Seasons) Essay, Research Paper
Morality is often overpowered by materialistic pursuits. In A Man for All Seasons ,Robert Bolt shows the corruption of those who put self interest above all other values. His use of such characters as Thomas Cromwell, Richard Rich, Chapuys and Wolsey help convey this
corruption. There is yet another character who is a pragmatist that Bolt successfully represents. Thomas More is an idealist as well as a pragmatist, for he is prepared to give up everything for his beliefs and takes all precautions possible to make his case watertight . It is through this pragmatism and idealism that Robert Bolt shows the corruption of the times.
Thomas More believed in his ideals to such an extent that he was prepared to sacrifice his life for them, if the need arrived. He was a firm believer in the separation of Church and State. When the King tried to start the reformation of England and the Church by a simple Act of Parliament called the Act of Supremacy, Thomas refused to sign it. He believed that the indictment of the King was grounded in an Act of Parliament which is directly repugnant to law
of God. The King in Parliament cannot bestow he Supremacy of the Church because it is a Spiritual Supremacy! And more to this the immunity of the Church is promised both in Magna Carta and the Kings own Coronation Oath! (Bolt, p. 92) The marriage was yet another reason why More refused to sign the Act. He knew that if he signed it then he would accept the King as the Supreme Head of Church and thus give the King the power to dispense with the dispensation which to him was against his morals and religion. Of course the marriage was associated with other things -attack on the abbeys, the whole Reformation policy-to which More was violently opposed. When told by Norfolk that his parish attire is a disrespect to the King
and his office. More replies that the service of God is not a dishonor to any office (Bolt, p.26) Even though he loves the King to death as proved by Mores loyalty towards him, he values his
morality and religion more. For his conscience is a little area where I must rule myself (Bolt,p.34). His position is perfectly described in his belief that when statesmen forsake their own
private conscience for the sake of their public duties… they lead their country by a short route to chaos. His idealism is clearly shown in his refusal to take the oath for the oath to him was an
invitation to God to act as a witness as well as a judge and the consequence of a perjury was damnation. He is a man who is anchored to his principles (Bolt, p.36). The issue is not about what other people see his beliefs as but not that I believe it, but that I believe it… (Bolt, p.53). He needs to be true to his conscience and cannot let other people interfere with these decisions, for when he faces his creator it is he alone who will answer Him. In matters of conscience, the loyal subject is more bounded to be loyal to his conscience than to any other thing (Bolt, p.89) Even towards his tragic end he is so sure of his righteousness that he advises the headsman to be not afraid of your office. You send me to God. He will not refuse one who is to blithe to go to him (Bolt, p.94) Thus, it becomes clear that Thomas alone possess the moral squint that no other character possesses in the play.
Thomas More is a pragmatist with a lawyers mind and a loyal heart. He was able to foresee the future and knew exactly what could be used against him later on. When Thomas More realized that the silver goblet that he received from the woman was a bribe he immediately got rid of it. He gave it to Rich, for he knew the type of person Rich was, and gave the woman an impeccably correct judgment. Not surprisingly, the goblet was later used against him but due to More s actions, it held little substance. More s trust in the law was his trust in society; his desperate sheltering beneath the forms of the law was his determination to remain in the shelter
of society. To him the law was a forest in which he could hide and never be found; it was a causeway upon which, so long as he keeps to it, a citizen may walk safely (Bolt, p. 89) Thus, with this belief More took every action to not to trap himself but rather be protected by the law. He avoided all events that may be misinterpreted as treason. When Signor Chapuys came to More to inform him that the people in Yorkshire were ready for resistance by force of arms,
More deliberately misinterpreted it as Metaphorical arms. The breastplate of righteousness and the helmet of salvation. (Bolt, p. 51) He is able to see right through people and he knows he has
spies in the house such as the steward looking for some evidence against him and thus he protects himself quit cleverly. Also, as soon as Norfolk arrives, More warns him of the rising in
Yorkshire, thus proving his loyalty to the King and protecting himself. On Chapuys second arrival, he offers More a letter from the King of Spain, he doesn t lay a finger on it, for then he
will be allying with the enemy. He further goes on to show it to Alice and everyone else that the seal has not been broken, thus showing that he has not read the letter. Even in the case of the
Maid of Kent, More writes to her advising her to abstain from meddling with the affairs of Princes and the State (Bolt, p. 67). As a precaution, More gets it notarized and thus it is evidence in favor of him, not against him. Other then refusing every possible way of being disloyal, More uses silence as his main strategy. He was a man with a firm sense of his own self. He knew where he began and left off, what area of himself he could reveal to the encroachments of his enemies, and what to the encroachments of those he loved. He refuses to talk to anyone or declare his position on the Kings divorce. He knows that anything he says canbe used against him as treason and thus repeatedly says that he will answer to the King alone. The corruption of the times is evident when, after failing to find anything on More, Cromwell decides to put something in the cupboard (Bolt, p. 69). The laws that More hid behind are
now twisted in such a way that he is charged with ingratitude and sentenced to death and it is
this single event that Thomas More fails to foresee.
