A policy that forbids any employee capable of reproducing from working with lead is a policy that interferes with the employees’ freedom of choice. Many women viewed Johnson Controls’ policy regarding fetal protection as another way to exclude women from the workplace.
Johnson Controls refused to hire any women who could not prove that they could not get pregnant and there were no exceptions. In 1990, only twelve (12) women worked at the Johnson factory in Bennington, Vermont. The reason why so few women work at this facility was because of Johnson Controls’ fetal protection policy. Women who worked for Johnson Controls felt that they were telling the world that they were sterile.
Johnson Controls made lead automobile batteries for Sears, Goodyear, and others. Inside the plant the air contained tiny toxic particles of lead and lead oxide. Scientific studies revealed that lead could lead to damage of the brain, retardation, miscarriages, damage to the central nervous system, and other disorders of a fetus. The toxic lead particles and lead oxide can stay in the bloodstream for a considerable amount of time, but according to Johnson Controls, the levels of lead at their plants was low enough for adults, but too high for children and fetuses. Therefore, even if a woman that worked for Johnson Controls found out that she was pregnant and left the job, the lead would still be in her bloodstream long enough to possibly harm the fetus. Johnson Controls’ stance “was protecting the health of unborn children”9.
Johnson Controls’ position was in line with the National Centers for Disease Control’s recommendation that “women of childbearing age be excluded from jobs involving significant lead exposure”1. The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) holds every company/organization responsible for reducing hazards in their workplace. On this basis, other companies, such as, General Motors, Allied Chemical, and B.F. Goodrich joined Johnson Controls in adopting fetus protection policies. These policies included working conditions that these companies believed to be hazardous to the potential offspring of women.
The United States Court of Appeals judged Johnson Controls’ policy to be “reasonably necessary to the industrial safety-based concern of protecting the unborn child from lead exposure”2. In this decision, the United States Court of Appeals in my opinion was sending a message that they believed women were not capable of making the right decision.
The unions contended that this “policy discriminates against women, jeopardizing their hard-won gains in male-dominated industries”3. Women advocates believed that policies like Johnson Controls and others “not only challenged a woman’s right to control her fetus but to control her unfertilized eggs”4. Isabelle Kant Pizler, director of women’s rights at the American Civil Liberties Union said, “since time immemorial, the excuse for keeping women in their place has been because of their role in producing the next generation “5. The American Civil Liberties Union argued in court, “since no activity is risk-free, deference to an employer’s analysis of fetal risk could limit women’s participation in nearly every area of economic life”6. A woman has a right to make her own choice where to work or anything else. If a woman accepts the personal responsibility to work at Johnson Controls with the knowledge of the chemical and its dangers, she also accepts the personal responsibility for anything that could possibly happen to her offspring. There are many reasons why a person might work a dangerous job, (i.e. the pay in their mind out ways the risk); regardless of the reason, it should be their choice.
I do not believe the policy that Johnson Controls instituted to be fair to employees who are fertile but plan to have no children. The reason that I take this stance is because whether you are fertile or not, it should be a person’s own choice whether or not to work in a harmful working environment. Evidence shows that women are not the only the ones that were affected by the tiny toxic particles and lead oxide. “In March 1991 the United States Supreme Court ruled unanimously that the fetal protection policy at Johnson Controls violated the Civil Rights act of 1964, which prohibited sex discrimination in employment. Pointing to evidence that lead affects sperm and can thus harm the offspring of men exposed to it at the time of conception”7.
Johnson Controls’ fetal protection policy is an invasion of privacy. Potential employees should be made aware of the possible dangers when working with lead at the initial job interview. The employer has no right to ask whether or not they are thinking about having a child.
Johnson Controls should be looking for a way that they can make the working environment safe for both men and women to work. Joseph Kinney, executive director of the National Safe Workplace Institute said, “ the ideal thing is to regulate lead out of the workplace and any other toxin that poses fetal damage”8. Johnson Controls is an example of a company that is willing to risk the lives of its employees to make a profit. Johnson Controls has a moral and ethical obligation to its employees to control and limit the risk involved when working with lead. Both men and women run a risk of passing lead on to the unfertilized ovum. Johnson Controls is controlling who is subjected to the lead purely for monetary reasons. Johnson Controls chooses to employ men because it minimizes the amount of times they will be sued. It is a numbers game. Johnson Controls is aware of the risk of working with lead, weighed their options and chose the path that will cost them the least in court. Men because of lead related injuries and women because of unfairly hiring practices will sue Johnson Controls. Johnson Controls is practicing discrimination. By employing women, even after informing them of the dangers of working with lead, would most likely result in a higher number of lawsuits.
Johnson Controls would want you to believe, that it has an obligation to the parties that cannot participate in the woman’s decision – namely, the unfertilized ovum and the fetus”10. However, the company has an obligation to its stockholders and that obligation accompanied by expected lawsuits creates the climate where this type of discrimination can exist.
