were forced into a life of suffering and confinement? If it was someone
such as your sister or brother? What if it was you who was chosen to suffer?
Would it still be acceptable if it was you who had to live a life of pain and
isolation? I think that most people in the world would argue that it is immoral
to allow someone to suffer. Ben: Your argument against sacrificing is based on
morals, however decisions shouldn?t be made based on morals, but rather on the
outcome of those decisions. Actions, such as sacrificing, should be measured
according to the overall happiness it will achieve. When weighed out,
sacrificing produces much more happiness than if we didn?t sacrifice.
Therefore, allowing one person to suffer is perfectly acceptable. It is our duty
to make sure that maximum happiness is obtained for all. Sandra: Sacrificing
this child is an action that has no moral worth. You allow this child to be
sacrificed because you want to be happy for the rest of your life. You?re not
accepting the sacrifice of this child because it?s your duty; you?re doing
it because you want to be happy. Therefore your acceptance holds no moral worth.
Ben: I accept the suffering based on the overall consequences. Overall, the
suffering is justified and thus acceptable. The happiness of the whole city
greatly outweighs the suffering of the child, and this makes the sacrifice okay.
Sandra: The fact is, a child?s life has been ruined. I can?t see how this is
justified. Ben: Let me give you an example of how a sacrifice was made in order
to protect the whole world, including Omelas. World War II was ended because of
a great sacrifice. A bomb was dropped on a city in Japan and a large number of
people were killed. This destruction caused Japan to surrender, and ended the
war. Had the bomb not been dropped, the war would have continued and millions of
people would have died. Omelas lives in freedom because the bomb was dropped and
the war was ended. This is a case of how the resulting happiness of the whole
world, outweighed the sadness caused by the bomb. Would you rather live without
freedom, without happiness? Sandra: Of course I want to have freedom and be
happy. But there must be another way to achieve these things. Why must we
sacrifice a person? This child is a rational human, he has rights, and he
deserves respect. Ben: How can you argue that he is rational. When I went to see
him he was about as irrational as anyone could be. He is an imbecile?. he is
afraid of mops and he just sits there and whines quietly, ?eh-haa, eh-haa.?
He has no idea of what happiness is, and probably never will. Therefore, I have
no problem with allowing him to stay locked up and suffer so that the rest of
the city may live a perfectly happy life. You argue that it is wrong to keep him
locked up because he is a rational being, but I have just explained why he is
not rational. Do you still think that his suffering is not justified? Sandra: I
can see how you would argue that he is not a rational person, but don?t you
feel guilty because you get to enjoy happiness while someone suffers. Ben: Let
me ask you a question. Would you rather live in a different city? In a city
where there are worries, murders, hurt, and sadness? Could you give up constant
happiness? Could you walk away from Omelas? Sandra: Honestly, I couldn?t live
somewhere that didn?t bring me happiness all the time. I guess that being a
part of the Omelas community forces me to accept the fact that someone must
suffer for me to enjoy life to the fullest. Ben: Don?t forget that the
suffering child will never know what happiness is. He is an irrational child. He
is barely functioning?he is an imbecile. Having the child suffer is justified
because the happiness of the whole city outweighs the suffering of the child. I
don?t see how anyone could ever leave a life of continual happiness. I don?t
see how anyone would walk away from Omelas. I would never walk away. Sandra: I
too, could not imagine my life without continual happiness. But, my decision to
never leave Omelas is an interesting decision. I?ve just realized that I came
to my decision through the same method that you used for your arguments. By this
I mean, that I came to my decision through weighing out the consequences of
leaving and staying. I came to the conclusion that staying would give me the
greatest happiness. I even took into consideration the fact that I may feel
guilty because I know that a child is suffering so that I may live a life that
is full of pleasure and joy. I now see that the suffering of the child is in
fact justified because a whole city gets to live a life of pure happiness.
Другие работы по теме:
Right Theory Essay Research Paper Right Theory1
Right Theory Essay, Research Paper Right Theory: 1. Rights create obligations, type of moral discourse & involve agents, being who act & are acted upon. People are given obligations to respect your rights. There is no right to obligate other people rights. (Conventional rights: Created by group of people as law or regulation in our society.
Masturbation Essay Research Paper They
Masturbation Essay, Research Paper They’re not blind. They don’t have hair on their palms. Even so, they still masturbate. Of all the topics that continually find themselves under attack, none seems to be restricted solely to quiet, taboo conversations as often as masturbation. For countless generations, this subject has been put down, looked down on, and kept behind closed doors, and no one is really sure why. “It’s immoral”, or “its dirty” are the best anyone has come up with.
