Ivan Ilyich Essay, Research Paper
Themes of a Poor Life in
?The Death of Ivan Ilyich?
It occurred to him that what had appeared perfectly impossible before, namely that he had not spent his life as he should have done, might after all be true. It occurred to him that his scarcely perceptible attempts to struggle against what was considered good by the most highly place people, those scarcely noticeable impulses which he had immediately suppressed, might have been the real thing, and all the rest false. And his professional duties and the whole arrangement of his life and of his family, and all his social and official interests, might all have been false. He tried to defend all those things to himself and suddenly felt the weakness of what he was defending. There was nothing to defend.
?But if that is so,? he said to himself, ?and I am leaving this life with the consciousness that I have lost all that was given me and it is impossible to rectify it- what then??
Tolstoy paints for the reader through the discourse of ?The Death of Ivan Ilyich? a social statement on the insignificance and banality of sociological conformity from a variety of viewpoints all perceptible to the reader from many sociological class structures. What we find in ?The Death of Ivan Ilyich? is a way of life, a comparison that defines for the reader a method of living outside that of the accepted sociological norm. This new take on life extends through the above passage as a method by which humanity can asses its place, its role, and the crucial role of the individual in the personal ?success? of the human individual. In this paper, I plan to outline several points used by Tolstoy through a means of sociological placement (i.e. Work, family, social attributes and practices) as a means of describing the true ?death? as portrayed in the work, and how the realizations of a dying man shape Tolstoy?s personal beliefs on life and the construction of personal and individual acclamation. In the above passage, Tolstoy delvers to the reader several main themes used throughout the work as a means of describing the greater role that Ilyich plays in the complex sociological themes outlined in the plot that is his life. ?The arrangement of his life and of his family, and all the social and official interests?.?
We will begin with an analysation of his family situation. Praskovya, his wife, had been a love constructed from the start of an economic and sociological expectation rather than that of a true courtship. The happiness therefore of the union was derived solely of a necessity to fulfill a desire on the part of others for a ?success? of sorts, surely her desire as well. ?Ivan Ilyich could have counted on a more illustrious match, but even this one was quite good. He had his salary, and her income, he hoped, would bring in an equal amount. (Tolstoy, 56)? Tolstoy goes on to make several remarks on the benevolent nature of the relationship between he and his wife. The arrival of his children creates no great marker in his life, and proves to be little more than a factor in his ever-lengthening retreat into his life of solitude and work.
It is obvious to the reader that this retreat into his work is the soul means by which Ivan moves towards a personal goal of self-justification and righteousness. It is no mistake on Tolstoy?s part that he is involved in a position of disciplinary authority. Through this discipline, one is exposed to the impression of society as a disciplinary function. This function is displayed through the judicial system, the work that Ivan creates for himself, as a leader in the federal disciplinary system is a commentary on the necessity for discipline within the social framework within which Ivan lives. This is an ever-present dichotomy that can be tied into both the familial and social framework within which Ivan lives. Is his personal discipline exorcized through the construction of disciplinary discourse as outlined in his work? Is his family a disciplinary presence in his life when regarded through his retreat into the work itself? Certainly, Ivan creates a knowledge if the disciplinary function of the time without a true understanding of the effects of discipline upon his own life. His family being a binding obligation of sorts, Ivan finds himself trapped within the social framework provided him by the actions which he has created through his education as a social creature as well as his marriage and procreation with a woman outside the boundaries of true love.
The absence of this love is apparent in all aspects of his existence. Without any passion for his family life, his social standing or his work (outside of the idea of his obsessive drive to achieve what he is inexorably destined to fail in his work), he finds a trapping the proportions of which lead to his impending death and the pain there in. socially, Ivan attacks the ideological question of true happiness. What constitutes this happiness? What creates a drive to become something more than what society expects in order to create a structure within which one can survive as a successful individual? On a personal level, Ivan fails to create for himself an environment conducive to the romantic ideal of self-fulfillment. However, in forsaking this ideal, Ivan conforms to the sociological norm as prescribed by the standards of the time. In other words, the position into which Ivan conforms is constructed completely of ideals provided him by a sociological discourse as conducted, created and adhered to by the upper social structure of the time period. This structure is regulated by the ever-changing discursive value revolving around necessary normalizations as dictated by the structure itself, in essence, creating for itself a form of disciplinary rule and power structure to be adhered to or disregarded by its members.
