Paper
Poles and Italians in Detroit
In the late 17th century and early 18th century Detroit was a hotbed for foreign immigration. The booming automobile industry and resulting growth of the city ensured that many jobs were available for those able to take them. Among these immigrants were distinct groups originating from many different countries. Two of these groups were the Poles and the Italians, who arrive to Detroit looking for a new beginning. Although many similarities can be found between the groups there are an equal number of differences, which defined each separate culture. In this paper I?d like to focus on the similarities and differences between the Poles and Italians in Detroit by looking at their reasons for leaving their countries and subsequent arrivals into Detroit, their lifestyles upon moving to Detroit, and the Americanization process that occurred when they arrived.
In my opinion both the Poles and Italians left their homelands not necessarily because they wanted to, but more as a means of survival. Both of these groups suffered from insufficient family incomes due to overpopulation, lack of peasant landholding, and changing word economy. Although they shared these similarities their were also striking differences.
?Poland was partitioned among three neighboring empires and disappeared as a state in Europe until after World War I? (Global View/Origins/Europe/Poland). Since the Poles were under foreign rule, which left them without a voice in their respective governments and society many, chose to immigrate to Detroit as a means of political relief. Upon arrival to Detroit they occupied the North Eastern side of the city, and because ?Poles comprised the largest European immigrant group in the metropolis,? (American Cities/Detroit/Poles/Neighborhood/In Streets/Detroit Polish Settlements) they soon occupied Hamtramck as well.
Most who left Italy and moved to Detroit were Southern Italian farmers. ?As Italy became unified and tied to the world economy, its economy and society changed sharply,? (Global View/Origins/Europe/Italy) due to the fact that most Italians used outdated methods of farming which produce insufficient crop when compared to more modernized societies. When they came to Detroit they shared a strong family ties and village obligation which led to most Italians settling together on the East side of Detroit.
To me, it is obvious why these two groups immigrated to Detroit. The Poles were under foreign rule, and had no say in their government. Their departure took place during World War I when the countries that were ruling them also persecuted them because of beliefs and political differences. This is true even today, no person wants to give up his right of free will, and if pressed into this it is much easier to leave for a place where you are free to exercise your own opinions. Likewise Italians were forced to leave as a means to find a source of income. However their emigration rate was the highest among immigrants, which leads me to believe that their reason for leaving was almost purely a matter of money. Which I again can identify with, it?s very common for people in today?s society to switch jobs because it ensures more financial security, even if that job may be undesirable.
One of the most defining characteristics, which separated the Poles and the Italians, were their varied lifestyles while living in Detroit. The major difference when looking at the two appeared in their means of employment. Most of the Poles in Detroit worked in the automobile or metal industries, and quite a few actually had skilled labor jobs. While some Italians worked in industry their employment tendencies had quite a bit of diversity. Jobs held by Italians included (but were not limited to) unskilled labor in the fields of auto, shipbuilding, and construction. Many were also involved in the pedaling of fruits and vegetables from street side stands.
The jobs that the Poles and Italians held while in Detroit make sense when you consider their background. Before arriving in Detroit Poles were exposed to the industrial explosion in their homeland. This also explains why some Poles had skilled labor jobs while in Detroit. On the other hand the majority of Italians in Detroit were poor farmers in Italy, and since they were now living in a budding metropolis many of the skills they acquired while farming were not applicable in the city. This forced the majority of the Italians to take unskilled labor positions.
Another important difference was what each group considered their top priority while in Detroit. ?For the first generation Polish immigrant, home ownership was the highest economic priority,? (American Cities/Detroit/Poles/Neighborhood/At Home/Thrift and Home Ownership) and often resulted in young boys being pulled out of school to work. In contrast the top priority for Italians seemed to be supporting the families that were left in Italy.
Because the Polish immigrations were more permanent than the Italians it is understandable why a nice home would be important. To many it was and still is a sign of wealth and prosperity. When considering the Italians you must realize that many were supporting families in Italy, and actually planned on returning which would mean that the home they would be interested in owning would be in a different country.
Finally another difference was the importance of religion. For the Polish, ?a church is considered the first need of a colony? (American Cities/Detroit/Poles/Neighborhood/In Streets/Location of Polish Colonies). Socialization of the Poles started in the church. However the Italians didn?t put near as much importance in religion, as is evident in the fact that many more Italian children attended public schools than did the Polish children (who were enrolled in parochial schools.
