Screw Essay, Research Paper
Greg Graziani
03-05-01
English 283 sect. 08
McLaughlin
Shakespeare’s Social Themes in Taming of the Screw
Shakespeare’s Taming of the Screw is widely viewed as a comical play. But are the views and topics that are expressed really intended to be funny or are they more of a serious concern of Shakespeare’s that women are mistreated? Throughout this paper I will try to explain that the perspective that Shakespeare is showing is one of concern over sexism and the treatment of women.
To understand the sexism and its context is to understand when the play was written and the history of the social system at the time. The play was first presented in the late sixteenth century, the role of the women was not much more than that of service. The privileges of women were virtually non-existent in terms of political and personal rights. The chief purpose of women was to provide children and care for the household. Most marriages were pre arranged or won, and initially had no love based relationship. The women were in a sense used and taken advantage of, they were expected to do what the husband said and agree completely with them.
In the play Taming of the Screw, Kate represents a strong minded and individual person who shows no sign of calming. Petruchio, Kate’s suitor, is a strong minded man bent on controlling and taking away Kate’s sense of individuality. When the two meet for the first time there doesn’t seem to be any attraction between the two. This is illustrated in act two scene one. The conversation of the two is filled with bickering and disagreement. Later in the scene Petruchio plainly states that his purpose is to tame Kate.” For I am he am born to tame you, Kate, And bring you from a wild Kate to a Kate conformable as other household Kates,(Shakespeare 47)”
This statement alone claims that Kate is to forget her own individuality and to conform to the norms of society and preferred behavior. Petruchio’s aim is to control Kate and develop her mentality and actions to that which pleases him. These actions for the time are not unusual. It was common practice to display control and dominance over your wife at this time. Is Shakespeare merely poking fun at this practice or is he putting it on display and trying to expose the problems with it? If Shakespeare was to more directly show his concern it could have hurt him both personally and professionally, maybe he was all right with the status quo but would have liked to see it changed.
As the play goes on Petruchio continues to try and break down Kate in to the women he wants. Petruchio goes on to publicly humiliate Kate and deprive her. He controls her socially, economically, and physically. She is not free to her own decisions and must at least agree with Petruchio. He goes as far as to deprive her of sleep and food. The battle between the two is underway. Which sex will win is at no point is in favor of Kate. It is her father’s will for her to marry Petruchio and to like it as well. Kate is faced with a dilemma, give in and be under Petruchio’s control or lead a life that will eventually find her dead.
Indeed Petruchio’s sexism is tearing Kate apart. She refuses to be dominated by her husband and continues to fight Petruchio’s dominating nature. This continues until the fourth act. Then while on a journey back to Petruchio’s home there seems to be a change of events. Petruchio makes reference to the sun as the moon, Kate initially disagrees but then breaks down in to telling Petruchio that she believes it is whatever Petruchio says it is.” Then God be blessed, it is the blessed sun. But sun it is not when you say it is not, and the moon changes even as your mind. What you will have it named, even that it is. And so it will be for Katherine.(Shakespeare 92)” How is it that something that is so obviously in Kate’s favor turns around and ends up favoring Petruchio. Maybe a turn around is starting to occur, or perhaps Kate is falling victim to society and its warped view of the household. From this point on Kate’s feistiness is depleted slowly, but surely not forgotten.
The ugliness of this woman loosing her personality and will is no less sad as that of a captured slave. Kate is commanded to do everything and has turned into a well trained dog, but is that really what is happening here. Is Kate turning into property or is she exploiting the social system for all its worth. It is obvious that Kate posses some intelligence, is she manipulating Petruchio? This looks as if it could be a possibility. This would certainly go against the social order of the time and expectations of the audience. Kate could be positioning it so socially it seems like Petruchio has tamed her and she does as he says, but privately Kate’s demeanor is one of individuality and discontent. Kate’s mind is still with her and her defiance comes from within the house and into Petruchio’s head. Where is the victory though, Petruchio still gets what he wants and everyone thinks she is trained as a conventional wife. That’s where the subtlety and undertone comes into play.