My intent here is to examine this ?normalization? process, or the process by which we conduct certain behaviour and the level to which Ivan conforms to this process. Through the normalization of Ivan?s life, he finds placidity, boredom and self-indignation in his actions as prescribed by the discourse. The normalization of his existence acts as the benign factor that leads to his pain and suffering throughout his illness. Contextually, this normalization process is what leads us to our opening quotation from the work. In this quotation, Ivan comes to the realization as to the placid and benign nature that his life took as a result of this conformity and normalization, the turns that his life took as a need to fit into the sociological norms and discourse set before him in his studies. In this most powerful and revealing of passages, Tolstoy uses metaphorically the figure of the ?highly placed people? as a signification of disciplinary function. He uses the family, as a realization of what he wishes his family and life could have been, the joy inherent in the imagery of ?the child.? His professional duties having amounted to little personal success, as well as his ultimate demise are portrayed as unnecessary and having been carried out without cause. It is at this point in ?The Death of Ivan Ilyich? that he realizes his end is near, that his life is the cause of that death, and that his permittance of this extra-discursive disciplinary force was, in hindsight, the true means to his end as an individual.
One of the defining moments of his death comes just after this realization, with the arrival of his wife and her request that he take a sacrament, to which, he agrees to some extent. However, with taking the sacrament, and gaining once again a false hope of being cured, comes the pain that had washed over him to this point. Here, the reader sees Ivan revert back to the demands of his prior constraints, entering yet another disciplinary force into the plot we with that of the accepted orthodox practice of last rights.
This action falls in a time when Ivan is finally at terms with his impending death, when the pain comes as a signification of the sensory deprivation to which he has subjected his physicality throughout his life. Physically, he experiences a re-exhileration of child-hood experience, perhaps the last time that he allowed himself to experience sensory perception at a pure level, a level unhindered by sociological normalization, categorization or disciplinary action. It is for this reason that throughout the pain, he re-lives the experience of childhood. At this point in his death, Ivan invites the pain as a metaphor for the sensory experience that he has not allowed himself to experience throughout his life. With this experience, he comes to terms with the death, with the movement of life to life, realizing that he cannot be cured, as to be cured would be little more than to continue into the life that has lead him to this pain. He would be perpetuating the existence that he has lead, and with this, he finds peace in the realization of it not being too late, but of finding the ability to experience a re-birth of sorts.
Tolstoy transports the reader through these examples of sociological thought with the suffering of his hero. Ivan likely mirrors the thoughts that Tolstoy has in reference to his own life, shunning institutions of society, education and religion. It is in these examples of conformity that the reader sees err, and the justification of that err not to return to a life of perpetual discontentment and conformity, but to move ahead through the pain that Ivan experiences to learn a lesson of accepting freedom, not only on the terms of the freedom itself, but in the burden with which freedom presents itself.
Другие работы по теме:
Macbeth Essay Research Paper MacbethIn the story
Macbeth Essay, Research Paper Macbeth In the story of Macbeth, there are three basic themes that are seen time and time again. The themes of disorder, darkness and gffgd. They not only are used to show, or describe something, they are also there to show a repeating symbolism throughout the play.
Scarlet Letter Themes Essay Research Paper Nathaniel
Scarlet Letter Themes Essay, Research Paper Nathaniel Hawthorne was a truly outstanding author. His detailed descriptions and imagery will surely keep people interested in reading The Scarlet Letter for years to come. In writing this book he used themes evident throughout the entirety of the novel. These themes are illustrated in what happens to the characters and how they react.
Ivan The Terrible Essay Research Paper Ivan
Ivan The Terrible Essay, Research Paper Ivan the Terrible was the first czar of russia. He was a very cruel ruler.His father and mother died shortley after his birth.So his grand father Ivan The Great Took him in as a son. He was very cruel to ivan,
Death Of Ivan Ilynch Essay Research Paper
? The Death of Ivan Ilych ? ?The Death of Ivan Ilych ? tells the story of a man on his deathbed realizing that the majority of the things he?s done throughout his life was for social acceptance. Concerned only with the thoughts of other people, his own ideas and thoughts were dismissed from importance when it came to self-image.