Richard Rich, Thomas Cromwell, Chapuys, and Wolsey are other pragmatist who use
their foresight of the future for personal power and advancement. Richard Rich is a very sneaky
and ambitious man. He wants to be popular for when he is offered the teachers job he comments
who would know it? (Bolt, p.6) It is evident that Richard is capable of bribery when he says
But every man has his price (Bolt, p. 4) Later on during the play, due to his hunger for fame
and money, he sells out to Cromwell and lies about More under oath. Richard climbs on other
people to get to where he wants to be. Every step that Richard goes up, Thomas goes a step
down. At the end, Richard gets what he wants. He wanted a gown like Thomas and now he has
it, symbolically meaning his status and position. Cromwell is another scavenger who is a
pragmatist. He knows exactly how to get what he wants. He is like the Kings ears, very cruel
and dangerous. He is a man for whom the ends justify the means and thus he feels no regret in
having More destroyed. He knows that in dark corners can lie ears waiting to hear, thus he is
very careful in planning his conspiracy. In the trial, Cromwell rewards Rich for lying about the
More and sends away the only two people that would be able to save the More. Chapuys is a
mirror image of Cromwell. Just like Cromwell is King Henry s ears, Chapuys is those of the
King of Spain. He hunts around for information by paying the steward and tries his best to get
More on his side, so later he himself may be rewarded. Last but not least, Wolsey is another
pragmatist who is a self serving man. Even though he is a churchman he has no moral
conscience. He wants to be the pope only for the materialistic rather than spiritual reasons. He
is supposed to be a holy man yet he speaks vulgarity. When talking about Queen Catherine he
calls her as barren as a brick and when addressing Anne he refers to her as a fertile thing
(Bolt, p. 12) He even sacrifices his conscience for the sake of loyalty to the King and says that
good statesmen shouldn t possess that horrible moral squint (Bolt, p. 11) and thus, through this
it is evident that Wolsey is morally corrupt. Thus, Richard Rich, Thomas Cromwell, Chapuys,
and Wolsey are like jackals who follow the King because he is their lion, and so they could
pick up the left over pieces from him.
The Common Man is the supreme pragmatist throughout the play. He functions as a one
man Greek chorus who is an outside observer as well as a commentator. As the steward, the
common man spies on his master for the sake of money. He is a pragmatist for he only tells
them things that are common knowledge! But now they ve given money for it and everyone
wants value for his money . When he realizes that his position may be in trouble he will go
deaf,, blind, and dumb . This shows his realism for he knows exactly what he wants, as well as,
his limitations and parameters. He will not leak any information that may get him into trouble.
The steward can also see through people. When introducing characters he comments on them.
Lady Margaret, my master s daughter; lovely, really lovely (Bolt, p. 7) He also comments that
Richard Rich is not a righteous person. Thus, he is able to see through people into their deeper
characters and can foreshadow later events. When Thomas More says that he will miss the
steward, Matthew is able to look through More and realize that it is a lie for he says what s in
me for him to miss (Bolt, p.56) and thus looks out for himself when he refuses a salary cut. Yet
another example of the common mans realism is his refusal to serve the More anymore. Before,
the boatsman used to give More rides on his boat, but as soon as the King ordered that More not
be served, the boatsman stopped answering to Thomas calls. Even as a jailer, the common man
is able to look into the future and thus save himself from destruction. When he is told that if he
reports any statements made by More, he will be given 50 guineas he is tempted. But later, he
realizes that Fifty guineas isn t tempting; fifty guineas is alarming. If he d left it as swearing…
but fifty- that s serious money. If its worth that much now its worth my neck presently. I want
no part of it. They can sort it out between them. I feel my deafness coming on. (Bolt, pp.
