The Violence Against Women Act creates a right to be “free
from crimes of violence” that are gender motivated. It also gives a
private civil right of action to the victims of these crimes. The
Senate report attached to the act states that “Gender based crimes and
fear of gender based crimes…reduces employment opportunities and
consumer spending affecting interstate commerce.”
Sara Benenson has been abused by her husband, Andrew Benenson,
since 1978. Because of this abuse, she sued her husband under various
tort claims and violations under the Violence Against Women Act. Now
Mr. Benenson is protesting the constitutionality of this act claiming
that Congress has no right to pass a law that legislates for the
common welfare.
However, Congress has a clear Constitutional right to regulate
interstate commerce. This act is based solely on interstate commerce
and is thereforeConstitutional. Because of abuse, Sara Benenson was
afraid to get a job because it would anger her husband. She was afraid
to go back to school and she was afraid to go shopping or spend any
money on her own. All three of these things clearly interfere and
affect interstate commerce. Women like Mrs. Benenson are the reason
the act was passed.
There has been a long history of judgements in favor of
Congress’s power to legislate using the commerce clause as a
justification. For the past fifty years, Congress’s right to interpret
the commerce clause has been unchallenged by the Court with few
exceptions. There is no rational reason for this court to go against
the powerful precedents set by the Supreme court to allow Congress to
use the Commerce clause.
In the case of Katzenbach v. McClung, the Court upheld an act
of Congress which was based on the commerce clause, that prohibited
segregation. McClung, the owner of a barbeque that would not allow
blacks to eat inside the restaurant, claimed that his business was
completely intrastate. He stated that his business had little or no
out of state business and was therefore not subject to the act passed
by Congress because it could not legislate intrastate commerce. The
Court however, decided that because the restaurant received some of
it’s food from out of state that it was involved in interstate
commerce.
The same logic should be applied in this case. Even though
Sara Benenson’s inability to work might not seem to affect interstate
commerce, it will in some way as with McClung, thus making the act
constitutional. The Supreme Court had decided that any connection with
interstate commerce,as long as it has a rational basis, makes it
possible for Congress to legislate it. In the United States v. Lopez
decision, The Supreme Court struck down the Gun Free School Zones Act.
It’s reasoning was that Congress had overstepped it’s power to
legislate interstate commerce. The Court decided that this act was
not sufficiently grounded in interstate commerce for Congress to be
allowed to pass it.
The circumstances in this case are entirely different than in
the case of Sara Benenson. For one thing, the Gun Free School Zones
Act was not nearly as well based in the commerce clause as is our
case. The Gun act said that violence in schools kept student from
learning and therefore limited their future earning power. It also
said that violence affected national insurance companies. These
connections are tenuous at best and generally too long term to be
considered. However, in the case of Mrs. Benenson, her inability to
work and spend directly and immediately affected interstate commerce.
Therefore, the Lopez decision should not have any part in the decision
of this case.
The Supreme Court, in McCulloch v. Maryland, gave Congress the
right to make laws that are out of their strict Constitutional powers
so as to be able to fulfill one of their Constitutional duties. In
this case, the Court allowed the federal government to create a bank.
There is no Constitutional right to do this and Maryland challenged
the creation of this bank. The high court ruled that in order for
Congress to be able to accomplish it’s duties. The same logic should
be applied here. The Violence Against Women Act is an example of
Congress overstepping it’s direct Constitutional rights so it can
better regulate and facilitate interstate commerce. In order for
Congress to legislate interstate commerce fairly, it must allow people
to be able to work and spend as they should be able to. If a woman is
afraid of being abused if she gets a job or spends money, it affects
interstate commerce. Thus The Violence Against Women Act is
Constitutionally based and necessary for interstate commerce.
Violence against women is a terrible crime. It destroys
women’s self esteem, tears apart families, and destroys lives. Many
times, it will lead to murder or other terrible crimes. What the
Violence Against Women Act is trying to do is give women a weapon to
protect themselves from violent spouses. Without this act, many women
would be left incapable of getting any form of financial redress for
the years of suffering and abuse they went through. It is wrong to
deny women a tool to rebuild they’re lives after an abusive
relationship. The years of abuse they went through makes it hard if
not impossible for them to get a job or work in an office. These women
are afraid for the rest of their lives that if they make a mistake or
displease the men around them, they will be beaten. This act allows
women to get some means of getting money to live on while they rebuild
their lives. It allows them to seek professional help if necessary.