It is my opinion that the Poles put so much emphasis on their religion because they were persecuted for it in Europe during World War I, and this was their chance to openly worship. It seems that in any time period, people hold on the tightest to the things that are being taken away from them and in this case it was religion.
A major movement in Detroit during the mid-1910?s was one to promote the Americanization of all immigrants including the Poles and Italians. ?Detroiter?s worried that, settled on racial lines, the immigrants lived apart, came in little contact with Americans, and sustained old customs, traditions, and prejudices? (American Cities/Detroit/Italian/Neighborhood/In Streets/Italian Settlements). The Detroit Board of Education through the offering off nighttime English classes pushed this Americanization. The Ford Motor Company also pushed it by offering English classes, American clothes, and the demand of American house keeping.
Although both the Poles and Italians eventually Americanized the time frame in which they did so was different. The Poles took a longer amount of time to act like ?Americans?, when compared to the Italians. I believe there art two reasons why the time frames differed. First, the Polish children were enrolled in parochial schools where they were spoken to in their native tongue. On the other hand most Italian children were enrolled in public schools where they were practically forced to learn English if they wanted to stay in school.
The other reason I believe it took the Poles longer to Americanize had to do with the role of the family. Polish children were spoken too in their native language while at home, and forbidden to use English. However, these children were treated very well and loved which made them more willing to take on the roles of their parents when it came to the Polish culture. For Italians it was a different story, the Italian fathers were very domineering which caused rifts between them and their sons. Through the strictness of their rules they caused many of their sons to rebel and to take on the characteristics of Americans just to spite their fathers.
I believe that although Americanization was inevitable, the industrial boom speeded up the process. The Detroit industries encouraged the ?American? way of life because they believed if all of their workers spoke a common language the business would be more efficient. While I tend to agree with the thinking about efficiency, this is just another example of how money makes the world go round. That coupled with the insensitive Italian fathers further pushed the second generation Italians away from the Italian culture and towards the American one.
There were many people who looked upon the immigrants as one huge group without taking the time to notice the sometimes-subtle differences, which defined each ethnicity. If Detroiters would have taken the time to notice these differences they may have found joy in becoming a more cultured person. By taking time to learn about the Polish and Italian?s reasons for leaving their home lands and subsequent arrivals into Detroit, their lifestyles while in Detroit, and the Americanization process they went through while in Detroit we learn a valuable lesson about the evolution of America. As time goes on I hope it becomes more evident that your ethnic background isn?t a tag that defines your role in society, but instead a tool to learn about your ancestors and the strife they went through to make your life a better place.
71a
American Cities/Detroit/Italians/Neighborhood/In Streets/Italian Settlements.
American Identity Explorer. Immigration & Migration.
Lansing: McGraw-Hill. 1999
American Cities/Detroit/Poles/Neighborhood/In Streets/ Detroit Polish Settlements.
American Identity Explorer. Immigration & Migration.
Lansing: McGraw-Hill. 1999
American Cities/Detroit/Poles/Neighborhood/In Streets/Location of Polish Colonies.
American Identity Explorer. Immigration & Migration.
Lansing: McGraw-Hill. 1999
American Cities/Detroit/Poles/Neighborhood/At Home/Thrift and Home Ownership.
American Identity Explorer. Immigration & Migration.
Lansing: McGraw-Hill. 1999
Global View/Origins/Europe/Italy. American Identity Explorer. Immigration & Migration.
Lansing: McGraw-Hill. 1999
Global View/Origins/Europe/Poland. American Identity Explorer. Immigration & Migration.
Lansing: McGraw-Hill. 1999
Другие работы по теме:
Detroit Free Press
Введение 1 История Список литературы Detroit Free Press Введение Detroit Free Press (русск. Детройт фри пресс) — первая по популярности газета в Детройте (США). Как и основная часть американских газет создана как региональное издание.
Henry Ford Essay Research Paper FORD Henry
Henry Ford Essay, Research Paper FORD, Henry (1863-1947). In 1896 a horseless carriage chugged along the streets of Detroit, with crowds gathering whenever it appeared. Terrified horses ran at its approach. The police tried to curb this nuisance by forcing its driver, Henry Ford, to get a license. That car was the first of many millions produced by the automotive pioneer.
Italian National Soccer Essay Research Paper ITALIAN
Italian National Soccer Essay, Research Paper ITALIAN NATIONAL TEAM HISTORY With an extraordinary record which includes three World Cups the Federazione Italiana Giuoco Calcio celebrated its 100th birthday in 1998. The Italian team was founded on March 16th 1898 on Torino, Italy. The first president of this federation ever elected was Mario Vicary.