78-79) Here the common man s pragmatism is clearly shown because as soon as he realizes that
he may be putting himself in danger he becomes deaf, blind and dumb , for he says I am a
plain and simple man who just wants to keep out of trouble. (Bolt, p.85) Even as a steward he
sees the future, My master Thomas More would give anything to anyone. Some say that s good
and some say that s bad, but I say he can t help it-and that s bad…because someday someone s
going to ask him for something that he wants to keep; and he ll be out of practice . (Bolt, p.10)
Here he sees how More will be asked to sacrifice his conscience for loyalty to the King and he
wont able to do that and as a result, be terminated. When the common man transforms into the
publican, he only emphasizes his pragmatism. He realizes that anything he says may be used
against him, so he only answers to Cromwell by saying I don t understand, sir. (Bolt, p.40)
The common man would rather be a live rat, than a dead lion. (Bolt, p.73) He is a
representative of us, the people. If we should bump into one another, recognize me. (Bolt,
p.95)
In conclusion, with the exception of Thomas More, moral corruption is evident
throughout the play. Robert Bolt uses the characters of Richard Rich, Thomas Cromwell,
Chapuys, and Wolsey to portray how corruption comes to those who put self interest above all
values. He uses pragmatism and idealism to show how each character achieves his goals, and
how even though More took all precautions possible, he wasn t able to escape the corruption of
society. He presents Thomas More s idealism as the only admirable quality in that class of
society, for at that time the upper class were extremely corrupt. It is through this idealism that
Thomas more becomes hero and a saint.
Другие работы по теме:
Initiation Into American Culture Essay Research Paper
Initiation into American Culture: The Hollywood Smoke Screen As a foreigner looking inward through a glass window, the foundation of the American culture appears to be based on the idealism of life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. Each year thousands migrate into the United States in search of freedom, democracy and the distinguished American Dream.
Am I An Idealist Essay Research Paper
Idealism is a very radical way of solving the mind-body problem, and what I mean by that is that it totally takes out matter and uses the mind as the sole reality. Idealists believe that the mind is reality. Idealism is a meta. Personally myself, I believe that I am and Idealist. The reason I think this is because of one main incentive monism.
The Last Tycoon Essay Research Paper Infatuating
The Last Tycoon Essay, Research Paper Infatuating Idealism in F. Scott Fitzgerald’s The Last Tycoon Idealism Is undoubtably present in F. Scott Fitzgerald’s The Last Tycoon. Infatuation may be a better word, for that was exactly what possessed the main character, Monroe Stahr. He was totally engorged with one Kathleen Moore.
Reality Vs Idealism Essay Research Paper In
Reality Vs. Idealism Essay, Research Paper In the short story, ?An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge?, Ambrose Bierce quickly drifted from realism in the beginning of the story to idealism throughout the rest of the selection. Immediately before Peyton experiences his first idealistic event, Bierce described a realistic thought on how Peyton closed his eyes and attempted to fix his final thoughts on his loved ones, his wife and children.
Idealism Essay Research Paper IdealismEveryone has ideals
Idealism Essay, Research Paper Idealism Everyone has ideals. From the most insignificant aspect in our life, such as the perfect meal, to the most important, perhaps the perfect family, we all have ideals. As a result, we must all be idealists, although some are more extreme idealists than others, as evidenced by the actions of Dr.
Don Quixote The Misadventures Essay Research Paper
In the Medieval Period, noblemen known as knight-errants roamed the countryside of Europe, searching for adventure. They rescued damsels in distress and vanquished enchanters, witches, and evil lords. The novel Don Quixote by Miguel de Cervantes Saavedra takes place in this magical time. Don Quixote, formerly Quixana, loved to read books of chivalry.
American Idealism In
“O Pioneers!” Essay, Research Paper American Idealism in “O Pioneers!” One of the foundations of America and one of the things that make America great is it’s idealism. Immigrants made their way to America with the attitude that they could
Frege Against Idealism Essay Research Paper Frege
Frege Against Idealism Essay, Research Paper Frege vs. Idealism In a nut shell Idealism is the position that IDEAS, not objects, are the basis of reality. So for idealists the meaning of an expression is the idea associated with that expression. For example, if one were to think of a lamp , then under the idea theory of reference the visual image that we pull up would be the meaning of the expression lamp .