Kant And Disinterestedness Essay Research Paper
“which we Disinterestedness has been a reaccurant theme in aesthetic thought throughout recent times. Kant was one of the first to discribe disinterestedness as an basic and universal part of the aesthetic judgement experiance. However the notion of disinterestedness did not origninate with Kant; it is to be found in the writtings of many Eighteenth centuray philosophers such as Stolinitz, Shaftsbury, Hutcheson, Gerard and Burke.
Kant Goodness Essay Research Paper Kant Goodness
Kant: Goodness Essay, Research Paper Kant: Goodness The philosopher I used is Immanuel Kant. He was very practical in his thinking of goodness. A quote of his was “I ought, therefore I can”. His view
Utiliatariasm And Its Authors Essay Research Paper
Utilitarianism is the principle idea for the greatest happiness for the greatest numbers. In other words, maximize the pleasure while minimizing the pain. One such philosopher and believer of Utilitarianism is Jeremy Bentham, who lived from 1748 until 1832. He believed that there should be a moral system, and that it should do two things.
Morality Essay Research Paper This essay will
Morality Essay, Research Paper This essay will compare and contrast the moral philosophies of three people: St Augustine, Immanuel Kant, and Aristotle. Everybody has their own concept of what good is. Most people agree on certain things such as the morality of murder, stealing, etc. , however, as our conceptions are looked at with greater detail, why we do good, how we do good, and basically what good stands for, varies.
Kant An Act Of Moral Worth
Essay, Research Paper Jill had been driving down a deserted road when her tire became flat. With no one around for miles she struggled with changing the tire when Jack happened to be driving by and stopped to give her a hand. How and why is this an act of genuine moral worth?
Kants Morality Essay Research Paper Kant starts
Kant`s Morality Essay, Research Paper Kant starts off making two distinctions regarding kinds of knowledge, empirical/rational and formal/material. Empirical or experience-based knowledge
Euthanasia Essay Research Paper In today
Euthanasia Essay, Research Paper In today’s society, if you ask five people who Jack Kevorkian is then three or more would know who he is. The issue of euthanasia has been on the media’s forefront for several years. There are several pros and cons to this issue. Some of these pros are as follows: it would help to end pain and suffering, it allows a person to die with dignity, and it also helps the grieving process because the person knows when they are gonna die.
Social Virtues Essay Research Paper Social VirtuesWhat
Social Virtues Essay, Research Paper Social Virtues What is being Social, and what virtues do you need to possess to become sociable? Throughout your life you are going to being interacting, and communicating with just about everyone who is living around you and working with you. In my paper I am going to be talking about some of the major virtues you will need to acquire to become a ethically wise and social person according to the three leading ethical philosophers; Aristotle, Kant, and Mills.
Utilitarianism Essay Research Paper UtilitarianismThe main idea
Utilitarianism Essay, Research Paper Utilitarianism The main idea of utilitarianism, according to Adam Morton s book Philosophy in Practice is to follow the action that brings about the greatest amount of pleasure or the least amount of pain. This idea at first seems simple but when applied to some examples the edges blur.
Kant Essay Research Paper KANTKant begins to
Kant Essay, Research Paper KANT Kant begins to claim that there is nothing in the world that can be regarded as good without qualification except good will. He says that qualities of temperment such as
Glass Ceiling Summary Essay Research Paper Utilitarianism
Glass Ceiling Summary Essay, Research Paper Utilitarianism favors unequal treatment in the work place.CONTROLLING IDEA: Big corporations should be forced into applying affirmative action to equal out the male/female ratio in management positions.
Metaphysis Essay Research Paper Hello I
Metaphysis Essay, Research Paper : Hello: : I need help, I have somes question would help me. 1. do the criticisms that hume makes of Design Arguments all apply to Thomas’ Teleological Argument?
Ethics 4 Essay Research Paper Connie Science
Ethics 4 Essay, Research Paper Connie Science s moral dilemma of whether or not to break government ethics laws regarding the acceptance of lobbyist s gifts has come to its climax where she must choose if she will jump on the bandwagon or not. Ms. Science could use a number of methods to come to a logical and morally sound conclusion.
Kant And Mill Essay Research Paper Kant
Kant And Mill Essay, Research Paper Kant: Universal Law Formation of the Categorical Imperative Mill: Utilitarianism Immanuel Kant?s philosophy frames the Universal Law Formation of the Categorical Imperative as a procedure for determining morality of actions. This method contains two vital components.