Skiing Essay Research Paper SKIINGSkiing is a
Skiing Essay, Research Paper SKIING Skiing is a competitive sport, recreation, and a way of travel. Skiing is a leading winter sport and there are many events in which you use skis. When skiing you are traveling on long, narrow runners gliding on the snow. Skiing was developed in the 19th century by farmers in Norway for fun.
How Do The Renaissances In Italy And
Northern Europe Differ? Essay, Research Paper In American schools, it is taught in history classes that there was a Renaissance, or ?rebirth,? in Europe up until the 17th century. This was known for being a glorious religion period, with art as an example. However, there are two separate Renaissances, one in Italy, and one in northern Europe.
Italy Essay Research Paper Factual InformationSubmitted By
Italy Essay, Research Paper Factual Information)Submitted By: Michael PilieciSubmitted To: Mr. RoganDue Date Friday, November 3/00-Discrimination against the Italians In 1963 In 1963 I immigrated to Canada with my family, I was 13 years old. My family consisted of 5 brothers and a sister. We emigrated from a small town in the southern part of Italy called San Nicola.
Jerry Uselmann Essay Research Paper Jerry Uelsmann
Jerry Uselmann Essay, Research Paper Jerry Uelsmann was born in Detroit, Michigan on June 11, 1934. He began his studies at the Rochester Institute of Technology where he received his Bachelor of Fine Arts degree. He continued on to Indiana University in 1960 and received his Master?s degree. Uelsmann?s first job was at the University of Florida in Gainesville teaching photography and in 1974 he became the graduate research professor of art at UF.
Italian Immigration Essay Research Paper Italians immigrated
Italian Immigration Essay, Research Paper Italians immigrated in large numbers in the early 1900’s. It is estimated that nearly three million immigrants came to the United States between 1900 and 1914. They immigrated to America to better themselves. Most of them lived in poverty and desperately needed an alternative.
Teenagers In Jail Essay Research Paper Should
Teenagers In Jail Essay, Research Paper Should teenagers spend their young lives in jail Recently in Detroit, Michigan a teenager was convicted in criminal court for a crime he committed. The judge place him in a juvenile facility and ordered him to mandatory psychiatrist evaluation, and base on his improvement, he will be set free at the age of twenty one.
Smoking Essay Research Paper According to these
Smoking Essay, Research Paper According to these 2 article many teens decide to smoke because of peer pressure and looking cool. According to this recent article that was in the Detroit News about an Edsel Ford High School student they asked him why he started smoking and he said he didn t no he just did. All most every article I came across said that Joe Camel was to blame but researchers aren t sure if that s still the case.
The Influence Of Nature In
“Tintern Abbey” Essay, Research Paper The Influence of Nature in “Tintern Abbey” In “Lines Composed a Few Miles Above Tintern Abbey,” William Wordsworth explains the impact of Nature from Tintern Abbey in his every day life. “Tintern Abbey” shows the great importance of nature to Wordsworth in his writings, love for life, and religion.
Patricia Smith Essay Research Paper Patti Smith
Patricia Smith Essay, Research Paper Patti Smith Homepages, Biographies, and Interests a patti smith babelogue – The premier site for any and all information, from contacting patti to poetry, sound clips, performances, etc.
Those Winter Sundays Essay Research Paper In
Those Winter Sundays Essay, Research Paper In the peom “Those Winter Sundays,” the author Robert Hayden uses folk motif drawn from his own experiences, but seeks inspiration from other sources as well.
Italy Essay Research Paper Boatshaped Italy which
Italy Essay, Research Paper Boat-shaped Italy, which covers 116,303 square miles, forms a bridge across the center of the Mediterranean sea from Europe almost to Africa. Italy is compared in size to
Immigration Facts Essay Research Paper 1 Some
Immigration Facts Essay, Research Paper 1. Some of the immigrants who came to the US between the Civil War and WWI include the Irish, Germans, Italians, Polish, Jews, Chinese, Japanese, and Koreans. Groups such as the American Protective Association, the Immigration Restriction League, and the notorious Ku Klux Klan discriminated against these groups.
Immigrants Essay Research Paper Are Immigrants A
Immigrants Essay, Research Paper Are Immigrants A To the U.S? Immigrants are not a burden to the U.S. Therefore, we shouldn’t stop all immigration . Immigrants are hard workers and are not causing unemployment for
Ben Carson Report Essay Research Paper Dr
Ben Carson Report Essay, Research Paper Dr. Benjamin Carson M.D. In 1951, Benjamin Carson was born to Sonya and Robert Carson. He grew up in Detroit, Michigan. In 1959, Ben?s parents divorced. Ben, his brother Curtis, and his mother moved to Boston, Massachusetts. They lived there for two years and moved back to Detroit.