Intro To Philosophy Essay Research Paper Phil
Intro To Philosophy Essay, Research Paper Phil or Sophie? In philosophy, there are three main worldviews: Scientific Materialism, Spiritualism and Idealism/Realism/Rationalism. Scientific materialism is holds much in what we observe. What we hear, see, feel, taste, and smell, is what s real. It is totally physical.
Ideas Of The Parthenon Essay Research Paper
Ideas of the Parthenon The Greek people of the 5th century BC created a culture that was deeply rooted in philosophy and the arts. Their endless search for their place in the grand scheme of the universe and in nature around them influenced everything in their lives especially their love of the arts. Their drama, sculpture, and even architecture are all shining examples of the ideas that were so dominant in the minds of the Greek people.
Empiricism Rationalism And Pragmatism Essay Research Paper
Empiricism, Rationalism, and Pragmatism, as theories of knowledge, attempt to prove the nature of reality and what can be considered true or real. All three of these philosophies, however, encounter problems when attempting to prove the nature of reality. How these different philosophies overcome obstacles in their attempt to prove the nature of reality is a factor in discriminating between the three.
Realism Vs Conventionalism And AntiRealism Essay Research
Paper The classical debate here is between realists and idealists. It is metaphysical in nature; i.e., it is about the nature of reality or, at least, about what our fundamental concepts imply about the nature of reality. Realism is the view that the world exists
Don Quixote De La Mancha By Miguel
De Cervantes (1547 – 1616) Essay, Research Paper It is surprising that Don Quixote should have come to be regarded as one of the greatest novels of all time, since
King James Essay Research Paper Chapter Two
King James Essay, Research Paper Chapter Two of William James’s Pragmatism called “What Pragmatism Means” begins with the famous metaphysical question: Does the man go round the squirrel or not? What he means by this is if a man walks around a tree in a full circle, and a squirrel is one of the tree branches, how come it never occurs to the man to say that he not only walked around the tree, but the squirrel as well?
Compromises Of Political Ideals In Favor Of
Political Expediency Essay, Research Paper Compromises of Political Ideals in Favor of Political Expediency The Constitution of the United States of America was a document that contained many compromises the balanced political idealism with political expediency. Political idealism is the set of beliefs that the Constitutionalists ultimately wanted to achieve in the new government.
Dewey Essay Research Paper Part 1
Dewey Essay, Research Paper Part 1 #1Whitehead claims that philosophy is the search for the solution to a problem. The problem is that throughout generations models used to analyze nature become outdated so to speak. This creates doubt in the systematic evaluation of nature which leads to philosophical inquiry into the interwoven concepts of nature and those of life and mind.
Berkeley Essay Research Paper In the
Berkeley Essay, Research Paper In the “Principles of Human Knowledge,” George Berkeley argues that material objects are nothing more than images within the mind. This idealism suggests that no physical non-thinking entities are real. The only reality of the objects is the image within the mind of the perceiver of the objects.
Is Mark Hulliung Right About Machiavelli Essay
, Research Paper Is Hulliung right? Hulliung discusses how people understand Machiavelli and what he thinks of some of Machiavelli?s concepts. In the chapter of ?interpreting Machiavelli?, Hulliung argues in the issues of means and ends, idealism Vs realism, political violence and weather Machiavelli is a pagan.
Happy Days Essay Research Paper Samuel Beckett
Happy Days Essay, Research Paper Samuel Beckett s Happy Days is to be read anyway but literal. Beckett uses his brilliance to create an allegory for human condition. Winnie babbling away pretends that she has created an order out of her odd predicament. The play abandons realism and takes on the role of an optimistic idealism.
Cash The True Patriarch Essay Research Paper
In reading the novel As I Lay Dying, many questions arose in my mind. However, the one that plagued me was the question that I could not pin down. All of the characters in the book have a personality and play a certain role in the tale. However, the one character who fascinated me, yet I could not explain was Cash.
Epistemology Essay Research Paper Epistemology is the
Epistemology Essay, Research Paper Epistemology is the nature of knowledge. Knowledge is important when considering what is reality and what is deception. The movie “The Matrix” displays a social deception in which Neo, the main character, is caught between what he thought was once reality and a whole new world that controls everything he thought was real.