Bibliography
Work Cited
1 Shaw, W. (1999). Business Ethics. Wadsworth Publishing. Belmont, California, pg. 270.
2 Shaw, W. (1999). Business Ethics. Wadsworth Publishing. Belmont, California, pg. 271.
3 Shaw, W. (1999). Business Ethics. Wadsworth Publishing. Belmont, California, pg. 271.
4 Shaw, W. (1999). Business Ethics. Wadsworth Publishing. Belmont, California, pg. 271.
5 Shaw, W. (1999). Business Ethics. Wadsworth Publishing. Belmont, California, pg. 271.
6 Shaw, W. (1999). Business Ethics. Wadsworth Publishing. Belmont, California, pg. 271.
7 Shaw, W. (1999). Business Ethics. Wadsworth Publishing. Belmont, California, pg. 272.
8 Shaw, W. (1999). Business Ethics. Wadsworth Publishing. Belmont, California, pg. 272.
9Shaw, W. (1999). Business Ethics. Wadsworth Publishing. Belmont, California, pg. 270.
10 Shaw, W. (1999). Business Ethics. Wadsworth Publishing. Belmont, California, pg. 271.
Другие работы по теме:
Nat King Cole Essay Research Paper NAT
Nat King Cole Essay, Research Paper NAT KING COLE BORN MARCH 17, 1919 DIED FEBRUARY 15, 1965 BORN NATHANIEL ADAMS COLES HE WAS THE FIRST AFRICAN- AMERICAN WHO BECAME A SUCCESS WITH THE WHITE AUDIENCE.
Protecting Our Children Essay Research Paper Protecting
Protecting Our Children Essay, Research Paper Protecting Our Children The overlap between domestic violence and child abuse has been well documented; where one form of family violence exists, there is a likelihood the other
My Mother Essay Research Paper My mother
My Mother Essay, Research Paper My mother is like a rose. She is beautiful, gentle, something special, She is strong, deeply rooted in the ground, There’s no wind that could fold her.
Isaac Netwon Essay Research Paper Sir Isaac
Isaac Netwon Essay, Research Paper Sir Isaac Newton and Gottfried Leibniz are both accredited for the discovery of Calculus. Both of these men were born about the same and died around the same time. Both were known as supreme intellects of the 17th century.
Dad Essay Research Paper DADHe left me
Dad Essay, Research Paper He left me when I was a baby Before I was even born But to think he never tried to find me Makes me shiver through the bone. Wondering year after year
Poem Essay Research Paper I went to
Poem Essay, Research Paper I went to bed last night Wishing on a star Your light shines in my heart No matter where you are It’s hard for me to say My words are sometimes few
Herodotus Essay Research Paper Herodotus Essay Herodotus
Herodotus Essay, Research Paper Herodotus Essay Herodotus of Halicarnassus was born about 484 B.C. he died 60 years later. For the time he lived in this age was very old though by today’s standards it is not. The reason why his age was so outstanding was in his time the average man live for maybe half that because of the harsh living conditions.
Jewish Essay Research Paper Beowulf EssayThere were
Jewish Essay, Research Paper Beowulf Essay There were many differences between Beowulf the play and 13th Warrior the movie. In the play Beowulf was depicted as a soul warrior who?s strength and ability was
Fences Essay Research Paper Get on your
Fences Essay, Research Paper Get on your mark! Get set! Go! From the moment we are born, we enter the race of life. The race to win, to live victoriously, or to be successful in the race of life. Generally, we can say that success is defined as the accomplishment of something attempted. Therefore, anyone can be successful.
Henry Cabot Lodge Essay Research Paper Henry
Henry Cabot Lodge Essay, Research Paper Henry Cabot Lodge Henry Cabot Lodge was an American diplomat. He was born on July 5th 1902. He was born in Nahant Massachusetts. He did alot for our country so in the next few paragraphs I will tell you about Henry Cabot Lodge and some of his accomplishments.
Poem Angel Essay Research Paper Once upon
Poem: Angel Essay, Research Paper Once upon a time, there was a child ready to be born. So one day he asked God, “They tell me you’re sending me to earth tomorrow but how am I going to live there being so small and helpless?”
Stealing Our Rights Essay Research Paper Stealing
Stealing Our Rights Essay, Research Paper Stealing Our Rights From the dawn of the first organized communities, to the powerful United States of America today, there have always been power hungry people who
Religion Is Important Essay Research Paper I
Religion Is Important Essay, Research Paper I think culture, religion, ethnicity is very important in one’s life. They should know where there from and who they are. Everyone comes from somewhere around the world, even if they were born in another country, they still
Sickle Cell Anemia Essay Research Paper Sickle
Sickle Cell Anemia Essay, Research Paper Sickle Cell Anemia Sickle Cell Anemia is a genetic disease that affects all kinds of people and can start before a person is even born. This paper will talk about
Settlers And Pioneer Essay Research Paper Settlers
Settlers And Pioneer Essay, Research Paper Settlers and pioneers led very different lives. The code of conduct practiced by both groups was the same. While both groups were dependant on consumer goods, the particular goods demanded by each group were different. Rebecca Burland was born in England and immigrated to Pike County Illinois in 1831 with her family.