At the very end of the play in act five it seems like the just married men have made a wager on their wives and their obedience. Between the three men it is understood that Kate has the least chance of winning between them, but Petruchio makes the bet with a curious sense of confidence. When the wives are summoned it is only Kate who responds. Petruchio has won the bet everyone is certain he had lost. In the ensuing moments Petruchio continues to order around Kate as if to prove his point. A great sense of wonder fills the room. Is the wonder because a screw has fallen down and finally been tamed, another victim of society and it way it has put complete dominance on the female sex. Or is their a difference sense of wonder, that between Petruchio and Kate, one that no one else sees. “ Thy husband is thy lord, thy life, thy keeper, thy head, thy sovereign one that cares for thee, and for thy maintenance commits his body to painful labor both sea and land, to watch the night in storms, the day in cold, Whilst thou li’st warm at home, secure and safe, and craves no other tribute at thy hands but love, fair looks and true obedience.(Shakespeare 108)” This statement appeals to the fact that she has been socialized and made obedient, but it seems as if Kate would have offered a wink to Petruchio after her little speech. Maybe she has won the battle of the sexes. Socially it looks as if Petruchio is the dominating party but privately both know that Kate hold the upper hand, for she can always go back to being a screw.
This play offers a different way of looking at marriage, if it were in now a day terms this relationship would look to be abusive and detrimental to Kate, but at the time it was written this offers a stark contrast in the ways of the wife. Kate is not trying to be a subordinate to her husband but has no choice, at least publicly, she is trying to encourage her individuality in the home. Shakespeare seems to be ahead of his time with his thought of the women and what their roles could be in the house as equals, but he doesn’t let it come out more straight forward due to the fact that it could embarrass him and hurt his career. I believe that Shakespeare was addressing this issue in the form of a comedy because when we are afraid of something or want to protect against it we blanket it by laughter. He might have been ok with the status quo but he might have also wanted to put this seeming problem on center stage to expose it.
Whatever the case might be Shakespeare does an excellent job of putting the home on center stage. His ideas of the home and it operation is completely similar to the times he lived in. Whether or not this is just a comical play or one with serious undertones of distress and or of concern one can only speculate, but it is understood that the complete meaning went to the grave with Shakespeare himself.
Bibliography
William Shakespear Taming of the Screw
36b
Другие работы по теме:
Taming Of The Shrew Comparison Essay Research
Paper William Shakespeare?s Taming of the Shrew is one of the most classic comedies throughout all of literature. Several stage productions have been professionally done, and each version has it positive sides and negative sides. This paper will be about comparing and contrasting the two versions I have seen.
The Taming Of The Shrew Analys Essay
, Research Paper The Taming Of The Shrew The Taming Of The Shrew by William Shakespeare is probably one of Shakespeare s earliest comedies. Its plot comes from the popular war of the sexes theme in which males and females fight with one another for dominance in a marriage. The play begins with a drunk man named Cristopher Sly being fooled into believing he is a nobleman and watching a play performed for him.
Taming Of The Shrew Views On Love
And Mariage Essay, Research Paper As a comedy, The Taming of the Shrew, by William Shakespeare, deals with a lot of very real issues. It speaks of the winners and losers on the ?marriage market,? and asks us many serious moral questions. Shakespeare presents us with two main views on love and marriage – male dominance, and money – the dowry for marriage and wealth as a measurement of partner suitability.
Taming Temper Tantrums Essay Research Paper Taming
Taming Temper Tantrums Essay, Research Paper Taming the Toddler Tantrums Tantrums are a normal part of growing up. Toddler’s aren’t bad when they are having a tantrum, they are just acting their age. Almost all children between the ages of one and three have a few temper tantrums. This just means they have finally gotten a sense of their own individuality.
Shakespearian Elements Of David GowS Essay Research
Paper How do the Shakespearian elements of David Gow?s Away, contribute to the overall success of the play.?? The Shakespearian elements of the play Away, by David Gow, contribute to the overall success of the play immensely. The play contains elements from a number of Shakespeares plays including King Lear and A Mid Summer Nights Dream.