Without this act, women would be forced on welfare or worse. When this
happens, it benefits no one. The Violence Against Women Act has a
strong Constitutional basis in the commerce clause, despite what
Andrew Benenson says.
The Supreme Court has allowed many acts such as this to stand
for the past fifty years. All the precedents of cases with similar
circumstances are to allow the act to stand. Also, we cannot forget
the human aspect of this case. This act is a tool for women to rebuild
their shattered lives after an abusive relationship. To declare his
act unconstitutional would be both legally and morally wrong.
33b
Другие работы по теме:
Koran Essay Research Paper The Koran or
Koran Essay, Research Paper The Koran or Qur’an is the sacred scripture of Islam. A scripture so sacred it urges a total commitment to him alone who is god. (Grolier Interactive 98). I found that
The Revolutionary Trend Essay Research Paper In
The Revolutionary Trend Essay, Research Paper In every revolution, there seems to be a few guidelines that it must follow. It seems that almost all revolutions, in their radical phases, tend to have the characteristics of excessive cruelty, extreme violence, and denials of the rights of freedom. But the question that befuddles many is why they always become this way.
Protecting Our Children Essay Research Paper Protecting
Protecting Our Children Essay, Research Paper Protecting Our Children The overlap between domestic violence and child abuse has been well documented; where one form of family violence exists, there is a likelihood the other
Violence Essay Research Paper Violence is a
Violence Essay, Research Paper Violence is a one of the biggest problems for many communities, but the community isn’t the real problem, almost all the problems start at homes, and at schools there are many ways of solving them, starting for ourselves and our family, and ending up helping to the other people.
Domestic Violence Essay Research Paper Wife BeatingDomestic
Domestic Violence Essay, Research Paper Wife Beating Domestic violence arrests have skyrocketed in the past decade, making this crime the leading violent felony arrest locally and nation-wide and placing it at the top of law enforcement’s priority list (Guido). Battering women occurs at all levels of society (Barstow).
ERASE How I Can End Racism And
Sexism In My School Essay, Research Paper What Can I Do to End Violence, Racism, and Sexism in My School Violence, racism, and sexism, some of the most used things in the school.
Gun Control 2 Essay Research Paper We
Gun Control 2 Essay, Research Paper We the students of class 7-508 do not agree with the statement that people should carry weapons. We do not agree with this statement
LATINA WOMENS ISSUES Essay Research Paper DOMESTIC
LATINA WOMEN?S ISSUES Essay, Research Paper DOMESTIC VIOLENCE AND CULTURAL INFLUENCES Domestic violence involves the systematic use of force, threats and intimidation by one partner upon another in order for the dominating partner to have control over the victim. In general, women who are abused physically are often isolated.
The Godfather Essay Research Paper Violence and
The Godfather Essay, Research Paper Violence and The Godfather Throughout time there have always been people who held more power than others. There are many different methods used to both demonstrate and maintain the power which they possess. Often times violence is the method chosen to achieve these goals.
Violence And Pornography Essay Research Paper Is
Violence And Pornography Essay, Research Paper Is pornography harmful to the human psyche? Interpretations of recent studies on violence and pornography have yielded a wide range of theories on this subject. Victor Cline asserts that there is plenty of evidence showing pornography to be harmful. He believes that it ?degrades women and desensitizes males to sexual violence? (Slife, 270).
Violence In Films Essay Research Paper What
Violence In Films Essay, Research Paper What place does violence have in the movies? Well, I believe that violence has a place in movies depending on the particular film and what the director of the film is trying to portray. If the director uses violence in his/her film and there isn’t any reason behind it, then I would disagree and say that violence shouldn’t be in THAT particular film.
School Violence Essay Research Paper Every day
School Violence Essay, Research Paper Every day a child is hurt purposely, or accidentally by another classmate. There are many things that cause people to take violence out on other people. It could possibly be parenting, bullies, television, and even video games.
The Cause Of Rape Essay Research Paper
Rape is a common crime that affects our friends, daughters and sister through drug dating, dressing revealingly and fliriting. Rape occurs everyday in small towns and in big citis. Rape not only happens to older women but youong women, too. Ra0pe is mose common in high schools and colleges.
Violence On Television Essay Research Paper Many
Violence On Television Essay, Research Paper Many shows include violence as a key factor to interest public viewers. However, people may think television violence is one of the many causes for everyday violence. Dr. Littner has slightly disagreed with this theory and explained his reasoning. Dr. Littner believes that television does not create the desire for violence but supports the existing desire that cannot be taken away.