Ivan Denisovich Essay Research Paper Imagine being
Ivan Denisovich Essay, Research Paper Imagine being captive in a concentration camp for over eight years. Ivan Denisovich Shukhov has experienced just this. In analyzing only one day of Ivan’s life in a concentration camp, he displays many traits that show that he is a hero. Hero, can be defined in many different ways.
Summary The Death Of Ivan Ilyich Essay
, Research Paper The Death of Ivan Illych The short story, “The Death of Ivan Ilych”, written by Leo Tolstoy, is about the reactions of a man and his friends to his suffering and death. Everyone who knows Ivan including Ivan himself has led a life of total disconcern for the feelings and sufferings of others. They all lead shallow lives not daring to probe into the feelings deep down inside for fear of stepping outside the lines of propriety.
Brothers Karamazov Essay Research Paper Dostoyevsky tries
Brothers Karamazov Essay, Research Paper Dostoyevsky tries to show the importance of believing in God in the novel The Brothers Karamazov. Fyodor Dostoyevsky was raised in a very religious environment. Much of Dostoyevsky s early learning was taught to him by his loving and devout Christian mother. His father was not as much a positive influence on him as his mother because he was a drunk.
Ivan The Terrible Essay Research Paper The
Ivan The Terrible Essay, Research Paper The Terrible Greatness Of Ivan the IV The era of Ivan the IV is one that triggers some of the most horrific nightmares to surface. It was a reign that spread a blanket of terror throughout Russia as Ivan the IV took his role as the first tsar to be bloody and tyrannical. Claims of pathological elements in his character cannot be denied as many lives were doomed to the fate of unnecessary death and suffering.
Ivan Iv Essay Research Paper Ivan IV
Ivan Iv Essay, Research Paper Ivan IV: The First TsarIvan the Terrible was only 3 years old when he became the tsar of Russia. Obviously too young to actually rule, his mother Elena and her lover, Ivan Obolensky, ruled the country for him. In 1538, Elena died and Ivan Obolensky killed for the chance to rule the country.
Cultural Assimilation Essay Research Paper Cultural AssimilationIt
Cultural Assimilation Essay, Research Paper Cultural Assimilation It is a big controversial subject that how much an international student should assimilate in the new culture. The result can move on a big scale. Depending on the person and its relationships it can cause depression. Two of my friends Aniko and Ivan are assimilating differently in the new culture.
Crucible 2 Essay Research Paper It is
Crucible 2 Essay, Research Paper It is more noble to die with integrity than it is to compromise one s principle in order to live. —– Danforth: I say, will you confess yourself, Goody Nurse? Rebecca: Why it is a lie, it is a lie;; how may I damn myself? I cannot, I cannot. —–Arthur Miller s, The Crucible, was a play with many themes.
Theme In A Raison In The Sun
Essay, Research Paper Theme in the A Raisin in the Sun There are many themes in A Raisin in the Sun. The this play was written by, an African American, Lorraine Hansberry. The three themes
Walden By Thoreau And Nature By Emerson
Essay, Research Paper Transcendentalism is used frequently as main topics in the stories ?Nature? and Walden. These two themes are heavily concentrated on though these two
Snows Of Kilimanjaro And Death Of Ivan
Illych Essay, Research Paper "The Snows of Kilimanjaro" by Ernest Hemingway and "The Death of Ivan Ilych" by Leo Tolstoy are both excellent literary works that both
The Death Of Ivan Ilyich Leo Tolstoy
– Rebirth By Death Essay, Research Paper The Death of Ivan Ilyich: Leo Tolstoy – Rebirth by Death Leo Tolstoy was a great humanist. Evolution of human character was a subject
Stoic Death Themes Of In The Name
Of The Father And Death Of Ivan Ilyitch Essay, Research Paper There are themes in life that everyone goes through at one point or another. These universal themes, however, are experienced in different orders. As in In the Name of the Father, sometimes it takes the death of a loved one to bring meaning to one’s life.
Ivan Ilyich And I Essay Research Paper
I related readily with Ivan Ilyich, the main character in Leo Tolstoy’s The Death of Ivan Ilyich. There was a time when I myself lived my life without regard to the spirituality of life. I, however, was very lucky in that it did not take death looming over my head to realize this. Maybe the fact that my bout of depression’s onset happened sooner in life allowed me to see it sooner.