Guilded Age Essay Research Paper During the
Guilded Age Essay, Research Paper During the late nineteenth century and early twentieth century, a period known as the Gilded Age, every man had the potential to become wealthy, to advance into the esteemed social class of the ?well- to-do?. While this may have been perceived as true by the wealthy, it was little more than a concept of idealism.
Romanticism And Naturalisticism Essay Research Paper Romanticism
Romanticism And Naturalisticism: Essay, Research Paper Romanticism and Naturalisticism: Reflections on Nature Essential to man?s survival, nature deserves respect. In fact, if nature is not respected or cared for, the future may be a place without a natural habitat. Growing with buildings and industrial parks, the world might be a place where one will not have a place to go to relax, to have fun, or to sit and collect thoughts.
Woodrow WilsonThe Idealist Essay Research Paper Wilson
Woodrow Wilson-The Idealist Essay, Research Paper Wilson the Idealist Wilson was not merely an idealist, but a crusading idealist (Link 50). His words, ideas, and actions are those of a man guided by morals, not realist views. The League of Nations, the WWI peace treaty, and his famous fourteen points were all products of his idealism.
Shakespeare Julius Caesar
– Brutus Essay, Research Paper Brutus? tragic flaws are part of what makes him a tragic hero. In Julius Caesar, Brutus is a great example of a tragic hero. His tragic flaws are honor, poor judgement, and idealism (Bedell). In Shakespeare?s plays, the tragic hero and his flaws cause the downfall of the play (Tragic Flaws).
Forms Of Assessment Essay Research Paper If
Forms Of Assessment Essay, Research Paper If one was to draw a continuum on a piece of paper to plot out the different methods of language education the transactional method would be close to the center of the line, with the transmissional method and organic/Romantic method on the opposing ends. The transmissional method of instruction stresses direct instruction, usually with drill and practice type of exercises.
American Philosophy Essay Research Paper In all
American Philosophy Essay, Research Paper In all its forms, American philosophy emphasizes freedom and the supreme importance of the individual. Indeed, an examination of four major American writers shows these concepts in all four main schools of American thought– Epicureanism, Transcendentalism, Pragmatism, and Protestantism.
Romanticism Essay Research Paper The start of
Romanticism Essay, Research Paper The start of the Romantic Age coincided with the start of the French Revolution in 1789. It ends in 1837. Just as the revolution was changing the social order, the romantic poets were taking literature in a whole new direction. The mechanical reason that pervaded the work of the previous era was replaced by strong emotions and a return to nature.
The Technique Of Role Playing Essay Research
Paper Philosophy in Practice One of the techniques used most often by theatre high school teachers is role-playing. The reasons that this technique is often used are numerous. When students read a text silently some of the nuance contained in the meaning can be lost. This is particularly true when dealing with a play, or anything containing multiple characters.
Political Theory Responses To Locke Montesqieu Marx
And Rousseau Essay, Research Paper Realism or Idealism: Responses to Locke, Montesqieu, Rousseau and Marx regarding human nature In the history of the western intellectual tradition, a simple (though not simplistic) way of seeing philosophers of social thought is to place them in one of two categories: realism or idealism.
Illusion And Reality In Gatsby Essay Research
Paper In The Great Gatsby, the confusion between reality and illusion is prominent within the key characters; Fitzgerald portrays this confusion though Gatsby’s obsession with Daisy, Nick’s idealism, and Myrtle’s dreams of success. Each of these characters possesses a flaw that causes their disillusion and their inevitable downfall.
International Relations Realism Essay Research Paper In
International Relations: Realism Essay, Research Paper In the discipline of International Relations realism, which developed as a reaction to idealism during the Cold War, has become the dominant school of thought . Realism makes power the currency of international politics. Realist argue that by accumulating power states can ensure the security of the population within the state.
Great Gatsby 2
Great Gatsby’s Dreams Essay, Research Paper Materialism and Idealism in The Great Gatsby The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald is a novel which deals with the quest for wealth and power in society, in order for Gatsby’s happiness to be fulfilled . The main character Jay Gatsby believes that if he achieves his financial goals that it would lead to his happiness and a better life.