Domestic Violence Essay Research Paper Children and
Domestic Violence Essay, Research Paper Children and Domestic Violence Child abuse and Domestic Violence are issues that isn t new in society. Both are considered problems that are accepted in the American culture. Domestic Violence is now politically recognized as one of the most pervasive forms of violence in society today, child abuse issues have yet to receive the same degree of attention.
Children And Violence Essay Research Paper JuvenilesChildren
Children And Violence Essay, Research Paper Juveniles Children and violence, were does it start? Some experts say that children from violent environments at home are more likely to commit crimes then others. Some very young children will witness crime at the home and think that it is ok, not knowing what is right and wrong.
A Short Essay On Conrad Black
’s Depiction Of Women Essay, Research Paper Joseph Conrad?s novella, Heart of Darkness, the representation of women is extremely limited. Conrad?s portrayals are extreme stereotypes meant to depict
Womens Studies Essay Research Paper Health Care
Womens Studies Essay, Research Paper Health Care Response to Domestic Violence Fact Sheet Email this page to a friend Domestic Violence: A pattern of assaultive and coercive behaviors, including physical, sexual, and psychological attacks as well as economic coercion, that adults or adolescents use against their intimate partners.
Domestic Violence Essay Research Paper Domestic ViolenceBy
Domestic Violence Essay, Research Paper Domestic Violence By: Kris Hudson Each day, the statistics on domestic violence get more and more horrifying. A woman is beaten every 15 seconds, 22 to 35 percent of emergency room visits from women are because of ongoing partner abuse, 1 in 4 pregnant women have a history of partner violence, and 63 percent of young men between the ages of 11 and 20 are in jail for murdering their mothers abuser.
Pornography 4 Essay Research Paper PornographyBased on
Pornography 4 Essay, Research Paper Pornography Based on the evidence Cline presents about non aggressive pornography I would say that viewing non aggressive pornography alone does not make men more callous towards women. I do think that other circumstances such as the influence of the media and of the adolescent male peer group can cause young men to become insensitive towards women.
Violence In Sport Essay Research Paper Violence
Violence In Sport Essay, Research Paper Violence in Sport In most of our popular spectator sports, winning depends on the use of violence. To score and win, athletes’ bodies are routinely turned into weapons to be used against other bodies, causing pain, serious injury, and even death. How do we interpret the social meaning of this violence? Commentators – both apologists and critics – have made sweeping statements about sports and violence, but their analyses rarely take into account the meanings of violence in sports to the athletes themselves.
Gender Stereotype Essay Research Paper According to
Gender Stereotype Essay, Research Paper According to the writers in chapter, “Gender Stereotyping And the Media”, gender stereotypes are harmful to men and women. Gender stereotypes set impossible standards for men and women that lead to unhappiness, loneliness and possibly violence towards themselves.
Violence Essay Research Paper Violence Violence is
Violence Essay, Research Paper Violence Violence is the biggest problem kids, teenagers, and adults have in our society today. Everyday there is usually a headline story or article about a shooting, or killing.
Youth Violence Essay Research Paper Youth violence
Youth Violence Essay, Research Paper Youth violence affects a lot of people. Hearing about it on the news is one way that youth violence has affected my life. In Washington, D.C. there is a lot of youth violence.
Computer Violence Essay Research Paper Violent Computer
Computer Violence Essay, Research Paper Violent Computer Games A lot of adults say violent computer games make you violent. I disagree. When you are mad you can take out your anger while playing that game. Lots of kids I know have violent computer games and none of them are violent. Pretty much everything in this world has violence in it.
VIOLENCE IN SPORTS Essay Research Paper Violence
VIOLENCE IN SPORTS Essay, Research Paper Violence in sports To: Mrs. Woods From: Jean-Philippe Do you think there?s a connection between sports and violence? If you do, do you think it should be banned? I too think that it?s connected but, unlike most people, don?t think it should be banned. I have many reasons to believe so and I will state them in my essay.
Sexism Essay Research Paper SexismSo what exactly
Sexism Essay, Research Paper Sexism So what exactly is sexism? Sexism is the belief that rights and roles in ones society should be governed by ones sex. Historically, sexism has been male-driven and
Symbols Of Women Essay Research Paper Symbols
Symbols Of Women Essay, Research Paper Symbols of Women There are many symbols placed on women in today’s society. These symbols act as stereotypes that usually degrade women on a daily basis. However, many of these symbols are just a term, and have no meaning behind them. An example of this is the reference of women being referred to as “dogs.”