Dry September Essay Research Paper Dry SeptemberIndividually
Dry September Essay, Research Paper Dry September Individually none of the men would have attack the black man, but the crowd mentality caused them to take actions that they normally wouldn?t have. The client, McLendon, and the youth are three prime examples of men who become influenced and dependent on the others.
Eli Whitney Essay Research Paper Whitney Eli
Eli Whitney Essay, Research Paper Whitney, Eli (1765-1825), American inventor, best known for his invention of the cotton gin. Whitney was born in Westboro, Massachusetts, on December 8, 1765, and educated at Yale College (now Yale University). In 1792 he visited the plantation, near Savannah, Georgia, of Catharine Greene, widow of the American Revolutionary War general Nathanael Greene.
Reflection Rap Essay Research Paper On my
Reflection Rap Essay, Research Paper On my neck, I still got marks from the day I was born. As a shorty, I always had to get scorned. I couldn?t have been more of a prick as a thorn. A bad report card-before it reached home it got torn. I didn?t know if I should be soft or hardcore, like porn. I stomped on authority, like a mat for a door.
Biography Of Oedipus Essay Research Paper Oedipys
Biography Of Oedipus Essay, Research Paper Oedipys’s date of birth is unknown. He was born to Polybus and Merope, but Jocasta is his real mother. Oedipus was born in Thebes, but he spent most of his adult life in Corinth. Due to some mistakes that Oedipus makes prior to the start of the play, trouble seems to surround him later.
Malcolm X Essay Research Paper Malcolm XIn
Malcolm X Essay, Research Paper Malcolm X In Our Own Image Malcolm X, one of the most highly controversial speakers for equal rights for African Americans was born in Omaha, Nebraska on May 19, 1925. He was his father s seventh child and his mothers fourth. His father, Earl, was a Baptist preacher who was born in Georgia.
Immigrants Essay Research Paper Are Immigrants A
Immigrants Essay, Research Paper Are Immigrants A To the U.S? Immigrants are not a burden to the U.S. Therefore, we shouldn’t stop all immigration . Immigrants are hard workers and are not causing unemployment for
Huck Fin Essay Research Paper Huck
Huck Fin Essay, Research Paper Huck’s acceptance of Jim is a total defiance of society. Ironically, Huck believes he is committing a sin by going against society and protecting Jim. He does not realize that his own instincts are more morally correct than those of society. At the conclusion of chapter 11 in The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, Huck and Jim are forced to leave Jackson’s Island because Huck discovers that people are looking for the runaway slave.
Darwin Research Essay Research Paper Darwin was
Darwin Research Essay, Research Paper Darwin was born in Shrewsbury, Shropshire. He was the son of Robert Waring Darwin and his wife Susannah; and the grandson of the scientist Erasmus Darwin, and
Basics On Keats Essay Research Paper John
Basics On Keats Essay, Research Paper -John Keats was born in 1795 and died in 1821 -John Keats was born in Moorfield, England -John Keats had two brothers, George and Tom, and a sister Fanny
Saving Mother Earth Essay Research Paper The
Saving Mother Earth Essay, Research Paper The way we think about nature affects both our individual and social decisions. Various things may be affected, from the kind of food that we eat, to the products we buy, and locations we may attend. Different people have different feelings and ideas towards things.
Wealth Essay Research Paper Dan NeffPeriod 43697WealthThere
Wealth Essay, Research Paper Dan Neff Period 4 3-6-97 Wealth There are differences between those who are born wealthy and those who earn money. Wealth, especially monetary wealth, means the person can meet all of their needs and wants with great luxury and still have money left to use, waste, save, or share.
Jesus Essay Research Paper JesusJesus is the
Jesus Essay, Research Paper Jesus Jesus is the center of Christianity, born in Bethlehem in Judea. To believers Jesus is the son of Mary. He is the son of God. Jesus was divine but led an
Julius Ceasar Essay Research Paper Julius Ceasar
Julius Ceasar Essay, Research Paper Julius Ceasar Julius Ceasar was born in the first century. He was deaf in his left ear and lacked physical strength. He was assasinated by many conspirators. The main ones being Cassius, Brutus, and Decius. They were all against an absolute monarch, and therefore feared the crowning of Ceasar.
Julius Caesar Essay Research Paper Julius Caesar10044
Julius Caesar Essay, Research Paper Julius Caesar 100-44 BC Born in 100 BC, Gaius Julius Caesar became one of the most famous and remembered Romans of all time. His parents were Gaius Caesar and Aurelia. Julius Caesar’s most famous
Poem Human
’s Hate Essay, Research Paper When I think of a human trait. I think of human’s hate. Although it’s our nature, I think its awfully immature. Hate is something thats lated through the ages, we learn about it everyday turning through out history pages. teh color of you skin, we can’t help what shade we were born in.
My Name michelle Essay Research Paper Once
My Name (michelle) Essay, Research Paper Once I looked up the definition of my name. It said ?Who is like god?, and it is also the fem. version of Michael. When I was born my name wasn?t as simple as Michelle, it was Michelle-Leann, and later