Theme In A Raison In The Sun
Essay, Research Paper Theme in the A Raisin in the Sun There are many themes in A Raisin in the Sun. The this play was written by, an African American, Lorraine Hansberry. The three themes
Walden By Thoreau And Nature By Emerson
Essay, Research Paper Transcendentalism is used frequently as main topics in the stories ?Nature? and Walden. These two themes are heavily concentrated on though these two
Tom Sawyer And Threasure Islan Essay Research
Paper Write a 200-word book report comparing the themes of Tom Sawyer and Treasure Island. Comparing the themes fo Treasure Island, which is Robert Louis Stevenson’s monst famous work of fiction, and the theme of the novel Tom Sawyer, by the beloved and very well-known American author and writer, Samuel Clemens (otherwise known by his nom de flame, or pen-name, Mark Twain) is a very hard and difficult job indeed and requires a lot of careful study.
Political Themes Essay Research Paper Jane RhoPS1
Political Themes Essay, Research Paper Jane RhoPS1- FahimiMW@9:30May 4, 1999Thought Paper #3Political Themes Most political stories and articles share prominent themes about the American government. The elements in these articles are the underlying factors holding up the stories. The most frequent found themes have to do with the congress, the two main political parties, and various interest groups with their political participation and opinions.
Of Mice And Men Four Major Themes
Essay, Research Paper Of Mice and Men: Four Major Themes “Of Mice and Men”, by John Steinbeck, is composed of four major themes. These themes are the value of dreams and goals, moral responsibility, social
Taming Of The Shrew Analysis Essay Research
Paper The Taming of the Shrew: Act IV Scene I Grumio arrives at Petruchio?s house after accompanying Petruchio and Kate on a long journey from Padua. Grumio affirms the fact that the servants are well prepared for the new couple?s arrival. He tells Curtis, another servant to Petruchio, of an incident that occurred on the trip.
Illiad Essay Research Paper The Illiad has
Illiad Essay, Research Paper The Illiad has by far endured the test of time due to the relation of ancient Greek themes to that of modern day. An abundance of themes from Homer?s era can clearly be observed in today?s society such as emotion, war, and honor. These themes are portrayed throughout the book in various passages, speeches, and dialogue.
Raisin In The Sun Themes Essay Research
Paper Important themes in A Raisin in the Sun A Raisin in the Sun examines an African-American s family struggle to break out of the themes of poverty, dreams, racism, society, and various social themes that they are faced with. Lorraine Hansberry analyzes how race prejudice and economic insecurity affect a black mans role in his own family, his ability to provide, and his identity.
The Ways In Which The Relationship Of
Tom Buchanan And Myrtle Wilson Influences The Great Gatsby’s Commentary On Social Classes In 1920′S America Essay, Research Paper The relationship between Myrtle Wilson and Tom Buchanan helps portray the themes of social classes in F. Scott Fitzgerald’s novel The Great Gatsby. The ways in which Tom and Myrtle’s relationship influences the novel’s commentary on social classes are basically two fold.
Repeat After Me-The Taming Of The Shrew
111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
Shakespeare Lack Of Understanding Of Women Essay
, Research Paper Shakespeare’s Taming of the Shrew Paper I believe that Shakespeare had a very little understanding of women. In this play The Taming of the Shrew the women seem very flat. There is Kate; she is the proverbial “witchy” woman. The butt of jokes men think of while sitting around a campfire discussing their troubles with women, or the woman everyman wants to go out with and “conquer” to prove how really “macho” he is.
Pride And Prejudice 12 Essay Research Paper
The novel, Pride and Prejudice, is a story about the romantic adventures of five sisters in 18th century England, by Jane Austen. There are two major themes in Pride and Prejudice, which are those of pride and prejudice. Pride is the high opinion of one’s own worth or possessions. The other theme, prejudice is an opinion formed without taking the time and care to judge something fairly.