Mill Vs Kant Essay Research Paper SummaryImmanuel
Mill Vs. Kant Essay, Research Paper Summary Immanuel Kant and John Stuart Mill are philosophers who addressed the issues of morality in terms of how moral traditions are formed. Immanuel Kant has presented one viewpoint in The Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals that is founded on his belief that the worth of man is inherent in his ability to reason.
Kant And Utilitarianism Essay Research Paper First
Kant And Utilitarianism Essay, Research Paper First of all I want to state the Kantian and the Utilitarian views butt heads on this issue. The Kantian view is nonconsequential, that is as a matter of
Utilitarianism 2 Essay Research Paper When first
Utilitarianism 2 Essay, Research Paper When first introduced to Utilitarianism one would think that it is pretty straightforward and easy to swallow. Utilitarianism relates to the greatest happiness of the greatest number. Although there are some problems with this theory. In the paragraphs to follow I will illustrate what Utilitarianism is, discuss why it is important to society, and discuss some of the problems related to Utilitarianism.
A Book Report On Kant
’s Fundamental Principles Of The Metaphysic Of Morals Essay, Research Paper Kant states (38,) “act as if the maxim of thy action were to become by thy will a universal law of nature”. This “categorical imperative” forms the basis of his book, Fundamental Principles of the Metaphysics of Morals. Though at times his writing is confusing Kant lays out his logic as to what a categorical imperative is.
American Transcendentalism Essay Research Paper American TranscendentalismTranscendentalism
American Transcendentalism Essay, Research Paper American Transcendentalism Transcendentalism as espoused by Ralph Waldo Emerson is essen tially an idealist philosophy, derived from Kant’s concept of the Tran scendental and opposed to the skepticism of Locke and the Empiricists. In the essay The Transcendentalist, Emerson wrote, “[Kant showed] that there was a very important class of ideas or imperative forms, which do not come by experience, but through which experience was acquired; that these were intuitions of the mind itself; and he denominated them Tran scendental forms.”1 According to Emerson’s understanding of Kant, Transcendentalism becomes a union of solipsism, under which the only verifiable reality is thought to be the self, and materialism, under which the only verifiable reality is the quantifiable external world of objects and sense data.
Immanuel Kant Essay Research Paper Meetesh Patel
Immanuel Kant Essay, Research Paper Meetesh Patel Philosophy Immanuel Kant Immanuel Kant is one of the most influential philosophers in the history of western philosophy. His contributions to metaphysics, epistemology, ethics, and aesthetics have had a profound impact on almost every philosophical movement that followed him.
Asses The Value Of Kant Essay Research
Paper The ethics of Immanuel Kant are based on the belief that ethics stem from rules and reason much like the law of gravity, they are universal and applied always regardless of circumstances. He believed that the capacity to reason was unique to man and when exercised this was what it meant to be a moral human being.
Classical Utilitarianism Essay Research Paper
“Classical Utilitarianism,” by John Rawls This short piece by Rawls makes the point that “utilitarianism does not take seriously the distinction between persons.” This is an intriguing statement and warrants discussion. Rawls view of utilitarianism is that the goal for society is the fulfillment of the maximum satisfaction of all its members.
Kantianism V Utilitarianism Essay Research Paper Ethics
Kantianism V. Utilitarianism Essay, Research Paper Ethics can be defined as the conscious reflection on our moral beliefs with the aim of improving, extending or refining those beliefs in some way. (Dodds, Lecture 2) Kantian moral theory and Utilitarianism are two theories that attempt to answer the ethical nature of human beings.
Kant Essay Research Paper Immanuel Kant was
Kant Essay, Research Paper Immanuel Kant was a sound, grounded philosopher of the Enlightenment. His explanations were black and white, clear-cut, which may be seen as his greatest attribute, as well as his worst flaw. The drive behind all of Kant’s ideas was reason. To Kant, morality was a matter of rational, acting morally equaled acting rationally.
Kant S Ethics Essay Research Paper Kant
Kant S Ethics Essay, Research Paper Kant s Ethics In the Metaphysics of Ethics (1797) Kant described his ethical system, which is based on a belief that the reason is the final authority for morality. Actions of any sort, he believed, must be undertaken from a sense of duty dictated by reason, and no action performed for expediency
Kant
’s Fundamental Principles Of The Metaphysics Of Moral Essay, Research Paper Kant’s Fundamental Principles of the Metaphysics of Moral The central concept of Kant’s Fundamental Principles of the Metaphysics of
LAW Ceciro Plato Socrates St Thomas Essay
, Research Paper REVIEWING KEY CONCEPTS 1) Define natural and positive law. Identify the fundamental differences between the theories of natural and positive law. Give an example to illustrate each of these theories.