Ben Carson Essay Research Paper Ben Carson
Ben Carson Essay, Research Paper Ben Carson In 1951, Benjamin Carson was born to Sonya and Robert Carson. He grew up in Detroit, Michigan. Six years later in 1959, Ben’s parents divorced and he, his brother Curtis, and his mother moved to Boston, Massachusetts. They lived there for two years and moved back to Detroit in 1961.
Earthquake Proof Building Essay Research Paper Our
Earthquake Proof Building Essay, Research Paper Our company name is CNN Incorporated. The first thing we did was dig up all the soft soil and filled it with cement. After that we stuck big steel poles into the cement to hold the building in place and keep it on the ground. The garage is made out of brick and it has 9 cement pillars to make the structure stronger.
Mitosis And Meiosis Essay Research Paper Mitosis
Mitosis And Meiosis Essay, Research Paper Mitosis and Meiosis : how they are similar and different Mitosis and Meiosis are alike in many ways essentially they are both forms of cellular reproduction. Both go through similar cellular division stages. Interphase, Prophase, Metaphase, Anaphase, Telophase, and Cytokinesis all occur in both Mitosis and Meiosis.
Mitosis Essay Research Paper MitosisThe Process of
Mitosis Essay, Research Paper Mitosis The Process of Mitosis is the term used to describe cell division for replication. The product at the end of mitosis is two daughter cells both genetically identical to the original (parent) cell. This process is used for growth and repair within an organism and also for asexual reproduction.
Mitosis Meiosis Essay Research Paper Mitosis evolved
Mitosis Meiosis Essay, Research Paper Mitosis evolved in complex plants and animals for growth and repair. Mitosis, the division of a cell resulting in two identical daughter cells, prolongs an organism s life by
Utopia V Dystopia Essay Research Paper Utopia
Utopia V. Dystopia Essay, Research Paper Utopia vs. Dystopia What is utopia? According to The Random House Dictionary, utopia is a place or state of political or social perfection based on the novel Utopia by Thomas More (Random House 976). Most people can not picture this definition because the real world is not as perfect as Thomas More describes in Utopia.
Aurora Borealis Essay Research Paper Near the
Aurora Borealis Essay, Research Paper Near the Earth’s poles a magnificent spectacle of shimmering colored light can sometimes be seen — the aurora. The aurora is called the aurora borealis (Northern lights) and the aurora austrails (Southern lights); it can appear as bright as a full moon. The aurora usually appears near the Earth’s poles, and more northerly (or southerly) your latitude, the more impressive the displays you will see.
Italy Essay Research Paper Italy is a
Italy Essay, Research Paper Italy is a country in southern Europe. It is located in the Mediterranean region. Italy is a peninsula that has the Tyrrhenlan Sea to its west, the Adriatic Sea to its east, and the Lonian Sea
Great Gatsby 5 Essay Research Paper Fitzgerald
Great Gatsby 5 Essay, Research Paper Fitzgerald s Masterpiece F. Scott Fitzgerald s The Great Gatsby is an enchanting novel, which tells an exquisite story through various techniques characteristic of a gifted author. The story has elements of deceit, high hopes, fallen dreams, and false intentions which make it thrilling to read.
Maglev Train Essay Research Paper The Maglev
Maglev Train Essay, Research Paper The Maglev Train Since before the United States came to be, during the Revolutionary war, trains were being used to transport soldiers and their artillery into battle. They were the original steam engines of the U. S. of A. and they were at full force traveling around 35 miles per hour.
Analysis Of A Newspaper Articl Essay Research
Paper 131-81 Analysis of The Union Racket There is an article in the April 24,2000 issue of The Detroit News called The Union Racket . This article explains how the International Brotherhood of Teamsters currently stands with its lawsuit against its former president. Though the essay dose communicate many useful points, is dose a poor job of not meeting the seven failure requirements for any writing as established by Orwell.
Night On Earth Essay Research Paper The
Night On Earth Essay, Research Paper The film “Night on Earth” portrays taxi drivers in different cities around the world. Our focus will be the story of the taxi driver in Rome, Italy. In this section the film centers on a taxi driver and a priest, two unlikely people in an unlikely situation at 4:00 in the morning.