John Donne Essay Research Paper Although the
John Donne Essay, Research Paper Although the main focus of many of his poems is death, Donne’s ego seems to steal the spotlight. In Holy Sonnet 10, he manages to defend humankind against death, possibly because he feels he cannot be defeated by God. As with most themes in his work, however, he often changes his opinion, leaving a confused reader to attempt to find his real belief about death.
Hamlet 13 Essay Research Paper In Shakespeare
Hamlet 13 Essay, Research Paper In Shakespeare’s tragedy, Hamlet, there are many themes that appear throughout the play. During the sequence of events in the play we see that there are many obvious themes and many underlying themes. One of these themes that can be seen throughout the play is the way characters appear as one thing, and really are different in their actions at different times.
Illiad Essay Research Paper The Illiad has
Illiad Essay, Research Paper The Illiad has by far endured the test of time due to the relation of ancient Greek themes to that of modern day. An abundance of themes from Homer?s era can clearly be observed in today?s society such as emotion, war, and honor. These themes are portrayed throughout the book in various passages, speeches, and dialogue.
Tolstoy And His Message Essay Research Paper
Tolstoy and his Message Leo Tolstoy is one of the greatest writers of the last two hundred years. His novels tend to convey an insight on life; whether it be about suffering, death, religion, art, or education. Tolstoy was a man with many strong beliefs, and one must understand these beliefs to fully understand the meaning of his works.
I Am Tolstoy But Not A Tolstoyian
Essay, Research Paper In 1828, somewhere in the countryside north of Moscow, Leo Tolstoy was born into the Russian nobility. Count Tolstoy, although acquainted with the finer things that life
The Effect Of Realism On Leo Tolstoy
Shown In The Death Of Iv Essay, Research Paper The Influence of Realism in Tolstoy?s The Death of Ivan Ilyich The novella, The Death of Ivan Ilyich, shows the influence of Realism on its author. Leo Tolstoy. The illusion of reality, the main theme of the novella, is an aspect of Realism that Tolstoy effectively used in this novella.
Dickens Biography Essay Research Paper In the
Dickens Biography Essay, Research Paper In the Charles Dickens novel, A Tale of Two Cities, symbolism in used to portray the themes though out the book. Through his characters and their actions as well as their
Sasa Essay Research Paper The theme of
Sasa Essay, Research Paper The theme of a book is very important as to understanding what a novel is about as well as teaching a lesson in life. Authors sometimes write books with no theme in mind, but as the words flow from their pen, themes will emerge unknowingly. The themes are vital as to understanding what is happening within the story, and finding out the meaning.
Ivanhoe Strengths Essay Research Paper The greatest
Ivanhoe Strengths Essay, Research Paper The greatest strengths of Ivanhoe were the themes of the novel. All the characters in Ivanhoe were in some way affected by the major theme of the hatred between the
Essay On The Short Story
“Divorce” By Ivan Klima Essay, Research Paper In the short story entitled “Divorce” by Ivan Klima a judge makes an important decision that will affect him for the rest of his life. The decision
Lonliness In Of Mice And Men Essay
, Research Paper Lonliness in Of Mice and Men The novel Of Mice and Men by John Steinback deals with many themes that are reflective of the time period in which the novel was written. Loneliness is one of the many themes in this novel that are reflective of the time period in which the novel was written. It is shown in many of the characters in the novel.
Peter Thegreat Essay Research Paper Peter I
Peter Thegreat Essay, Research Paper Peter I the Great 1672 – 1725 Russian Czar Peter was born in Moscow. He was joint czar with his mentally retarded half-brother, Ivan, under the regency of their sister, Sophia (1682-9). On Ivan’s death (1696) Peter became sole czar.
The Scarlet Ibis By James Hurst Essay
, Research Paper The Scarlet Ibis-Analyze 3 themes. Discuss. In the short story The Scarlet Ibis by James Hurst, has various themes. A theme is a subject, topic or ideas that happen throughout a short story, essay, or a composition. The three themes in The Scarlet Ibis are Doodle never gives up, his older brother loves him and unforeseen things happen.
Swan Lake Essay Research Paper Swan LakeSwan
Swan Lake Essay, Research Paper Swan Lake Swan Lake is a ballet that consist of four acts. It is based from a German fairy tale. It contains music from Peter Ilyich Tchaikovsky. The first performance of Swan Lake was in Moscow at the Bolshoi Theater. It was held on May 4, 1877. The choreographer was Julius Reisinger.