The Taming Of The Shrew Kate
’s Soliloquy Essay, Research Paper The Taming of the Shrew: Kate’s Soliloquy Kate’s soliloquy bring about a joyous conclusion to The Taming of the Shrew. The audience leaves the theatre with a pleasant feeling, glad that such
Exploring Sexuality In Taming Of The Shrew
Essay, Research Paper Exploring Sexuality in “Taming of the Shrew” Andrea Blacksten Shakespeare Plays Professor Christopher Human sexuality underlies many of the happenings of “Taming of the Shrew.” It affects the conflicts, theme, and resolution of the play. It becomes evident throughout the play that sexual behavior denotes whether a character is thought of as good or evil (not necessarily good evil as meant in conventional terms, but rather as a “nice” character versus a “waspish” or “mean’ character).
Sasa Essay Research Paper The theme of
Sasa Essay, Research Paper The theme of a book is very important as to understanding what a novel is about as well as teaching a lesson in life. Authors sometimes write books with no theme in mind, but as the words flow from their pen, themes will emerge unknowingly. The themes are vital as to understanding what is happening within the story, and finding out the meaning.
Contrasts In Taming Of The Shrew Essay
, Research Paper Shakespeare loves to use contrasts in his play: these contrasts in setting, people, events, belief system help to develop the plots or themes of the play. Identify three of these contrast and explain how these help to develop the plot or the theme.
William Shakespeares Tragedy Hamlet Essay Research Paper
William Shakespeare?s tragedy Hamlet has been one of the most controversial works of all time. There have been so many criticisms on this book and opinions on what the main theme behind the play is. Many themes have been proposed such as revenge, sex, reality and jealousy. I myself believe that there is no one theme behind Hamlet and it is a complex with work with many complex ideas behind it.
Themes Displayed In To Kill A Mockingbird
Essay, Research Paper In To Kill a Mockingbird, Harper Lee does a very effective job of making many different themes come across during the course of the novel. Many characters show that social justice is not always easy to achieve. Also, there theme of many helpless victims comes across. Lastly, growing up is a prevalent theme in the novel.
Romeo And Juliet Persuasive Essay Essay Research
Paper ROMEO AND JULIET PERSUASIVE ESSAY Romeo and Juliet is a play about tow young adults that fall in love with each other. The only thing that is holding these tow lovers back is the feuding between the two families.
There Eyes Were Watching God Essay Research
Paper Their Eyes Were Watching God, written by Zora Neale Hurston, is a novel of self-realization about a woman on a quest for her own identity. Other black writers of the Harlem Renaissance were angry that Their Eyes Were Watching God was not a novel of bitter social realism, but one of joy and celebration. In her novel, Hurston dares to portray the black woman as a hero.
Taming Of The Shrew 4 Essay Research
Paper The Taming of the Shrew The Taming of the Shrew written by William Shakespeare depicts the common roles of men and women in the early seventeenth century. Shakespeare writes of Petruchio and Kate, a male and female who sharply oppose each other. Petruicho must tame his wife Kate without breaking her true inner spirit.
The Humor In Taming Of A Shrew
Essay, Research Paper The Taming of the Shrew – Humour In The Taming of the Shrew, Shakespeare creates humour through his characters by creating false realities (as demonstrated by Petruchio?s behaviour and attire in the scene of his wedding) and by the use of subterfuge and mistaken identity (shown in the final scenes with the transformation of Kate and Bianca?s respective personas).
The Taming Of The Shrew Katherine Essay
, Research Paper The Taming of the Shrew: Katherine In William Shakespeare’s play, The Taming of the Shrew, the shrew played by Katherine, had a terrible outlook on life and just about everything else. Her
Taming Of The Shrew 2
Taming Of The Shrew – Analysis Essay, Research Paper TAMING OF THE SHREW – Analysis In the Taming of the Shrew, Petruchio recognizes, respects and desires Kate’s intelligence and strength of character. He does not
The Taming Of The Shrew Essay Research 2
The Taming Of The Shrew- Essay, Research Paper The Taming of the Shrew- In Shakespeare’s comedy, “The Taming of the Shrew,” one of the main ways that the theme is shown is by mistaken identity. The main
Taming Of The Shrew Play Review Essay
, Research Paper The Taming of the Shrew Keeping within the imaginative boundaries of human life, without becoming overly outlandish, the comedy demonstrated in the play was often sardonic, lighthearted, and always entertaining.